Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving family 3 hours to be near parents

63 replies

Lifethroughlenses · 30/08/2022 07:02

I honestly don’t know what to do. I’ve lived down South since uni but DD is coming up to high school age and I can’t stand the thought of my parents struggling to get to hospital appointments, deal with everyday life etc without me as they age. They’d never ask me or expect me to move but the thought of being 3 or 4 hours away kills me. I also think it will get harder to drag the kids back for weekends and holidays once they are teens. My DH isn’t massively keen but would move if I really want to. I’m happyish down South but I feel this is last chance saloon really. There are other pros - family nearby (we have none here), slightly cheaper house prices, chance to explore new areas.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1477391263 · 31/08/2022 10:28

I also think it will get harder to drag the kids back for weekends and holidays once they are teens.

Most teenagers see their grandparents "sometimes," but constantly dragging teenagers off to spend numerous weekends and holidays at their grandparents' place is a recipe for resentment, even if you live close by. They will have other things going on when they are teenagers. The question is, is this place you are thinking of moving to, a good place for teenagers anyway?

user1477391263 · 31/08/2022 10:25

As for the move, I would only move if there are a lot of pluses to moving there anyway. Moving to somewhere nobody in the family likes "for the old folk" and then everyone resenting them heartily is not a good idea.

user1477391263 · 31/08/2022 09:27

Well surely if you have a DD going to secondary school your parents are not that old . Are they hard up and can't afford taxis?
I wouldn't move near until they are mid 80s (near 70 year old here)

Do you live in an area where most people have all their children really young? If Grandma and Mum both had their kids in their early 30s (hardly unusual), the grandparents will be close to 80 as the kids enter their teens.

hewouldwouldnthe · 31/08/2022 09:14

If you add up all the pros and can have a better standard of living as well as be nearer family, then do it. There's no magic about living in the south. I was born in London and lived in Surrey and Hampshire. Kids born there. Moved to Yorkshire and have a much better standard of living, good schools, lovely countryside etc. Hampshire meant a busy town life and it wasn't for me, plus housing was ridiculously expensive Do it before the kids become really entrenched in school life

alphasox · 31/08/2022 08:50

We’ve had this discussion too but the main factor
in deciding for me was thinking even further ahead - ie what would we do after my parents died - which is likely for us to be anytime in the next decade. I realised that long term there are better opportunities for me, DP and the kids where we are now. So we are staying put, and helping parents from afar (eg I paid to get them meal delivery service when my DM was recovering from an op).

Interestingly my parents had this decision to make too and when I was 11 they moved us from a busy and prosperous city to a little village 90 minutes away, to be near my grandparents. I hated it as a teen and left and went back to the city for Uni and moved to London after graduation.

SleeplessInEngland · 31/08/2022 08:25

My youngest is only 5 so I’ve got a long wait before he leaves secondary. I think it would be hard for him if I moved as he went to uni as well.

Eh?

Anyway, I wouldn’t make decision based on your parents. Take them out of the equation and ask yourself if you’d move there anyway.

TakeMeToYourLiar · 31/08/2022 08:20

You know people have kids at different ages right?

when my eldest starts secondary FIL will be 80

wheb my nephew starts his grandad will be 90

Petronus · 31/08/2022 08:18

I think the key thing is that your husband isn’t keen.
if you are just moving because your parents might need help then I think you might be jumping the gun. Both my grandparents moved to where we lived when they got older, one to social housing. If they have a large family home at the moment they are not going to need it forever, when the time comes that family home probably would translate to a retirement flat even in the south. However if you would like to move to improve your own lifestyle and dh agrees I think you should go for it. One move for pre-secondary dc is absolutely fine.

Ski4130 · 31/08/2022 08:14

Oh, and just to add, those stating that it’s as easy as paying for care, or not that difficult to arrange transport when sick/elderly people need it don’t sound like they’ve tried to access those services lately. My mum is unable to drive herself (her eyesight deteriorated badly during her illness and she had to give up her car) and was in the midst of chemo & radiotherapy, during covid, so taxis/hospital transport were off limits. The sheer volume of appointments (consultants, chemo, scans, steroid injections, unexpected hospital admissions etc) is mind blowing, and it was a struggle to coordinate them all even between my ds, db & I. Mum also lives alone, so one of us would stay with her when she felt too sick to function and she needed someone there to make sure she was ok.

It’s genuinely not as easy as just paying for care, and accessing support isn’t that easy.

Testina · 31/08/2022 08:14

Is your husband on Dadsnet posting about moving for caring for his parents? 😉

Nobody on this thread knows you’re children. It’s theoretically fine and most settle. I could have moved my youngest in Y5 easily. Going into Y7 she had a large and hugely important to her friendship group and I think it would have been really awful for her.

Ski4130 · 31/08/2022 08:07

All those posters saying it’s a terrible thing to move children, it genuinely isn’t, children are far more adaptable than people seem to give them credit for!

Yes it can be difficult and there are times when it feels emotionally fraught to uproot your family, but people can, and do, move away quite successfully. We’ve done two major moves (to NZ, and back again) when the children were 1, 4 & 7 and then 5, 8 and 11, and yes there were hard moments, but they coped far better than I’d tied myself up in knots thinking they would. We’ve also moved ds2 from a school where he was unhappy, to another mid way through Yr10, with no ill effects.

People move all the time OP, and for the reasons you give, I did (my dm had secondary cancer, and was very ill, I felt I needed to be home to help care for her, and I’m eternally grateful that I was, and am still, there for her)

Novum · 31/08/2022 07:57

Do your parents actually need your help? Do they have any other friends and relatives around to support them? Do you have any friends in your parents' area? Where are your husband's family?

kitcat15 · 31/08/2022 07:52

Festoonlights · 30/08/2022 07:27

What? No. Don't do it.

Your parents came move to be nearer to you.
Uprooting your whole family, including a dh that is not keen on the move to be an unpaid carer is absolute madness
Have you considered how seriously unsettling it is going be for your dc to live their home, friends, memories and life to live elsewhere in a place they have no connection to?
What about their future prospects in your parents' home town?
Good jobs are plentiful in the south, will it be the same where your parents live?

I would not even consider doing this, your poor kids!

FFS 🙄

unicornsarereal72 · 31/08/2022 07:48

My mum moved nearer to us ten years ago now she has been able to help us with childcare when we needed her too and I'm on hand to support her as and when she needs me too. My dad is 25 miles away and mid 70's and is terminal. I'm glad they are near so I can do what I can to support them. I would have the conversation with your parents and see if this is on their radar.

Maray1967 · 31/08/2022 07:33

We’re in one of those nice areas in Liverpool mentioned in a previous post and we could save money moving back to south yorks, but we wouldn’t dream of moving unless it was absolutely essential eg DH redundancy. My DC still at school has a close circle of friends and would hate to move. We were not disrupted by school moves by our parents and we won’t inflict it on ours unless essential.

Maray1967 · 31/08/2022 07:29

We’ve made it clear that we won’t disrupt our DC schooling so no move for us for a few more years. Our parents are 80. All are fine, are not expecting us to move at this stage, and they could move here if they wanted to.
Then we will move back because we want to. I will retire then and DH works from home - is only expected in the office once a week, if that, and the journey would be less than two hours, so manageable.

Summergirl5 · 31/08/2022 07:25

Festoonlights · 30/08/2022 19:48

Just because it didn’t bother you doesn’t mean it won’t deeply affect other children. It’s a big risk. A child that constantly moves will feel very differently to one that has never moved.

Do you know lots of children that moved once and were permanently affected by it then ? It’s normal to move ,it’s life ,it’s what people do .

Summergirl5 · 31/08/2022 07:22

I moved lots of times as a child …have lived all over ,moved from one end of the country to the other ,think entire day traveling,at age 14 ..turned out to be the best thing for me .
im certainly not scared by it ..I moved actual families ,like one family to another 3 times ..I’m still here ,still got good GCSE went to uni .……so many peal clutches on this thread

Lifethroughlenses · 31/08/2022 06:54

@CurlyhairedAssassin 4 beds here are well over £1million. And I’ve contacted the local authorities and checked which schools have places. Although we would rent first so could then buy according to where the school was.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 31/08/2022 02:08

If it’s a nice family area with good schools up north and you’re moving from the south, you’ll be joining hundreds of people who will be doing the same. I’m in a nice part of Liverpool. I’ve noticed so many non-local accents the past few years. Many of them stay here after uni and start their families here but still more come because they think the housing is way cheaper. Well, it’s not really, round where I am. Not any more. Bigger 3 beds are pushing 500k. 4 beds are 500k plus. It’s unbelievable. But the biggest shock they get is that all the best primary schools are full, with waiting lists. People move up and pick an area based on schools and then they are completely shocked to find there is no room for their child at any of the local schools and they’re stuck with one a 20 min car ride away which may not have any kids likely to be going to the same secondary as your child.

Full schools will take your name and put it on the waiting list but until you’ve actually moved and can prove your address they won’t be able to hold it for you and will give it to the next person waiting who is already living there.

just be careful in your assumptions about a school place. The best areas have generally very oversubscribed schools.

i have to say, I have no idea how parents make moves like that when it comes to schools. I feel sorry for those for whom it’s a forced move. And for those who end up with no school place for their child.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 30/08/2022 20:44

WifeMotherWorker · 30/08/2022 19:59

I wouldn’t move teenage children.
Why can’t your parents move??

She doesn't have teenagers. She's already explained why her parents can't/shouldn't move & she likes where they live.

WifeMotherWorker · 30/08/2022 19:59

I wouldn’t move teenage children.
Why can’t your parents move??

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 30/08/2022 19:57

@Lifethroughlenses

I have read both your posts, but not all the replies.

I would move. It sounds like a good move for you all.

you have other family up there, it's a nice, family, area with good schools, cheaper houses & you get to be near your parents as they age without traipsing up & down the motorway.

It's a good time to move before DD gets settled into high schools & DS will soon make new friends (as 5yr Arnold's do)

you'll regret NOT moving more that you'd ever regret doing it.

MY main suggestion would be to really think about which house you buy and your finances in general, so that if you ever wanted to move back down one day, you are in a good position to do so.

Festoonlights · 30/08/2022 19:48

riotlady · 30/08/2022 19:01

This is a bit over dramatic tbh- I moved a lot as a child and my main problem was the frequency as I never felt like I got to put down roots. The moves pre-secondary were also a lot easier than the post-secondary ones as you make friends so much easier and changes in curriculum are much less noticeable. A single move age 10 may be tricky for a bit but I don’t think it’s going to be devastating her into adulthood!

Just because it didn’t bother you doesn’t mean it won’t deeply affect other children. It’s a big risk. A child that constantly moves will feel very differently to one that has never moved.

MMBaranova · 30/08/2022 19:05

Perfectly sensible to THINK about this, but their lives may not follow the paths you assume. Would you all collectively probably have a better quality of life?

My father’s dilemma was separated parents, one in Spain and one in England (plus a feeling of some responsibility for an old single relative in Ireland). Things would run smoothly for years and then some alignment of the stars would set them all off at almost the same time.