Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
tobee · 30/08/2022 14:40

"If I don’t think school is the reality of later life either. No where else in later life I can think of where you put 30 plus completely different people together for 6 hours a day and expect them to get on and I’m not an advocate of home schooling"

Well you don't expect them to "get on". You hope to give them the tools to work out how to co exist.

Also you could argue that if most children have been to school and they meet up later on than they both have that as a reality of their previous life so everyone has experience with dealing with co existing with others iyswim.

I don't think mainstream school is brilliant in every way but I can't see how you can truthfully argue that your children are mixing with a wide range of children that haven't selected through some common hobby or interest, or because they're other home schoolers. Plus I think school also introduces children to a wide range of adults to interact with.

Booklover3 · 30/08/2022 14:39

Ahh quite damning views on home educating.

We never ever thought we would home educate until our children were pretending to be sick every day because they didn’t want to go to school. It was an awful time. One of our children in particular was becoming a shadow of herself. Completely lost her love of learning. So sad.

I’d been into the school multiple times but nothing ever changed. Every time we complained things would settle down for a few weeks and then the bullying would start again. She was 7 at the time.

Its bloody hard work home educating (and trying to work also) but it was what was best for our children. They are free to return to school whenever they choose. It would be easier for me if they did!

There must be more people like me who are trying to do the best they can. We are quietly getting on with it.

I don’t believe that home education is best. I don’t believe that school is the best way either. I think children are individuals and all have different needs. As a parent all you can do is try to do your best for them to meet those needs.

I generally don’t volunteer the information that we home educate because of the judgement I receive. It’s perfectly illustrated on this thread.

pawkins · 30/08/2022 14:36

SeaToSki · 30/08/2022 13:10

I ended up home schooling my youngest (aged 12 at the time) through covid as I am CEV and we couldnt risk her going to school daily until I was vaccinated. My older ones were at boarding school and so we managed them into and out of my bubble.

We decided to home school, rather than use her school’s online curriculum and teachers (which were available) as she had tried that for the last part of the 2019 school year and found it immensley frustrating at it went at the speed of the slowest child and since there were unlimited opportunities for children to not listen, then the speed of the class was glacial. I found a online provider that we could pick and choose classes from and then we worked up a timetable from there with a mixture of online academics, arts, sports and more classic home ed parent taught stuff.

What we discovered was that she thrived academically being able to move at her own speed. That some classes she was self driven and motivated and could work with just the online material and would research and follow independently. Other classes she needed some one on one tutoring to keep her jogging along. She finished the school year requirements by Feb ish and by June had finished 3 school years worth of work in Spanish, in math had done 2 school years of work, realized she hated biology and loved history and creative writing. She learned to play the flute and discovered lots of art and crafts skills using outschool.com. She was able to do a few outdoor sports that were more individual. But she became quite lonely as her friends from her old school just dropped her despite our efforts to keep the friendships going outside and over zoom.

She is now back at a new school (we moved) and is loving the social side but is using after school time to push academically as she find that the academics in school are still too slow in many subjects.

So my experience of online schooling is that it does allow you to customise for your child. Not surprisingly that is helpful in allowing your child to progress specifically where they need or want to. It also needs careful monitoring so that they dont miss out on a fully rounded experience and I dont doubt that (covid excepted) extensive socialising is as possible with home schooling as with ordinary schooling. As with everything in life, when something is done carefully and thoughtfully it can be an enriching and rewarding experience, when it is done slapdash and for the wrong reasons then it can be detrimental.

I’d really appreciate if you could share where she had her online tutoring? I use outschool sometimes but it’s hit and miss for us. I’m interested in getting extra help for one of my children in particular. Thanks in advance!

RidingMyBike · 30/08/2022 14:23

For one of my home ed friends she seems unaware of what school is like now and bases her views (which she posts about on SM) on being at primary school in the 80s and a lot of stuff she's been told by other home ed people. She half-heartedly viewed a couple of primaries for her eldest, but then didn't apply because she didn't approve of their discipline expectations - which sounded just like the usual, fresh start every day approach.

I'm a similar age and my DD's primary bears little relation to my 80s primary - the lessons are inspiring and fun, the teacher is brilliant, there is a strong emphasis on creativity and art. She learnt to read fluently by end of Year 1 and really enjoyed how they learned how to do this. She likes the school dinners. PE/Games actually sounds fun rather than the misery we endured. And it's only a 'good' state primary serving an area with a higher than average number of pupils getting free school meals.

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 14:09

I think home ed does change as children get older. Most home ed people I know decide to send their 11+ children to alternative ed settings part of the week. We are quite lucky in having Montessori and project based learning schools in my area where kids attend 2/3 days a week. There are also traditional forest schools offering days. Also the local college offers GCSE provision for home ed kids and work placements at 14. For many home ed parents there comes a time where the kids need a separate, group learning space and they will send them there. Often the kids have had a really bad school experience before home ed, so the parents take time to prepare them for return to classroom type environments with 1-1 learning and building self esteem first. Many home ed kids look up to people like Billie Eilish, Thomas Edison, Margaret Atwood, Yehudi Menhuin etc who were substantially home educated, among others. There's a very long list of successful home ed people who serve as inspiration.

xippo · 30/08/2022 13:18

GeorgiaGirl52 · 30/08/2022 02:51

I worked for 30 years in a public (state) school and educated my three children in private (religious) schools. I have met and interacted with many home-schooling parents and can say this with some assurance.

  1. There are parents who want their children to believe only what they believe and not be exposed to different ideas.
  2. There are parents who don't want the bother of getting up and getting their children to school at a certain time every day.
  3. There are parents who are anti-vaxxers and won't comply with state laws.
  4. There are parents who are paranoid or highly anxious who are convinced that their children are in physical danger if they are out of sight.
  5. There are very few parents who have the intelligence, the commitment and the ability to teach children properly. Those who do realize that the
purpose of school is also socialization and teaching children that they do not always have power of choice, and must conform to other timetables.

this

ElephantsintheCupboard · 30/08/2022 13:17

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 11:51

abusive parents keep their kids at home on purpose you do realise @ElephantsintheCupboard

No, home education is not a safe guarding issue. It's a perfect legal choice, the legal default .

Obviously it would be easier to hide abuse if you didn't send your child to school and kept them at home all the time. But many children are abused at school. Or they are abused at home but nobody at school finds out about it or does anything about it . If there's any evidence that proves your statement "abusive parents keep their kids at home on purpose" I would like to see it please.

SeaToSki · 30/08/2022 13:10

I ended up home schooling my youngest (aged 12 at the time) through covid as I am CEV and we couldnt risk her going to school daily until I was vaccinated. My older ones were at boarding school and so we managed them into and out of my bubble.

We decided to home school, rather than use her school’s online curriculum and teachers (which were available) as she had tried that for the last part of the 2019 school year and found it immensley frustrating at it went at the speed of the slowest child and since there were unlimited opportunities for children to not listen, then the speed of the class was glacial. I found a online provider that we could pick and choose classes from and then we worked up a timetable from there with a mixture of online academics, arts, sports and more classic home ed parent taught stuff.

What we discovered was that she thrived academically being able to move at her own speed. That some classes she was self driven and motivated and could work with just the online material and would research and follow independently. Other classes she needed some one on one tutoring to keep her jogging along. She finished the school year requirements by Feb ish and by June had finished 3 school years worth of work in Spanish, in math had done 2 school years of work, realized she hated biology and loved history and creative writing. She learned to play the flute and discovered lots of art and crafts skills using outschool.com. She was able to do a few outdoor sports that were more individual. But she became quite lonely as her friends from her old school just dropped her despite our efforts to keep the friendships going outside and over zoom.

She is now back at a new school (we moved) and is loving the social side but is using after school time to push academically as she find that the academics in school are still too slow in many subjects.

So my experience of online schooling is that it does allow you to customise for your child. Not surprisingly that is helpful in allowing your child to progress specifically where they need or want to. It also needs careful monitoring so that they dont miss out on a fully rounded experience and I dont doubt that (covid excepted) extensive socialising is as possible with home schooling as with ordinary schooling. As with everything in life, when something is done carefully and thoughtfully it can be an enriching and rewarding experience, when it is done slapdash and for the wrong reasons then it can be detrimental.

Farmmum77 · 30/08/2022 13:01

@Hoowhoowho maybe your problem isn’t home educators but your friend constantly trying to convert you to her latest cause, how many other home educators do you know?

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 12:49

Hoowhoowho · 30/08/2022 12:09

My experience is that the home education community is quite divided.

A large group consists of parents of children with additional needs, usually but not always ASD who end up removing their children after schools fail then. There are key times when children sink and you see the patterns if you hang in home education communities long enough. The saddest imo are the large numbers that end up home educating in Year 10/11 after their child finally just won’t go to school anymore. This group are often raging about schools, resistant to the LA, their very negative experiences of the system play out for years after they’ve left.

Another group are the alternatives, the anti vax, breastfeeding forever, baby wearing sorts for whom home education is just another item on the ticklist of alternative parenting. Some of them are fairly mild, some full on cult, freeman of the land, flat earth sorts. This group are anti system in general and indeed they post the anti school memes between the anti vax ones on Facebook.

Then there is a small but persistent group of philosophical home educators. They often decided years before they had children that they would home educate. Their objections to the system are long standing but often they’re not otherwise particularly alternative. They tend to be parents who are themselves neurodiverse and had poor experiences of school. They also rely heavily on evidence. They’re not likely to be anti vax or flat earth sorts. This group will engage with the LA but only the minimum that is required generally,

Then there are the little groups
Religious home educators- small group in the UK but definitely exist, generally evangelical Christians or Muslims. Many but not all are more insular, tending not to attend non religious home Ed groups

The academics. This lot believe they can give a better traditional education to their kids than schools can. They tend to look down on other sorts of home educators although they do socialise with them and they mostly engage with the LA including permitting home visits.

The misfits- lots of reasons from waiting for a desired school place, to delaying school entry etc.

Then among the groups, you get more divisions between the full on academics, the electics, the unschoolers, the radical unschoolers.

Home education isn’t a cult because it has so many internal divisions.

@Hoowhoowho I really liked reading your comment and I think you've summed it up well. My friend (and friends linked to her) are definitely 'alternatives' in all the ways you've mentioned. I don't have a problem with any of these things at all but I don't like the fact my friend is being so militant. Thinking about it, she does the same with veganism and breastfeeding on social media.

OP posts:
Lunabun · 30/08/2022 12:49

@Wouldloveanother well I don't know do I? I didn't interrogate her. She was just someone I had something to do with professionally for some time.

Though to be perfectly honest, when I described her as well-accomplished, that was probably downplaying it a little. Due to her position and the inevitable nepotism that follows, no I don't imagine for a second that her children are ever going to struggle for work.

JeminaPuddlegoose · 30/08/2022 12:47

I'm honestly so conflicted.

I used to tutor for a HE organisation and the parents were without exception caring and invested in their child's well-being, and at the end of their tether by being failed by mainstream school. I think more or less every child either had SEN or physical illness meaning they couldn't thrive in mainstream school. (Of course, by definition, parents who choose to sign their children up for a structured educational course taught by a teacher are not going to be the hardcore antivax 'keep my children away from all that' type, or the neglectful type.)

On the other hand, my legal guardian pretended to home educate me as a cover for serious abuse and neglect, which was facilitated by total lack of any checks or safeguarding at all.

I've discussed my experiences several times on MN and every single time I get my arse handed to me, and am greeted with extreme hostility and basically people minimising or making up excuses for what I went through (like playing the "but kids who go to school get abused too" card, or confidently but VERY wrongly stating "there's not a single case of an abused HE child who wasn't previously known to social services", or again confidently but very wrongly stating "but HE children go out and are seen by lots of people eg dentists who can perform the same safeguarding duties as teachers, and if a child wasn't being regularly seen by a dentist and doctor that would be a safeguarding flag and someone would call SS" - the point is only HE kids from loving families do these things; kids being HE as a cover for abuse are not going to be joining HE groups or taken out, and a teenager not being seen by a dentist or GP regularly would certainly not be a flag for SS - who would even know if a teen was going to the dentist regularly??)

Some posters have just blatantly had the attitude "I would be happy for a child to be abused if it means I don't have to tolerate any intrusion into my rights over my child, I wouldn't tolerate even a once a year check I don't give a shit if it saves children from abuse."

That kind of attitude is terrying.

