Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think tiered electricity prices might work ?

113 replies

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:25

I saw a suggestion today that a way forward with rising energy prices might be to give every household an allowance ( based on number occupants ?) of x units of energy at a subsidised price. Any units used over that price would then be more expensive, a little more than predicted now, to help finance the reduced price units.
This way the least well off can have at least a minimal amount of heating and power to cook etc without worrying about horrendous bills.
Anyone wanting to use more, and can afford to do so, is then helping to subsidise the price for those less able to pay .
Seems to allow an element of choice whilst encouraging less energy use and therefore having green credentials
Sure there are flaws but seem to be some advantages too ?

OP posts:
MissyCooperismyShero · 29/08/2022 23:41

Why would the energy companies do this?

CapMarvel · 29/08/2022 23:40

Oh doubtless we need to help people in the short term.

So much more the government can and should do to move people into energy efficiency though, and long term that is the best way to mitigate rising prices.

bellac11 · 29/08/2022 23:39

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

Wouldnt that be the choice of the person to use less though and therefore not pay the higher price

Nothings perfect but I like this idea

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:37

CapMarvel · 29/08/2022 23:31

What we should be doing is heavily subsidising ways for people to make long term savings on their bills.

Free insulation. Significant discounts on new efficient heating systems/ solar panels/double glassing/ energy efficient applicances and lighting and things like e-bikes as alternatives to cars for commuting.

You can either give someone £500 to just spend on power in the short term, or fund the means to save that money through long term reduced bills.

Agree with this, definitely, but I think both schemes would be needed

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:33

JaninaDuszejko · 29/08/2022 23:29

What about people living in the far north of England where it is colder than the south coast?

Never mind the 'far north' of England, what about those in Scotland???

I can see several issues. Imagine two equivalent houses. One is privately owned and the owners earn a good salary and have put in double glazing, cavity wall insulation, underfloor insulation, roof insulation, and have installed solar panels and an air source heat pump. Their gas boiler is a modern energy efficient model. The owners regularly move energy suppliers to get a good deal. The house next door is a rental property that has had no energy efficiency improvements and has an old inefficient gas boiler. The tenants are on a prepayment meter. Guess who has the highest bills and yet still has the coldest home? Should they subsidise their better off neighbour's lower energy costs?

There needs to be money spent on improving our old housing stock so that we use less electricity and gas and the cost of green electricity may need to be decoupled from the price of gas. And the government need to think about how they tax property as well as wages.

These are more problems that exist already and regardless of this suggestion - but I agree home insulation should be a priority for this government.

Scotland / North England could have a different basic allowance if necessary.

CapMarvel · 29/08/2022 23:31

What we should be doing is heavily subsidising ways for people to make long term savings on their bills.

Free insulation. Significant discounts on new efficient heating systems/ solar panels/double glassing/ energy efficient applicances and lighting and things like e-bikes as alternatives to cars for commuting.

You can either give someone £500 to just spend on power in the short term, or fund the means to save that money through long term reduced bills.

Thisismynamenow · 29/08/2022 23:31

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:25

I don't see how it changes anything. If LL knows your individual energy consumption, it's straightforward. If he's splitting the bill among a few of you, you may already be paying for other people's higher usage. Or they may be paying for yours. That would keep happening.

@Mangledrake I suppose my immediate thought was HMO's where the LL doesn't know whos using what.

If the house/flat etc has a separate meter then the LLwill just pass it on as usual

JaninaDuszejko · 29/08/2022 23:29

What about people living in the far north of England where it is colder than the south coast?

Never mind the 'far north' of England, what about those in Scotland???

I can see several issues. Imagine two equivalent houses. One is privately owned and the owners earn a good salary and have put in double glazing, cavity wall insulation, underfloor insulation, roof insulation, and have installed solar panels and an air source heat pump. Their gas boiler is a modern energy efficient model. The owners regularly move energy suppliers to get a good deal. The house next door is a rental property that has had no energy efficiency improvements and has an old inefficient gas boiler. The tenants are on a prepayment meter. Guess who has the highest bills and yet still has the coldest home? Should they subsidise their better off neighbour's lower energy costs?

There needs to be money spent on improving our old housing stock so that we use less electricity and gas and the cost of green electricity may need to be decoupled from the price of gas. And the government need to think about how they tax property as well as wages.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:25

Thisismynamenow · 29/08/2022 23:23

There's always going to be nuances to a plan like this.
The landlord may have to unfortunately split the bill evenly I guess. It wouldn't be a foolproof plan, just better than others.
Though someone much smarter than me could perhaps offer a solution.

I don't see how it changes anything. If LL knows your individual energy consumption, it's straightforward. If he's splitting the bill among a few of you, you may already be paying for other people's higher usage. Or they may be paying for yours. That would keep happening.

Malad · 29/08/2022 23:24

I think anyone at home all day should be subsidised first. Pensioners, those who can’t work due to disabilities. people with pre school kids etc. if you are choosing to work at home when you could go into work then that’s a no from me. Your work should pay if they want you to work from home or you pay yourself.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:23

XenoBitch · 29/08/2022 23:20

How would this work with people who pay rent and bills combined to their landlord?

Same way it does now, so long as you're renting legally. You'd have an allowance. Whether you're on your own meter or a shared meter, x units could be paid at basic rate. Your landlord must be paying an agreed rate at the moment. You just may not know what it is.

Thisismynamenow · 29/08/2022 23:23

XenoBitch · 29/08/2022 23:20

How would this work with people who pay rent and bills combined to their landlord?

