Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think tiered electricity prices might work ?

113 replies

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:25

I saw a suggestion today that a way forward with rising energy prices might be to give every household an allowance ( based on number occupants ?) of x units of energy at a subsidised price. Any units used over that price would then be more expensive, a little more than predicted now, to help finance the reduced price units.
This way the least well off can have at least a minimal amount of heating and power to cook etc without worrying about horrendous bills.
Anyone wanting to use more, and can afford to do so, is then helping to subsidise the price for those less able to pay .
Seems to allow an element of choice whilst encouraging less energy use and therefore having green credentials
Sure there are flaws but seem to be some advantages too ?

OP posts:
Parrotpretty · 29/08/2022 22:58

I think anyone that qualifies for the existing warm homes discount should automatically be on a social affordable tariff straight away. That should take the pressure off the most vulnerable.

mumda · 29/08/2022 22:58

Heat the person not the house.

An allowance per person could maximize use of housing but would cause issues with people sharing who shouldn't. Majorly difficult to implement.
Tiering of rates so first few units are sensible priced wouldn't help those who need more electric but additional ratings could help. But then the energy companies would struggle to manage the billing for anything so complex.

The govt just throwing money at energy companies isn't going to help or be a long term solution.

Vulnerable people who need to be warm need good quality insulated homes that are cheap to keep warm. We need to be insulating where possible too for everyone.

Will office buildings finally turn everything off at night?
Will streetlights times be reduced or turned off entirely?

Sittingonabench · 29/08/2022 22:56

I think it’s a pretty good idea. And while it may start off a blunt tool could be improved with time to address unfairness. When it comes to disabled I would expect the benefits to increase to supplement support. If we can get to a place where energy which is needed for basic eating and not freezing is affordable and surplus luxury/ ease use is more expensive - that would seem sensible. This seems one of the best ideas I’ve heard so far.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/08/2022 22:53

Poorer people would still end up paying more due to not being able to afford the most economical appliances, furnishings or even have control over the insulation or appliances in rented accommodation - if the 2nd tier was dearer to encourage less use, it would therefore organise them even more.

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:51

@HotPenguin I think it would gave to be a fairly blunt tool and not be fair in some ways, just like the furlough payments etc.
I don't think you can be fair to everyone just the majority?

OP posts:
secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:49

@Christmasiscominghohoho yes but everyone gets the basic amount , so if you choose not to use more than that then you aren't subsidising anyone.
Thing is that those that are financially better placed, are going to end up paying for this one way or another with increases in tax, at least this feels more direct in a way.

OP posts:
HotPenguin · 29/08/2022 22:48

It's a good idea. It would be difficult to come up with a basic allowance that was fair for everyone - for example people who are ill/disabled need to be home all day, and some use electricity for heating while others don't. But I think it would be possible to come up with a system eg giving extra allowance for people who need more energy due to illness.

byvirtue · 29/08/2022 22:47

Interesting idea, however a lot of rural homes depend on electricity because there is no gas to the premises and there has been a move away from oil especially in new builds. A lot of my neighbours are electricity only.

Unbridezilla · 29/08/2022 22:47

Not a bad idea, but not implementable in time for this winter I'd bet.

That's the big problem. Huge structural change required, but not the time to do it before the problem hits.

So need brute force implementation of help now, in a way that will be massively criticised and unfair, whilst also building long term changes which are more nuanced.

Cupofteainthemorning · 29/08/2022 22:44

I like the idea of having a basic allowance of cheaper of electricity for everyone. So you can at least cook one hot meal a day and have heating on a bit without worrying. That would be better than giving more handouts.

However, I'm not sure its fair charging some people more for the higher rate when they have no choice but to have the heating on more e.g. sick and disabled, families with young children, elderly. What about people living in the far north of England where it is colder than the south coast? Would they get a bigger allowance? It seems there would be too many exemptions and it would get complicated.

The simplest solution is to tax the gas and oil companies on their profits and use that money to reduce the price cap. That helps everyone equally but of course the government won't do that.

Metabigot · 29/08/2022 22:43

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

Isn't taxation a case of those who can afford it (life) subsidising those that cannot? Yet people largely accept the need for taxation.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

amicissimma · 29/08/2022 22:31

"Sure there are flaws but seem to be some advantages too ?"

I'm not sure there is any solution to the energy price problem that is flawless. This one seems quite sensible. Best not to let the perfect be the enemy of the good.