Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 09:36

But I don't like how 'them and us' it seems to now be with my friend. It's just strange that since she's started homeschooling, she's just changed, friendship wise.
@WobblyWellies

I suspect your friend is fairly new to home-ed?

Most of us go through a bit of an evangelical period after having made the decision/deregistered (and I agree it is like a sort of self-affirming thing - and it's worse if there's been an issue at the school or some sort of confrontation/challenge with family/friends)
Most of us get over that bit or at least it calms down a lot!

The reality is neither is better, they are just different. However because school is the "norm" and people who don't home-educate view everyone as either hippies, militants, anarchists, religious fundamentalists or political extremists (and to be honest, some of them are - but then, those people exist in the school-going population, too), there's an uphill battle against misconceptions - as clearly demonstrated by some of the posters on this thread.

Most home-educators are fairly normal, but understandably some might be very angry about "the system" if they've spent years trying to get help for their child without result.

Dodosdoingit · 30/08/2022 09:36

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 09:23

That's exactly what I'm planning for my new year 1 class 😂

Go for it! Grin We got cult in yr 1 to do with bonfire night and a confused child.
I wasn't actually having a go at you, more the idea that it can matter when delivering lessons.
Our year 1 teacher got "I been" and "I seen" and cafe pronounced as caf, firmly into ASD child's vocabulary.

Dodosdoingit · 30/08/2022 09:25

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:20

I completely agree. I really like grammar (weirdly) but I generally never correct it in real life. I was making a point because the person I was relying to was saying that the spelling was important, and then made an error.

It’s like when people say the whole “umm you’re a teacher and you can’t spell XYZ???” thing. It’s obnoxious.

Anyway, not the focus of the thread!

I am a poorly educated berk who wasn't taught grammar at all, and actually appreciate being corrected. But I do expect a teacher to be able to use the basic right word for something they are discussing.

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 09:24

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:20

I completely agree. I really like grammar (weirdly) but I generally never correct it in real life. I was making a point because the person I was relying to was saying that the spelling was important, and then made an error.

It’s like when people say the whole “umm you’re a teacher and you can’t spell XYZ???” thing. It’s obnoxious.

Anyway, not the focus of the thread!

Yes sorry - I possibly should have quoted the previously quoted post. Your correction made me smile!

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 09:23

Dodosdoingit · 30/08/2022 09:11

Well it will if her lesson, like this post, is on clique's and cults.

That's exactly what I'm planning for my new year 1 class 😂

OP posts:
Thesearmsofmine · 30/08/2022 09:22

Just like any other part of life cliques can form in home ed. You also find cliques at the school gates or inside classrooms, people are drawn to others similar to themselves.

Again like anything else you will have people who are evangelical about home educating in the same way some on here insist school is the only correct way to educate a child. Most people are somewhere in the middle and can acknowledge that there can be benefits to both.

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:20

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 09:17

An excellent example of how correcting grammar and spelling within a thread tends to make the correcting poster look like a bit of a berk.

I completely agree. I really like grammar (weirdly) but I generally never correct it in real life. I was making a point because the person I was relying to was saying that the spelling was important, and then made an error.

It’s like when people say the whole “umm you’re a teacher and you can’t spell XYZ???” thing. It’s obnoxious.

Anyway, not the focus of the thread!

Libertyqueen · 30/08/2022 09:20

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 09:15

But any career may involve working with people who are vastly different to you.

Adults can also choose how to spend their free time, evenings and weekends and can adapt that to fit their needs whereas state schools are very much a "one size fits all approach". But don’t require attendance 24/7?

My job is much easier than secondary school ever was. That’s true for many, many people I would think. I did really well at school but hated being cold, being constantly told what to do and the constant noise.
I do a job I mostly enjoy. I realise that’s a privilege but it’s also true for many people. Finding work easier than school I’d guess is more common for neurodiverse people who may have particular skills and interests, as well as particular challenges. Working life does allow you to play to your strengths.

Dodosdoingit · 30/08/2022 09:17

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:14

*cliques

Thank you. Smile

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 09:17

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:14

*cliques

An excellent example of how correcting grammar and spelling within a thread tends to make the correcting poster look like a bit of a berk.

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 09:16

I’d love to see the stats on how many home educated children get 9 good GCSEs, 3 top A Levels and who go on to good universities.

How about stats on the mental health of home educated children v school educated? Suicide rates?? Or just good GCSEs...

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 09:15

mountainsunsets · 30/08/2022 09:03

Maybe for some, but it's still more choice than you have as a child.

I picked a job/career I knew I could cope with, looked at my earning potential and planned everything else around that because that's what was necessary for my MH needs. It means I don't earn much but I'm happy and no longer struggling to fit into a world that's not built for people with autism and other neuro-diversities.

Adults can also choose how to spend their free time, evenings and weekends and can adapt that to fit their needs whereas state schools are very much a "one size fits all approach".

But any career may involve working with people who are vastly different to you.

Adults can also choose how to spend their free time, evenings and weekends and can adapt that to fit their needs whereas state schools are very much a "one size fits all approach". But don’t require attendance 24/7?

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:14

Dodosdoingit · 30/08/2022 09:11

Well it will if her lesson, like this post, is on clique's and cults.

*cliques

SleeplessInEngland · 30/08/2022 09:14

mountainsunsets · 30/08/2022 09:03

Maybe for some, but it's still more choice than you have as a child.

I picked a job/career I knew I could cope with, looked at my earning potential and planned everything else around that because that's what was necessary for my MH needs. It means I don't earn much but I'm happy and no longer struggling to fit into a world that's not built for people with autism and other neuro-diversities.

Adults can also choose how to spend their free time, evenings and weekends and can adapt that to fit their needs whereas state schools are very much a "one size fits all approach".

I think you're labouring the point a bit. Yes, school and work aren't exactly the same but most people work because they have to and would rather not be - having a choice between a few unenjoyable jobs doesn't change that.

Of course some people like their jobs, but then some people like school too.

OperaStation · 30/08/2022 09:14

Morph22010 · 30/08/2022 07:15

I’m not sure a formal study would give the true picture anyway, as it’s like the arguement that la’s always use when trying to argue against specialist that children perform better in mainstream schools than specialist schools! Of course they do as mainstream school are full of kids without Sen so statistically their results will obviously look better. Home Ed won’t be the same mix of kids as a mainstream so won’t be comparable, needs to be looked at on an individual basis which is impossible.

It would be very easy to do a study that was accurate. You would take kids from similar socioeconomic backgrounds, similar levels of educational attainment for the parents, you would correct for any SEN and you would give them the same test under the same conditions. The difficulty would be getting a large enough sample size. Similar studies have already been carried out in the US but the sample size is small.

parentingscience.com/homeschooling-outcomes/

Theh found a huge difference in outcomes for structured versus unstructured home schooling.

VestaTilley · 30/08/2022 09:14

Agree. I think it’s a recipe for disaster - it’s all about what the parent wants, and it can be easy for vulnerable and abused children to then slip under the radar.

I have every sympathy for people doing it if their children have SEN needs that aren’t being met, or if their child is badly bullied etc and other schools aren’t working, but I don’t think you can provide a good quality education without being a qualified teacher or subject specialist.

I’d love to see the stats on how many home educated children get 9 good GCSEs, 3 top A Levels and who go on to good universities.

Lilylizard · 30/08/2022 09:13

Maybe they want their children to spell clique properly 😂

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 09:12

@DobbyHasASock 👏🏻❤️

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 09:11

Morph22010 · 30/08/2022 07:15

I’m not sure a formal study would give the true picture anyway, as it’s like the arguement that la’s always use when trying to argue against specialist that children perform better in mainstream schools than specialist schools! Of course they do as mainstream school are full of kids without Sen so statistically their results will obviously look better. Home Ed won’t be the same mix of kids as a mainstream so won’t be comparable, needs to be looked at on an individual basis which is impossible.

Schools have to submit statistics on SEND pupils, too.

If the statistics were analysed properly, the results would take into account SEND.
Although I concede that this probably would not help the likely scenario of people quoting "headline statistics" as comparison.

However, I also don't think it's massively helpful to go around saying that home-ed has better outcomes when nobody has actually proved that in the UK to any great extent. Rothermel's study is quite old and the sample was self-selecting to a degree.

Dodosdoingit · 30/08/2022 09:11

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:06

Yes, this particular, not often-used spelling will definitely impact her ability to deliver the curriculum!

Well it will if her lesson, like this post, is on clique's and cults.

AntlerRose · 30/08/2022 09:08

Nekomata · 30/08/2022 01:41

I think it can be really isolating for parents who home educate, so they look for friends who are in a similar situation. People can be very judgmental about HE, so I imagine they are just trying to be positive about the experience.

I think this. They are probably trying to re-inforce their own decision making in moments of doubt.

I also think its very normal to bond with people who are in the same boat if you are outside of the norm. Its a common interest, like getting a group of harley davidson drivers together.

My experience of homeschool is through the sen world, where many of us are forced into it for a year or so whilst we wait for a school place or even permanently as no place exists. Generally pissed off about the whole thing, nut positive articles sort of reassure us.

CherryGenoa · 30/08/2022 09:08

Some people are forced to home school temporarily whilst they try to get a place in a setting that will accommodate their child’s complex needs. I know several families in this position and it was stressful for all concerned, not least because it is expensive to have only one parent in paid work.

I also know a couple of families who actively chose to home educate. I recognise elements of the OP and the hippy vibe with one. With the other, the family is very religious and they wanted to work Jesus into the entire curriculum.

DobbyHasASock · 30/08/2022 09:07

I think your premise absolutely lacks nuance op.

Many have mentioned Sen. I'm surprised as a teacher you haven't come across children you just couldn't provide for. I know I have, mainly just due to having thirty other children of different needs to consider at the same time.
My son is likely Sen. Not school age yet. But having seen the damage a school who can't provide to Sen can do I'm absolutely bricking it that if have to home school. I'm a qualified teacher and have a lot of 'specialist' friends I could call on later, but I think you'd have to have a good combination of confidence and knowledge to feel secure in your homeschool decision, and I lack the former. However, recognising the damage that can be done if a child is in the wrong environment I'd still absolutely do it. Same goes for bullying. There's a lot of research that shows that bullying can have long-term implications for esteem, trauma and brain development.
I also think that teaching itself is a skill that is acquired, not gained. Nqts with Qts are no way educated enough to teach, most of their craft I'd learned along the way and some teachers are arrogant so never learn this.
So by the same vein, they'll be some home schoolers who are so arrogant they never adapt their practice and they'll be some that become very skilled and adaptive.
Lastly op, if you work with children you must know every one is different and sadly one size does not fit all.

Oh and I'm vegan as well btw. Bash away.

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:06

SleepingAgent · 30/08/2022 08:59

@WobblyWellies OP, you're a teacher and don't know the correct word is "clique" not "click"? Confused

Yes, this particular, not often-used spelling will definitely impact her ability to deliver the curriculum!

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 09:03

Glad at least a few people mention parents home educating out of necessity rather than 'luxury'. OP your very narrow and judgemental view is surprising if you're a teacher! ...or maybe it's not, I swear some teachers must walk around with their eyes closed. You have no idea why people keep their kids at home. Yes maybe they're in a cult, or maybe school traumatised their children. Maybe they just don't want to hand their kids over to the education system and hope for the best! My kids are at school and I'm grateful for that, but if they needed to be at home, I would keep them at home. It wouldn't be a luxury, it would be really really hard. Just think before you post shit like this. A lot more people will see it than the 5 families or whatever that you are describing 🙄