Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving family 3 hours to be near parents

63 replies

Lifethroughlenses · 30/08/2022 07:02

I honestly don’t know what to do. I’ve lived down South since uni but DD is coming up to high school age and I can’t stand the thought of my parents struggling to get to hospital appointments, deal with everyday life etc without me as they age. They’d never ask me or expect me to move but the thought of being 3 or 4 hours away kills me. I also think it will get harder to drag the kids back for weekends and holidays once they are teens. My DH isn’t massively keen but would move if I really want to. I’m happyish down South but I feel this is last chance saloon really. There are other pros - family nearby (we have none here), slightly cheaper house prices, chance to explore new areas.

OP posts:
riotlady · 30/08/2022 19:01

Festoonlights · 30/08/2022 18:50

Well feeling like a change and being tired of the drive are not good enough reasons to uproot everyone op!
What if your dc hate it?
Maybe they won’t fit in, and miss their home, friends, life etc. I imagine they might think you were selfish putting your wishes first, before them. Who could blame them?
For some reason people that had a move forced on them as a child that didn’t work out rarely get over it. They still speak about it a lot and are affected even well into adulthood.

This is a bit over dramatic tbh- I moved a lot as a child and my main problem was the frequency as I never felt like I got to put down roots. The moves pre-secondary were also a lot easier than the post-secondary ones as you make friends so much easier and changes in curriculum are much less noticeable. A single move age 10 may be tricky for a bit but I don’t think it’s going to be devastating her into adulthood!

TeaThings · 30/08/2022 18:56

Would you be nearer cousins and your own childhood friends? Would your DH be able to meet people he could become friends with? Moving before secondary is best - friendships change from primary regardless if you stay in the same area or not.

Lurkerlot · 30/08/2022 18:54

Yeah, move, spend time with them before their ailments set in.

Festoonlights · 30/08/2022 18:50

Well feeling like a change and being tired of the drive are not good enough reasons to uproot everyone op!
What if your dc hate it?
Maybe they won’t fit in, and miss their home, friends, life etc. I imagine they might think you were selfish putting your wishes first, before them. Who could blame them?
For some reason people that had a move forced on them as a child that didn’t work out rarely get over it. They still speak about it a lot and are affected even well into adulthood.

Lifethroughlenses · 30/08/2022 18:44

For context, our jobs are mostly remote so we could work from anywhere. My parents couldn’t afford to move to me and they live in a nice family friendly area where schools are good. There are other reasons they can’t move. My youngest is only 5 so I’ve got a long wait before he leaves secondary. I think it would be hard for him if I moved as he went to uni as well. I am excited at the thought of a change and I’m fed up of driving up and down the motorway all the time.

OP posts:
Creepymanonagoatfarm · 30/08/2022 11:40

Have they actually asked you to? Yabu to put them before your dd and dh.

Festoonlights · 30/08/2022 11:34

Porcupineintherough · 30/08/2022 07:35

@Festoonlights that seems a bizarrely emotive response to a quite normal human activity (moving house). There is life beyond the southern UK.

I am genuinely horrified at the prospect of uprooting pre teens from a happy life they have always known and a less than keen husband to move 3/4 hours away so i could drive my parents to hospital appointments! To me that is utter lunacy and a sure fire way of making life extremely difficult for her children and husband.

By all means organise a driver or carer to help, but to move everyone is a really big deal, and fraught with potential problems and pitfalls too many to list.

There is stability for children in having all of their childhood friends, friends parents, childhood memories, family friends and hobbies etc around them as they enter a big change such as a new secondary school, to take all of that away at such a difficult age anyway unless it is really essential seems quite cruel to me. The gps hospital apps should not come before the children’s needs.

Book more time to see your parents op, perhaps for longer periods over the holidays when you can but I would carefully consider a full relocation.

WhereAreMyAirpods · 30/08/2022 08:47

Moving isn't that easy though. Jobs, houses, friendship networks - you're giving all of that up because of what might happen. Not every older person needs regular hospital appointments - my own granny was shockingly healthy until her mid 80s and was never in hospital at all until she died suddenly.

My own parents are both late 70s and are not in the best of health, dad has dementia, but again this does not mean regular hospital appointments.

It sounds really harsh but I would always prioritise my own children over my parents. My parents would also not expect us to uproot the children and move them a substantial distance just because of the worry that they might need help at some point in the future. What about your husband's family? Is it only you who feels this duty to be close to your parents - not his?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 30/08/2022 08:46

Don't do it just because your parents need support, that's insane. If you want to move for other reasons, and the whole family want to move, then absolutely do it. But imagine if someone in your family was desperately unhappy having moved and resented it. You'd probably be spending more time with your side of the family too, and could end up in much more of a caring role than you'd anticipated and your own family may hardly see you for a number of years. What if it's the other way and your elderly parents die within a year or two of you moving everyone up there - would you then be happy to stay there? What if each member of your immediate family disagree as to what to do in those circumstances? What if you all realise it was the wrong decision but financially it's too hard to move back.

I've had experience with relatives who beome elderly and they don't live close by and have no children of their own (not parents, but as the closest relative you do feel a sense of responsibility). One 3-4 hours away and one the other side of the world. Yes, it becomes v difficult when they age to support them from afar, there is little practical help you can give, and the guilt is terrible when it's neighbours who end up being put upon. But when you have that conversation about theiir plans for later in life and they decide they want to stay put then what can you do?

I know a couple of people who retired and decided to downsize. Then they thought that as all their family ties had moved away from themfor work etc then what was stopping THEM moving to their younger family, who have all their lives ahead of them? So they did, and were positive about making a new life for themselves. I think that decision needs to be made at an early stage, though, when you're a relatively fit and well retiree, as if you leave it too long the move can feel like too much of an upheaval.

I don't konw how I'll feel when I get to that age but at 50, as much as I love my home, I'm aware that I could end up a lonely old woman unless I am open-minded to the thought of moving towards wherever my family may be.

Novum · 30/08/2022 08:40

What are the chances of both of you getting jobs if you move?

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 30/08/2022 08:27

I think it’s well worth considering, as long as it will work for your family as well as for your parents. If there are good schools, good housing, you’ll both get good work, then why not?

For those saying DP can move to you when they get needy, or they can pay for care - a quick flip to the Elderly Parents board will show just how difficult that is. Especially if it would mean them moving to a more expensive area. But you might want to talk to them about their plans before you do anything drastic.

Butterlover1 · 30/08/2022 08:25

Move them closer to you. It's a huge upheaval for your family and once your parents are no longer living your family, especially your kids will need to live with the consequences of this move forever.

We made a big life choice in our 30s centred around our parents and I totally regret making a life long decision for what in hindsight was a relatively (in terms of your entire life) short issue

cptartapp · 30/08/2022 08:22

Surely your parents wouldn't have you running round after them anyway? That's what we scrimp and save all our lives for, to buy in care as needed as we age and let our busy families live their own lives.

GeekyThings · 30/08/2022 08:21

YANBU to consider it, it's a good idea to think about it now and try to time it so it works best for everyone.

I'd say in terms of kids you would be best looking at now, or waiting until they're college age, which is a long time away. So depending upon the age of your parents it depends if you can wait that long or not. I moved a lot when I was younger, but settled when I was around 10 or 11, and most of my friends are from around that age, so I think in terms of your kids it would be fine to do it now.

Your husband isn't keen, but he isn't against, he probably realises it's something you'll have to do eventually anyway. It's one of those things about marrying someone from out of area, it's bound to happen at some point, so I think he's being sensible.

Logistics would be the thing to think about - where you would go, how you would afford it, where you would work, where the kids would do to school. Things are easier with a plan in place so I would concentrate on that first.

Also bear in mind - 3 hours is a bit too far to be caring daily for elderly parents; but it isn't that far in terms of young people branching out in the world, like you did yourself, so you won't be stifling your kids' futures. And you and your needs are as important as anyone else's in your family, and although they may not be keen on moving, you sound like you may be devastated if you don't, and your parents may end up in desperate need without you, so I would think that is a priority consideration under the circumstances.

