Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent my parents choice of name for me?

367 replies

Blaengwnfi · 29/08/2022 22:36

This is a rant - apologies.

I’ve always hated my name.

No one can pronounce it. Not even my father or siblings. It was always read out incorrectly at school and the other kids would laugh at me. It gives me major anxiety having to introduce myself.

I use my middle name professionally but it doesn’t feel like “my” name. I feel so angry with my parents sometimes for burdening me with this name.

Parents - please think before giving your kid a weird or “unique” name! It could really mess them up…

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 30/08/2022 11:23

I find the generational aspect of wanting a special /untoasted? name that expresses the unknowable uniqueness of a new baby interesting. Relatively recently, parents in working class UK towns were happy to send their child to a primary with several Julies, Claires, Sarahs, Rebeccas, Catherines, Davids, Simons, Marks, Pauls, James and Richards and by my rough calculation, c3% of a primary class had an unusual names. No stress by parents or children and no expectation of a disaster if another child in the school dared have the same, no calling family or friends copying a name someone had declared they owned evil or copycats. The names changed by cohort and fashion.

Malie · 30/08/2022 11:23

My father always hated his name. Thankfully he had been given to others so he used one of those. Interesting that Clive Staples Lewis the great author never liked his name from a boy and always insisted on being called Jack. Published under the name CS Lewis

Kennykenkencat · 30/08/2022 11:22

Marvellousmadness · 30/08/2022 11:15

Boohoo
You hate your name?

Change it

And stop using excuses why you can't
If you HATE your name CHANGE it

I did. When I was 15. I hated my name
And how now lived almost 3 decades with a name I love and makes me feel shiny and happy

Stop sulking and staying in a victim role. It is time to take action

Tick tock up. life is too short . And a name is one of the most important things. It defines who you are in a way
Your name should make you happy. Not miserable and awful.

Ps i never changed my name LEGALLY
Because $$$
But I just started going by a different name. And have never looked back.

I changed my name for £20. I have passport, driving licence etc in my new name

TeaAddict235 · 30/08/2022 11:22

SequinsandStilettos · 29/08/2022 23:03

Sharon Horgan (whose daughter is Sadhbh) did a whole shtick in Catastrophe about no-one being able to pronounce Muirann.

Yes but then she goes on to do the typical thing of laughing at African names with clicks in them. The whole world is supposed to be respectful of Gallic names but can always poke fun at African names. Confused oh ha ha funny times Sharon

DacwMamYnDwad · 30/08/2022 11:17

@MolkosTeenageAngst , but your suggested alternatives are mostly nothing like the original. Buddug to Beth - just why? Gwenllian wouldn't call herself Llian, but she could call herself Llio or Gwen. Leanne sounds nothing like Gwenllïan and has a completely different vibe.
How would you get Do or Ira from Blodeuwedd, and why wouls a woman want to give herself a man's name (Ira) as a nn?
Heulwen to Helen or Ellen - Helen maybe, but why not just use Heulwen.

Your suggestions are like suggesting that a Jacqueline call herself Kelly, or a Caroline call herself Roly or Colin something.

Marvellousmadness · 30/08/2022 11:15

Boohoo
You hate your name?

Change it

And stop using excuses why you can't
If you HATE your name CHANGE it

I did. When I was 15. I hated my name
And how now lived almost 3 decades with a name I love and makes me feel shiny and happy

Stop sulking and staying in a victim role. It is time to take action

Tick tock up. life is too short . And a name is one of the most important things. It defines who you are in a way
Your name should make you happy. Not miserable and awful.

Ps i never changed my name LEGALLY
Because $$$
But I just started going by a different name. And have never looked back.

JubileeTissues · 30/08/2022 11:13

"I just cannot imagine growing a human being in my body, birthing them, looking into the face of this human that I’ve created…and then giving them a boring untoasted bread name like ‘Elizabeth’ or ‘James’ that six other kids they know will have. It seems mad to me."

Get a grip. There is 1 James in my DCs primary school and no Elizabeth. Both are lovely names.

SirVixofVixHall · 30/08/2022 11:08

KirstenBlest · 30/08/2022 11:04

@elphame, Buddug isn't obscure. I don't know many, but I know more than one.

Same.

RaRaRaspoutine · 30/08/2022 11:07

Blodeuwedd is pronounced so beautifully. I've never heard of it before today (sheltered!!)

SirVixofVixHall · 30/08/2022 11:07

My friend, who always hated her name, changed it in her late twenties or early thirties to something completely different . I met her a few years later so only knew the new name. Her mother was annoyed and would still use her original name but her siblings were understanding. Change it OP, as it makes you so unhappy.
Just a thought, are you still Naomi on your birth certificate?
Do you live in Wales ? As many, if not most, Welsh names get totally mangled by anyone not Welsh speaking. Neither of my dc have the family names I might have chosen, as I was worried if they left Wales for university or work nobody would ever say their name correctly. I regret this now though it worried me at the time. My children have easy to say names that still get mispronounced so I should have stuck with the others !

Elphame · 30/08/2022 11:06

KirstenBlest · 30/08/2022 11:04

@elphame, Buddug isn't obscure. I don't know many, but I know more than one.

The only one I know is my Aunt.

Chillow · 30/08/2022 11:05

cooliebrown · 30/08/2022 10:28

I have often wondered how people feel about being named Roxanne, after the Police song - Roxanne in the song was a suicidal prostitute...

Roxanne is the anglicisation of Rokhsane, an Iranian name for Alexander the Great's wife, meaning bright star. Nothing to do with prostitutes.

KirstenBlest · 30/08/2022 11:04

@elphame, Buddug isn't obscure. I don't know many, but I know more than one.

unname · 30/08/2022 11:01

DrJump · 30/08/2022 06:07

Ive got an unusual welsh. I love it.

“Give your daughters difficult names.
Names that command the full use of the tongue.
My name makes you want to tell me the truth.
My name does not allow me to trust anyone
who cannot pronounce it right.”

—Warsan Shire

I really love this.

I have a double barrel name. The first part is boring (to me) but when I introduce myself, lazy people will just hear that. They won’t bother to say my full name. If you yelled it at me on the street I wouldn’t turn around.

The second part is better, but I don’t like it alone.

So I introduce myself as a diminutive of the 2nd name, which I don’t really like much either but I can live with it. A friend in college told me her family made fun of it and said I sounded like a telemarketer. (I thought her name was old fashioned and weird but was polite enough not to say so!)

Most people only find out my real name after knowing me a long time. The people that call me by it are my real friends. I’ve come to feel protected by keeping it to close friends and family.

SoupDragon · 30/08/2022 10:56

generalh · 30/08/2022 10:10

As it is my name, I know how to pronounce it. There is no r. I have been called Shane Shaney, even Shyann ( by those who do not speak Engkish as a first language) but it is the spelling which bugs me the most. It is my only name so I dislike it when the ^ is missed. It is a different word without it. Siân!!! A first world problem but still...

I know there's no R. I never said there was. And I'm sure you do know how to pronounce your own name.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 30/08/2022 10:55

DacwMamYnDwad · 30/08/2022 07:40

@MolkosTeenageAngst , how on earth do you get these:Eg:
Buddug - Biddy, Beth
Heulwen - Helen, Ellen,
Angharad - Angie, Harriet
Gwenllian - Gwen, Leanne
Blodeuwedd - Di, Ira,?

Buddug - BITH-ig, th like in the and that, not like the th in Beth
Heulwen - approx. HAIL-wen
Angharad - Ang-HARR-add, no g soung in ng
Gwenllian - Gwen-LLEE-ann, LL like the ch in liebfraumilch, but not like in scottish loch
Blodeuwedd - Blod-EY-weth, th like in this and that, not like th in Beth.

I’m well aware of how they’re all said in Welsh thank you, but the OP isn’t in wales and has said that she doesn’t like having a welsh name that people in England cannot pronounce. I was thinking of alternative names that have some sort of vague link to the original name.

Obviously if her name is Gwenllian and she went with Llian people in England still wouldn’t be able to pronounce it, if she went with Leanne (which I know is not said as the Llian in Gwenllian) then people would be able to say it and it would at least have a vague link in some of the sounds to her current name.

I wasn’t suggesting Welsh nicknames using the Welsh sounds to Welsh names because it was the Welsh sounds whilst living in England that the OP was saying are the difficulty!

MolkosTeenageAngst · 30/08/2022 10:55

DacwMamYnDwad · 30/08/2022 07:40

@MolkosTeenageAngst , how on earth do you get these:Eg:
Buddug - Biddy, Beth
Heulwen - Helen, Ellen,
Angharad - Angie, Harriet
Gwenllian - Gwen, Leanne
Blodeuwedd - Di, Ira,?

Buddug - BITH-ig, th like in the and that, not like the th in Beth
Heulwen - approx. HAIL-wen
Angharad - Ang-HARR-add, no g soung in ng
Gwenllian - Gwen-LLEE-ann, LL like the ch in liebfraumilch, but not like in scottish loch
Blodeuwedd - Blod-EY-weth, th like in this and that, not like th in Beth.

I’m well aware of how they’re all said in Welsh thank you, but the OP isn’t in wales and has said that she doesn’t like having a welsh name that people in England cannot pronounce. I was thinking of alternative names that have some sort of vague link to the original name.

Obviously if her name is Gwenllian and she went with Llian people in England still wouldn’t be able to pronounce it, if she went with Leanne (which I know is not said as the Llian in Gwenllian) then people would be able to say it and it would at least have a vague link in some of the sounds to her current name.

I wasn’t suggesting Welsh nicknames using the Welsh sounds to Welsh names because it was the Welsh sounds whilst living in England that the OP was saying are the difficulty!

gatehouseoffleet · 30/08/2022 10:55

The name existed before the song, and unless a name is both distinct and attached to something truly awful (like Adolf) then it will continue to be used after a historical figure or cultural reference

I was very surprised to meet an Adolf in his mid 20s in 1992! Not only does it have awful connotations, but it's a horrible name as well. But maybe it sounds horrible because of who you associate it with.

gatehouseoffleet · 30/08/2022 10:54

It’s interesting, isn’t it? Lots of English people seem unable to get their heads around even Welsh and Irish names, much less anything properly ‘forrin

I saw something on LinkedIn a while ago saying that people were capable of pronouncing (European) foreign footballers' names properly but not eg Sri Lankan or some African surnames, which are long but phonetic so easy to say. The point was you can pronounce things properly if you make the effort.

Mind you, my son and I got onto the subject of where the M4 ends today (long story how we got there) and I said "oh it ends at Pont something" (thinking of Pont Abraham) but it actually ends at Pontarddulais. I've got to say that did stump me from a pronounciation perspective. My guess would be Pont-a-thi-lice but I am guessing that is completely wrong!

IheartJKRowling · 30/08/2022 10:53

My friends named their son Inigo. I asked if it was in reference to the architect and she said her husband greatly admired him but I was the first person to make the connection. Mostly people replied to the name choice by quoting Inigo Montoya "you killed my father, prepare to die" line from the Princess Bride.

She and her husband were completely unaware of the film and the often quoted line. Selfish parents trying to impress people with their name choice. Poor little Inigo grew up hating his name and now calls himself a very bland generic male name.

toastofthetown · 30/08/2022 10:51

cooliebrown · 30/08/2022 10:28

I have often wondered how people feel about being named Roxanne, after the Police song - Roxanne in the song was a suicidal prostitute...

Probably ambivalent if they think of it at all. The name existed before the song, and unless a name is both distinct and attached to something truly awful (like Adolf) then it will continue to be used after a historical figure or cultural reference. The memory of Oliver Cromwell hasn’t stopped that being the most popular boys name for the last decade.

Kennykenkencat · 30/08/2022 10:49

FWIW I changed my name completely.

Did it through a form from a solicitors and I think it cost me £20 at the time and it was witnessed and stamped and done in a few minutes.

Ilkleymoor · 30/08/2022 10:47

My child has a slightly more unusual Irish name that's easy to say but people get the Heebies when they see the spelling. Which is funny as they've literally just said it right. Did have people who would see themselves as right on go but why would you do that? I asked if they would say the same to a polish, Ghanaian or sri Lankan family and they went quiet. No idea why it's ok to make an enormous fuss about Irish names

Or maybe they are secretly thinking the same about the polish, Ghanaian and sri Lankan names.

Chillow · 30/08/2022 10:45

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 10:32

Same!

I was the only person with my (traditional W.African language) first name on FB for over a decade and I loved it. 😂There’s a few dozen of us now, but another person with the combination of my first and last name will never happen.

I have always REALLY loved my name. It’s pretty, it’s unusual and it’s three syllables and completely phonetic, so quite difficult to get wrong unless you’re particularly stupid. My parents did well.

Same! Grin

Mine is an Arabic name.

I hope you nabbed the hotmail and gmail accounts for your names? Sadly, I didn't.

Bobadob18 · 30/08/2022 10:44

I totally feel your pain. My parents gave me a name which meant I am continually teased and dread telling people it. I use a shortened version but I hate it and wish I had used my middle name. To make it worse after my dad died my mum showed me a list of names they were considering. They were all really lovely names and I too feel cross with them (still!) that they didn’t choose one of those. My grandfather told them that naming me that name would lead to a lifetime of teasing and they sadly didn’t listen to him.
So a long winded story to say that I am in total sympathy with you and whilst I am sorry you are going through similar it was nice to know I am not the only one who feels this way.