Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think tiered electricity prices might work ?

113 replies

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:25

I saw a suggestion today that a way forward with rising energy prices might be to give every household an allowance ( based on number occupants ?) of x units of energy at a subsidised price. Any units used over that price would then be more expensive, a little more than predicted now, to help finance the reduced price units.
This way the least well off can have at least a minimal amount of heating and power to cook etc without worrying about horrendous bills.
Anyone wanting to use more, and can afford to do so, is then helping to subsidise the price for those less able to pay .
Seems to allow an element of choice whilst encouraging less energy use and therefore having green credentials
Sure there are flaws but seem to be some advantages too ?

OP posts:
Mangledrake · 30/08/2022 00:28

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:19

That’s true but those of us who are just clinging on are starting to slip now too it’s really worrying.

This scheme could help you too @BashfulClam

I am a single homeowner and I remember adding up my council tax and saying to my Dad, I don't get much back for it. He pointed out that that's the system working the way it needs to - a single, healthy adult in full-time employment, without dependents, should be a net contributor unless wages are skewed.

Cost of living is going up so fast that wages are skewed, so I understand your alarm. But a scheme like this that keeps middle earners coping as well as helping the poor is an excellent idea.

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 00:26

Vegay · 30/08/2022 00:18

@BashfulClam I'm not saying you should subsidise others. I'm saying that I'd be happy to help others in such a way as the OP suggests. I live in Yorkshire, so although not as cold as beautiful Scotland, it can still get cold. I'm going to make sure I don't use the heating unnecessarily, I can't stop imagining the most vulnerable who are cold though...children, the elderly. I feel sick. This is not an acceptable situation for anyone to be in. It's disgraceful.

Unemployed people get a shade over £4k a year as a standard element of UC which is £334 a month. Imagine that for a second.
If you loved.in social housing, UC pays your rent.. if you don't live.in social housing, you have to make up the rental shortfall from that £334

I helped a family. £950 a month UC.
Rent £450
Council tax £40
Water £13
Gas and electric at the time £60

And that's before food.

If we hadn't got them moved and got them into a cheaper social housing house.. I don't know how they'd have made it through tbh. Bad enough they had to move 85 miles from their home town.
But that's nothing to do with the topic really.

Wishyfishy · 30/08/2022 00:25

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 00:10

The government and utility companies do not know how many people live in each house.

The water companies base their bills on exactly this info,.unless you've got a meter.
I've just been helping a family sort their bill out with Severn Trent. They told the family they had 5 people living in the house, having a shower every day and doing 5 loads of washing a week. Which was a shock, there's 3 of them and they don't own a washer or a shower. Severn Trent based their info on previous tenants info.
That family signed up to Severn Trent and applied for Severn Trent Big Difference Scheme which helps those on low incomes and benefits to lower their bill.
They didn't qualify in the end, it's means tested, but it was worth applying just in case.

I don’t recall any kind of information gathering from my water company, and if there was how often do they ask for it to be refreshed? Your example sadly shows that the data they hold would often be completely wrong which would make the idea of allocating per person a bit of a nightmare.. You’d have to phone up your energy provider after the birth of every child for instance… !(and probably provide proof).

@BashfulClam I consider my family squeezed middle in many respects too. I’ve never claimed a benefit in my life. I wouldn’t consider this idea subsidising anyone at all. We are relatively low energy users for two main reasons 1) I always try and make environmentally conscious decisions where I can and 2) We are pretty conservative and would rather put extra money into the mortgage / savings etc than spend it washing towels after every use.

I would likely benefit from this change purely because we are low-ish users. The people I know who would be “subsidising” me would be those who keep thermostats on 20oC day and night etc. This is a choice and nothing to do with income.

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:19

That’s true but those of us who are just clinging on are starting to slip now too it’s really worrying.

Vegay · 30/08/2022 00:18

@BashfulClam I'm not saying you should subsidise others. I'm saying that I'd be happy to help others in such a way as the OP suggests. I live in Yorkshire, so although not as cold as beautiful Scotland, it can still get cold. I'm going to make sure I don't use the heating unnecessarily, I can't stop imagining the most vulnerable who are cold though...children, the elderly. I feel sick. This is not an acceptable situation for anyone to be in. It's disgraceful.

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 00:10

The government and utility companies do not know how many people live in each house.

The water companies base their bills on exactly this info,.unless you've got a meter.
I've just been helping a family sort their bill out with Severn Trent. They told the family they had 5 people living in the house, having a shower every day and doing 5 loads of washing a week. Which was a shock, there's 3 of them and they don't own a washer or a shower. Severn Trent based their info on previous tenants info.
That family signed up to Severn Trent and applied for Severn Trent Big Difference Scheme which helps those on low incomes and benefits to lower their bill.
They didn't qualify in the end, it's means tested, but it was worth applying just in case.

CapMarvel · 30/08/2022 00:08

Apl · 29/08/2022 23:10

I’m fed up of being told to subsidise others. I pay six figures in tax a year, that is what it is for. The government needs to sort this mess out using tax money, not have different tiers of energy prices etc.

If you are really paying over 100k in tax you are earning at least 250k a year, and you begrudge perhaps a little more of that going towards people who are literally having to choose whether to buy food or heat their homes?

Fucking hell.

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:07

Also agree with a pp that I live in Scotland it’s much colder here for more of the year so do we get extra allowance?

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:06

@vegay but we never get anything ourselves. We are constantly asked to help those on less than us but at the same time we’re just afloat. Earn too much for benefits, too old or young for free transport, pay full mortgage, council tax etc and are very much ‘the squeezed middle’.

Wishyfishy · 30/08/2022 00:06

You also couldn’t do it per person. The government and utility companies do not know how many people live in each house. They have vague ideas on a population level from the census and things but not granular and up to date.
Even the data you provide the council is generally normally on adults only. I don’t think other than council tax or electoral roll the council knows who lives in my house and that’s only updated annually and doesn’t include my DC.

Make it as simple as possible is the only way.

XenoBitch · 30/08/2022 00:01

toooldtocarewhoknows · 29/08/2022 23:59

I think it's a good idea.

Another variation to help those with disability would be to give an additional amount of KWH at the reduced rate to those who claim PIP, DLA or Attendance Allowance.

This then covers the higher costs associated with disability. The database is already running as these groups are due to get £150 in September which won't touch the sides.

Not everyone who claims those benefits use anymore KWH though. You can claim PIP and be out in a full time job.

You can also be on Jobseekers and be home all day, hence using more energy to power devices and keep warm.

Vegay · 30/08/2022 00:00

@BashfulClam our household earns a very healthy salary, and I would be more than happy to support a suggestion such as the OPs. We will be doing whatever we can for those that need help, regardless of what the Govt do - probably fuck all, although I do think there will be civil unrest soon.

I do think it is crass when someone comes on with such a username, when the reality is that many people won't be doing Christmas this year, stating their suggestion that 'why should we help them out'.

toooldtocarewhoknows · 29/08/2022 23:59

I think it's a good idea.

Another variation to help those with disability would be to give an additional amount of KWH at the reduced rate to those who claim PIP, DLA or Attendance Allowance.

This then covers the higher costs associated with disability. The database is already running as these groups are due to get £150 in September which won't touch the sides.

Wishyfishy · 29/08/2022 23:57

It absolutely should not be means tested though. That adds complexity to it that makes the whole thing non viable. You simply can’t look at each household on a case by case basis.

Just have incremental higher rates for energy as we do things like stamp duty.

Those who need extra energy due to medical needs eg needing dialysis or a CPAP machine could get a code that gives them a higher allowance at the lower rate. That would be my only exception to the rule.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:56

BashfulClam · 29/08/2022 23:51

we earn £50k between us and are in our 40’s. We always seem to be subsiding someone but in reality although that sounds like a good amount of money it only really stretches so far and we will be subsiding more people but never getting any help ourselves.

This would help you yourselves - you'd be entitled to basic rate too

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:54

Vegay · 29/08/2022 23:47

@Christmasiscominghohoho as someone that can sustain this horrendous situation, I think the OP's suggestion is quite a compassionate one, one which could stop people from freezing to death, starving to death or ending their own life.

Why should those that are more healthy financially help those that aren't? It's called kindness, compassion and actually being a fucking human being.

Hope you enjoy your coming Christmas ho ho ho, it's probably one that you need to be really extravagant with, because this country is fucked! We'll be losing businesses galore, the economy is fucked, people aren't going to be able to afford to continue their small independent businesses, house prices will reduce drastically, and hopefully our money will become worthless. It's a fair thing when millions of people are being screwed over and can't even afford to heat their homes. Merry fucking Xmas.

And remember - when you put cash back in poorer people's pockets, they spend it - because they need to. That boosts the economy. Low to middle earners will help keep hairdressers and hospitality going locally in the same way. People paying six figures in income tax? They're more likely than the others to stash any gain overseas or tie it up to avoid tax. So if you want a functional society for purely selfish reasons, help the poor

XenoBitch · 29/08/2022 23:54

Unemployed on UC get little more than £70 a week. They will probably be at home a lot more (and using more energy) compared to someone who is out at work all day. How will that work?

Livelovebehappy · 29/08/2022 23:53

Apl · 29/08/2022 23:10

I’m fed up of being told to subsidise others. I pay six figures in tax a year, that is what it is for. The government needs to sort this mess out using tax money, not have different tiers of energy prices etc.

100% agree with you.

Wishyfishy · 29/08/2022 23:52

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

It’s not this though is it? Those who can afford would also have the same allowance. If they choose to run hot tubs, use the tumble dryer daily etc etc they can but no one is forcing others to do this. We would all benefit from the lower rate if we limited our use.

Even before the money came into it I was always trying to reduce our energy use for environmental reasons. Until fossil fuels are gone lower use should always be encouraged.

BashfulClam · 29/08/2022 23:51

Vegay · 29/08/2022 23:47

@Christmasiscominghohoho as someone that can sustain this horrendous situation, I think the OP's suggestion is quite a compassionate one, one which could stop people from freezing to death, starving to death or ending their own life.

Why should those that are more healthy financially help those that aren't? It's called kindness, compassion and actually being a fucking human being.

Hope you enjoy your coming Christmas ho ho ho, it's probably one that you need to be really extravagant with, because this country is fucked! We'll be losing businesses galore, the economy is fucked, people aren't going to be able to afford to continue their small independent businesses, house prices will reduce drastically, and hopefully our money will become worthless. It's a fair thing when millions of people are being screwed over and can't even afford to heat their homes. Merry fucking Xmas.

we earn £50k between us and are in our 40’s. We always seem to be subsiding someone but in reality although that sounds like a good amount of money it only really stretches so far and we will be subsiding more people but never getting any help ourselves.

MoistBandana · 29/08/2022 23:50

I reckon:
Scrap standing charges at a flat rate.
Instead, standing charges are based on a percentage of usage costs, say 10%

So people using as little as they can, say £100 a month, will pay £10 standing charge.
People using more pay more.

Then, have a means tested energy cost reduction scheme that anyone can claim.
Someone earning 45k whose essential outgoings mean they can't afford energy, they get help just like someone on Universal Credit will.
But, the essentials would have to be quite strict. If someone's ringing up thinking their holiday to Vegas at £3000 counts as an essential, it won't be..
But..
Mortgage / rent, childcare, commute, council tax, insurance, water, food, internet. They'd be counted.
The reduction would be a percentage of their average bill for the last 12 months.

That's what I reckon would work.

A phone line would be needed to administer it, maybe 3. South, Midlands and Scotland. Creating jobs on their local areas.

#voteformoistbandana
#leaderofthetitheadparty

🤪

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:49

BurscoughBooths · 29/08/2022 23:43

A standard allowance of cheap rate energy per household could work.
Per household only as it would be far too complicated to increase the cheap rate allowance per person. The admin costs would be horrendous.
There needs to be an incentive to cut usage, I would not be happy to subsidise those people who wash towels after one use or who heat their houses to tropical temperatures

I think you could have more than two tiers without major complicates - look at all the different rates on offer at the moment. But even if this didn't solve everything, it would be an excellent starting point. You could keep mechanisms like warm home payments etc alongside it.

Agree that it's hard to see why we should all suffer consequences of higher demand from people who won't consider reducing exorbitant usage. Give everyone a basic rate to cover essential usage, tweak with rebates and additional payments for those with higher needs, charge the rest at a higher rate

Vegay · 29/08/2022 23:47

@Christmasiscominghohoho as someone that can sustain this horrendous situation, I think the OP's suggestion is quite a compassionate one, one which could stop people from freezing to death, starving to death or ending their own life.

Why should those that are more healthy financially help those that aren't? It's called kindness, compassion and actually being a fucking human being.

Hope you enjoy your coming Christmas ho ho ho, it's probably one that you need to be really extravagant with, because this country is fucked! We'll be losing businesses galore, the economy is fucked, people aren't going to be able to afford to continue their small independent businesses, house prices will reduce drastically, and hopefully our money will become worthless. It's a fair thing when millions of people are being screwed over and can't even afford to heat their homes. Merry fucking Xmas.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 23:44

MissyCooperismyShero · 29/08/2022 23:41

Why would the energy companies do this?

It would have to be imposed (like the price cap) or subsidised (like the rebate) - I doubt they'd do it without government intervention.

But the government should be intervening.

BurscoughBooths · 29/08/2022 23:43

A standard allowance of cheap rate energy per household could work.
Per household only as it would be far too complicated to increase the cheap rate allowance per person. The admin costs would be horrendous.
There needs to be an incentive to cut usage, I would not be happy to subsidise those people who wash towels after one use or who heat their houses to tropical temperatures