Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think tiered electricity prices might work ?

113 replies

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:25

I saw a suggestion today that a way forward with rising energy prices might be to give every household an allowance ( based on number occupants ?) of x units of energy at a subsidised price. Any units used over that price would then be more expensive, a little more than predicted now, to help finance the reduced price units.
This way the least well off can have at least a minimal amount of heating and power to cook etc without worrying about horrendous bills.
Anyone wanting to use more, and can afford to do so, is then helping to subsidise the price for those less able to pay .
Seems to allow an element of choice whilst encouraging less energy use and therefore having green credentials
Sure there are flaws but seem to be some advantages too ?

OP posts:
newbiename · 30/08/2022 15:11

Christmasiscominghohoho · 29/08/2022 22:41

umm no. I’m not sure why the people that can afford it should have to subsidise for those that can’t!

You advantage is make those that have more money pay for everyone else.

just no.

Like tax you mean ?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 15:03

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 14:03

The idea has flaws but I think it's one the the best for achieving the long term goal of reducing energy consumption, even after this current crisis has passed.

Allocation by council tax banding - not great but the categories already exists and generally mean the bigger the house, the bigger the allocation. Use averages for each sized home to determine their cheaper allowance and everyone who uses up to that amount gets to do so cheaply. Anyone who uses over pays more heavily for the units over and above their allocation.

No reason why averages cannot be specific to country, so Scotland has its own average allocation calculation. As does Wales etc.

Social tarriffs can exist for those who need to use more than the average for medical reasons.

I am pretty sure we'd personally end up worse off with electric bills but may be ok with gas. But I could see this working and it encouraging us to keep cutting down on energy use permanently.

Council tax bandings would fuck over everybody who lives in social housing built after a certain year and in areas they have no control over living in in the first place, as they have to take what they're offered when homeless or need a particular type of property.

Combined with already higher council taxes, energy use because they don't own the heating, insulation or windows to decide to have more economical versions installed and rents that don't bear much relation to those charged for a council house in, say, Doncaster, for the sin of being born in Tooting, somebody could be paying thousands more but ineligible for council tax relief, low emissions zone charging, and now would also be expected to pay more for electricity because they have no choice about how much is used beyond breaching tenancy regulations by not having the heating or hot water on at all and causing damp and frozen pipes?

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 30/08/2022 14:31

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:51

@HotPenguin I think it would gave to be a fairly blunt tool and not be fair in some ways, just like the furlough payments etc.
I don't think you can be fair to everyone just the majority?

Sod those with disabilities then that have to use extra electrical equipment etc

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 14:29

I’m not sure what the council tax bandings have to do with it. Why should a big house have a different energy tariff than a small house?

Because, in theory, a bigger house = more people in it.

It's not always true, of course, but it seemed like a reasonable/blunt tool to get to a quick answer. Which is what I meant by "not great but the categories already exists".

How else would you do it?

Ariela · 30/08/2022 14:25

XenoBitch · 29/08/2022 23:20

How would this work with people who pay rent and bills combined to their landlord?

It would work in the same way winter fuel allowance, energy rebates etc simply don't happen for the most vulnerable in society on the least income.

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 14:13

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 14:03

The idea has flaws but I think it's one the the best for achieving the long term goal of reducing energy consumption, even after this current crisis has passed.

Allocation by council tax banding - not great but the categories already exists and generally mean the bigger the house, the bigger the allocation. Use averages for each sized home to determine their cheaper allowance and everyone who uses up to that amount gets to do so cheaply. Anyone who uses over pays more heavily for the units over and above their allocation.

No reason why averages cannot be specific to country, so Scotland has its own average allocation calculation. As does Wales etc.

Social tarriffs can exist for those who need to use more than the average for medical reasons.

I am pretty sure we'd personally end up worse off with electric bills but may be ok with gas. But I could see this working and it encouraging us to keep cutting down on energy use permanently.

I’m not sure what the council tax bandings have to do with it. Why should a big house have a different energy tariff than a small house?

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 14:03

The idea has flaws but I think it's one the the best for achieving the long term goal of reducing energy consumption, even after this current crisis has passed.

Allocation by council tax banding - not great but the categories already exists and generally mean the bigger the house, the bigger the allocation. Use averages for each sized home to determine their cheaper allowance and everyone who uses up to that amount gets to do so cheaply. Anyone who uses over pays more heavily for the units over and above their allocation.

No reason why averages cannot be specific to country, so Scotland has its own average allocation calculation. As does Wales etc.

Social tarriffs can exist for those who need to use more than the average for medical reasons.

I am pretty sure we'd personally end up worse off with electric bills but may be ok with gas. But I could see this working and it encouraging us to keep cutting down on energy use permanently.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 13:44

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 12:35

That's expensive.conpared to areas like Grimsby, Cleethorpes, Scunthorpe, Doncaster etc etc.

They often have quite odd rents like 88.17weekly. why the 17p I don't know.

Price of needing disabled accessible housing - ie, somewhere with step free access to the front door - in the only area you have family ties to (ineligible for housing in any other area). And nobody from the cheaper areas is interested in a swap for obvious reasons.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 30/08/2022 13:05

PestorPeston · 29/08/2022 23:01

Good to see Christian ethics in full flow 😣

They missed the point too that they don't actually have to use more. They can choose to and pay extra for it, but don't have to. Can't expect Christians to have compassion or brains though. 😂

bigvig · 30/08/2022 12:57

It's a decent idea OP (and better than any of the politicians have come up with). However I think the problem is too big for a bit of tinkering. The government needs to produce it's own power through nationally owned companies (North Sea Oil and Gas, wind power, tidal power - we have the means) and introduce a national provider into the market. It'll easily drive out of business the private companies profiteering off everyone else's misery - no need for expensive buy outs. By producing our own power Britain would also be less at the mercy of international prices and could provide power as a service at cost rates. Why not? The current system is clearly broken.

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 12:35

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 11:06

Social housing rent here for a two bed is £720 pcm.

That's expensive.conpared to areas like Grimsby, Cleethorpes, Scunthorpe, Doncaster etc etc.

They often have quite odd rents like 88.17weekly. why the 17p I don't know.

Brogues · 30/08/2022 11:57

isn't this what is already happening? £400 back for everyone (universal kW you proposed) and £600 for those in certain benefits (additional kW).

Like PP pointed out it would be a challenge to go any further by need. We have solar so don’t use much during the day but have EV and are high users at night. I wouldn’t want the job of someone trying to figure out whether we should get more or less allowance :)

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 11:46

The problem with Kiers plan is that it is staggeringly expensive and we cannot tell
where the high prices - and the support required - are going to end. The advantage with a tiered system is that if it is made ludicrously expensive to have high energy use, people will change habits. Those that can will plough money into making their homes more energy efficient.

Poorly insulated rental properties would become much less attractive and command lower rents. Just think, if you rented a place with no central heating and an outside loo you’d expect to pay a lot less. If you rent a place with no insulation and single pane glazing in the future you could expect to pay a lot less too.

Uncoupling electricity from gas prices would be excellent too. Is gas that’s expensive. All of a sudden an electric hob, electric heating and a few solar panels sounds much more attractive.

Walkden · 30/08/2022 11:39

Obviously ed Davey and Keir starmer and others have proposed capping unit costs for electricity and gas for the short term. Perhaps only subsiding related to the average use may be workable.

Longer term moves are afoot to decouple electricity prices from gas. At present renewable nuclear etc are also paid gas price related units.

Even more longer term I suppose it might be possible to introduce a tiered rate based on the baseline of electricity generation with higher usage households having to pay unit costs in line with the costs of meeting surges in the grid with gas etc.

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 11:28

CapMarvel · 29/08/2022 23:31

What we should be doing is heavily subsidising ways for people to make long term savings on their bills.

Free insulation. Significant discounts on new efficient heating systems/ solar panels/double glassing/ energy efficient applicances and lighting and things like e-bikes as alternatives to cars for commuting.

You can either give someone £500 to just spend on power in the short term, or fund the means to save that money through long term reduced bills.

But by using a tiered energy method means that I’ll save money by insulating my home as my bills would reduce, so the government doesn’t need to introduce incentives, the tiered billing system is the incentive.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 11:06

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 00:26

Unemployed people get a shade over £4k a year as a standard element of UC which is £334 a month. Imagine that for a second.
If you loved.in social housing, UC pays your rent.. if you don't live.in social housing, you have to make up the rental shortfall from that £334

I helped a family. £950 a month UC.
Rent £450
Council tax £40
Water £13
Gas and electric at the time £60

And that's before food.

If we hadn't got them moved and got them into a cheaper social housing house.. I don't know how they'd have made it through tbh. Bad enough they had to move 85 miles from their home town.
But that's nothing to do with the topic really.

Social housing rent here for a two bed is £720 pcm.

Thisismynamenow · 30/08/2022 09:14

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 00:30

What about people who live in flats? Nowhere to hang washing & no option but to use a tumble dryer. Would they get a special rate? Why not encourage councils to burn more rubbish instead of using landfill & use the heat generated to provide heating for council estates? In Sheffield if you are on an estate where district heating operates you only pay £15 a week for as much heat & hot water as you want, after that you only have to pay for electricity, my exh lives in a bungalow that gets it & it is boiling, he could have it on 24/7 if he wanted it. Or pay councils to fit every council home with Solar panels & batteries, bulk buying would be cheaper & rents could be increased to pay rental of the panels & batteries.

I lived in my council flat for about 7years and only had the tumble drier for about 2 of those. Buy a clothes airer or hang coat hangers on door frames like the rest of us?

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:37

BloodAndFire · 30/08/2022 00:35

We're in London and had to have electric fans running in every room throughout much of July and August. We also got through bags and bags of ice just to stave off heatstroke. The heatwave was literally unbearable (and I like summer weather usually). Trying to divide people/regions like this for your own benefit isn't going to work.

Our heating normally runs Oct-April and it can be minus temps for a majority of the winter. So it does need to be fairly managed or it means people is colder areas get shafted in winter.

midgetastic · 30/08/2022 00:37

Isn't part of the problem that the people with least have higher bills due to poor insulation, damp and old inefficient goods

DiddlyDoris · 30/08/2022 00:36

One of the more sensible suggestions I've seen, I'd back this idea.

BloodAndFire · 30/08/2022 00:36

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 00:30

What about people who live in flats? Nowhere to hang washing & no option but to use a tumble dryer. Would they get a special rate? Why not encourage councils to burn more rubbish instead of using landfill & use the heat generated to provide heating for council estates? In Sheffield if you are on an estate where district heating operates you only pay £15 a week for as much heat & hot water as you want, after that you only have to pay for electricity, my exh lives in a bungalow that gets it & it is boiling, he could have it on 24/7 if he wanted it. Or pay councils to fit every council home with Solar panels & batteries, bulk buying would be cheaper & rents could be increased to pay rental of the panels & batteries.

I've never owned a tumble drier and lived in my flats my whole life until 2018. There is no point trying to score these points, everyone has their own 'needs' from their own point of view. Tumble driers are definitely not a necessity.

BloodAndFire · 30/08/2022 00:35

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:07

Also agree with a pp that I live in Scotland it’s much colder here for more of the year so do we get extra allowance?

We're in London and had to have electric fans running in every room throughout much of July and August. We also got through bags and bags of ice just to stave off heatstroke. The heatwave was literally unbearable (and I like summer weather usually). Trying to divide people/regions like this for your own benefit isn't going to work.

BashfulClam · 30/08/2022 00:34

@Nat6999 i lived in a flat for ten years. Never had a tumble drier so there isn’t ‘no
option’.

Vegay · 30/08/2022 00:30

@MoistBandana no, I can't even begin to imagine it.

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 00:30

What about people who live in flats? Nowhere to hang washing & no option but to use a tumble dryer. Would they get a special rate? Why not encourage councils to burn more rubbish instead of using landfill & use the heat generated to provide heating for council estates? In Sheffield if you are on an estate where district heating operates you only pay £15 a week for as much heat & hot water as you want, after that you only have to pay for electricity, my exh lives in a bungalow that gets it & it is boiling, he could have it on 24/7 if he wanted it. Or pay councils to fit every council home with Solar panels & batteries, bulk buying would be cheaper & rents could be increased to pay rental of the panels & batteries.