Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
BoxOf · 30/08/2022 11:38

Chillicheesebites · 30/08/2022 11:25

I home educate. We are not a privileged family, we live on a council estate and my husband works a minimum wage job.
The main reason I home educate is actually my own school education, my children deserve better.
We have incredibly low standards for teachers in this country, in some countries it is harder to become a teacher than a doctor. Here for many it is the back up because they messed up their degree.
I feel let down by education, so I follow curriculums which hold my hand a little. They have far more opportunities than they would in school. Including foreign languages, instruments, art etc. They are not housed, we do school 4 mornings a week and at 7 and 5, it never takes the full morning. They are leaps ahead of their school educated friends and family.

Also I feel it is a bit unnatural on a primal level, school is a relatively new thing.

I don't feel schools are really safe for girls, I think the statistic is 1 girl is raped at school every day.

They mix with home and school educated children and have no issues socially. They go to clubs with school educated children where some do struggle socially. School clearly isn't a magical place to raise well rounded kids. Some children who go to school struggle too, it isn't a home educated thing.

There are some cult-like vibes in the unschooling community near me so I tend not to mix with them. I went to a group once where there were lots of unschoolers and they certainly looked down on me for doing formal work. For the most part is normal people just trying to do the best by their children.

Yes we have issues and are judged because we do formal work and work towards gcses

Snoozer11 · 30/08/2022 11:38

Farmmum77 · 30/08/2022 11:35

My son went to a selective grammar school and was taught history by a pe teacher with no qualifications in history when the history teacher left….

To be fair, you don't really need a specialist skillset to teach something like history, other than an ability to read and use a search engine.

Something like maths, English, the sciences, languages etc are the subjects where you need specialist teachers.

Farmmum77 · 30/08/2022 11:35

RunningSME · 30/08/2022 11:33

Oh bless you, do you honestly believe that children in schools have specialist maths teachers and specialist language teachers and specialist science teachers available to them on a daily basis?
we pulled our son from the top performing Academy because he didn’t have four out of the five course subjects teachers at all. Cover supervisors I believe they called them.

My son went to a selective grammar school and was taught history by a pe teacher with no qualifications in history when the history teacher left….

RunningSME · 30/08/2022 11:33

Creativecrafts · 30/08/2022 01:55

Your daughter is only 4 at the moment. I understand how you can teach her when she is young, but how are you going to cope when she's a teenager? Are you able to teach maths, sciences, languages, to GCSE and A level standards? Won't she need specialist teachers for those subjects?

Oh bless you, do you honestly believe that children in schools have specialist maths teachers and specialist language teachers and specialist science teachers available to them on a daily basis?
we pulled our son from the top performing Academy because he didn’t have four out of the five course subjects teachers at all. Cover supervisors I believe they called them.

Chillicheesebites · 30/08/2022 11:25

I home educate. We are not a privileged family, we live on a council estate and my husband works a minimum wage job.
The main reason I home educate is actually my own school education, my children deserve better.
We have incredibly low standards for teachers in this country, in some countries it is harder to become a teacher than a doctor. Here for many it is the back up because they messed up their degree.
I feel let down by education, so I follow curriculums which hold my hand a little. They have far more opportunities than they would in school. Including foreign languages, instruments, art etc. They are not housed, we do school 4 mornings a week and at 7 and 5, it never takes the full morning. They are leaps ahead of their school educated friends and family.

Also I feel it is a bit unnatural on a primal level, school is a relatively new thing.

I don't feel schools are really safe for girls, I think the statistic is 1 girl is raped at school every day.

They mix with home and school educated children and have no issues socially. They go to clubs with school educated children where some do struggle socially. School clearly isn't a magical place to raise well rounded kids. Some children who go to school struggle too, it isn't a home educated thing.

There are some cult-like vibes in the unschooling community near me so I tend not to mix with them. I went to a group once where there were lots of unschoolers and they certainly looked down on me for doing formal work. For the most part is normal people just trying to do the best by their children.

ElephantsintheCupboard · 30/08/2022 11:24

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 10:44

its a bit of a minefield for child protection issues

Sigh...

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 11:23

As I said home education is not better just different.

Much of the arguments seem to stem from one side or the other trying to insist that their way is better.

If everyone would just calm down and accept that others are entitled to do things differently, these arguments would not occur.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 11:22

Adventur3time · 30/08/2022 10:58

I home educated until I became too ill to continue, and I completely agree.

