Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
Helenahandcartt · 30/08/2022 20:03

I spent my life meeting so many insular people who avoided me or spoke down to meet because I was different. It actually really matters to me @MiddleOfHere my kids aren’t part of that. Totally happy to be an outsider to that world. Happy as in a good social life happy too.

pastypirate · 30/08/2022 19:57

Around here the home Ed families congregate around the pre school activities like Forrest school and the museum play group. Baffles me why parents do this with much older children.
The parents always say the same thing - oh little Johnny has loads of friends. No, you just know lots of other home Ed families and that's who you let him socialise with.

I find home Ed incredibly insular and controlling.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 19:51

OperaStation · 30/08/2022 18:47

I’m sure your kids aren’t missing out by not socializing with the local anti-social behaviour kids.

All these arguments about home schooled kids not mixing with a diverse range of people is rubbish. We all choose schools specifically to avoid this. We want the school with the nice middle class kids who aren’t going to be disruptive and spend over the odds on houses to live in these areas. We want to send our girls to girls schools so that they don’t have to put up with sexual abuse from boys. We send our kids to private schools to give them the best possible start in life, regardless of it meaning they don’t have much contact with more deprived people. These are all decisions that we make because we want the best for our kids.

True! No school is selling itself based on the lower incomes and greater free-school-meals entitlement of some of its pupils.

There would be uproar if the local school decided to become more diverse by attracting families of different socio-economic backgrounds.

The families who live here have all bought houses specifically to be in this catchment area, lobbied the council to stop changes to the catchment area and generally done everything to maintain the demographic of white middle class offspring who do rugby, ballet and piano lessons. Black and Asian are acceptable - preferably if your child is an overachiever - but definitely still middle class, please.

So, yeah, it is a little odd that home educators have to bend over backwards to prove that their home educated children are Experiencing Diversity.

I'm pretty sure that the average school pupil in our local school hasn't met child who has been "in and out of care" either.
Literally nobody is worried if Peter and Sophie don't have any Muslim friends.

OperaStation · 30/08/2022 19:50

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 19:20

@OperaStation Thank you, that's a good point about girl's schools, particularly. It's horrible to see a local girl's name on a bus stop with obscene comments and drawings.I do take it on board that I need to look for ways to broaden my children's understanding of deprivation, but I feel they work on that by attending local activities, youth clubs and perhaps doing voluntary work when they are older.

I really wouldn’t worry too much. If that’s how the boys treated the girls at my local school I wouldn’t send my daughter there.

Trying20 · 30/08/2022 19:41

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 19:40

tobee · 30/08/2022 16:28

"What's diverse about interacting with a greater number of similar children?"

Diverse personalities for example? Why are you assuming 200 children (or more), 30 teachers and support staff (or more) are all the same? Why is that a good assumption and yet it's a poor assumption that the group of home schoolers or people from their hobby groups are all the same?

I'm talking about similarities in all the different dimensions of diversity with respect to school pupils.

Where I live is overwhelmingly middle-class. Mainly white. Those who aren't white are still middle-class.
Politically it's also overwhelmingly Conservative.
The catchment area for the school covers 3 well-to-do estates; At least one of them (possibly all of them) is known to have a high average income per household.
The school has a really low eligibility rate for free school meals.
It's the sort of place where people rent for 6 months to get into the school.

All the children do the same sort of middle-class hobbies and clubs after school.

I'm not particularly denigrating this - obviously we fit this demographic ourselves, to a certain extent.

But it has to be said that the only diversity going on here is the colour of the cars on the driveways.

That's why it is mystifying that having friends all living in a very similar house to you, with parents in similar jobs/careers to your parents, doing the same clubs and hobbies as you would be seen as more diverse than a hanging out with a bunch of people from different countries, speaking different languages in some cases, with different incomes, different housing - and different personalities).

You might "see" 200 people (which I concede is more than a home-ed meet or even a trip) at school but you're not going to be interacting with them all, so the fact that they all have different personalities is somewhat academic if you only speak to 20 of them in any meaningful way.

The staff may be a little bit more diverse, I'll give you that, though, but the pupils aren't going to be making friends with the staff.

Regarding the hobbies thing, I think that was another poster's point but I guess that if people are coming together just on the basis of a hobby, provided that hobby is relatively accessible, you might at least get people of slightly more varied backgrounds doing it.

RunningSME · 30/08/2022 19:28

Ask Rushi how his career and life has panned out without having any working class friends … seems to be going ok so far

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 19:20

@OperaStation Thank you, that's a good point about girl's schools, particularly. It's horrible to see a local girl's name on a bus stop with obscene comments and drawings.I do take it on board that I need to look for ways to broaden my children's understanding of deprivation, but I feel they work on that by attending local activities, youth clubs and perhaps doing voluntary work when they are older.

OperaStation · 30/08/2022 18:47

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 17:03

@Tobee It's actually true that I don't know any home ed children from deprived homes. They are are always much loved, well fed, well clothed and most of us acknowledge that home ed parents have a level of privilege. We know some of the secondary schooled kids in our area, a group of whom seem to be from difficult backgrounds and they and parents engage in anti social behaviour, vandalism and write truly awful graffiti about the girls in the school on our local bus stop. It's true my kids miss out on socialising with them.it is true we live in something of a bubble. But for many of us home edders it hasn't been a choice, and so we make the best of our options, including trying to educate around tolerance and understanding. If you have any ideas how I should improve my children's access to mixing with those from a deprived background I would be interested to hear.

I’m sure your kids aren’t missing out by not socializing with the local anti-social behaviour kids.

All these arguments about home schooled kids not mixing with a diverse range of people is rubbish. We all choose schools specifically to avoid this. We want the school with the nice middle class kids who aren’t going to be disruptive and spend over the odds on houses to live in these areas. We want to send our girls to girls schools so that they don’t have to put up with sexual abuse from boys. We send our kids to private schools to give them the best possible start in life, regardless of it meaning they don’t have much contact with more deprived people. These are all decisions that we make because we want the best for our kids.

Thesearmsofmine · 30/08/2022 18:25

If you want to home educate and only mix with a small group who are like you then you can. There are absolutely pockets of people like this who keep within their small circle. If you want to home educate and mix with a diverse range of people then that is doable too, home educators as a whole are a hugely diverse bunch of people. Then of course you don’t just mix with other home educators, for example my dc have spent a lot of time at a summer holiday club this year and they were the only home ed children attending. It was just a general club not linked with a particular sport or activity.
I guess with a school setting the thing that is different is the element of choosing who you are mixing with, there is no choice who you are in a class with although simply being in a class with someone doesn’t mean that they actually mix.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 18:09

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

There are definitely people who were knew who were home-educating and living in some very challenging conditions and some are also known to social services and are definitely struggling.

Some families have had home-ed forced on them, to be fair - it was that or be excluded. Basically, they were off-rolled (which is technically illegal but doesn't stop it happening)

I know one alcoholic who home-educated while holding down a minimum wage job. They lost custody of the children and that was the end of that.

Families living on boats and in caravans are not uncommon in home-education circles. We also know people who live in gorgeous 5 or 6 bed houses with acres of land.

We know plenty of single-parent families and some wealthy two-parent families and gay singles and couples who all home-educate. There's also a number of non-binary home-educated children.

There are home-educators on benefits or earning minimum wage and people on six figures and a fair few who are carers.

Home education has quite a lot of children with complex emotional needs - probably a higher percentage than school-going children - because that's probably the reason they're home-educated. And some children (and parents) with mental health needs.

Also plenty of dyslexic children, and lots of children with autism and ADHD etc (a lot of times because schools can't meet their needs but places at specialist schools for autism are few and far between and also the funding for such places is a battle that can take years) and some with children (and parents) with physical disabilities.

I also know more than one family whose child competes at a national level. They're the exception, most seem pretty average (or even terrible) at sport, obviously.
Same goes for art, music (ranging from tone deaf to grade 8 and everything in between) and a whole load of other stuff.

We have friends who have straight As (or almost straight) As and 8s and 9s and went on to vet and med school.
Equally, we have friends who have no GCSEs or qualifications at all.

I know two families with adopted children, one of whom had been in care. The only demographic I haven't come across is children shuttling in and out of care - and that is because looked-after children are by default going to be in state education and LAC is usually the top schools admissions criteria.
With that said, my children would probably not have come across looked-after children in the cosy middle class school (or the feeder primaries) down the road either, because its the sort of school that people rent property in the area for just to get their children in, and its free-school-meals eligibility is way below the national average. So home-education hasn't really decreased the "diversity" in that sense.

I'm in no way saying that home educated children "experience diversity because we've got muslim friends" or "They experience kids from different background because sometimes horse riding is discounted" because that would be ludicrious and insulting.

When I say "diversity" I mean it in the sense that an EDI manager or an LA would and not because "poor people can afford horse-riding too".
I don't think we're particularly unusual but may be we are.

Not sure if you're aware but a small number of home-educating families are in receipt of personal budgets or are technically EOTAS.
So their activities are effectively subsidised and that might include horse-riding or some other therapeutic thing (I don't generally ask people, obviously but once I did have to supply costs& receipts for an activity I organised for a family's personal budget)

Additionally, people can prioritise their income, so what is unaffordable in mainstream school might just become affordable in home-education because they're spending less on school-related stuff.
It might be the only thing they do all term but at least one family who was significantly disadvantaged (by all the usual social services parameters) did have one of their children to home-ed horse-riding (with the help of lifts from other families). I didn't ask them how they afforded it because that would have been patronising.

You seem to have no actual idea of how diverse home-education is - and why would you, to be honest.

But for some reason you're convinced that home-education is the purview of white middle class women with well-paid husbands. I'm not denying that those sorts of home-educators do exist - they obviously do - but they're not the only demographic by any stretch.

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 17:27

@antelopevalley Yes, of course, these are just the ones that roam our streets. I acknowledge we are unlikely to meet families in dire poverty or with other problems, that's all. Although we do spend 4 hours a week in the company of 3 children now in foster care due to one of our hobbies. So we are not unfamiliar with the issues children in care face.

Morph22010 · 30/08/2022 17:20

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 11:07

I find a lot of home schooling parents by choice have very outdated ideas of schools.

When did it change as it was like that when my child was in mainstream (he’s now in specialist not home Ed) and he only left mainstream 3 and a half years ago

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 17:20

Children from deprived homes can be much loved and well-behaved.

gnilliwdog · 30/08/2022 17:03

@Tobee It's actually true that I don't know any home ed children from deprived homes. They are are always much loved, well fed, well clothed and most of us acknowledge that home ed parents have a level of privilege. We know some of the secondary schooled kids in our area, a group of whom seem to be from difficult backgrounds and they and parents engage in anti social behaviour, vandalism and write truly awful graffiti about the girls in the school on our local bus stop. It's true my kids miss out on socialising with them.it is true we live in something of a bubble. But for many of us home edders it hasn't been a choice, and so we make the best of our options, including trying to educate around tolerance and understanding. If you have any ideas how I should improve my children's access to mixing with those from a deprived background I would be interested to hear.

moofolk · 30/08/2022 16:56

YANBU

Booklover3 · 30/08/2022 16:55

Ikeabag · 30/08/2022 16:45

@Booklover3 you sound like us. Be my friend. 😁

I’ll be your friend. Can never have enough friends 😆

Booklover3 · 30/08/2022 16:51

pawkins · 30/08/2022 14:57

I don’t homeschool but this post really struck a cord with me.

My DC has had a number of poor teachers a few years in a row and cca I can see the joy of learning has disappeared.

It’s not a great school and we are outside the catchment for a better one.

I really hope your child gets a good teacher that they really click with this year @pawkins. That’s all they need, just one, and their love for learning will return. I’m sorry my post struck a cord. We can all only do our best 💐

Ikeabag · 30/08/2022 16:45

@Booklover3 you sound like us. Be my friend. 😁

Ikeabag · 30/08/2022 16:38

We home ed. Neurodiversity played a big part. There is no middle ground between the rigidity of school and completely opting out - if there was a genuine 3rd option, not just flexi schooling, I'd love it. I've really struggled to find people on my wavelength who also homeschool. I'm low drama, low fuss, we do enough, my kid is fairly academic, articulate, very maths-interested - but was like this anyway, I don't credit his years at school for this or my own efforts. I should say I live in an area that's known to have a thriving home ed population. I was aware of it previously but I've not seen the cohesive wholeness that I'd hoped for, but really, that makes sense. People home ed in different ways, and for different reasons. I've definitely met people who think that agreeing with everything that is the opposite of the general concensus in mainstream society is somehow thinking critically. If I let it, it would keep me up at night (I previously worked in safeguarding), but I don't have the headspace spare. WRT prev poster and child who is learning work ahead of peers, that can level off as they get older. Mine was in the same situation. We're currently working to age rather than yeargroup (so a year ahead calendar, but my child is one of the older ones, so arguably just in the expected niche). Child was further ahead for a while. I find it comes in fits and starts and depends on their interests, so yeargroup comparisons not always useful. Ultimately I just wish we had a school in this area that could provide what he requires, but the system is a mess. And yes, it's massively privileged to be able to do it, no doubt about it. I'm disillusioned with it, honestly. With support for kids generally, in school and who have additional needs. And I'm tired. I really do think in terms of people I've met, that they double down on their absolute conviction that it's right, because any doubt that creeps in threatens to overturn the boat. But, not all homeschoolers. Just some of the ones that stand out to me, having been in it a couple of years. Also, covid and extended isolation periods have probably made things a bit weird and fractured for home ed communities. They've also polarised people within them. I often wonder what it might have been like before social media existed.

tobee · 30/08/2022 16:33

foxlover47 · 30/08/2022 16:12

What about the likes of me who are home educating due to the fact that their child has severe anxiety and cannot cope too well in a busy noisy environment? Whilst waiting assessments which as you know can take years if you don't go private we try our best to give our children a safe and happy home Ed alternative to school.
I only know a couple of others who home Ed , I find it's other mums who look down on me when they find out I am not sending her to "mainstream school "

There are definitely exceptions to the idea that everyone home schools for the same reason. The provision by the state is woefully inadequate for sen and is not looking likely to improve. And very likely to get worse.

tobee · 30/08/2022 16:28

"What's diverse about interacting with a greater number of similar children?"

Diverse personalities for example? Why are you assuming 200 children (or more), 30 teachers and support staff (or more) are all the same? Why is that a good assumption and yet it's a poor assumption that the group of home schoolers or people from their hobby groups are all the same?

tobee · 30/08/2022 16:23

"Firstly there is more crossover between home schooled and schooled kids than you might think. My local boxing club, scouts and music schools have both. Also. it's unlikely a child in a school of 200 will interact with all other children. Lastly, in my area it is largely white and still quite racist. There are a larger number of ethnically diverse children amongst the home ed community because of racism, which I am sure schools try to stamp out but is impossible to avoid on the way home, during break times or just as a subtle form of ostracising."

But as I said previously, the groups you're talking about are already special interest/hobby groups so have things in common. And, as I also said, you're limiting your idea of diversity as only pertaining to race in your comment. That's Diversity not diversity.

Trying20 · 30/08/2022 16:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

2bazookas · 30/08/2022 16:15

As you're a teacher, it's clique, (rhymes with leek), and cliquey, not click/clicky.

IME, people I've known who home-educate their children are far too diverse to qualify as a cult. I've seen some making a real hash of it (small wonder their feral brats didn't thrive in school) and others doing a grand job until their lively well-socialised teenagers entered university (sciences) or skilled apprenticeships.