Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
foxlover47 · 30/08/2022 16:12

What about the likes of me who are home educating due to the fact that their child has severe anxiety and cannot cope too well in a busy noisy environment? Whilst waiting assessments which as you know can take years if you don't go private we try our best to give our children a safe and happy home Ed alternative to school.
I only know a couple of others who home Ed , I find it's other mums who look down on me when they find out I am not sending her to "mainstream school "

Marikali · 30/08/2022 16:10

When people make a choice that is outside the mainstream it can feel important to be sure of your choices which can sometimes come across as evangelical but it is probably masking insecurity. Equally important to find a tribe of people who validate those choices.
It sounds like your own choices around education feel threatened?
I home educated my 3 older kids, we are very secure in our decisions but over the years I have noticed how prickly some people can be about our way of life. I am not financially privileged at all, we have very little money but I hear what you are saying around this aspect of home ed. Neither am I a driver which makes it difficult again. It is best I think not to clump everyone together, there are many reasons for people behaving as they do.
The world would be a peculiar place if we were all the same. Perhaps the best you can do is support your friends on this new and probably scary adventure they have embarked on and when you feel threatened to recognise that is your own stuff and not to put that on them.

Thesearmsofmine · 30/08/2022 16:04

I’m so sorry that you had a horrible experience @JeminaPuddlegoose

I feel like home educators get so defensive about their choices (because so many people are critical and rude about them) and are always quick to shoot people down who have had bad experiences rather than acknowledge the potential issues that home educating can hide. You are correct that a child not seeing a GP or a dentist for several years isn’t going to automatically raise a red flag to other services. I don’t think it does us any favours to pretend that there is no possibility that there are children out there in homes that aren’t being treated well. I have home educated for years and haven’t had any contact regarding the education of my children in all that time, sometimes I do find that very bizarre.

JeminaPuddlegoose · 30/08/2022 15:57

If there's any evidence that proves your statement "abusive parents keep their kids at home on purpose" I would like to see it please.

I'm not saying it happens a lot, but Jesus Christ how can you post something like that on the very next page after a poster has shared their personal experience of exactly that?

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 15:52

balalake · 30/08/2022 15:47

Those who home school children seems to be very forthcoming about it and very proud. I would not use the word cult, but I get where the OP is coming from.

What a strange comment - would you prefer it if all home-educators were ashamed or embarrassed about it instead?

Thesearmsofmine · 30/08/2022 15:48

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 15:23

I really agree with this. I have a few HE friends. One posted on social media about how much her kids benefitted from the classes run by the local museum for HE families. She was very put out when another friend said they also run these for schools and most local children will have attended. The museum was trying to give the same opportunities to HE families as kids at school already had.

I would be very surprised if your friend wasn’t well aware of the activities run for schools by your local museum. Home educators are usually the ones who are communicating with the museums in order to get these activities set up for their children too, I have done this successfully myself several times with local museums and galleries.
I have been involved in both home ed and school visits to museums, farms, zoos and more, the sessions don’t tend to be the same due to a school session usually being set up to fit in with the curriculum, all of the children being around the same age and stage and tend to be very much focussed on timings x minutes to complete this task then move on so they can get back to school on time. A home ed session tends to be much more flexible and varied and can go off tangents and it also tends to have a much more relaxed atmosphere for both the organisers and the children. So just because both schooled and home educated children attend a museum to do a session on the Vikings for example, doesn’t mean they will have the same experience.

balalake · 30/08/2022 15:47

Those who home school children seems to be very forthcoming about it and very proud. I would not use the word cult, but I get where the OP is coming from.

Softplayhooray · 30/08/2022 15:46

I honestly think it depends on the child,and on the life stage of that child. I could imagine one of mine doing amazingly if he'd been home schooled - until 10/11 when the first rumblings of puberty hit - then that's when he really needed a great sports coach/PE/school sport influence, the social element, etc, and he needed it about 100% more than when he was littler. If we were home schooling I think we'd have missed out on seeing what he needed to develop confidently through puberty as a self assured kid, as he'd have not been put in those certain situations that put a spotlight on certain behavioural issues (nothing serious, but coping strategies for stress etc that weren't that great, for example, and which left unchecked could've made life generally more difficult as time went on). There are just some things we couldn't teach him at that life stage. We were really glad for teachers and coaches that were great influences.

BoxOf · 30/08/2022 15:45

Tigofigo · 30/08/2022 15:22

Those who home ed and work - how do you make that a success? The home ed groups can legally only take children for 15 hours per week which means working maybe 1.5-2 days max...

We didn’t we both gave up but we were able to as could apply as carers as dc get dla

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 15:45

Tigofigo · 30/08/2022 15:22

Those who home ed and work - how do you make that a success? The home ed groups can legally only take children for 15 hours per week which means working maybe 1.5-2 days max...

I would leave teenagers a day a week.

But in the scenario where they've already had 15hrs elsewhere, I wouldn't leave them for any more because we'd not fit everything in.

Personally, I wouldn't have left non-teens for anything other than the occasional day.

I know that people say you can work full time and still home-ed afterwards but in reality, that's meh (and I worked throughout home-ed even when they were little). How would you go to meet ups and trips? And find time to eat and sleep.

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 15:36

Tigofigo · 30/08/2022 15:22

Those who home ed and work - how do you make that a success? The home ed groups can legally only take children for 15 hours per week which means working maybe 1.5-2 days max...

It's extremely difficult, often a matter of juggling two p/t incomes or working from home. It's probably impossible for some people, though I think if you are sending your 14 year old to home ed college placement it gets easier. Parents make sacrifices, such as not flying abroad for holidays, buying second hand, cycling everywhere. Even so, I am aware it's an impossibility for some people, which I think is a shame.

Helenahandcartt · 30/08/2022 15:35

I don’t work a consistent pattern (dh does). I tutor at the weekends or evenings, I sometimes pick up supply teachings p/t but as a SENCo or intervention teacher. Some is just paperwork based and doesn’t need to be fully at school. I have used a range of friends/ childcare and family when working p/t. The reality of working full time while they are primary aged was after childcare x 3 I took very little home, with this bitty pattern of supply and tutoring I actually take more home. Kids are expensive every way you work it out realistically.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 15:25

Tigofigo · 30/08/2022 15:22

Those who home ed and work - how do you make that a success? The home ed groups can legally only take children for 15 hours per week which means working maybe 1.5-2 days max...

Depends on the age of their children. Plenty of teenagers are left at home while their parents work.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 15:23

RidingMyBike · 30/08/2022 14:23

For one of my home ed friends she seems unaware of what school is like now and bases her views (which she posts about on SM) on being at primary school in the 80s and a lot of stuff she's been told by other home ed people. She half-heartedly viewed a couple of primaries for her eldest, but then didn't apply because she didn't approve of their discipline expectations - which sounded just like the usual, fresh start every day approach.

I'm a similar age and my DD's primary bears little relation to my 80s primary - the lessons are inspiring and fun, the teacher is brilliant, there is a strong emphasis on creativity and art. She learnt to read fluently by end of Year 1 and really enjoyed how they learned how to do this. She likes the school dinners. PE/Games actually sounds fun rather than the misery we endured. And it's only a 'good' state primary serving an area with a higher than average number of pupils getting free school meals.

I really agree with this. I have a few HE friends. One posted on social media about how much her kids benefitted from the classes run by the local museum for HE families. She was very put out when another friend said they also run these for schools and most local children will have attended. The museum was trying to give the same opportunities to HE families as kids at school already had.

Tigofigo · 30/08/2022 15:22

Those who home ed and work - how do you make that a success? The home ed groups can legally only take children for 15 hours per week which means working maybe 1.5-2 days max...

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 15:17

@MiddleOfHere @Helenahandcartt I agree with you both. We enjoy mixing with schooled children and maintain friendships, but home ed has greatly diversified our experiences.

Helenahandcartt · 30/08/2022 15:10

tobee · 30/08/2022 14:56

"There’s not, in huge areas of the UK, much truth in claiming that school offers children exposure to a broad range of diversity for most children."

But there is in a range of home schoolers you physically interact with on a daily basis? And it doesn't have to be just "diversity" in a modern usage. Diversity in numbers and personalities et etc

Yes. My nearest school is a faith school, I honestly don’t think we’d have Muslim friends if we hadn’t home educated the youngest ones for example (despite being about a third of the wider area we live in). There’s also a significant non-UK number who don’t want to use the UK system for various reasons. There’s a significant number of black boys/ black boys with SEN who have had poor experiences in school for various reasons. The people who are failed by school tend to be those who are a little different. The ones who opt out are often a little different.

Its actually one aspect of home Ed, having to have an attitude to set differences aside. There’s less of you, and you’re a diverse crowd. You can’t just keep hanging out with those just like you. You learn the hippies are lovely gentle people in the most part.

Obviously great diversity includes having some real twats or people you can’t stand under the umbrella of home Ed. You learn to ignore them or just rub along if the kids are ok.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 15:09

"Yes but, I mean you could argue that about anything. But it's still going to be a bigger pool of children at school in most cases. A small primary would have sat a 200 children?"

What's diverse about interacting with a greater number of similar children?

My children could interact with 30 or 1000 children of primarily white middle class Conservative parents at the local school (you'd then see a smaller subset of the same children at Scouts or dance or football),
or 30 children from 12 different countries, 5 different religions, 4 different ethnicities and a handful of SEND. (I don't ask about their politics but I am guessing that they're not all Conservative voters) and also see some of the local children at afterschool things, too.

"But there is in a range of home schoolers you physically interact with on a daily basis? And it doesn't have to be just "diversity" in a modern usage. Diversity in numbers and personalities et etc"

One day they might be at a large event with 100 at it and the following day, there could be half a dozen.

You might regularly see the same 40 children on a kind of rotating basis, depending on the activities you've signed up for, in a reasonably-sized town.

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 15:04

tobee · 30/08/2022 14:53

"Isn't it the same for school kids? They mix with others through hobbies or because they are other schoolers?"

Yes but, I mean you could argue that about anything. But it's still going to be a bigger pool of children at school in most cases. A small primary would have sat a 200 children?

Firstly there is more crossover between home schooled and schooled kids than you might think. My local boxing club, scouts and music schools have both. Also. it's unlikely a child in a school of 200 will interact with all other children. Lastly, in my area it is largely white and still quite racist. There are a larger number of ethnically diverse children amongst the home ed community because of racism, which I am sure schools try to stamp out but is impossible to avoid on the way home, during break times or just as a subtle form of ostracising.

pawkins · 30/08/2022 14:57

Booklover3 · 30/08/2022 14:39

Ahh quite damning views on home educating.

We never ever thought we would home educate until our children were pretending to be sick every day because they didn’t want to go to school. It was an awful time. One of our children in particular was becoming a shadow of herself. Completely lost her love of learning. So sad.

I’d been into the school multiple times but nothing ever changed. Every time we complained things would settle down for a few weeks and then the bullying would start again. She was 7 at the time.

Its bloody hard work home educating (and trying to work also) but it was what was best for our children. They are free to return to school whenever they choose. It would be easier for me if they did!

There must be more people like me who are trying to do the best they can. We are quietly getting on with it.

I don’t believe that home education is best. I don’t believe that school is the best way either. I think children are individuals and all have different needs. As a parent all you can do is try to do your best for them to meet those needs.

I generally don’t volunteer the information that we home educate because of the judgement I receive. It’s perfectly illustrated on this thread.

I don’t homeschool but this post really struck a cord with me.

My DC has had a number of poor teachers a few years in a row and cca I can see the joy of learning has disappeared.

It’s not a great school and we are outside the catchment for a better one.

tobee · 30/08/2022 14:56

"There’s not, in huge areas of the UK, much truth in claiming that school offers children exposure to a broad range of diversity for most children."

But there is in a range of home schoolers you physically interact with on a daily basis? And it doesn't have to be just "diversity" in a modern usage. Diversity in numbers and personalities et etc

tobee · 30/08/2022 14:53

"Isn't it the same for school kids? They mix with others through hobbies or because they are other schoolers?"

Yes but, I mean you could argue that about anything. But it's still going to be a bigger pool of children at school in most cases. A small primary would have sat a 200 children?

Helenahandcartt · 30/08/2022 14:53

Primary schools are pretty narrow in particular for their lack of diversity in intakes. Similar housing surrounds the school. In cities many are either faith schools or simply parents select schools with similar intakes. Round here you can pretty much walk past a school playground that’s 80-90% white then a few minutes later another that is 80-90% brown. Or one school serves an estate, the next nearest school is surrounded by leafy streets and large houses, with people even renting to get kids in. There’s not, in huge areas of the UK, much truth in claiming that school offers children exposure to a broad range of diversity for most children.

tobee · 30/08/2022 14:49

Ironically my dd went to mainstream school. Where they didn't pick up on her being autistic (she was diagnosed after university) and the sen teacher laughed when I suggested she might be adhd because she was anything but hyper (she was diagnosed with adhd after she was diagnosed as autistic ) but the structure and timetabling of mainstream school was when she's been at her happiest. And she was lucky that she wasn't bullied.

However, I appreciate that that is very much not always the case.

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 14:48

I don't think mainstream school is brilliant in every way but I can't see how you can truthfully argue that your children are mixing with a wide range of children that haven't selected through some common hobby or interest, or because they're other home schoolers.

Isn't it the same for school kids? They mix with others through hobbies or because they are other schoolers?