I met hundreds of other home ed parents and the vast majority were anti-vaxxers, most of them also anti-covid nuts. Everyone was in uproar if someone from the local education department dared to check in on them once a year (encouraging each other to ignore them, DO NOT let them in, there's no legal requirement, don't show them ANYTHING etc). It was very heavily implied that people who sent their kids to school didn't care about their kids enough, just wanted to send them away so that they didn't have to deal with them. The MC mums were always vegan and very condescending about it. They'd all get really petty and territorial in the school holidays, complaining that all the 'muggles' were invading the parks and family attractions. And they'd always talk about their other friends who sent their kids to school, about how sorry they felt for their kids and spend a lot of time bashing public schools.

I do think that there's a lot of serious flaws with the school system, and there's a lot of kids who struggle with school and would be better off not going if their parents are in a position to home educate them. But yeah, it's definitely very cult-ish and holier than thou.

(There were plenty of nice, normal people who didn't buy into this crap and just got on with things of course, but these were definitely in the minority where I am)

I do agree that there are plenty of anti-vaxxers in home-ed. But there are also plenty of people who went the other way, during covid.
Actually I found it a bit stressful trying not to offend one side or the other (not just in home-ed), generally during covid because everyone on all sides got a bit angry, shall we say.

I do know of someone who said "bad mummy" to someone whose child went into school... that was weird.

The LA reports/meetings are a whole topic to themselves. But there is a section of home-educators, encouraged by ex-home-educators who are very militant about LA dealings. Personally, I disagree with all of that nonsense. There's plenty of reasons why you might engage positively with your LA.

I used to call people on "school-bashing", it's unnecessary and pretty futile since it doesn't really solve anything. There's actually plenty of families who have some in and some out of school, and plenty fighting to get back in, so it's actually quite rude, imho.

There is a certain self-affirming thing (generally strongest in new home-educators - because deregistering is a really big decision and I get that).
But generally beyond that, home-educators who think they've achieved some kind of sainthood simply because they're home-educating - well that's all a bit cringey, as is the word "muggles" in relation to school-goers (although I actually think "sheeple" is far worse)

I do think it is a bonus being able to go to places during term time, though.

Trying20 · 30/08/2022 11:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 30/08/2022 11:20

sadaboutfriendship · 30/08/2022 09:20

I completely agree. I really like grammar (weirdly) but I generally never correct it in real life. I was making a point because the person I was relying to was saying that the spelling was important, and then made an error.

It’s like when people say the whole “umm you’re a teacher and you can’t spell XYZ???” thing. It’s obnoxious.

Anyway, not the focus of the thread!

I'm a teacher and also dyslexic , there are threads now I just won't reply on including this one , I'm fascinated by home education. I just know anytime u mention ur a teacher and I will definitely make grammar and spelling mistakes , I get riped to pieces, so won't put myself through it.

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 11:20

I find a lot of home schooling parents by choice have very outdated ideas of schools.

Again, not a homeschooling parent. One kid comes home with a 'phonics superstar' sticker regularly, the other comes home and tells me 'I was on a final warning today' (traffic light system, so red I'm assuming on the chart of shame)

& fair enough @antelopevalley but I think context is important here. I have had to ask someone in similar situations but not for permission, just to cover!

zingally · 30/08/2022 11:13

YABU. You're a teacher (as am I), and you feel defensive. I do as well, when I feel like someone is criticising something they don't really know anything about. Unfortunately, everyone feels like they are an expert on schools and education, because they went through the system. But it's very different on the other side!

And it's clique, not click. ;)

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 11:12

Biscuitsneeded · 30/08/2022 10:39

’I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children’

Better for whom? Children need to interact with other children.

But that's not the reason tp send them to school

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 11:08

Maybe you just haven't experienced schooling recently

I have. In more than one setting too. However I'm glad to hear you haven't experienced it.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 11:07

PonyTime · 30/08/2022 11:05

Most schools don't use sticker charts and shaming for this very reason

Maybe you just haven't experienced schooling recently

I find a lot of home schooling parents by choice have very outdated ideas of schools.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 11:06

@ILiveInAmphibia I am well aware there are plenty of minimum wage jobs where you do not have to ask permission to go to the toilet. But I have done jobs where you have to and it is not as simple as advocating for yourself. Working on a factory production line you can not just walk away from the line. Working in a nursery covering the outside area, I could not just walk away and go inside to the toilet. Working as a tram conductor I could not just walk away off the tram and go to the toilet.
Minimum wage jobs in offices are those you can go to the toilet at anytime unless your boss is a wanker. But lots of lower paid jobs are designed so that you can not just walk away to the toilet when you want to.

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 11:05

Just to add (again) my kids are in school. It's a good school and I'm grateful they are happy there. However I know there are issues with education and I'm hyper aware one of my kids might not stay happy in school. I wish things in the system overall would change to accommodate more children but I don't think they will. My kids mental health and well-being will always come first over grades.

PonyTime · 30/08/2022 11:05

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 10:54

@SleeplessInEngland yes they are! However they are very different kinds of control. We don't get a sticker for doing our tax return or publicly shamed* for not doing it. Whilst we're at it, preparing kids for these types of adult 'controls' should be taught more in school! I had no idea how to successfully live in the adult world when I couldn't depend on my parents anymore and I was 23!!

*I'm referring to behaviour charts here and I don't care if you all think I'm dramatic - it is public shaming!

Most schools don't use sticker charts and shaming for this very reason

Maybe you just haven't experienced schooling recently

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 11:03

I didn’t think Home Ed kids sit in a cage and never go out - but was wondering how you get the exposure to other people outside of your “immediate” bubble.
From what you’ve said, if I’m honest, sounds like you had a great upbringing - surrounded by other middle class kids. And I think that’s the point I was getting at.
@Trying20

Why do people think that home-educators only mix with people from their own socio-economic background?

My children's home-ed friends ranged from working class single parents to middle class Oxbridge families. They also had friends of different religions (well, we're not religious, so any religion would be different, I suppose) and different ethnicities and cultural backgrounds.

Home-education is not limited to one demographic.

It isn't only middle-class parents who home-educate. There are plenty of people on benefits and/or are single parents who are home-educating, too.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 11:02

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 10:54

@SleeplessInEngland yes they are! However they are very different kinds of control. We don't get a sticker for doing our tax return or publicly shamed* for not doing it. Whilst we're at it, preparing kids for these types of adult 'controls' should be taught more in school! I had no idea how to successfully live in the adult world when I couldn't depend on my parents anymore and I was 23!!

*I'm referring to behaviour charts here and I don't care if you all think I'm dramatic - it is public shaming!

It sounds like your parents did not bring you up to be independent.
We get punishments as adults not rewards. So fines if we do not do our tax return.

ILiveInAmphibia · 30/08/2022 11:01

Plenty of workers do have to ask their boss if they can go to the toilet.
Middle-class people though will not have to.

Sorry but it's nothing to do with class, it's just who you work for. There are plenty of minimum wage jobs (if that's what you're implying) where you can go to the toilet of your own free will. I'm in one of them. If children were given more autonomy in school then maybe they would advocate for themselves if they found themselves in shitty working conditions!! See the problem?! You're taught you need permission to pee then you accept that as an adult. Actually that's not ok. Just because it happens (I know it does) - doesn't make it ok!!

WhereshouldIgo · 30/08/2022 11:01

There’s a big home schooling movement in our town, and from the ones I’ve dealt with there’s definitely a bit of smugness and a desire to ‘convert’ others. From what I’ve seen though, the kids aren’t any better off than schooled ones - a bit worse off when it comes to socially interaction…

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 11:00

And you can work and have children home-schooled. I know parents that work full time and leave their teenage children home alone to "home school".
You can also get childcare tax credits to help pay for childcare while you work and try to homeschool in the evenings and at weekends.
I am not advocating this, but it is what some people do.

Adventur3time · 30/08/2022 10:58

I home educated until I became too ill to continue, and I completely agree.

I met hundreds of other home ed parents and the vast majority were anti-vaxxers, most of them also anti-covid nuts. Everyone was in uproar if someone from the local education department dared to check in on them once a year (encouraging each other to ignore them, DO NOT let them in, there's no legal requirement, don't show them ANYTHING etc). It was very heavily implied that people who sent their kids to school didn't care about their kids enough, just wanted to send them away so that they didn't have to deal with them. The MC mums were always vegan and very condescending about it. They'd all get really petty and territorial in the school holidays, complaining that all the 'muggles' were invading the parks and family attractions. And they'd always talk about their other friends who sent their kids to school, about how sorry they felt for their kids and spend a lot of time bashing public schools.

I do think that there's a lot of serious flaws with the school system, and there's a lot of kids who struggle with school and would be better off not going if their parents are in a position to home educate them. But yeah, it's definitely very cult-ish and holier than thou.

(There were plenty of nice, normal people who didn't buy into this crap and just got on with things of course, but these were definitely in the minority where I am)

Marvellousmadness · 30/08/2022 10:58

Academically i think home schooling can have significant results
Socially??? Jezus... Socially the kids will fail . Epically.
School isn't just about academics. And if you think you can teach your kids better than your teacher can ? Tutor them yourself after school time. But don't rob such important social skills from your kids. They will stand out like a sore thumb. They way you can always spot an only child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread