Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home schooling is a bit cult like?

358 replies

WobblyWellies · 30/08/2022 00:27

This is purely anecdotal but based on a group of friends who are all home schooling now, it makes me feel like there is a cult like element to it. There's definitely a click amongst the mums. One of my friends in the group has changed quite a bit since she started home schooling. She's almost become a bit militant about the whole thing. She often posts things on social media about how terrible schools are for children and how home schooling is much better. I feel like she's stirring things up. I am in fact a teacher but I don't push school on people I meet or social media, it's totally individual choice how you want your child educated. I'm not sure if my friend is out to convert people.

However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority. My friend has a house with acres of land and woods, she does loads of outdoor learning with her kids which is great but I wouldn't say it's the norm to have that.

So this group of friends are very clicky over homeschooling and it feels like a them and us scenario now.

Aibu to say it's like a cult for some people?

OP posts:
hop321 · 30/08/2022 07:01

Credit to HEers. I just couldn't. I've supported my kids with some extra teaching and it tests my patience after more than an hour...

Would I consider HE? I guess only if the local schools were dreadful. I've found helping with some GCSEs and A levels fine but, even having done A level Maths for example, I'd struggle to teach it.

I also agree with the poster that said it takes ages. I sat down to look at a set poem with my son yesterday and there was a lot of preamble, both getting everything printed and ready, but also finding online resources to support it. Extrapolate that over a whole day and I'd be needing to do quite a lot of preparation to make sure work was covered as efficiently as possible.

The volume of subject information and support online is great, but it is also time-consuming sifting through it to find the best one. I'd also worry about marking GCSE and A level work, even having looked at the mark schemes.

Presumably HEers use specialist tutors for the more advanced work? Are there HE specific ones or do you have to work outside school hours as most are FT teachers?

I like the variety of school, particularly learning to interact with teachers and other pupils respectfully. I'm also a big fan of school sport. My kids love sport and have at least one or two sports sessions every day plus one or two fixtures a week. That's hard to replicate even with club sport.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 07:00

@Aretheyhavingalaugh
There are no large formal studies of UK home education. So it is impossible to say whether home ed or schooled children in the UK perform better or have better outcomes.

Similar to the school myth that school is the only place where children can be socialised, there are a lot of myths in home education, too.

academicyeah · 30/08/2022 06:59

Perhaps your friends are drawn to home schooling because they would prefer their children to be taught by people who can spell?

1AngelicFruitCake · 30/08/2022 06:56

@Aretheyhavingalaugh How can you be so certain she’ll thrive? For me school is about far more than learning information. It’s about socialising with a wide range of children, not other home schooled children who are going to be similar to an extent. To relate to different adults and learn from them.

I also enjoy watching my children take part in whole school events and special days.

I find it interesting to know your views. There must be a good degree of self confidence to home school. I’m a teacher and I don’t think I’m always the best person to reach my children. My 6 year old has been incredibly inspired this year by her teacher who has a real flair for art, she wouldn’t have got that passion from me!

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 06:55

I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

I’m not sure that’s ideal for your children though. They need their own space!

LastWordsOfALiar · 30/08/2022 06:55

Tumbleweed101 · 30/08/2022 06:27

I home schooled my eldest two children for a while. What I learned is that you definitely do need other home schooling families around for support which is perhaps why this group appear ‘clicks’. My main reason were both children were July and August birthdays and I didn’t feel they were ready for a school environment. At the time I was working part time, opposite shifts to my partner so it worked well.

I had to stop though when I had my younger children as there simply wasn’t the time to devote to all the children’s needs and we had moved area (not by choice) away from the support we’d had.

I became a single parent a few years later so HE has never been an option since as you do need to be able to support the family financially too.

Just for the purpose of letting people know, many areas now allow you to delay school for 1 year for Summerborn children (born April-Aug). So they get their full education, just starting the term after they turn 5, not 4.

Unfortunately some areas still make you fight for it but lots are very accepting. Stats do show Summerborns are at a disadvantage (obviously) so I can see why you felt hesitant sending them at the time.

