Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another electricity one. Sse is going to tell the bank to increase my direct debit to £400.00 a month.

84 replies

coodawoodashooda · 29/08/2022 23:56

Do I cancel the direct debit? Is there a penalty for not paying by direct debit. I can't possibly afford that.

OP posts:
BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 30/08/2022 08:39

FayeGovan · 30/08/2022 08:20

I read somewhere the energy companies are hiking up the DDs of everyone so that the people that overpay compensate for the people that wont pay or underpay. So it leaves their balance sheets ok.
I know someone will come along and tell me thats rubbish but it makes perfect sense to me. If its wrong why are people in credit who are good payers being asked to pay even more???

Because the prices are going up significantly and credit will disappear very fast once the darker nights and colder weather hits

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 08:37

chillipenguin · 30/08/2022 08:21

If that's true that's bloody awful.

that can't be right
they have increased it already, a couple of weeks ago in my case, they forecast this is what I need to pay
regardless of whether other people will pay or not.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 08:36

the bank will automatically take the direct debit and then any other outgoings will be less,
there will be no food
no petrol
just direct debits

chillipenguin · 30/08/2022 08:21

FayeGovan · 30/08/2022 08:20

I read somewhere the energy companies are hiking up the DDs of everyone so that the people that overpay compensate for the people that wont pay or underpay. So it leaves their balance sheets ok.
I know someone will come along and tell me thats rubbish but it makes perfect sense to me. If its wrong why are people in credit who are good payers being asked to pay even more???

If that's true that's bloody awful.

FayeGovan · 30/08/2022 08:20

I read somewhere the energy companies are hiking up the DDs of everyone so that the people that overpay compensate for the people that wont pay or underpay. So it leaves their balance sheets ok.
I know someone will come along and tell me thats rubbish but it makes perfect sense to me. If its wrong why are people in credit who are good payers being asked to pay even more???

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 08:18

@EmmaH2022 Most of the last few years the price cap was about £1200, last October it went up a little more, in April it went up to £1,971, from last week it's £3,549, in January it's expected to be £5,386, and then go up to about £7k in April. Maybe £9k or even £10k in October.

Based on what you had been paying the energy company algorithm must have thought you needed an adjustment. At these kinds of prices, a few hundred in credit can be eaten up quite quickly,

Northernerinwales · 30/08/2022 08:16

I’m with SSE and they’re so bad. They set me up with a direct debit for our flat. I had the bill from the previous tenant as it had numbers on for us to call to set up our own account. The previous tenant was paying for her usage monthly and was paying about £30 in electric and £20 in gas. When I called them they set me up a DD for £140 for both after two months of paying it we were in massive amounts of credit. I called them and cancelled the DD and now I pay quarterly. I have the SSE app which tells me my usage for the month and whatever I have used that month I top up my account into credit so when the bill does come it’s already paid for with the credit. It might not work for Everyone but our flat is small and our usage costs aren’t that much so this works for us. We had worked out that we would have been about £700 in credit from when we moved in until Christmas is we had continued with the DD which is a ridiculous amount of money considering we would still be paying the DD every month with all that in credit

CeeJay81 · 30/08/2022 08:14

I'm on a fix until 3rd November. Can change direct debits myself and I'm around £400 in credit. I'm hoping eon will let me decide on my new direct debits from then but going by all these posts I'm wondering what the minimum amount is they'll let me do. There's no way I can afford £400 plus. About £300 including the £66 is what I'm going to pay. I just hope they accept it. I'll be cutting back as much as possible but we aren't high users anyway. Looking at usage it should be enough esp with the credit We have just in case.

Bonbon21 · 30/08/2022 08:12

Keep the direct debit you have at the moment... send in a reading online on payday every month and pay the excess amount... they cannot object as you do not owe them any money... if you cannot pay the full amount then tell them and pay what you can to top up the direct debit amount.. they will have to make allowances for millions of people i this country.... while countjng their millions and millions of profit in their spare time..

CredibilityProblem · 30/08/2022 08:12

This is all pretty scary. I imagine there will be a lot of people like the OP moving to variable DD because they simply can't afford four hundred pounds, and then building up an eye watering amount of debt at eight hundred pounds per month over the winter. Unless Truss and Kwarteng intervene radically in September they'll have no choice but to nationalise the suppliers by Spring because they'll all be bust.

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 08:09

Here's the Which? calculator if you want to compare it with what your energy company is suggesting:

www.which.co.uk/news/article/energy-price-cap-rises-to-3549-how-will-it-affect-your-bills-aZkHR2p2t2P7

TwoCoffeesPlease · 30/08/2022 08:08

EDF wanted to double my DD payment after our tariff changed. Would have been fair enough if they hadn’t just issued us a £350 refund because our actual usage and their estimated usage are wildly different.

In reality we are only now using in £ what we were paying before our tariff increased. Obviously this is summer so it will go up later in the year. I agreed a cursory £20 increase to my direct debit and am monitoring the smart metre and will make changes in autumn/winter as necessary but I want to the impact of the £66.

I basically told them what pp have said, I am a grown up and perfectly capable of managing my own payments thank you. They give you the waffle and not advising that you pay less - this is because they want to steal the interest on your money. Don’t let them. Tell them what you can afford to pay and what is reasonable based on actual usage, or simply pay whenever your bill arrives.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 30/08/2022 08:07

i keep trying to reduce and will keep doing so

FatOaf · 30/08/2022 08:05

If you want to cancel your DD, you are free to do this. There is no penalty. If you are on the standard tariff, you may find when you cancel your DD the daily standing charge goes up by a few pence. The reason for this is many energy suppliers will knock a few pence off the daily standing charge as a thank you for paying by DD, as it lowers their admin costs.

This is incorrect.

If you pay on receipt of a bill instead of by direct debit the unit cost will go up, not just the standing charge.

www.mirror.co.uk/money/martin-lewis-warns-against-cancelling-27848340

BordoisAgain · 30/08/2022 08:01

I'm currently over £400 in credit too...

BordoisAgain · 30/08/2022 08:00

XmasElf10 · 30/08/2022 07:53

I change my ScottishPower DD amount on the app because what they choose to charge me is always far more than I use and leaves me in a lot of credit.

I tried that, but they will only let you reduce it to a point that you are no more than £100 in debt based on their estimated usage.

They are charging me £350 at the moment, despite me using less than £200 and are refusing to lower it any more.

I have explained til I am blue in the face that our energy usage last year was artificially high and it is a lot less now, but they aren't budging.

EmmaH2022 · 30/08/2022 08:00

Danikm151 · 30/08/2022 00:01

Call them and tell them you can’t afford it. The call centre person will say how you risk going into debt. Acknowledge this and tell them an amount you can afford.

I did it last year when they wanted to triple my dd despite me being in credit

Oh...so I'm not the only one who was asked to increase despite being in credit. This happened to me in March. I still can't figure out what the hell that was for.

XmasElf10 · 30/08/2022 07:53

I change my ScottishPower DD amount on the app because what they choose to charge me is always far more than I use and leaves me in a lot of credit.

coodawoodashooda · 30/08/2022 07:30

Thank you everyone

OP posts:
MsJinks · 30/08/2022 07:06

Shell wanted me to pay 250 per month from April I think it was. I could alter this on the app though couldn’t get it below 170 and got lots of messages pointing out this was not enough. Have you got an app that gives information, or possibilities available on the website? I think if you call you will be able to negotiate if you want to stay on the DD, or change to pay your bill each month - I think that is Martin Lewis advice along calling to register a complaint if you’re worried you can’t afford the bills.
I didn’t choose Shell, got them when my previous one went bust, and I am in some credit now. My usage last year was higher than it has been since April, but guess they can only go on last year’s. Also understand that they like cash in their bank to get energy at good rates, though not sure how this works when we don’t store it in the U.K.
These are ridiculous prices and I expect mine, and everyone’s will be looking at similar rises - so this thread will be useful. Though maybe Sept 5 will change things - maybe!

londonrach · 30/08/2022 06:40

Ring your energy company and talk to them and agree an amount you can pay

cakeorwine · 30/08/2022 06:40

You really need to look at your usage in KWH and see what you think it will be under the new rates.

Identify what devices are using a lot of energy - and see if you can make some lifestyle changes.

Reducing the DD will not reduce the overall bill - so make sure you understand where the energy is going

chillipenguin · 30/08/2022 06:32

BarbaraofSeville · 30/08/2022 05:38

I've never had a direct debit been too much. We've almost always been in debt to the energy company, often by hundreds of pounds.

OP, what is your projected annual cost and do you have any debt on your account? Are you on a fixed or variable tariff and how many units do you use?

Are you planning to use a lot less in the coming winter?

There seems to be an awful lot of people saying they'll pay what they owe on variable direct debit, which seems quite a risky strategy at the end of summer when bills are lowest.

Those bills 'paying for what you owe' early next year need to incorporate a doubling in the unit rate if you're on the price cap and much higher winter usage.

If your annual predicted use is £4k your bills for December to March could be £6/7/800 a month.

I predict a lot of complaints about this early next year from people who just don't realise this.

Yup agree. When the unit prices go up more it will only get worse.

chillipenguin · 30/08/2022 06:31

You'll have to give the energy company a ring and ask them to take less.

BarbaraofSeville · 30/08/2022 05:38

Eeksteek · 30/08/2022 00:19

I don't know how it works with DDs. I just want to pay what I owe each month, same as I do with my phone bill. I think the argument of 'Building credit so you can budget' is bollocks. They ALWAYS want to take more than they need (by about 20% in my experience) even when you have actual usage data.

Octopus wanted to put my DD up to some stupid amount. I said no. So they didn't. I still built two month's credit over the summer. Obviously that won't be sufficient for the winter, but how I budget for that is MY problem to choose how to solve, not theirs to dictate in advance.

I've never had a direct debit been too much. We've almost always been in debt to the energy company, often by hundreds of pounds.

OP, what is your projected annual cost and do you have any debt on your account? Are you on a fixed or variable tariff and how many units do you use?

Are you planning to use a lot less in the coming winter?

There seems to be an awful lot of people saying they'll pay what they owe on variable direct debit, which seems quite a risky strategy at the end of summer when bills are lowest.

Those bills 'paying for what you owe' early next year need to incorporate a doubling in the unit rate if you're on the price cap and much higher winter usage.

If your annual predicted use is £4k your bills for December to March could be £6/7/800 a month.

I predict a lot of complaints about this early next year from people who just don't realise this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread