Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our cost of living crisis. The only solution is to move and uproot the children (teens) but AIBU - WWYD?

242 replies

Powerdough · 30/08/2022 12:02

So we are in real trouble. Redundancy (Covid related). Business bankruptcy. Disability, caring responsibilities, we are self employed now, but not bringing in enough for a mortgage that was taken when we had what we thought secure business and jobs. Now it is totally unaffordable and with the insane cost of living we are going to start defaulting in a few months. We can't keep up with bills as it is. We definitely can't find an extra £700 a month for energy bills. I am anxious and I feel like this is a slow moving car crash.
We have the option to sell our house and move to a rent free property that belongs to a family member. The only problem is that it is at the other end of the country literally in the middle of nowhere (think the most remotest part of the British Isles). I would love it, DP and I can work from home. We could financially ride out this shit storm. But for our teens it would be awful. One is in the middle of his A-Level course and expected to get top grades. One is passionate about a hobby (sport) and trains competitively, wants to make it into a career, there are no facilities or opportunities where we would be moving. They would leave behind their friends.
On one hand, economic realities dictate that sometimes you have to do hard things. But I dread what it would mean for the kids. How should I talk to them? I don't want to make them anxious but I also think we need to be realistic and live according to our means even if it means moving. WWYD

OP posts:
Dibbydoos · 30/08/2022 18:51

Powerdough · 30/08/2022 12:20

@MarianneVos we have equity but not enough to buy outright, and we can't get another mortgage with our credit rating in tatters (fell into arrears when lost jobs/business)
I know and agree. I am trying to find a middle ground

You can get a mortgage. Go to a good broker and be honest about everything.

Use Eden to buy up some of the property value so you buy a house using a share equity approach. I think you'll find you can buy a similar house etc. Good luck.

NovaDeltas · 30/08/2022 18:50

Throwing a grenade onto their education condemns them to a difficult life of low paid work and poverty even more extreme than what you're facing. They will never be able to build a life living on a rock in the Outer Hebrides or wherever.

Dibbydoos · 30/08/2022 18:48

I am so sorry to read your post OP. Can you get financial help?

There is a property crash on its way, so def either release equity or get it sold quickly. If there's equity, it might allow you to rent something smaller near where you are for a period? If not, could you buy a cheap caravan or river/ canal boat nearby and live in that at least for most of the year?

What an awful situation :(

I'm self employed, my contract ends in Nov and I'm worried about what that means for me, so I'm planning to land a second 6-12m contract ASAP and just work like a nutter for 3 months.

My suggestion is to see if there is interim work you can do now. Blend your working hours so you can do what you currently do plus the new job. I know it'll be hard, but recessions are to be ridden out, 24m at most and I'm hoping this one is less than 12m.

SkygardenTower · 30/08/2022 18:46

Would online school help with the eldest? Not ideal but might be an option to allow A levels to finish. There are several but the best known is interhigh.

What would happen if you defaulted on your mortgage and were made homeless? Is the council accommodation that might be available? Given you have 3 children, one with extra needs, you should be high on the list.

Have you thought through all the practicalities of attended hospital appointments, when the nearest town is so far away?

QuattroFromagio · 30/08/2022 18:46

Are there 2 teens living there all the time, 1 disabled teen living there during school holidays, and then half the time, 2 (presumably older teens/young adults) from your DH's previous relationship? Or are the 2 teens the 2 who are only there half the time?

Could the residential school provide further accommodation/care during the holidays for some of the time? Even if not the longer summer holiday, if they could help in some of the shorter holidays, then perhaps you could make the 1 bed flat or even caravan idea work. I do know someone who lived in a caravan in Cornwall for most of a year while waiting for housing to be available.

There must be cheaper places than Cornwall elsewhere in the country, though, if not in Cornwall, where you could either buy a 1-bed outright or rent something more suitable. then when the eldest is done A-levels, think again about moving to Scotland if still needed. The costs of living up there sound like they would be worse though, between energy, transport, etc.

Could the eldest start A-levels again if needed, if you could move to somewhere else suitable in England? There is usually funding for 3 years of sixth form, so you might be able to find a place that would accept him as Year 12 again next year, if you did have to move.

Caterina99 · 30/08/2022 18:45

Is the free house living with family? Or is it possible they rent it out and lend/give you some cash?

I live in a fairly remote rural location. It has its own costs, heating oil is ridiculously expensive. Increased fuel costs because you have to drive miles to get anywhere. Sharing a car is more challenging due to zero public transport so many people are 2 car families. If DH has to go to a meeting or anything in the real world the cost of travel is high because it’s so far away.

Also how important is decent internet and communications for your self employment? Ours internet is pretty crap and DH wfh and despairs of it. And he’s the only one using it all day.We’re looking into satellite internet or something. We also had no mobile signal for a few weeks last winter as a mast was down. And that’s assuming you can get reception at all with your network.

Maybe make a plan to move to Scotland in a few years when it’s less critical timing for your children. It is a lovely way of life, but probably not the ideal time for you

Zezet · 30/08/2022 18:45

This would work in my country, not sure in UK: could you sell the house (for a reduction in price) under condition that you get to live in it 12 or 24 more months? To allow kid to finish A-levels etc?

Malad · 30/08/2022 18:38

If this was my situation then I wouldn’t move until the kids are older and can decide if to stay or move with you. Presumably the eldest may be off to University?

I would

  1. Sell the house - much more preferable to repossession. However if your credit rating is shit anyway and you are not currently in arrears then I would just stay for as long as you can. Even if you find a buyer, you can delay moving out or even come to agreement with the buyer. Is it possible that your house may be bought as an investment opportunity (ie holiday let) - if so tell the buyer that you will rent it for a year or more if you can agree a price. They may snap your hands off or at least let you stay until next Spring.
  2. If the above is a non starter then Rent and pay a year up front if needs be. I accept you won’t have the money to do this initially so arrange an Airbnb or even a lodge on a holiday park. Expensive but works short term.
  3. Move in a few years. Yes you won’t have as much money but if the offer for free rent is still there then you won’t need as much.

How old are you both?

JimJamJollyWolly · 30/08/2022 18:13

Don't have much to offer. Having read all your posts I just don't see how the move is viable (and energy costs in the north of Scotland will be higher than the south of England). It seems like you have been offered a bit of a lottery ticket you can't cash in, but there are so many caveats to the win it would be crazy to pursue it. I'm sorry, you sound like you have a LOT going on!

MSE have a forum that has helped me out in the past with financial worries.

LobeliaBaggins · 30/08/2022 18:06

I moved countries for A levels. Didn't end up hating my parents. I am not suggesting you move them, but just in case you have no choice.

It's a hard situation all round.

Joystir59 · 30/08/2022 17:58

Any chance of your son lodging with family or friend and joining you in your new remote lodgings during holidays?

SylvanianFrenemies · 30/08/2022 17:29

How much equity do you have?

GetOffTheRoof · 30/08/2022 17:24

Moving to a remote place with free rent isn't your only option though. No reason you couldn't move further north than Cornwall, but rent or buy something else. Rent a place in Liverpool or outside Glasgow on the West Coast maybe?

Why are your lenders saying they won't approve a shift to a BTL?

OakPine · 30/08/2022 17:24

Are you familiar with the new location in Scotland? There is a massive difference between living in the SW of England, and living in the remote North of Scotland.

How far is your new location from the nearest high school?

There are many locations in England which would be much cheaper, and would allow you to continue in the same education system.

OneMomentPlease · 30/08/2022 17:18

OP with your recent update I don’t see how you can move at all. Provision for your third DC will likely be a huge issue and how will DP’s other DC maintain contact?

In answer to your question, yes you have to balance the needs of everyone in this decision, but I can’t see how it will benefit any of you to move. I would take the free rental out of the equation, as PPs have said energy bills/education differences/ total lifestyle change for DCs / DP’s DCs having little to no contact just make it unworkable.

The move seems tempting because it would solve what at the moment is your biggest problem ie finances, but in turn it would create so many huge new problems in its place, many of which will directly impact DC more than you or DP.

The harsh answer is that as parents your needs are less important than DCs, so your desire to be stress free about finances is not as important as your DC losing so much.

A previous PP who says you have met sounds like they have a workable solution and I really hope that they are thinking of the right person and it would be a possibility for you.

Completely understand the flexibility needed to work around a child with complex needs, but still either you or DP could look for a second income?

goldfinchonthelawn · 30/08/2022 17:17

In your position I would put the house on the market and try to secure a cheap rental within reach of school and training ground. I would tell the relative that you would love to take up their rent free offer in a couple of years' time once DC have finished school, if the house is still available. You could even move most of your stuff up to the new fre ehouse and just keep the basics in a scaled down rental.
But to wrench DC from school at this critical point in their academic career would be seriously damaging. A levels matter almost more than any other exam as they are the gateway to uni or further training or a good job. And if the DC who trains towards a profession in a given sport has that opportunity taken from them, that too is a step too far. I'd rather live in a two room flat in the right area than do this to them.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 30/08/2022 17:15

Acreativeusername · 30/08/2022 17:10

Looked online heaps to rent in the south west . Sorry think this is more about you and hubbies dream of living in the middle of no where and working from home, by looking back at your initial post. More to a really cheap area. You and husband live in lounge.

I'm sure there's a lot to rent in the South West, but if OP's son is at sixth form/college in, say Truro, he can't exactly commute from Somerset, can he?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 30/08/2022 17:14

gatehouseoffleet · 30/08/2022 16:47

Also if your other child has complex needs, shouldn't you be a priority to be housed if your lender effectively forces you out of your house? Or do the powers that be not care because the child is at a boarding school in term-time?

There is very limited housing in Cornwall- families are being housed in temporary accommodation out of the county if they can't find something to rent. OP's family would, of course, be a priority, but there is a real lack of suitable housing for families in the county. I don't think they could rely on being housed by the council- there are a LOT of people who need help with housing, unfortunately.

OP, I really empathise, and I don't have any real solutions for you. I do think the situation sounds really, really difficult. If you're able to hang on for another month or so, you might be able to find a winter let somewhere- which might keep you going until April or so? Then find a short term solution until June for A-levels?

But it will likely make your financial situation worse long term. I hate to say it, but I doubt you'll be able to cling on for another three years, so it might be better to suck it up and move your second child now, before they're tied in to the GCSE system.

Acreativeusername · 30/08/2022 17:11

*move to a cheap area, down size , you and hubby live in lounge and fulfil your dreams when your kids have had the chance to fulfil theirs.

Acreativeusername · 30/08/2022 17:10

Looked online heaps to rent in the south west . Sorry think this is more about you and hubbies dream of living in the middle of no where and working from home, by looking back at your initial post. More to a really cheap area. You and husband live in lounge.

Winter2020 · 30/08/2022 17:00

Hi OP,
Is non mortgage debt a factor in your financial problems? (you mentioned liability for business debts?)

You should prioritise essential costs of mortgage, Council tax and utilities and default on non essential debts such as loans and credit cards as you can't afford them.

Charities such as Christians against poverty and Stepchange can help with solutions to debt. Don't pay for debt help.

Can you look at shared ownership. Use the equity in your house to buy the owned bit outright so there is no mortgage and then pay the rental part. I believe you can claim benefits towards the rent part if your income is low but check this.

I would try to arrange meetings with hoysing associations /your local shared ownership representatives and get help and advice.

The rental situation is terrible but you only need one property so you could ask on facebook/ local sites for family looking for rental. You never know there might be a friend of a friend.....

Personally I think you need to try to pretend the free rental didn't exist. You have mentioned your son was having a rough time with his mental health but discovering his sport (and probably friends along with it) has got him on track. I don't think you can risk him not coping with the move and becoming depressed again. Rather the one bedroom flat -anything.

If it is your dream to live in this cottage in the wilds do it when your youngest leaves home/goes to uni.

Snoken · 30/08/2022 16:49

How big is the shortfall? Would it be possible if both you and DH took on additional work, such as delivery driver, cleaning, dog walking, supermarket shifts etc? Just to tie you over for another year?

Have I understood it correctly that your DH has two DC and then you have one additional DC together?

For your kids sake I wouldn't move them to Scotland now, or at all. I think anywhere in England will be better so they stay in the same education system. Lots of places are cheaper than Cornwall.

lapasion · 30/08/2022 16:48

Powerdough · 30/08/2022 16:32

@Redqueenheart ok. Well yes in theory I/we could. Have tried that too. But the jobs we would be able to get hired for, would pay no more than what we make now self employed. I am also a carer. I have a severely learning disabled child still living at home but at school term time. And whilst this thread is not about the ins and out of raising a child with complex needs, I will tell you that no job would entertain the kind of flexibility I need, with hospital appointments, and time off when he is sick and can't go to school. But thank you for taking the time to make a suggestion, appreciated.

It is really tough with a disabled child. When mine was younger, DH had a 9-5 job and I had to work 6pm until midnight. That meant someone was always around for our DS. Admittedly, evening jobs are usually pretty crap pay.

Are there any areas near you that are less desirable and less likely to be full of airbnbs? The south west is beautiful but there are definitely towns that have little tourist appeal. As for credit ratings etc, yes it is tough. When we moved recently, we both had crap credit ratings after some tough times through Covid. However, we were very lucky and found a private rental through open rent. We had to provide proof of income etc but the landlord didn’t do a credit check.

gatehouseoffleet · 30/08/2022 16:47

Also if your other child has complex needs, shouldn't you be a priority to be housed if your lender effectively forces you out of your house? Or do the powers that be not care because the child is at a boarding school in term-time?

Eastangular2000 · 30/08/2022 16:47

Powerdough · 30/08/2022 16:32

@Redqueenheart ok. Well yes in theory I/we could. Have tried that too. But the jobs we would be able to get hired for, would pay no more than what we make now self employed. I am also a carer. I have a severely learning disabled child still living at home but at school term time. And whilst this thread is not about the ins and out of raising a child with complex needs, I will tell you that no job would entertain the kind of flexibility I need, with hospital appointments, and time off when he is sick and can't go to school. But thank you for taking the time to make a suggestion, appreciated.

Have you checked the implications for your child with SEN in terms of whether there placement will continue if you move countries. That may actually be one of the most difficult things to manage. If it is being funded through an EHCP that won't transfer to scotland and as I am sure you are aware even moving within england could lead to the placement being changed.