I have 3 kids and couldn't home school, I wouldn't be giving them enough time and attention.

I also love working and having time for ME. So homeschooling wouldn't be in anyone's best interests in my family.

LittleBearPad · 30/08/2022 06:54

I think the people who don’t have to HE because of SEN feel they have to defend their decisions so rhapsodise about HE being amazing and then sound a bit evangelical/cult-like.

OperaStation · 30/08/2022 06:52

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:07

We are planning to home school our children ( 4 year old DD & 7 month old DS) we are in a very fortunate position to be able to do this as many parents who work full time, wouldn't be able to afford the luxury. I don't see it as a ' cult' or as a opting out of society. In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children. I understand school is a service for the mass population, but my DD will definitely thrive with 1 on 1 teaching and not have to compete with 30 children. It is also to be noted that the smart children in the class don't progress fast enough and they can only learn at the pace of the slowest child. My DD has just turned 4 and is already learning what they teach in year 1( age 5 - 6). I think if you have to time, inclination and resources to teach your children yourself, they will be greater achievers and I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

I would love to see your stats about home schooled children doing better than state and privately educated children. This topic seems to come up regularly on mumsnet and the studies that I’ve seen shared do not support your claim.

Why do you fear your child having to compete with 30 other kids in a classroom? Did you have a bad school experience yourself?

sarahc336 · 30/08/2022 06:51

What do people think the child would prefer? I always feel sad for home schooled children, surely they don't get the same
Social interaction with friends 🤷🏻‍♀️ I am however poorly educated on home schooling but I always wonder if the child would pick home schooling over mainstream school x

Stellaris22 · 30/08/2022 06:51

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

I don’t see it as very likely that this persons children will be entering the ‘normal’ work place (or work at all) from their post about incredible luxury.

LastWordsOfALiar · 30/08/2022 06:48

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 30/08/2022 01:07

We are planning to home school our children ( 4 year old DD & 7 month old DS) we are in a very fortunate position to be able to do this as many parents who work full time, wouldn't be able to afford the luxury. I don't see it as a ' cult' or as a opting out of society. In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children. I understand school is a service for the mass population, but my DD will definitely thrive with 1 on 1 teaching and not have to compete with 30 children. It is also to be noted that the smart children in the class don't progress fast enough and they can only learn at the pace of the slowest child. My DD has just turned 4 and is already learning what they teach in year 1( age 5 - 6). I think if you have to time, inclination and resources to teach your children yourself, they will be greater achievers and I can't imagine anything better than spending all my time with my children.

Do you worry that they'll miss out on the social side of school?

Academic performance is important, but isn't hanging with your friends, playing silly games and chatting over lunch important too?

My son's a similar age to your eldest and whilst I can see some benefits to homeschooling, I can't imagine keeping them back from the "softer" benefits of school. Mine loves preschool at the moment.

byvirtue · 30/08/2022 06:47

I find Home Educators fascinating I inadvertently stumbled on a network of them during covid where we attended a local forest school. I typically found a degree of evangelism (they were passionate about doing the best for their children), a rejection of mainstream education (for many reasons) and often an element of wanting to live an alternative lifestyle without so much government intervention.

To be honest I agreed with a lot of it, i generally think our society is geared up now to get women into some form of work so they are contributing £££ to the economy. To do that there needs to be childcare/full time schooling. I don’t think that’s necessarily best for children especially primary age.

Personally for my family I would love a hybrid method of home education where kids are in school part time and home educated the rest. It doesn’t exist so my child goes to school but I certainly see why parents opt out of traditional schooling.

OldWivesTale · 30/08/2022 06:43

He was very interesting and very bright but socially awkward and a smidgen odd. Home schooled til Alevels

See. He's not like this because he's home schooled. He was like this anyway because he's very likely to be autistic. This is why the mum has chosen to home school because her kid was probably being excluded and bullied at school.

Underhisi · 30/08/2022 06:43

"However, I do see homeschooling as a privilege to a certain extent because it relies on a parent not working (or part time) and is self funded for the majority."

Everyone who I know does it because there is no suitable school for their school.
Some 'chose' in that they pulled their child out of school because of what was happening in school ( child's needs not being met).
One was told by the school to choose between exclusion or home educating.

Others had no choice because their was no school for their child. Some of these children actually have 'education other than at school' but this was provided after huge battles with LA who didn't want to fund it even though they couldn’t offer a school place.

Charley50 · 30/08/2022 06:42

"In terms of statics, privately educating children do better than state educated and actually home schooled children do better on average than privately educated children." @Aretheyhavingalaugh - where is this statistic from?

OldWivesTale · 30/08/2022 06:41

Most parents who homeschool do so out of necessity because the state school system is wholly inadequate for children with any kind of SEN; and many of those kids won't have a diagnosis of ASD but they will be struggling in mainstream, usually in a social sense. So it's often done in desperation at a crap state system and a lack of any alternatives. Also, in terms of the actual "education" that state schools provide, they are right, it is crap. And I say this as a teacher. We churn out minions who learn to do as they are told and question nothing; it's important for maintaining the status quo. God forbid we should encourage children to think critically. If we did, those at the top would be in trouble.

Wallywobbles · 30/08/2022 06:39

I traveled in my late 20s with a guy that had been homeschooled by his lawyer mother. He was very interesting and very bright but socially awkward and a smidgen odd. Home schooled til Alevels.

I also have an American friend, the middle of 3 daughter, part of a very Christian group, who were homeschooled through high school to keep them pure. They married the first person they kissed.

She was charming, traveling in a safe way, lots of home skills, jam making traditional American recipes, knitting, sewing etc. She'd have preferred school. But they did get through the curriculum by April so got to have a really long summer break.

Tumbleweed101 · 30/08/2022 06:27

I home schooled my eldest two children for a while. What I learned is that you definitely do need other home schooling families around for support which is perhaps why this group appear ‘clicks’. My main reason were both children were July and August birthdays and I didn’t feel they were ready for a school environment. At the time I was working part time, opposite shifts to my partner so it worked well.

I had to stop though when I had my younger children as there simply wasn’t the time to devote to all the children’s needs and we had moved area (not by choice) away from the support we’d had.

I became a single parent a few years later so HE has never been an option since as you do need to be able to support the family financially too.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 06:13

tobee · 30/08/2022 02:31

Exactly! This is what seems so obvious to me! You're children are just going to be mixing with a very similar like minded group of other children, and adults. Nothing like reality of later life. Such a limited preparation. Also such a small pool.

And also: "Even doing those things it's still a small pool of like minded kids; hobbies and special interest." - @tobee

You're assuming that home educators are a homogenous group of people who all think the same - they aren't and they don't.

My children probably saw more diversity from a cultural, racial, socio-economic and political perspective in the people they had to mix with at home ed groups and activities.

if they had gone to the local schools they would have mainy mixed with middle class white children of Conservative voters, because that's the demographic of the school catchment area we live in.
it is difficult to see how that would have been more varied.

Ragged · 30/08/2022 06:08

Disclaimer: the more I was exposed to HEing, the less I ever wanted to ever do it. Most things HErs extolled as advantages of HE: I saw as disadvantages. And (imho) HErs are definitely far more prejudiced against school-ed than other way around. No one else says this and it's definitely not the most important thing... most of the long-term HE kids I know are under-achievers academically as adults. Which makes sense if you were raised being strongly told how unimportant and low value are things like: material wealth, qualifications, fitting in with your community, prestige....

That said, I've know a dozen families who did HE over the decades. New HErs especially can be especially evangelical about HEing. But among themselves, sometimes ferrets in a sack. Big diversity of perspectives and strategies. Some more hands on than others. None of the HErs I know are "unschooling is wonderful!" believers. Most of them despaired & were sneery about unschooling. About half of them only HE'd for a relatively short period, maybe 2-3 years. It's a very broad movement.

LondonWolf · 30/08/2022 05:17

BattenburgSlice · 30/08/2022 02:40

There isn’t adequate school provision for my ASD dcs so we have to home Ed out of necessity. Many SEN children are home Ed for this reason.

This.

Not sure where that fits in with parents being "weird as fuck and totally co-dependant" though 🤔

Also OP, you're a teacher but spell clique as click?

Morph22010 · 30/08/2022 05:07

Newuser82 · 30/08/2022 04:50

@Morph22010 I don’t think school is the reality of later life either. No where else in later life I can think of where you put 30 plus completely different people together for 6 hours a day and expect them to get on and I’m not an advocate of home schooling

A workplace??

even in a workplace you don’t end up with completely different people to the same extent as a school, people tend to go into a job in which they have some sort of interest on the whole and that suits their personality, so an introvert for example probably wouldn’t go for a job in sales where they are having to deal with people all day. School is just the whole cross section of interests and personality’s thrown in together and expected to get on. Then in the workplace if people don’t get on their is the option of leaving and finding somewhere else which is a lot more difficult with a school.

justtheway · 30/08/2022 05:03

Well said @DanielTheGhostGangbanger.

MiddleOfHere · 30/08/2022 05:03

People have some very strange ideas of home education. We home educated for years.

To people who have never home-educated, home educators must seem like a homogenous group of social outcasts. But in reality, it isn't like that at all.

The people we came across are much more varied than if we had simply sent them to the school down the road which is primarily white middle class.
During our time, we came across people of all kinds of religions, different socio-economic backgrounds, cultures, heritages and nationalities.
It was like the UN. We knew people from the UK, France, America, South Africa, India, Ireland, Germany, Portugal, Italy, to name a few. We knew Catholics, CofE, Methodist, Baptist, Jehovas Witnesses, 7th Day Adventists, Muslims, atheists, agnostics.
The parents' occupations were doctors, dentist, software engineers, unemployed/non-working, carers, accountants, sales reps, retail workers, solicitors, writers, chefs, scientists, civil servants, social workers and lots of ex-teachers just to name a few. And there were some people into MLM, too - there's really no escape from MLM, it seems.

We knew people who lived in huge houses with acres of land and tiny terraced houses, new builds, 1930s semis and Victorian red-bricks and those who lived in boats and caravans. Had they simply gone to the local school, they would have only known children who lived in houses very similar to ours.

The reasons why people home educate are so varied. Some people chose it from the start and others come to it because of difficulties at school - usually bullying or un-met SEND needs and some that aren't particularly struggling at school but still want to try home education. And those who chose it from the start do it for different reasons. There are some who do it because they disagree with mass education, school teaching methods, but others do it because work means they move around a lot and don't want to keep changing schools, religious reasons or to avoid religious teaching.

People home educate in so many different ways from completely child-led to very structured. Some follow the national curriculum and some don't. Some are at home a lot and some are always out.

Also, in reality, home educators are not all in agreement- just like the parents of school-going children don't always agree.
Everyone knows a home ed family who they would not choose to spend time with, for example. It isn't one great big love-in or cult.

Home educators aren't all insular either, they do all kinds of clubs and activities too and their parents are just as likely, if not more likely, to be volunteering in things like scouts and other community groups.

Most home educators are massively concerned about socialisation and put a lot if effort in to ensure their children are isolated. However depending on the child and the area, home ed children may have fewer friends but from a wider age-span or a wider geographical area.
However, the number of genuine friends (as opposed to classmates and acquaintances) that school children have varies too. Very social children will have many friends but quiet or more introverted children may have only one or two. Home educated children are the same!

Some home ed children come out with fantastic grades at GCSE and A level, some come out with average grades and some (like school pupils) don't get any at all. Some go to university and others don't.
And some home ed children go onto be doctors and vets and others go on to be circus performers and everything in between.

It's such a common but lazy generalisation to assume all home educators are either anarchists or hot-housing elitists.

avamiah · 30/08/2022 05:00

@DanielTheGhostGangbanger
I don’t know if your a regular on here but I am and I appreciate your post but it’s a bit too long and many people will just think they can’t be bothered reading such a long post and not even read it.

Your post is very relevant.
x

Swipe left for the next trending thread