There's always going to be nuances to a plan like this.
The landlord may have to unfortunately split the bill evenly I guess. It wouldn't be a foolproof plan, just better than others.
Though someone much smarter than me could perhaps offer a solution.

XenoBitch · 29/08/2022 23:20

How would this work with people who pay rent and bills combined to their landlord?

Thisismynamenow · 29/08/2022 23:19

I suggested this to my husband earlier today.

The average household (2.4 people) is 2900kwh of electricity and 12000kwh of gas. So each household gets that at the April Cap.

Add an extra 1000kwh of electric and 3000kwh of gas for each additional household member.

Those on low income/disability/uc etc. Get immediately put on a social tariff back to 2021 price cap plus additional support if needed.

Heck, even give those in the North beyond the wall (excuse the lame GOT joke) extra gas to stay warm in the colder weather.

Anything above that usage gets charged at the full cap.

Obviously if your a full electric house another average for that would need to be considered.

Complicated but fairer and probably more sustainable than other options. Richer people can use more, but those who can't can still get support and heat/eat. Also encourages reduction in energy use.

It's too obvious for the government to implement though.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:17

ExcuseeeeMe · 29/08/2022 23:14

Would cost people in cold parts of the country like Scotland more. So no it wouldn’t work. Also would cost people who run expensive medial machinery from their house more too. Also people with medical conditions that require heat like arthritis would end up in serve debt . It’s a terrible idea.

But all those things are happening now anyway, unfortunately.

And you could offer the people above more units at basic rate to bring their costs down - unlike now.

ExcuseeeeMe · 29/08/2022 23:16

*medical

ExcuseeeeMe · 29/08/2022 23:14

Would cost people in cold parts of the country like Scotland more. So no it wouldn’t work. Also would cost people who run expensive medial machinery from their house more too. Also people with medical conditions that require heat like arthritis would end up in serve debt . It’s a terrible idea.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:13

Apl · 29/08/2022 23:10

I’m fed up of being told to subsidise others. I pay six figures in tax a year, that is what it is for. The government needs to sort this mess out using tax money, not have different tiers of energy prices etc.

Tax take could subsidise the basic rate for everyone, then? After basic rate, you pay what the market dictates. But the idea if I've understood right is everyone gets the basic rate.

Apl · 29/08/2022 23:10

I’m fed up of being told to subsidise others. I pay six figures in tax a year, that is what it is for. The government needs to sort this mess out using tax money, not have different tiers of energy prices etc.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:07

Sounds good to me. Given that people are on different rates at the moment, it may not be that difficult to have a basic rate (with different thresholds by household size and circumstance) and a premium rate.

We do need to incentivise people to use less. It wouldn't be a matter of those who can afford it paying for those who can't any more than lots of other services - e.g. people who buy multiple cars pay more road tax; people who travel first class subsidise cheaper tickets: your choice to choose to pay extra for a luxury.

silverclock222 · 29/08/2022 23:05

By that theory I'd be classed as being 'well off', presumably because I don't claim any benefits. Unfortunately I have cancer and two autoimmune diseases and work only 4 days a week (although been off sick for months). Because I work and no educational age children, even though my DP is out of work we get precisely £0. I would be about £400 a month better off if I wasn't working. I'm sure there are many in my financial (if not medical) situation where we just aren't entitled to anything.

Thisismynamenow · 29/08/2022 23:03

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

@Christmasiscominghohoho you realise even those who are well off are going to struggle?
We're on a relatively higher income ( though we are both still within the 20% tax bracket) and I can't just poof an extra £7k out of thin air.

Higher income earners pay more tax subsidising others, so why can't they get help when also needed?

Also, those who have spare money will need to continue spending to keep businesses going as long as possible. Once higher earners cut back then you will see the retail/hospitality/beauty sectors collapse. Guess who's usually employed there? Those who may struggle. Sounds insensitive but those higher earners spending may keep businesses going for longer.

PestorPeston · 29/08/2022 23:01

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

Good to see Christian ethics in full flow 😣

Getoff · 29/08/2022 23:01

It would be difficult to come up with a basic allowance that was fair for everyone

Maybe just add a tax/charge of 10p (or any fixed number) per kwh to both electricity and gas bills, and distribute the proceeds evenly to all electricity accounts. Everyone would pay the charge on all their consumption, but people who used a below-average amount of energy would get back more than they were charged.

GrumpyPanda · 29/08/2022 22:59

Cupofteainthemorning · 29/08/2022 22:44

I like the idea of having a basic allowance of cheaper of electricity for everyone. So you can at least cook one hot meal a day and have heating on a bit without worrying. That would be better than giving more handouts.

However, I'm not sure its fair charging some people more for the higher rate when they have no choice but to have the heating on more e.g. sick and disabled, families with young children, elderly. What about people living in the far north of England where it is colder than the south coast? Would they get a bigger allowance? It seems there would be too many exemptions and it would get complicated.

The simplest solution is to tax the gas and oil companies on their profits and use that money to reduce the price cap. That helps everyone equally but of course the government won't do that.

Nope. The point is we are facing a twofold problem atm. 1) We need to reduce demand. The best way to achieve this is still through the price mechanism. 2) We need to do this without hurting the weakest members of society, who don't have a choice about basic consumption- they need to eat, they'd rather not freeze to death.

Tiered rates are a sensible way of addressing both problems by keeping base consumption alone but addressing optional consumption at the margin.

The problems you bring up are about fine-tuning. In principle it's not impossible to introduce a differentiated base tariffs - depending on household size, with exemptions, etc. Just a matter of how much administrative capacity you have to work with, and what costs that will incur. And also, it's never possible to do justice to each and every individual circumstance- that's the dilemma of rule-making in general.