10HailMarys · 30/08/2022 12:43

Homeschooling - fine.

Going on smugly all the time about how homeschooling is so much better than school and how your homeschooled children are so much happier and more well-adjusted and well-educated than children who go to school - not fine.

Moonface123 · 30/08/2022 12:34

HS was the best choice for my younger son, eldest son sailed through school no problems. Deregistered son age 13, he then organised and managed his own education, no outside help or online schooling, the information is all online, free. He sat exams as a private candidate and achieved really high grades. Now 17, been working part time for a year, a longside studying A levels. The self discipline and motivation he has acquired filters through all aspects of his life, re his fitness, diet, wellbeing etc. His mental health is very good, he is confident and articulate.
Alot of HE students have brothers and sisters that attend main stream school, and they do mix with all kinds of other children/teens, some of them have attended school at some stage.
There is no comparision between covid HS and HE. De schooling plays an essential part to the success of HE.
I felt a great deal of unwarranted judgement when l took my son out of school due to MH issues, so it is a huge relief and all credit to my son, (l am a lone widowed parent, l had to carry on working) that he made it work.

Wouldloveanother · 30/08/2022 12:28

Are they going to work for her too when they get older @Lunabun ? Does she keep the protective bubble of weird going forever?

Lunabun · 30/08/2022 12:23

Wallywobbles · 30/08/2022 06:39

I traveled in my late 20s with a guy that had been homeschooled by his lawyer mother. He was very interesting and very bright but socially awkward and a smidgen odd. Home schooled til Alevels.

I also have an American friend, the middle of 3 daughter, part of a very Christian group, who were homeschooled through high school to keep them pure. They married the first person they kissed.

She was charming, traveling in a safe way, lots of home skills, jam making traditional American recipes, knitting, sewing etc. She'd have preferred school. But they did get through the curriculum by April so got to have a really long summer break.

Your first point makes me think of the only home-Ed parent I've ever met. She is incredibly accomplished and intelligent, a little zany/eccentric but not to an unusual extent. Just a really interesting person. A bit of a hippy but definitely not the anti vax variety.

She home educated her children, and openly told me (with affection) that her children are "weird" - but she said that people often assume that her children are "weird" because they're home schooled. But she says the whole reason she began home ed was because they are "weird" and it became clear that they wouldn't fit in at school. I don't know if there were any diagnoses or conditions going on, I didn't pry. But by all accounts they seemed a very happy, high-achieving family.

So I just wonder if your friend may have been awkward because he was homeschooled, or homeschooled because he was awkward Smile

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 12:17

Home education isn’t a cult because it has so many internal divisions.
@Hoowhoowho

Well, yes quite. 2 home-educators, 3 points of view.

There's almost no agreement in Home education. If someone suggests they "speak for home-educators" they're almost immediately shot down in flames.
(Or the person(s) wishing to speak for "all home-educators" blocks and bans their dissenters first)

Good luck anyone trying to organise home-educators into a cult.
It would be easier to herd cats😂

Hoowhoowho · 30/08/2022 12:09

My experience is that the home education community is quite divided.

A large group consists of parents of children with additional needs, usually but not always ASD who end up removing their children after schools fail then. There are key times when children sink and you see the patterns if you hang in home education communities long enough. The saddest imo are the large numbers that end up home educating in Year 10/11 after their child finally just won’t go to school anymore. This group are often raging about schools, resistant to the LA, their very negative experiences of the system play out for years after they’ve left.

Another group are the alternatives, the anti vax, breastfeeding forever, baby wearing sorts for whom home education is just another item on the ticklist of alternative parenting. Some of them are fairly mild, some full on cult, freeman of the land, flat earth sorts. This group are anti system in general and indeed they post the anti school memes between the anti vax ones on Facebook.

Then there is a small but persistent group of philosophical home educators. They often decided years before they had children that they would home educate. Their objections to the system are long standing but often they’re not otherwise particularly alternative. They tend to be parents who are themselves neurodiverse and had poor experiences of school. They also rely heavily on evidence. They’re not likely to be anti vax or flat earth sorts. This group will engage with the LA but only the minimum that is required generally,

Then there are the little groups
Religious home educators- small group in the UK but definitely exist, generally evangelical Christians or Muslims. Many but not all are more insular, tending not to attend non religious home Ed groups

The academics. This lot believe they can give a better traditional education to their kids than schools can. They tend to look down on other sorts of home educators although they do socialise with them and they mostly engage with the LA including permitting home visits.

The misfits- lots of reasons from waiting for a desired school place, to delaying school entry etc.

Then among the groups, you get more divisions between the full on academics, the electics, the unschoolers, the radical unschoolers.

Home education isn’t a cult because it has so many internal divisions.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 12:01

DontMakeMeShushYou · 30/08/2022 11:58

@Chillicheesebites

I don't feel schools are really safe for girls, I think the statistic is 1 girl is raped at school every day.

Do you have a source/link for this statistic please?

The statistic will come from here.
www.endviolenceagainstwomen.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/All-Day-Every-Day-Sexual-violence-in-schools-legal-briefing-Sept-2016.pdf

DontMakeMeShushYou · 30/08/2022 11:58

@Chillicheesebites

I don't feel schools are really safe for girls, I think the statistic is 1 girl is raped at school every day.

Do you have a source/link for this statistic please?

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 11:52

"We attended many different groups, from horseriding, to gymnastics, to folk dance, to meditation and evening art classes. We went to church and on church camps. We joined Guides and other clubs." (by @Apl )

@Trying20 I guess they are fairly middle-class activities, in the normal scheme of things.

But those activities are pretty typical for many home-educators, regardless of social class.

In home-ed, someone will say, "my child fancies, x, y, z - anyone want to join us?" because it makes it cheaper for everyone to do a group booking. So you end up with all sorts of people signing up for whatever it is.
Also, some things are easier to organise for home-ed partly because you'll likely have different age-ranges (and capabilities), rather than all within 12 months of each other.
So horse-riding, gymnastics, dance, swimming are easier to do than football and netball (where the participants need to be of a similar size and aptitude otherwise it can be horribly unbalanced)

Horse-riding, although on the more expensive end, is cheaper during term-time during the day, particularly on a group booking and where you don't have to have expensive pony club kit. So this opens it up to families that wouldn't necessarily be able to afford weekend/afterschool pony club prices.

For some reason, every home-ed group seems to have a mum who is into yoga or medidation and it's also one of the easier activities to do cheaply with mixed ages.

Home-ed trips are cheaper than school outings, too and obviously home-educators have more days available to them to go out. Which is why my children have been able to go to so many different places. We also don't have to cover a coach (they're notoriously expensive). So several of us went for the same price as it would have cost one child to go to the same place on a school trip.
But reeling of a full list of where we've gone sounds like the sort of list Eton or St Paul's would boast of in their prospectuses.

That's not to say that some people do stick to their socio-economic demographic, obviously that happens too, but it isn't a given.
To some extent, you can't help who your children makes friends with and often you're just so pleased and relieved that your children have found friends.

I think unless you live in an area where there is a huge home-ed population, you can't be that choosy. (Those areas do exist, of course, there's one town I know that has a massive amount of home-educators and a lot of them went to a particular church, so you can imagine how that would influence the local home-ed "scene" even if you weren't religious yourself)

Also, some of these activities aren't done every week, all year round.
You might only do a few weeks of something and then move onto something else.

Anyway, just to sort of try to explain why some home-ed activities look exclusively middle class when they might not necessarily be.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 11:51

abusive parents keep their kids at home on purpose you do realise @ElephantsintheCupboard

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 11:50

ElephantsintheCupboard · 30/08/2022 11:24

Sigh...

you can sigh and deny all you like but everyone is not the same

Numbershere · 30/08/2022 11:40

Wow. Is there any wonder we defend our choice to HE with so much judgement from so much of society? Really, is it ANY of your business?
As for 'do poor home ed children get a choice of going to school' I know many families who give that choice. How many school parents who could home ed give their 'poor school children' a choice to home ed? It works both ways.

RunningSME · 30/08/2022 11:39

Snoozer11 · 30/08/2022 11:38

To be fair, you don't really need a specialist skillset to teach something like history, other than an ability to read and use a search engine.

Something like maths, English, the sciences, languages etc are the subjects where you need specialist teachers.

You may well need them but you won’t get them necessarily 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread