Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
Pyewhacket · 30/08/2022 02:21

I can see the advantage for primary school kids. They'll get a lot more share of mind, personal tuition and 1-2-1 attention.

I lived in Provence until my early teens so I taught my kids to speak French which made them pretty much fluent by the time they went to big school.

Baoing · 30/08/2022 02:21

I’m sure they do have friends. Part of the school experience is getting along with all those who aren’t friends, that they might not like but still might have to work with

I'm not sure that kids growing into teens, with the all the stuff they do could avoid this. They have to negotiate this kind of thing the whole time. They go to drama groups, cadets, rangers, language groups, etc. - all mixed home ed/school kids. They go on camping trips, water sports team stuff, recording weekends (they're in a band), all kinds of stuff. They have freedom to take up work experience places when they present - one has just spent two weeks doing an amazing placement off shore. Not friends, real world.

They have no 'them and us' attitude - that really stands out for me - they're happy kids.

FlorettaB · 30/08/2022 02:10

’they have a big group of friends’

I’m sure they do have friends. Part of the school experience is getting along with all those who aren’t friends, that they might not like but still might have to work with.

avamiah · 30/08/2022 02:09

I knew a mum a couple of years ago who home schooled her daughter because she said she got bullied.The girl used to go to the same dance school as my daughter and was the same age.
I always thought it strange that she did dance classes and gymnastic classes mixing with lots of kids but she was home schooled.

I met her husband one evening after dance class as he came with her to pick up their daughter and I always thought he seemed a bit controlling well that was my opinion but I could of been wrong.

Anyway, I never really saw them much after that as my daughter went to secondary school.

beachcitygirl · 30/08/2022 02:08

It's weird as fuck & the parents who do it ste totally co-dependent

Baoing · 30/08/2022 02:05

School allows for emotional development, feeling connected to a peer group, forming friendships, negotiating their way through conflicts, having a whole world of their own independent from home and learning to cooperate with others. That’s valuable

Home ed teens do exactly this, just not in school! It's not school 'allowing' it - it's just where it happens for kids in school. Kids out of school do the same thing - they have a big group of friends (inc. diversity!) and they're not shackled to the dining room table!

There's a huge gulf between the home ed families I know and the comments here!

SD1978 · 30/08/2022 02:04

It's like veganism. Home schooling isn't the 'norm' but those who do it can't understand why you don't understand the impact you're having on your children by not doing and want to get their message out their to show you that they are right. And they are for them, I have no issue with it if it's right for your family, but whilst respecting your choices I'd appreciate it if they respected mine too.

malificent7 · 30/08/2022 02:03

It works for some but bloody hell...i admire people who can put all that energy into teaching their own kids. My dd would go bonkers...as would I.

FlorettaB · 30/08/2022 02:01

’I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children’

That sounds stifling and unhealthy to me.

FlorettaB · 30/08/2022 01:57

I agree that those who homeschool through choice from the start can seem very cult-like but lots of parents who end up homeschooling (in the U.K. anyway) are doing it out of necessity not choice. Their DC aren’t having their needs met in school or are desperately unhappy in school. For them, homeschooling is a response to a problem rather than a proactive choice.

For me, school is about socialisation. A bright child could learn faster at home with one to one teaching but what benefit is there to the child sitting a maths GCSE at 9 rather than 16? School allows for emotional development, feeling connected to a peer group, forming friendships, negotiating their way through conflicts, having a whole world of their own independent from home and learning to cooperate with others. That’s valuable. If school doesn’t work for a child, if it’s causing them anxiety and making them unhappy, then obviously homeschooling is the better option.

Creativecrafts · 30/08/2022 01:55

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:07

We are planning to home school our children ( 4 year old DD & 7 month old DS) we are in a very fortunate position to be able to do this as many parents who work full time, wouldn't be able to afford the luxury. I don't see it as a ' cult' or as a opting out of society. In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children. I understand school is a service for the mass population, but my DD will definitely thrive with 1 on 1 teaching and not have to compete with 30 children. It is also to be noted that the smart children in the class don't progress fast enough and they can only learn at the pace of the slowest child. My DD has just turned 4 and is already learning what they teach in year 1( age 5 - 6). I think if you have to time, inclination and resources to teach your children yourself, they will be greater achievers and I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

Your daughter is only 4 at the moment. I understand how you can teach her when she is young, but how are you going to cope when she's a teenager? Are you able to teach maths, sciences, languages, to GCSE and A level standards? Won't she need specialist teachers for those subjects?

Trying20 · 30/08/2022 01:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Nekomata · 30/08/2022 01:41

I think it can be really isolating for parents who home educate, so they look for friends who are in a similar situation. People can be very judgmental about HE, so I imagine they are just trying to be positive about the experience.

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:28

Sometimeswinning · 30/08/2022 01:17

I think you pretty much proved the ops point! I've learned this holiday that my kids need school. They need an environment which isn't their home. I need to go back to work aswell!!

I don't think my kids need school, I just said that most people don't have the luxury to be able to do it. For example if both parents work full time and need the money, especially in this day and age then they really have no option but to send them to school. I don't agree it's the best place for them though or that it's cult like to home school. As a previous posted said, the children to wear uniforms, sit where they are told, put thier hand up if they need the toilet so in all honesty that is far more cult like than being taught at home. I also don't want my children being taught that transgender is normal, I've heard from friends whose kids go to school, the sorts of things that they have been learning. On a side note I read today that schools may have open 3 days a week due to the energy crisis and they can't afford to keep them warm 5 days a week.

tobee · 30/08/2022 01:22

I feel it sad that, whatever, path you use to educate your children, that exam results are the be all and end all. And if you home educate your children miss out on being with other children, all types of other children, those you get on with and those you don't. As you would have to in later life.

Trying20 · 30/08/2022 01:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Hairday · 30/08/2022 01:18

Yes, people can be cultlike about schools, ranting on about the atmosphere, opportunities, self esteem, community etc. I mean, seriously.

Sometimeswinning · 30/08/2022 01:17

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:07

We are planning to home school our children ( 4 year old DD & 7 month old DS) we are in a very fortunate position to be able to do this as many parents who work full time, wouldn't be able to afford the luxury. I don't see it as a ' cult' or as a opting out of society. In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children. I understand school is a service for the mass population, but my DD will definitely thrive with 1 on 1 teaching and not have to compete with 30 children. It is also to be noted that the smart children in the class don't progress fast enough and they can only learn at the pace of the slowest child. My DD has just turned 4 and is already learning what they teach in year 1( age 5 - 6). I think if you have to time, inclination and resources to teach your children yourself, they will be greater achievers and I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

I think you pretty much proved the ops point! I've learned this holiday that my kids need school. They need an environment which isn't their home. I need to go back to work aswell!!

Wafflesnsniffles · 30/08/2022 01:17

You've based your opinion OP on having met one group of people who home ed their kids (who are very unlikely to call what they do "home schooling" btw *) Ive based my opinion (in my comment above) on having met literally hundreds of different home educating families in various areas of the UK across the last 15 years or so.

*Homeschooling....... what its generally called in the US. Or by people in the UK who dont know what they are talking about.
Home Education........what its referred to in law in the UK. And by HErs themselves. People who know about home ed.

TheOtherWoman2 · 30/08/2022 01:17

Yes absolutely they give me Mormon vibes

Hairday · 30/08/2022 01:17

The only ones I've met were very religious, down to the mum needing permission from her husband for everything. So yes. But I don't think they were representative.

Gruffling · 30/08/2022 01:15

I actually think there are many aspects of mainstream schooling that don't make sense and could be described as cultlike. The way the children all have to wear the same clothes and sit obediently en masse in silence listening to one person in assemblies - what is this really teaching them apart from conformity?

Wafflesnsniffles · 30/08/2022 01:13

Often but not always clicky. Never cult like. To suggest it is culty is to not fully understand the meaning of the word cult I think.

Baoing · 30/08/2022 01:07

I know a few homeschool families - I don't see them here at all. Totally normal, no massive agenda about home-ed, it just suits them. The kids are fine, learning well, do lots of groups and have a big group of friends. Not 'evangelical' or school-hating... we all mix very happily. We live in a very home-ed area, so it's a fairly well-trodden pathway.

So, YABU, no cult here. I have seen several anti-home-ed threads recently.

One other thing...

All three have mothers who don’t wish to conform and who think their way is best
There's definitely a click amongst the mums
I know three people (mums) who homeschool

Is it just mums who home educate?

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:07

We are planning to home school our children ( 4 year old DD & 7 month old DS) we are in a very fortunate position to be able to do this as many parents who work full time, wouldn't be able to afford the luxury. I don't see it as a ' cult' or as a opting out of society. In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children. I understand school is a service for the mass population, but my DD will definitely thrive with 1 on 1 teaching and not have to compete with 30 children. It is also to be noted that the smart children in the class don't progress fast enough and they can only learn at the pace of the slowest child. My DD has just turned 4 and is already learning what they teach in year 1( age 5 - 6). I think if you have to time, inclination and resources to teach your children yourself, they will be greater achievers and I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread