Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent my parents choice of name for me?

367 replies

Blaengwnfi · 29/08/2022 22:36

This is a rant - apologies.

I’ve always hated my name.

No one can pronounce it. Not even my father or siblings. It was always read out incorrectly at school and the other kids would laugh at me. It gives me major anxiety having to introduce myself.

I use my middle name professionally but it doesn’t feel like “my” name. I feel so angry with my parents sometimes for burdening me with this name.

Parents - please think before giving your kid a weird or “unique” name! It could really mess them up…

OP posts:
OldFan · 31/08/2022 12:57

It is exceptionally bizaare that you know excess amounts of Elizabeths AND Mohammads, neither are comments on race but rather the fact you must live in a very bizaare place to have you circle heavily infultraited by both when relative to the 'name list rank' NEITHER are that common amoung the amount of general population and spaced fairly distantly location, class and culture wise.

@mam0918 'Infiltrated.' 😮 Mohammed is very common as a name (obviously it'd depend on the demographics of your area how often you come across a Mohammed.) It doesn't show as being as popular as it is on graphs/stats, precisely because it can be spelt in several different ways.

speakout · 31/08/2022 06:50

I hear you OP.
My parents allowed my 6 year old sister to choose my name, as she didn't want to have a baby sister.

sashh · 31/08/2022 06:46

I think it depends on when you have come across a name before. I used to work in healthcare and I once went and called for a patient called Siobhan.

The patient and her mother looked at each other in shock, I thought I'd screwed up. Nope, just the first person not to say See-o-ban.

Doing supply teaching I have often said, "If I get your name wrong taking the register, please let me know."

I've come across a Sian pronounced Cyan, Iona is a 50/50 if it is Yonna or Eye-o-na, in my accent.

It is more difficult to pronounce some names and I sometimes have to have more than one try. And I do try.

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 21:10

😂

KirstenBlest · 30/08/2022 21:04

@Cherchezlaspice , maybe I live in Bizarretown but have a 2nd home in Bizarre-on-Sea.

Chillow · 30/08/2022 20:44

mam0918 · 30/08/2022 19:13

I didnt 'assume' by the way I ASKED... do you know how questions work?

It is exceptionally bizaare that you know excess amounts of Elizabeths AND Mohammads, neither are comments on race but rather the fact you must live in a very bizaare place to have you circle heavily infultraited by both when relative to the 'name list rank' NEITHER are that common amoung the amount of general population and spaced fairly distantly location, class and culture wise.

I know several Kevins, Garys and Waynes (as mentioned before) I do not know many Victorias, Charlottes and Alexandras not saying either doesnt exist or wasnt statistically common when I was born but the cross over of 'social pockets' is not common, certainly not common enough to know several of all 6.

I know a few Mohammads and a few Elizabeths too. Your choice of the word is ‘infiltrated’ is bizarre to say the least.

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 20:37

KirstenBlest · 30/08/2022 18:52

I don't live in a city and know several Muhammads/Mohammeds/Mohameds, and Elizabeths.

Apparently that’s exceptionally bizarre. The circles don’t overlap and people who know Mohammeds don’t know Elizabeths. THE CIRCLES DO NOT OVERLAP.

And that’s not a comment on race, apparently.

This thread is hilarious. Parochial mindsets hoicking up their collective pants.

mam0918 · 30/08/2022 19:13

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 16:25

@mam0918 I didn’t quote any stats. You did (1 in 250, circle of 150). And if you do that without a citing a source, then it’s random. Do you know what ‘quoting stats’ means? As you don’t appear to.

Unless you’re Jubilee Tissues, I didn’t tell you to check anything. We hadn’t communicated at all until you tag/quoted me above.

I live in London. It wouldn’t matter if I lived in Leeds, your assumption that I wouldn’t know anyone named Mohammed would still indicate your reflexive assumptions around race. And Elizabeth would still be a common
name.

I didnt 'assume' by the way I ASKED... do you know how questions work?

It is exceptionally bizaare that you know excess amounts of Elizabeths AND Mohammads, neither are comments on race but rather the fact you must live in a very bizaare place to have you circle heavily infultraited by both when relative to the 'name list rank' NEITHER are that common amoung the amount of general population and spaced fairly distantly location, class and culture wise.

I know several Kevins, Garys and Waynes (as mentioned before) I do not know many Victorias, Charlottes and Alexandras not saying either doesnt exist or wasnt statistically common when I was born but the cross over of 'social pockets' is not common, certainly not common enough to know several of all 6.

KirstenBlest · 30/08/2022 18:52

I don't live in a city and know several Muhammads/Mohammeds/Mohameds, and Elizabeths.

StripeyDeckchair · 30/08/2022 18:34

I get what you mean. I have always disliked my name, for the opposite eason to you, it is old fashioned, plain and boring.
When I left home at 18 I lacked the confidence to use my middle name or choose a new one I liked. Now I feel its too late.

Ironically my mother uses her middle name because she hates her first name.

lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 18:29

live in London. It wouldn’t matter if I lived in Leeds, your assumption that I wouldn’t know anyone named Mohammed would still indicate your reflexive assumptions around race. And Elizabeth would still be a common name

to be fair if we’re talking about how common names are then the name Mohammed is associated with a minority religion (6.3%) in the U.K .So assuming a majority 93% of the population probably wouldn’t give their child that name. It’s more an assumption that you don’t live in a city which I agree is fairly presumptive.

JubileeTissues · 30/08/2022 17:43

Also, you're the one having arguments with several posters about stats and all sorts and then accusing someone of sock puppeting on a baby name thread. Very strange indeed.

I'll hide the thread then you can get on with your day unless anyone else appears you fancy having a pop at!

JubileeTissues · 30/08/2022 17:40

Sorry what? Sock puppeting?

I'm reading replies to threads I'm on and this is at the top, you don't need to tag me.

No popcorn necessary, it's not that exciting. Although is a false accusation of sock puppeting the same as troll hunting?

SoupDragon · 30/08/2022 17:09

🍿

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 17:06

@JubileeTissues I didn’t even tag you. So, you’re sock puppeting, now? All in defence of Elizabeth? Sweet Jesus. Yes, I’ll do my best to calm down. 😂

JubileeTissues · 30/08/2022 17:01

"Unless you’re Jubilee Tissues, I didn’t tell you to check anything."

Keep me out of it sweetheart, remember, it's just a name and the poster is right. Hardly anyone will know 6 Elizabeth's, never mind 6 children in the same social circle. That's all anyone is saying. Seriously, calm down.

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 16:25

@mam0918 I didn’t quote any stats. You did (1 in 250, circle of 150). And if you do that without a citing a source, then it’s random. Do you know what ‘quoting stats’ means? As you don’t appear to.

Unless you’re Jubilee Tissues, I didn’t tell you to check anything. We hadn’t communicated at all until you tag/quoted me above.

I live in London. It wouldn’t matter if I lived in Leeds, your assumption that I wouldn’t know anyone named Mohammed would still indicate your reflexive assumptions around race. And Elizabeth would still be a common
name.

mam0918 · 30/08/2022 16:08

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 15:49

I didn’t quote a single statistic, blindly or otherwise. 😂

I’m related to a Mohammed and a Muhammad. I know at least three more (various spellings). Your assumption that I wouldn’t know any (despite it being common) is actually very interesting. Says something about your reflexive assumptions re race.

‘Everyone else’ isn’t pointing out they know very few Elizabeths. A couple have. And none of them have said they don’t know any. That’s a common name.

I think certain names, of which Elizabeth is a prime example, are common and boring. Your argument that 1 in 250 people (yet I’m the one apparently quoting random stats) is named Elizabeth doesn’t really counter any of that.

Your the one quoting its popularity, how long its popularity has been going and stating ONS to back it up... my statist was from ONS which is what YOU told me to check so NOT random lol.

You know many Mohammads and Elizabeths, where do you live?

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 15:50

Zilla1 · 30/08/2022 13:32

@Cherchezlaspice apologies, my post was for an English context and I'm aware some other cultures have different approaches. Have met some people from one of the communities in the USA that seem to place a premium on a completely unique name with spelling. Other places can be more like the scene from Goodfellas where most of the men share a couple of names (Big Paulie, little Paulie...) Although the names would change over the course of a generation, almost everyone in my primary class shared names with several others.

Oh, I totally got what you meant. It’s interesting, isn’t it? I wonder where the different attitudes stem from?

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 15:49

mam0918 · 30/08/2022 15:24

Your blindly quoting random statistic.

Statistically Mohammad is one of the most common names in Britain but how many Mohammads do you know?

'Common' is relative and as everyone else is pointing out we know very few Elizabeth's then its NOT common.

Just because something is historically well established and well known does NOT means its in common usage.

1 in 250 people are called Elizabeth, the average person has a social circle of 150 people, it's really not unusual for people not to really know ANY Elizabeths.

Generational trending reigonal peak names are 'common' and thats relative to things like class and race - example: Kevin and Wayne might be 'common' to someone here because there was several in their infants school but it might be unheard of by someone who attended a posh private school.

I didn’t quote a single statistic, blindly or otherwise. 😂

I’m related to a Mohammed and a Muhammad. I know at least three more (various spellings). Your assumption that I wouldn’t know any (despite it being common) is actually very interesting. Says something about your reflexive assumptions re race.

‘Everyone else’ isn’t pointing out they know very few Elizabeths. A couple have. And none of them have said they don’t know any. That’s a common name.

I think certain names, of which Elizabeth is a prime example, are common and boring. Your argument that 1 in 250 people (yet I’m the one apparently quoting random stats) is named Elizabeth doesn’t really counter any of that.

mam0918 · 30/08/2022 15:24

Cherchezlaspice · 30/08/2022 12:02

If I had said ‘six other kids in their class’, you’d have a point. I didn’t, however. Again, loose grip on reality. Perhaps actually read what you’ve responded to.

Elizabeth has been one of the most popular female names in the U.K. for decades. There are more Elizabeths than any of the names you’ve listed. The fact that ‘Clara’ or ‘Delilah’ might be popular for a few years doesn’t change that. This is basic common sense, but you can check ONS stats if you don’t believe me.

They are (indisputably) common names, I think they’re boring and I don’t like them. The fact that this upsets you so much (but you apparently have no objection to people complaining about ‘unusual’ names) is extremely funny.

Your blindly quoting random statistic.

Statistically Mohammad is one of the most common names in Britain but how many Mohammads do you know?

'Common' is relative and as everyone else is pointing out we know very few Elizabeth's then its NOT common.

Just because something is historically well established and well known does NOT means its in common usage.

1 in 250 people are called Elizabeth, the average person has a social circle of 150 people, it's really not unusual for people not to really know ANY Elizabeths.

Generational trending reigonal peak names are 'common' and thats relative to things like class and race - example: Kevin and Wayne might be 'common' to someone here because there was several in their infants school but it might be unheard of by someone who attended a posh private school.

Elphame · 30/08/2022 14:29

RaRaRaspoutine · 30/08/2022 11:07

Blodeuwedd is pronounced so beautifully. I've never heard of it before today (sheltered!!)

That's my pups name!

I did consider it for DD. Lovely name from the Welsh mythology but hard to cope with living in England.

Zilla1 · 30/08/2022 13:32

@Cherchezlaspice apologies, my post was for an English context and I'm aware some other cultures have different approaches. Have met some people from one of the communities in the USA that seem to place a premium on a completely unique name with spelling. Other places can be more like the scene from Goodfellas where most of the men share a couple of names (Big Paulie, little Paulie...) Although the names would change over the course of a generation, almost everyone in my primary class shared names with several others.

lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 13:04

DacwMamYnDwad · 30/08/2022 12:13

@lightisnotwhite , the google translate sounds really strange saying it.

Budd rhymes with with, ug rhymes with wig

Thank you, that’s really helpful.

Shedcity · 30/08/2022 13:03

‘Made up a nonsense spelling’ / ‘made up names’
as opposed to what? All the ‘real’ names that were also at some point made up?

people saying ‘Christ im not saying that’ or similar are so rude. What is wrong with a ‘how would you like me to pronounce your name?’

the concept of ‘prime minister names’ seems similar to me to sending your child to a private school because the comp isn’t good enough. You are perpetuating and enabling a system that disadvantages others, typically based on race and class. That’s fine you have to do what’s best for your children, but it’s odd to feel superior or judge others for not doing so.

and it’s really odd to me to judge someone for a ‘unique’ name, when the point of a name is to literally differentiate you from other people.

over and over this thread is examples of people trying to demonstrate how a name is ridiculous, but in fact just demonstrating how rude they or the people around them are.