Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think tiered electricity prices might work ?

113 replies

secrethedgehog · 29/08/2022 22:25

I saw a suggestion today that a way forward with rising energy prices might be to give every household an allowance ( based on number occupants ?) of x units of energy at a subsidised price. Any units used over that price would then be more expensive, a little more than predicted now, to help finance the reduced price units.
This way the least well off can have at least a minimal amount of heating and power to cook etc without worrying about horrendous bills.
Anyone wanting to use more, and can afford to do so, is then helping to subsidise the price for those less able to pay .
Seems to allow an element of choice whilst encouraging less energy use and therefore having green credentials
Sure there are flaws but seem to be some advantages too ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HoppingKangaroo · 05/09/2022 13:27

FreddyHG
Looking at your comment on the Statement made by Ukrainian First Lady thread (with her urging Britons to keep up support despite cost of living crisis) you are fine with taxpayers money going to subsidize the Ukraine but not to people in the UK who will find it hard to heat their houses this winter which will include the squeezed middle not just the people on benefits (who you say suckle at the teat of the state) who you seem to have disdain for?

You literally said This thread shows me modern Brits are just so self centered (especially the Mumsnet ones) lol really your comment compared to this one I won't bother trying to do the right thing next time and instead suckle on the teat of the state 😂

FreddyHG · 05/09/2022 12:28

Rosehugger · 05/09/2022 12:06

Because the prices are unlike anything we've ever had before in history. It's not bailing out the poor or feckless, it's rebalancing the economy which will slide into long depression.

Why did I bother spending money on solar panels and insulation if the state will just bail you out with subsidy at great future expense

And oh, well done you. What do you want, a fucking biscuit for being well off? Count yourself lucky.

I haven't had a foreign holiday and don't feel financially well off enough to have children. I come from a working class background a worked to where I am. I am a huge net taxpayer I don't wish to subsidize any more.

Rosehugger · 05/09/2022 12:09

I'm relatively well off, for what it's worth and still think the state should intervene, and realise I will probably end up paying for that in some way. Because I'm not a right wing I'm all right jack fucking twat and acknowledge that good fortune played a part in where I am today, even though I came from a very ordinary working class background and not from privilege.

Rosehugger · 05/09/2022 12:06

Because the prices are unlike anything we've ever had before in history. It's not bailing out the poor or feckless, it's rebalancing the economy which will slide into long depression.

Why did I bother spending money on solar panels and insulation if the state will just bail you out with subsidy at great future expense

And oh, well done you. What do you want, a fucking biscuit for being well off? Count yourself lucky.

FreddyHG · 05/09/2022 11:59

Rosehugger · 05/09/2022 11:49

I think a fairer way is the government subsidise it- keep the cap as it currently is and recoup it through income tax.

Why should taxpayers pay for others electricity? Why should I shower at work have bothered to go on a long term fixed tarrif last year when it was obvious to anyone with an ounce of common sense where energy prices were going. Why did I bother spending money on solar panels and insulation if the state will just bail you out with subsidy at great future expense. I won't bother trying to do the right thing next time and instead suckle on the teat of the state. Personal responsibility is long gone.

Rosehugger · 05/09/2022 11:49

I think a fairer way is the government subsidise it- keep the cap as it currently is and recoup it through income tax.

verdantverdure · 05/09/2022 11:46

WyldeSwan · 04/09/2022 11:32

In effect, this is exactly what the £400 is doing (but with less admin and per household rather than person). Energy companies are refunding £66 pcm over six months, so in effect everyone is getting the first x number of units free, before paying the price cap rates.

I've not worked out what the x number of units is!

It's fewer and fewer units each time the price goes up.

ShesNotTheMessiah · 05/09/2022 11:37

I've not worked out what the x number of units is!

If you allocate £200 to Oct-Dec (and those prices) and £200 to Jan - Mar (and those predicted prices), it works out as 640 electricity kwh free.

WyldeSwan · 04/09/2022 11:32

In effect, this is exactly what the £400 is doing (but with less admin and per household rather than person). Energy companies are refunding £66 pcm over six months, so in effect everyone is getting the first x number of units free, before paying the price cap rates.

I've not worked out what the x number of units is!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 04/09/2022 11:07

silverclock222 · 29/08/2022 23:05

By that theory I'd be classed as being 'well off', presumably because I don't claim any benefits. Unfortunately I have cancer and two autoimmune diseases and work only 4 days a week (although been off sick for months). Because I work and no educational age children, even though my DP is out of work we get precisely £0. I would be about £400 a month better off if I wasn't working. I'm sure there are many in my financial (if not medical) situation where we just aren't entitled to anything.

I'm in the same boat as you. I have 2 cancers and a host of autoimmune conditions. If I get cold Im in so much pain that I cant move .
Our income is £50 per month over the threshold for income related benefits because my husband who is in his 70's still works part time to make ends meet and keep his mind and body active. That £50 goes into savings to replace my wheelchair because im not in it full time yet I'm not entitled to a nhs one.

I get full rate pip ongoing because I'm not going to recover or get any better, I'm doubly incontinent so the washer and dryer are on twice per day, I use a stair lift and a rise and recline chair, I have to charge my wheelchair, I need regular showers.
Out of all the things listed above, what should I cut down on?

HannahSternDefoe · 30/08/2022 19:45

Won't work.

Conservative voters won't subsidise the poor more than they do already.

balalake · 30/08/2022 19:41

Tiered energy prices might work in theory, but not in practice. Poor insulation and windows I am sure up the cost of heating, and then there are those with medical conditions, older people, for example.

Thatswhyimacat · 30/08/2022 19:39

My understanding is that it is usually much more expensive to implement any system like this with exemptions etc than it is to just give everyone some money.

As a rough idea it's interesting, but pps have already brought up issues where your energy consumption is not always directly correlating with your ability to pay for it, and adding all those in as exemptions etc or increasing the complexity is going to be a huge expensive hassle and vulnerable to exploitation.

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 19:27

But you also can't give 10 people living in one house the same allocation as one person living alone.

But we don't have an easy/already available way to determine the number of people living in a home (only voters). If one can be devised cheaply and easily - so much the better.

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 18:45

I wouldn’t be giving people in large houses more energy at the cheap price than others in smaller houses. The people in bigger houses are more likely to be able to afford high bills and address the energy efficiency of the property they live in. Why should they get more cheap tier energy?

Grumpybutfunny · 30/08/2022 18:36

I mentioned this on another thread, the idea wasn't to get us in the middle to pay more to subsidise others. The idea was we would get an allowance of X then everyone would pay more above that as it's unsustainable use. That excess use could be paid down on the system we are having installed, so our solar panels will largely power our house but if we want to keep the hot tub running and all the gadgets we would buy that off the grid out of our allowance. Driving down the amount we consume means demand is less and therefore market forces should bring down the unit cost as the demand won't be there.

The idea is it stops people buying large amounts of unsustainable energy as they will invest in green technology like panels, air/ground source heat pumps. This should also be available on interest free finance. Would be interesting if heating could have a maximum setting to stop excessive gas consumption, we live in the far north not far south of the Scottish Borders.

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 18:30

I am pretty convinced that some form of energy rationing will be put in place at some point, but I'm pretty sure "you can go to a warm bank if you like" is the plan for the least well off.

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 18:25

Seems like whatever happens, somebody loses unfairly if they're at the poorer end of the spectrum/don't have the ability to improve their homes' efficiency because they don't own it and/or can't afford to purchase new appliances/are forced to tumble dry, dehumidfy or buy a heated airer for their home because it, for example, doesn't have space from drying things outside?

Yep, I think so. And I think that is happening now - probably to an even greater degree - under the 'same price for all the kwh' model we have.

Whatever is done is has to go hand in hand with:

a) greater UK energy security
AND
b) greater power/incentive to improve all property efficiency, but especially rental properties.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 18:20

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 18:11

Ah!

No, the cost doesn't go up with the banding. Your allocation of cheaper energy does. As an example...

Household A, Band C gets to use 10,000 kwh at 10p a kwh and anything above it at 50p a kwh.

Household B, Band G gets to use 20,000 kwh at 10p a kwh and anything above it at 50p a kwh. They have a greater allocation of cheaper energy using a blunt assumption that a bigger home = more people living in it (far from perfect, I know).

Both actually use 15,000 kwh over a year.

Household A pays £3,500 for that usage.
Household B pays £2,000 for the same amount of energy.

Oh, OK, I see where you're coming from - but;

Wouldn't this then make it unfair on those in lower banded properties that are in poor repair in either area?

Seems like whatever happens, somebody loses unfairly if they're at the poorer end of the spectrum/don't have the ability to improve their homes' efficiency because they don't own it and/or can't afford to purchase new appliances/are forced to tumble dry, dehumidfy or buy a heated airer for their home because it, for example, doesn't have space from drying things outside?

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 18:11

Ah!

No, the cost doesn't go up with the banding. Your allocation of cheaper energy does. As an example...

Household A, Band C gets to use 10,000 kwh at 10p a kwh and anything above it at 50p a kwh.

Household B, Band G gets to use 20,000 kwh at 10p a kwh and anything above it at 50p a kwh. They have a greater allocation of cheaper energy using a blunt assumption that a bigger home = more people living in it (far from perfect, I know).

Both actually use 15,000 kwh over a year.

Household A pays £3,500 for that usage.
Household B pays £2,000 for the same amount of energy.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 16:50

It's complex (or I'm not being very clear!)

Premise:

Everybody who lives in Council Tax Bands A-D gets to use 200 at £1 each
Everybody who lives in Council Tax Bands E-H gets to use 200 at £2 each

This is fair because somebody living in a house in a higher band must have a bigger property/higher income

Household A,

Band C, Three bedroom semi. Has a new boiler and additional insulation fitted in the last 5 years because the property is 30+ years old.

Rent £500, Council Tax £100, Pays £200. Total = £800

Household B,

Band G because they're been housed in a place with fewer bedrooms than A somewhere else in the country because that's the only area they are eligible for housing. Property is smaller, newer but doesn't have a combi boiler or anything more than the legal minimum insulation. Housing Association will not be replacing anything for around 10 years.

Rent £650, Council Tax £240, Pays £400. Total = £1290

Income of Household A = £2500/pcm
Income of Household B = £1900/pcm

(amounts chosen because they're above the earnings level for UC in the case of both households)

They both have the same appliances and use exactly the same amount of energy. Energy is down as a generic 200 units of something at £1/2 for ease.

Household A also received £400 Council Tax support because of their banding. Household B didn't. And now A's fuel costs are lower as well because they live in a place that has a lower banding (and in a cheaper area). It's not B's fault the only place they can live is deemed to be of greater value, they had to take what they were given and were eligible for (and they are grateful for it, the alternative was homelessness, after all), but they have to pay more in rent, council tax and energy bills as a result.

Same way C and D could live in exactly the same band property in the same town, but D doesn't own theirs, so has no influence upon the landlord to fit insulation, double glazing or a combi boiler, but they do have to buy and run a dehumidifer to prevent damp as it's a condition of their tenancy. C uses 200 at £1 = £200, D uses 400 at £1 = £400.

It's not D's fault that they can't get approved for a mortgage, but they have to use and pay for more energy for reasons completely outside their control. As a result, they fail affordability checks for a mortgage and can't save a deposit anyhow with double the amount going on fuel bills.

It would be beneficial to introduce a system that helps people in areas of lower property values and perhaps that would lead to those areas being more likely to vote for the party who put it into action at the next election. But that's political, not environmental or ethical.

Effectively, the suggestion is a way to make people less able to pay the increased bills more because they don't have a way to live in the cheaper areas or mitigate their expenses through making home improvements or moving.

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 15:32

I also can’t see why the house size / council tax band matters.

House size doesn't really. But more people in a home = greater need. So there needs to be a way of allocating greater kwh to multiple occupancy houses and we don't currently have an up to date record of how many people live at an address, including children etc and to introduce one is likely to increase admin costs and cause privacy concerns.

But maybe I'm missing a better way we can get an allocation that matches the number of people in the home?

This also has an advantage of further incentivising multiple occupancy which is better for the planet and better for the housing shortage, Much as I loved living alone, it's a really inefficient way to house everyone.

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 15:28

The advantage of tiers is that the energy user feels that they have some form of control on the costs they face.

ShesNotTheMessiah · 30/08/2022 15:27

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/08/2022 15:03

Council tax bandings would fuck over everybody who lives in social housing built after a certain year and in areas they have no control over living in in the first place, as they have to take what they're offered when homeless or need a particular type of property.

Combined with already higher council taxes, energy use because they don't own the heating, insulation or windows to decide to have more economical versions installed and rents that don't bear much relation to those charged for a council house in, say, Doncaster, for the sin of being born in Tooting, somebody could be paying thousands more but ineligible for council tax relief, low emissions zone charging, and now would also be expected to pay more for electricity because they have no choice about how much is used beyond breaching tenancy regulations by not having the heating or hot water on at all and causing damp and frozen pipes?

I'm not following 100% but don't think this would be the case, would it?

I think your point about paying more council tax means you are worried about those in higher bands through no 'fault' of their own? But they would benefit from banding being used because they'd essentially have a higher allowance at the cheaper rent.

It's those in artificially low bandings that might need tweaks to aid them: so that they have an allowance that is still fit for basic needs.

That said, I'm all for making sure everyone gets what they need, so it might be that those in social housing are just on the cheaper rate, full stop?

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 15:26

So imaging the average house uses 150kwh a month (I haven’t a clue how many kWh a house uses, this is just an example). The first 100kwh are paid at April 2022 rates. 101-150kwh are paid for at October 2022 rates and anything above that is January 2023 rates. Everyone has a massive incentive to reduce your energy intake.

if you’re poor you’ll get a grant for the first 100kwh every month. You are incentivised to reduce your usage but things are still doable. If you have medical equipment everything apart from the first 50kwh is free. The reductions for the poor and ill are paid for on windfall taxes on the gas and electricity generators (I.e. BP etc who are currently making a killing) and a small rise in the highest tax band.

I can’t see why this wouldn’t be fair. I also can’t see why the house size / council tax band matters. I live in a big draughty house so my bill will be big, but Like most who live in a big house I have access to funds to insulate it better - which is a good thing for net zero.