Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this upset you?

86 replies

PickAPatter · 30/08/2022 09:13

If you had children from a previous relationship and a child with your current spouse and you heard a telephone call between your spouse and their parents asking if they could meet at a local attraction at some point soon but specifically asking not to bring your older children so they could spend some time with their grandchild.

We tend to do lots together so the older kids tend to come along a lot when we meet with spouses parents. Older kids really like spouses parents too although don't call them grandparents.

They were 4 & 6 when we met.

YABU - there's nothing hurtful in this conversation.

YANBU - I'd be hurt and would say something.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LosingTheWill2022 · 06/09/2022 12:00

I would have them spend more time with their biological grandparents but by your logic @Firefly528 the OP'S younger children would be hurt and not understand why their siblings were spending time without them at their (the older dsc's) paternal grandparents. Now that's clearly nonsense so why why is it such a problem the other way round?
You seem mystified by children's ability to understand their different relationships within a blended family. If handled sensitively and openly children get it! The OP says her older dc don't call them grandparents so the dc clearly understand better than some posters.

Firefly528 · 06/09/2022 11:09

They also didn't decide to have biological grandkids.

Firefly528 · 06/09/2022 11:05

Who cares how the in laws feel? I don't understand why so many people are siding with them. I think it is messed up for them to even ask that knowing how your older kids might feel. Kids will not understand their reasoning behind the request, they will understand rejection. Obviously you can't force the in laws to spend time with them so I would have them spend more time with their biological grandparents or take them somewhere better so they don't feel left out.

Mamakg · 04/09/2022 04:54

I was in that sitiuation...starting at 10 years and on. The step-grandparents weren't "my grandparents" and I was well aware of that fact. They treated me kindly when I was there for holidays or whatnot, but I had my own grandparents. I didn't expect them to treat me the same as their grandchildren. An adult being ugly to a child is one thing, but to simply want to spend time with their own grandchildren,
and not other children? I think that is fine and the mother is being ridiculous. YABU

YOU choose who you marry and have children with, and accept the children they bring into the relationship. Other children shouldn't be forced onto everyone else because of the (let's face it, because if once married/divorced its likely to happen again, so probably temporary marriage) decisions you make. The children will just as quickly disappear out of their lives when the parents divorce again. That affects the adults feelings as well. They are bonded with their own, not with every kid that comes into your relationships. Again, as long as they aren't ugly to the other kids when they are around them, there's nothing wrong with wanting time alone with their own grandchild.

AshleyJean · 03/09/2022 18:48

My sister has a stepchild. He came into her life when he was 4, I met him closer to 5 when things got more serious - she got pregnant soon after. Honestly, he’s a nice kid but I don’t view him as a nephew. I buy him Christmas gifts and I am fair in that way. However, he also does have a whole “extra” family that my nieces don’t have. So, I do get frustrated when I ask can I take the girls (there are two now) to Disney on Ice or a county fair and her husband will say only if his son can go too. I get blending is tricky sometimes but I also remind my sister the girls don’t get to go to the fair or zoo (for example) when he’s with his mom. It’s part of life… we all do our best but at the end of the day it’s sometimes hard to be fair. We might have a more natural connection to our own. I would say if the grandparents aren’t being malicious and it’s an occasional thing you should honor it. We don’t want to hurt any child’s feelings … they didn’t sign up to be part of a blended family but it’s okay to explain to them they get to do special things with their other parent or parents family side too.

Calphurnia88 · 03/09/2022 16:12

*I can confidently say.

Calphurnia88 · 03/09/2022 16:11

MamaOwl1985 · 03/09/2022 14:00

I have always believed this and always will. You and your husband went into this marriage knowing you had kids from a previous relationship. Those are just as much his kids as they are yours and it's not right that his parents want to spend time with "HIS biological" child. This is setting them up to be treat different from the get go. Your kids from the previous relationship will grow up seeing THAT child as the he favorite or golden child to them. I would put a stop to that now. You aren't wrong. The GPs are.

As someone who's father remarried (i.e. I had a stepmum and step siblings) and can confidently say that this might be true for some families but not all.

In fact the concept of being just as much my stepmum's child as my biological father's child is totally alien to me (and I can't imagine my mother being too happy about it), let alone her parents considering me their grandchild. Appreciate this won't be everyone's experience but it was definitely mine.

LosingTheWill2022 · 03/09/2022 14:13

MamaOwl1985 · 03/09/2022 14:00

I have always believed this and always will. You and your husband went into this marriage knowing you had kids from a previous relationship. Those are just as much his kids as they are yours and it's not right that his parents want to spend time with "HIS biological" child. This is setting them up to be treat different from the get go. Your kids from the previous relationship will grow up seeing THAT child as the he favorite or golden child to them. I would put a stop to that now. You aren't wrong. The GPs are.

Not even all step parents feel that way, so why would you expect step grandparents to do do?
The dc don't refer to them as grandparents so they recognise the difference in relationship.

SoupDragon · 03/09/2022 14:04

(I.e. they made no commitment at all)

SoupDragon · 03/09/2022 14:04

You and your husband went into this marriage knowing you had kids from a previous relationship.

Their parents didn't though.

MamaOwl1985 · 03/09/2022 14:00

I have always believed this and always will. You and your husband went into this marriage knowing you had kids from a previous relationship. Those are just as much his kids as they are yours and it's not right that his parents want to spend time with "HIS biological" child. This is setting them up to be treat different from the get go. Your kids from the previous relationship will grow up seeing THAT child as the he favorite or golden child to them. I would put a stop to that now. You aren't wrong. The GPs are.

Frangle101 · 03/09/2022 11:10

I am a individual that grew up in a similar situation. I am the biological child along with my elder sister. My mom had 2 children from previous relationships. They are older 10 yrs & 5 yrs from me. They didn't have other grandparents to go to so this may not be completely relatable. However, my grandparents never that I am aware of treated my other siblings different than they treated biological grandkids. If my siblings were younger I'm certain my grandparents would have been fine with them being around. There were times where I can't remember exactly but we did have sleep overs at my dad's parent's house I believe it was just my sister and I though. That's probably, because we were younger than the other 2 & it was probably when my parents needed care while my siblings were in school. This was back in the late 70's & 80's. When blended families were more rare then. I just wish blended families of today were accepting as my grandparents were. They had flaws might have spoiled some of us a little more at times, but they always remembered birthdays and holidays for my siblings as well.
I get where the biological grandparents are coming from but it makes sense to me when the step grandchildren are at maybe their other grandparents or with their other parent if that's actually thing for you (though not in my situation) that would be great time to have one on one quality grandparents' time. If they have other grandparents that's in their lives you might be able to do grandparent day. Where the ones spend time with their grandparents and the other spend time with the other grandparents and when they get home they can talk about what they did and you can help guide them so hopefully it's not about jealousy but more about what grandparents share time with them.

TXmum3 · 03/09/2022 00:13

Nothing hurtful here. It may feel like that because the olders are yours and it can sound exclusive but if they are really good with the olders generally than I think it's no big deal. You said your kids don't call them grandparents so I don't think it's unreasonable for them to feel their is definitely a difference in relationship with the younger kiddos than the olders. If its expected that the olders should always be included then maybe it should also be expected they view and call the grandparents grandma and grandpa etc.

Grumpypants78 · 02/09/2022 23:24

YANBU to be hurt but YABU to say anything as it's perfectly understandable they would want to spend time with their GC without the distraction of the older kids as long as it doesn't happen too often or are overly obvious in treating the kids differently 💐

Mooloolabababy · 02/09/2022 23:20

Favorsgrace · 02/09/2022 21:06

im in a somewhat similar situation though all my children are from the same dad, And two older children go to grandmas and the two younger children have no idea what that’s like. It’s quite sad and I’m still trying to navigate these waters I guess all I can say is thanks for taking and treating the older two, at home it causes hurt feelings and one son who walks around mr “ high all mighty “ I’m gonna go to grandmas at the end of the week so I don’t have to follow ur rules blah blah it’s not a very good situation but I’m unsure how to handle

What's the reason given for this? Could the grandparents start to alternate weekends with them? (Two oldest one weekend, two youngest the next weekend) So that all dcs get a chance to stay at their grandparents as when the oldest two get too old to want to go to granny's then the younger two won't have built up that close bond to want to stay over, surely?
Also, with regard to the high and mighty attitude, I'd have to say to dc that if they continue to behave that way then the won't get to go.

canteatlovefood · 02/09/2022 22:20

My stepson is 12 and we have 2 more kids 8 and 3. My parents have known SS since he was 2 and he is basically their grandchild. If my parents ever asked to spend time with the younger 2 and exclude SS I would say no. When he's at our house they're a package deal of 3 siblings whatever we do. Not that my parents ever would request this, but it'd be pretty hard to explain to SS.

Favorsgrace · 02/09/2022 21:06

im in a somewhat similar situation though all my children are from the same dad, And two older children go to grandmas and the two younger children have no idea what that’s like. It’s quite sad and I’m still trying to navigate these waters I guess all I can say is thanks for taking and treating the older two, at home it causes hurt feelings and one son who walks around mr “ high all mighty “ I’m gonna go to grandmas at the end of the week so I don’t have to follow ur rules blah blah it’s not a very good situation but I’m unsure how to handle

Jimzle · 02/09/2022 19:39

I wouldn't like that. Siblings are a package deal. Period.

ddl1 · 01/09/2022 15:47

Not hurtful if it only happens very occasionally. Hurtful if part of a consistent pattern.

Musti · 01/09/2022 15:30

I think it is fine. Even doing stuff with only one or some of the kids at a time when they are related. When I spend one on one time with one of my kids, it is completely different to when there are 2 or more. Talk more, open more, no bickering etc

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 01/09/2022 15:28

She was happy to see mine. When her biological dgc arrived she dumped us all. Especially her dgc! Made no sense.

Calphurnia88 · 01/09/2022 14:24

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 01/09/2022 10:40

A bizarre one we had. Mil really took to my dc. 3 under 8.... Wanted to be Dgm-name. All good.
Then we announced I was pregnant and she backed away. Stopped bothering. When ds was born totally snubbed him. Went on holiday several times and brought gifts for my dc but not her dgc. We moved away. Haven't seen her for over 7 years. Wish my dc had never met her. Strange bloody woman!

So your children were basically 'stand-in' grandchildren before biological grandchildren were born?

This sounds particularly cruel.

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 01/09/2022 10:40

A bizarre one we had. Mil really took to my dc. 3 under 8.... Wanted to be Dgm-name. All good.
Then we announced I was pregnant and she backed away. Stopped bothering. When ds was born totally snubbed him. Went on holiday several times and brought gifts for my dc but not her dgc. We moved away. Haven't seen her for over 7 years. Wish my dc had never met her. Strange bloody woman!

songdancer · 31/08/2022 21:02

Been there. Gone through that. My parents didn't accept my step son as part of the family. They said so. They even told him. When they told people how many grandkids they have, they didn't include my stepson in the count.

I eventually adopted him, making him officially my son. My parents still don't count him as one of the grandkids.

Now my son is grown and has kids. My grandkids don't know my parents, because my parents didn't accept my stepson/son as part of MY family. So I recently went to my granddaughter's wedding, and my parents weren't invited. We have Christmas with my kids (all of them), and my parents aren't invited.

I also have girls with my husband. Since my parents don't accept my son as part of my family (even after I adopted him), that means that my other children (the girls) have decided not to spend time with my parents as well. They have no interest in doing "family" things without all of their family, and that includes their brother.

Separating out siblings and treating them differently tends to lead to bad feelings. While the grandparents may not have a blood tie to the stepchild, the other children in the family do have a blood tie with their sibling. The half-sibling can feel like a second-class citizen in the family and may not want to live in that household when he/she is older.

It is easier to be inclusive. And it pays off over time.

BobbysGirly · 31/08/2022 18:20

It wouldn’t upset me at all. I have 2 children from my first marriage and 3 children from my second marriage. We are all invited to family gatherings - my own family and DH family - such as weddings, BBQ’s, birthday celebrations etc

My eldest children have a great relationship with their father and his extended family and see them regularly. My youngest are not invited to their family gatherings. Nor should they be.

Youngest children have every right to spend time with their paternal GP’s without their older half siblings. Their GP’s want to spend time with their GC. Of course they should.

My parents used to invite all the GC to spend time with them, at their holiday home, during school holidays. Because they are all my children, therefore all are their GC.

Eldest DC’s father and GP’s don’t buy Birthday or Christmas presents for elder DC’s half siblings. Why would they? Younger DC’s paternal family don’t buy Birthday/Christmas presents for eldest DC. Why would they?