You sound like a great daughter to have, your parents are very lucky.

autienotnaughty · 30/08/2022 08:15

Lots of factors
Do your parents need support
Do they have other support
Parents aside would you move
Are you happy where you are
Is dc happy in school has friends etc
Is dh happy where he is

T he errs nothing wrong with moving but it needs to be about more than be nearer parents. (Unless they desperately need support)

Quartz2208 · 30/08/2022 08:12

THis is a tricky one because of course it is possible to move but it seems that it is all caught up in some guilt you feel for moving away?

Is it a good enough reason to move given that your DH isnt keen and your children are I assume settled and your parents are presumably still in their 70s at the oldest

My parents did similar (moved after Uni from the midlands to the South Coast) ended up in South London later. My Maternal GM moved down to around 30 mins away after my Grandad died (closest Retirement flat we could get) and Mum visited her once a week until she died. My Paternal Grandmother is still in the Midlands at 98 (around 2 hr drive 3 hrs on the train). Pre Covid my Dad visited once a week, now with his own health issues once a month. His sister is in Australia! They manage perfectly well to sort everything out (and at that age there is quite a lot!)

autienotnaughty · 30/08/2022 08:11

Hyacinth2 · 30/08/2022 07:06

Well surely if you have a DD going to secondary school your parents are not that old . Are they hard up and can't afford taxis?
I wouldn't move near until they are mid 80s (near 70 year old here)

My ds is 7. My dad is 76 and needs support.

WimpoleHat · 30/08/2022 08:04

if your parents are worried about this, then they can move (with your help) closer to you. You can’t expect your whole family’s needs to revolve around theirs. Plus - what about your DH’s parents in all this? How do they figure in this move?

Hankunamatata · 30/08/2022 08:01

Surely it depends if parents live in nice area, can you get jobs, schools

If your going to move I'd def do it for dc starting high school

TiredzzZZ · 30/08/2022 07:50

Well, it depends how close you are to family I guess. As someone who's mum has just passed away, there are several things I'd like to have done differently. Might be easier to move now than in a few years, so I see your perspective. If you children would be on board and excited to move, your DH ok with it, and you are close to your family, then maybe do it. But if the children are not keen, maybe think twice. You sound like a lovely daughter

MichelleScarn · 30/08/2022 07:50

Where are your husbands parents? If not close to yours what if his then need help? Are you looking for a job which will have the flexibility to allow all the time off for attending all these appointments? Are there openings for both you and dh in your areas of work? What about school places?

Longdistance · 30/08/2022 07:45

No. You need to put your dc and dh first. Your parents can get taxis to appointments if they can’t drive and if they’re that infirm go to a care home.
Being a carer for parents is miserable. Why uproot everyone?

Redqueenheart · 30/08/2022 07:45

I think you need to put the needs of your own family (kids, partner) first.

  • would you both have to change jobs? would that mean a set-back in your careers and moving to an area where there are less opportunities? because that would affect your financial stability long term
  • This might affect your children's education and they would obviously also lose their existing friends. Also if there is less to do there for them as teenagers that will be an issue
  • If you move somewhere where they are less jobs and higher education opportunities it means your children are likely to move away from you when they are older for jobs and university so your own family could end up being apart
  • Where are your husband's parent and family living? would you being closer to yours means he is then more cut off from his own family, because that will be an issue too
  • why don't you ask your parents to move closely?

So I think I would look at this carefully and discuss all the aspects and the impact on everyone before you make that decision with your partner.

I personally would not move because I think the impact on everyone else might not be positive and there are other options

redtshirt50 · 30/08/2022 07:43

I moved a few hours away from primary to secondary school and was fine.

That said I wouldn’t move just because of the parents thing.

I’d move because you want to - otherwise you may well grow to resent it

N4ish · 30/08/2022 07:39

Meraas · 30/08/2022 07:27

Why? I thought moving to high school would be a good time to move, as you make nee friends anyway.

I think a child of that age is heading into some of their most tumultuous and difficult years (that was certainly the case for me) and the last thing they need is to be removed from all existing support and friendship networks and moved to a completely new place hours away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread