Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 30/08/2022 09:03

SleeplessInEngland · 30/08/2022 08:57

But isn't the point that, as an adult, you can generally choose.

Well, most adults choose from a limited range of options and economic necessity. I daresay most office workers neither particualrly like their jobs nor their colleagues with whom they have little in common with beyond having to earn money.

Maybe for some, but it's still more choice than you have as a child.

I picked a job/career I knew I could cope with, looked at my earning potential and planned everything else around that because that's what was necessary for my MH needs. It means I don't earn much but I'm happy and no longer struggling to fit into a world that's not built for people with autism and other neuro-diversities.

Adults can also choose how to spend their free time, evenings and weekends and can adapt that to fit their needs whereas state schools are very much a "one size fits all approach".

Libertyqueen · 30/08/2022 09:02

I don’t think it’s any more cult like than any other parenting choice. Less than some baby lead weaning group's
I’ve done both school and home education. I’m also a teacher.
In an objective sense state schools current funding is inadequate and methodology isn’t in line with developmental research. So in that sense I am pretty convinced there is a problem. Whether home education is the solution of course depends hugely on all kinds of factors including your personal resources (mentally, emotionally, physically and financially) as a family.
I’m still on a good few groups and mostly they are supportive of individual choices- it’s really common to be home educating one child and not another. So more parents than you may think do both.

Elleherd · 30/08/2022 09:01

The thing is, I don't disagree with homeschooling because I respect individual choice. But I don't like how 'them and us' it seems to now be with my friend. It's just strange that since she's started homeschooling, she's just changed, friendship wise.

Has anyone else found this with home schooling friends?

No,.
I found that when I was forced into HE, so many local schooling parents literally started cutting us dead on the street. We hadn't changed overnight. My child had done nothing wrong. Just SEN, not getting an education, isolated, and a victim of intense bullying.

He found friendships, communities, a few people he didn't get on with as well, and one he really couldn't stand, through home ed. But having additional time and energy every day he also found a huge range of people outside home ed to converse with and know.
Most of the teachers we met were very positive about HE, a couple came out with the usual tropes.
It was only people with school age children who made a big deal of cold shouldering us because he wasn't being educated the same way as their children.
The sadder thing was years later come exam time when no one had spoken to me for years, I suddenly started being stopped on the street and his results demanded from me. No Hi, how are you? how's the last few years gone? Just What did X get?

After years in a different lane, it did seem awfully competitive, and only one parent had the grace to congratulate him.

Farmmum77 · 30/08/2022 09:01

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 08:56

Some home educators may home educate in a bubble. Just like some school-going parents are in their own little bubble (for example, I know plenty, those who cannot conceive of anything outside their own small existence of 9-5 in the same/similar job that their parents worked, living in the same town and going to the same place for their annual holiday and expecting that their children do the same)

Many home educated children (mine included) have been exposed to far more diverse people than they would have been had they simply gone to their local school which only draws from its local demographic (in my case, white middle class Conservative voters)

My teens' GCSE results exceed the national average for English and Maths and attainment 8. I taught most almost all of them myself. It is very possible and not particularly difficult either, from an academic point of view.
The stress/difficulty of home ed exams often comes from having the sole responsibility and also things beyond your control like exam cancellations, rather than the teaching. (And for some families, there is the stress of expense because home educators have to pay for everything themselves, including exam fees, and of having to organise SEN access arrangements)

They had lab time at a local university and geography fieldwork on the South Coast, they learned how laws are made in the Houses of Parliament and watched a live debate there, held a mock trial at the Royal Courts of Justice, learned about plants and ecology at Kew Gardens, learned about WW2 at the D Day beaches, learned about motors at Silverstone, learned about water and sewage at the sewage works... the list goes on. Plus all the fun stuff like theme parks.
None of this is particularly unusual for home-ed children. And many of these activites were in groups of 30 students.

If home educators are sometimes "righteous" (or even defensive or angry) it might be because they're dealing with the same misconceptions day-in, day-out from people who make narrow-minded assumptions that home educators are socially isolated with only YouTube and study guides to get them through a GCSE.

I don't know about how home educated children in general fare in the real world because there are no large-scale studies in the UK.
Anecdotally, most of the ones I know have gone onto jobs or uni.
There are a couple who haven't but I am not sure of their outcome would have been any different had they gone to school (they have SEN)
Equally, I know unemployed ex-school-children who seem unable to stick at one thing or hold down a job (and, as far as I know, have no SEN) but nobody blames the school (even though that perhaps is the reason).
Why is it that school hasn't failed unemployed school children but home-ed has failed for unemployed home-ed children.

Anyway, I wouldn't say that home education is better, per se, it is just different - horses for courses and all that.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

SleepingAgent · 30/08/2022 08:59

@WobblyWellies OP, you're a teacher and don't know the correct word is "clique" not "click"? Confused

SleeplessInEngland · 30/08/2022 08:57

But isn't the point that, as an adult, you can generally choose.

Well, most adults choose from a limited range of options and economic necessity. I daresay most office workers neither particualrly like their jobs nor their colleagues with whom they have little in common with beyond having to earn money.

Fluffygreenslippers · 30/08/2022 08:56

I always think of two types of people that home school.
One is the vegan, hippy, vaccines are poison type with a compostible toilet. I knew a woman that was home schooled, her father was a vicar. She only sat two gcses and married her boyfriend at 16. She was very nice but also very odd. Hair down to her knees sort of thing.

The other type has a child with complex learning needs or is bullied. I knew of a girl that had severe dyslexia and wasn’t getting the help she needed so her mother home schooled her. From what I could see the mother spent most of her time smoking and drinking tea and occasionally threw a worksheet the daughters way.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 08:56

WifeMotherWorker · 30/08/2022 07:05

YANBU - I agree OP people I know who homeschool are very evangelical and righteous!!
It’s a really bizarre choice to remove children from school, effectively cutting them off from society. School is more than just traditional education, is about socialising and being exposed to lots of different characters and personalities through peer and teacher engagement, learning about structure rules and conformity. How can these parents impart GCSE level information onto their kids, surely it’s all YouTube and study guides, at secondary school pupils have 10+ teachers for all their subjects plus access to all the associated specialist learning facilities and equipment (Science, technology topics etc).
I wonder how these kids will fare in the real world after living in a cult like bubble for their whole childhood!!!

Some home educators may home educate in a bubble. Just like some school-going parents are in their own little bubble (for example, I know plenty, those who cannot conceive of anything outside their own small existence of 9-5 in the same/similar job that their parents worked, living in the same town and going to the same place for their annual holiday and expecting that their children do the same)

Many home educated children (mine included) have been exposed to far more diverse people than they would have been had they simply gone to their local school which only draws from its local demographic (in my case, white middle class Conservative voters)

My teens' GCSE results exceed the national average for English and Maths and attainment 8. I taught most almost all of them myself. It is very possible and not particularly difficult either, from an academic point of view.
The stress/difficulty of home ed exams often comes from having the sole responsibility and also things beyond your control like exam cancellations, rather than the teaching. (And for some families, there is the stress of expense because home educators have to pay for everything themselves, including exam fees, and of having to organise SEN access arrangements)

They had lab time at a local university and geography fieldwork on the South Coast, they learned how laws are made in the Houses of Parliament and watched a live debate there, held a mock trial at the Royal Courts of Justice, learned about plants and ecology at Kew Gardens, learned about WW2 at the D Day beaches, learned about motors at Silverstone, learned about water and sewage at the sewage works... the list goes on. Plus all the fun stuff like theme parks.
None of this is particularly unusual for home-ed children. And many of these activites were in groups of 30 students.

If home educators are sometimes "righteous" (or even defensive or angry) it might be because they're dealing with the same misconceptions day-in, day-out from people who make narrow-minded assumptions that home educators are socially isolated with only YouTube and study guides to get them through a GCSE.

I don't know about how home educated children in general fare in the real world because there are no large-scale studies in the UK.
Anecdotally, most of the ones I know have gone onto jobs or uni.
There are a couple who haven't but I am not sure of their outcome would have been any different had they gone to school (they have SEN)
Equally, I know unemployed ex-school-children who seem unable to stick at one thing or hold down a job (and, as far as I know, have no SEN) but nobody blames the school (even though that perhaps is the reason).
Why is it that school hasn't failed unemployed school children but home-ed has failed for unemployed home-ed children.

Anyway, I wouldn't say that home education is better, per se, it is just different - horses for courses and all that.

Sprogonthetyne · 30/08/2022 08:56

I have a friend from before kids, who decided to home Ed, and through her I've met a group of home edders. The kids are all still quite young and they all decided home Ed from the start, some before the kid was even born, so for this particular group it's ideologically driven not a reaction to kids needs.

I've definitely seen the type of behaviour op describes, and lots of Facebook posts shared about how school is traumatic/ damaging / abusive to children. They're all 'alternative' anti establishment types, and the 'education' seems to be based around unschooling & child interest lead (my opinion is, there is a place for this but 5yo's don't know what there is to be interested in without some input).

When the kids were younger we had quite a lot of overlap with gentle patenting, extended breastfeeding and baby carrying. But they all seem to take things to extreme, so while I stopped the latter 2 at around 2-3 years, a lot of this group are still going at 5+, and their kids seem to be babies in other ways aswell. To the extent DFriends 8yo is at a similar level to my 5yo, while her 5yo is still treated like a toddler and grouped with my 2yo when we meet up.

plantseverywhere · 30/08/2022 08:55

I am not saying there’s not times when home education is a fair option (SEN etc) and I know parents can feel forced out of the education system by very poor support.
I also personally have many criticisms of the education system and the curriculum and I’m a teacher.

However… I definitely think home education can be a result of parents’ anxieties which then shut down a huge, huge part of a child’s life. And I find that incredibly sad. It definitely can be cult-y.

AyBeeCee · 30/08/2022 08:55

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 30/08/2022 08:50

You're a teacher and you write click instead of clique?!

My 1st thought was I hope OP doesn't teach English Confused

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 08:54

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 30/08/2022 08:47

^^ This.

I had similar with NCT friends who were raving about how essential nursery is for 9 month olds and that this was a superior choice than having family/Childminder care. I assumed it was a way of justifying their choice, when in reality, like most things, it's horses for courses and no one way is superior to another.

I think the degree of vehemence for any explanation usually equates to a pack of confidence in the decision taken

Holidaydreamingagain · 30/08/2022 08:53

I absolutely see a place for home education where there are SEN or other issues where a suitable school can’t be found. However, to home educate because your children are too special to go to school, just no.

mountainsunsets · 30/08/2022 08:53

Also, I'm not saying homeschooling is wrong. It isn't wrong, it's alternative choice. But what I am saying, is why be so militant about it?

Because when people feel judged and criticised, they get defensive and feel like they have something to prove.

Look at all the judgement on here - according to most posters, homeschoolers are weirdo anti-vaxxers who are raising their kids in a cult where they'll never learn social skills or how to cope in the real world.

If your parenting choices were constantly bashed and attacked, you'd probably feel pretty defensive and militant too.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 30/08/2022 08:53

I homeschooled my daughter since she was 13 (due to illness & extreme bullying), and I definitely wasn’t in some cult-like clique (in fact, I eschewed all that bollocks).

I’m lucky as I trained as a teacher, and my son’s Dad trained as a secondary English & Drama teacher so DH & I pulled him in to tutor her (not weird, we worked bloody hard for a ‘no animosity’ relationship for the benefit of my son when I met my now DH, even if I wouldn’t piss on my ex if he was on fire).

But we also spent a bloody fortune for online tutoring for the GCSE syllabi with Oxford Learning, lead by my daughter who guided her education (starting all of her GCSEs a year early to boot).

Maybe it’s because I am trained I have a different view of how to home educate whilst still providing an enriched environment for my daughter, rather than go utterly free range like the local home educators do. Not that it’s particularly wrong in anyway of course, but we very much let our daughter lead her home learning experience.

She’s 25 now, and concurrently with her tutoring she spent hours developing her art interests (something she has done since she was old enough to hold a pencil), and at 14 was selling her art worldwide & is now an illustrator who is invited to speak at conferences around the world. Online, as she still is allergic to bloody light, but she’s achieved that all on her own.

It all depends on your children & making the best decisions based on their wants and needs. Some children want to follow a more classic education route (like my daughter), others are more free range. Our local HE group was a bit too free range & looked like an excuse for the parents to do sod all & let their kids rule the roost. And, yeah, it was clique-y & to be honest.

Velvetbee · 30/08/2022 08:52

I’ve been home educating my lot for about 15 years now. I’ve just got to get the youngest one through GCSEs and I’ll be done. The older ones are at college, working full time/doing OU degree and a graduate working full time so they’re doing ok.

Some home educators are militant though this is sometimes because their wider family/friends are very critical and they’re defensive. Some HE parents are aggressively Vegan, some are smug, some are evangelical about their religion, some are managing MH issues for them and their kids. The vast, vast majority are just anxious about doing their best.
I’m sorry your friendship group has changed. They might calm down a bit as time goes on.

Dajeeling · 30/08/2022 08:51

Unless it’s for reasons like serious bullying, serious illness or SEN (and this should be addressed more seriously by the local council for better provision) then I have no time for it whatsoever. It’s an attempt to control your own children in my view- they need to socialise with others their own age (and the same set of 30 kids) and see outside of home/ parents daily. I’ve seen too many aged 7/8 in our area (it’s a hotspot for it, clearly a newish fad) spending all morning in a play gym- you can’t tell me that’s the same as a child who spends the morning doing English and Maths. Their parents tend to be the arrogant type who have been bankrolled by mum and dad and not accomplished much for themselves other than kicking against the privileges they have- not a generalization, very frequent here. Certainly not people I’d want to have sole responsibility for educating me.

ElephantsintheCupboard · 30/08/2022 08:51

When someone talks about "cults" it makes me think if people who are all dressed the same, males often wearing trousers and females skirts.

They all do the same thing at the same time, not much individuality.

If you break the rules there are consequences. For children it might be things like not being allowed out to play, or having to go and speak to the leader of the "cult" .

Children are separated from parents and are taught by selected and specially trained cult members according to a strict schedule set by high ranking cult members.

In a lot of these "cults" people have to ask permission to go to the toilet

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 30/08/2022 08:50

You're a teacher and you write click instead of clique?!

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 30/08/2022 08:47

autienotnaughty · 30/08/2022 08:06

It's like the breast/bottle feeding debate. Why does there have to be a superior?

It's all parents doing their best.

^^ This.

I had similar with NCT friends who were raving about how essential nursery is for 9 month olds and that this was a superior choice than having family/Childminder care. I assumed it was a way of justifying their choice, when in reality, like most things, it's horses for courses and no one way is superior to another.

Holidaydreamingagain · 30/08/2022 08:47

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:07

We are planning to home school our children ( 4 year old DD & 7 month old DS) we are in a very fortunate position to be able to do this as many parents who work full time, wouldn't be able to afford the luxury. I don't see it as a ' cult' or as a opting out of society. In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children. I understand school is a service for the mass population, but my DD will definitely thrive with 1 on 1 teaching and not have to compete with 30 children. It is also to be noted that the smart children in the class don't progress fast enough and they can only learn at the pace of the slowest child. My DD has just turned 4 and is already learning what they teach in year 1( age 5 - 6). I think if you have to time, inclination and resources to teach your children yourself, they will be greater achievers and I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

Proving the OP’s point completely. Your children are too special to go to school.

ElephantsintheCupboard · 30/08/2022 08:43

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 08:39

It's strange how many people have drawn likenesses to veganism. My friend is also vegan and fiercely into animal rights. She hates 'the system' in general. Can this all go with some home ed parents?

Yes, some home educating parents are also vegan

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 08:42

hop321 · 30/08/2022 07:04

Also OP, you're a teacher but spell clique as click?

I've been trying really hard to ignore this. Glad it's not just me...

@hop321 Teachers aren't perfect you know, especially when they're making threads at 12.30am at night due to night feeding a baby! But thank you for pointing that out, I shall now remember it forever all thanks to you 🤣

OP posts:
WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 08:39

It's strange how many people have drawn likenesses to veganism. My friend is also vegan and fiercely into animal rights. She hates 'the system' in general. Can this all go with some home ed parents?

OP posts:
WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 08:36

londonrach · 30/08/2022 08:06

Tbh someone who posting that is struggling and trying to validate what they doing. I have two friends on my Facebook who home school...nothing is mentioned about the home schooling... maybe a photo of experiment or something that's all.

@londonrach I did wonder that. May e my friend is posting loads about home ed on social media because she's insecure about it and needs validation? I don't know? Or maybe it's just a novelty for her atm.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread