Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this dog isn't our/DHs responsibility?

193 replies

Dogg0 · 29/08/2022 18:35

DHs ex has a dog from when they were together. They purchased him as a puppy when they were together not long before they separated. He's about 8 now I think. Me and DH been together 6 years, married for two. We have a one year old baby together.

DH and his ex were never married but she wanted to keep the dog when they separated. DH was upset about it but agreed and she's had the dog since, he'd been with them around a year-ish before they separated. He's not really seen other than at the odd pick up for their DC, this dog since, never contributed toward it or anything like that.

Ex needs to get a new rental as her landlord is selling. She's struggling to find a rental that will take this dog and is insisting DH needs to take him as he's 'both their responsibility'.

We are not in the position for a dog. We own our house so not an issue with a landlord or anything but we have a baby, he works all day, I work part time (very part time, only 1 day a week) but I have no desire to be looking after a dog as well as a baby.

AIBU in thinking a dog is the responsibility of whoever kept it after the separation and you can't just demand it's your exes responsibility 8 years later when it doesn't work out for you? Or is this dog just always supposed to be DHs responsibility whenever she demands it despite not being able to see it really for the last 8 years.

OP posts:
BadNomad · 30/08/2022 08:32

It's ok, OP. I'm sure all the people here who are outraged on behalf of the dog will offer to take, house, feed, and walk it, then nurse it in its old-age and pay all its vet bills etc.

EsmeSusanOgg · 30/08/2022 08:30

Not your responsibility. But does your DH have children with her? Are they/ your DH bonded to the dog? Could a temporary option, where she take him for regular walks etc until she finds somewhere where she can take the dog sorted?

Dogg0 · 30/08/2022 08:26

Also I'm not heartless as a PP so kindly said. I've owned pets before and loved them dearly. But our life isn't set up for one right now time wise, with a baby or even financially hence why we don't have one.

OP posts:
Dogg0 · 30/08/2022 08:25

I really don't understand how PP can say it's of no relevance whether or not I want it! It's my house as well! And of course I have the final say if I'm the one who'll be at home with it all day.

We can't afford dog daycare or dog walkers everyday, no DH can't just magically swap his job around so he's here everyday. It'll be me, the one who's at home, cleaning up after it, walking it, taking into the vets.

And that's not even mentioning the money an old dog starts costing as they become unwell and elderly.

PPs asked what DH thinks. DH would be happy to have the dog. But surely the person who doesn't want it gets the last say as with every other dog or pet or even baby thread I've read on here?

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 30/08/2022 08:08

Doorhandleghost · 30/08/2022 06:59

This has been the most entertaining thread I've read on mumsnet for ages.

Clearly, OP, there is only one possible solution here - you need to move the dog AND the ex in with you immediately. You must then do all the cooking, cleaning, looking after the dog for ever in perpetuity - all because you had the audacity to marry a man who once owned a dog.

I find it interesting that your DH finds it quite easy to decide to have the dog, probably because he isn't going to have to look after it!

Always the way on here when pets are involved! There's never any shortage of people volunteering the woman, and it's always a woman, to take on the labour of looking after a pet that isn't hers, that she doesn't want and that no reasonable person could think she owed an ethical duty towards. It's laughable.

Also, the people suggesting taking the dog on as a temporary arrangement are being very naive. They, and by they I mean OP, will end up lumbered. Once the dog is in, it'll be established. XP will have a dragon of a landlord, or not want to risk her tenancy, and the teenager away at uni will be about as reliable as a teenager at uni can be expected to be in that situation. Sure, some of them might turn up for walks but that's about it, and only in the best case scenario. It'll be OP lumbered with most of the shitwork, literally, and he'll cost money they already don't really have. In this situation, OP and DH would be stupid to take the dog in unless they knew and were fine with it being a permanent arrangement.

Formerpupil · 30/08/2022 07:30

@CakeCrumbs44 if the dog is likely to die soon surely the more relevant emotional argument is that the DC have presumably loved their pet for 8 years and will have no idea how it lived out it’s last days and whether he came to a comfortable end?

CakeCrumbs44 · 30/08/2022 07:09

The fact that it’s a boxer means it’s an elderly dog and for that reason I would take it in for its last days if she doesn’t have anyone else to take it
It's "last days" could be 3 years. And an elderly dog is probably going to cost more to insure and/or in vets bills. If the dog is likely to die soon then the emotionally blackmail of "taking the dog away from kids who love it" is less relevant surely.

Jengnr · 30/08/2022 07:07

Wishihadanalgorithm · 30/08/2022 04:06

What does OP’s DH want to happen? This hasn’t been mentioned.

I totally see both sides of the issue but as a dog lover I would do my best to make it work or find a solution which doesn’t end up the the dog being PTS.

I respect the OP’s stance and clear boundaries but I think there is a lack of kindness there. The ex is in a difficult position, and the dog was once part of the DH’s family. I understand why the dog stayed with the DC and now it’s difficult for her.

The OP is not being unreasonable but I think could have a kinder approach.

Kinder how?

She’s not being unkind here, she’s just saying no. Which you agree in your post is reasonable of her.

Formerpupil · 30/08/2022 07:06

Tbh I think agreeing some sort of temporary measure with the ex, including her covering costs of food etc., is the right thing to do by the dog and that your DH needs to be the person finding a way to make it work - whether through WFH certain days if he can, getting a dog walker in, getting the DC involved. If they’re late teens then the dog is their responsibility too.

Realistically the dog’s chances of finding a new home in a general rescue are slim, agree with the pp suggesting a breed specific rescue if it comes to that. If he comes to your DH in the short term then he at least has some continuity with the DC when they are with you while the ex sorts something out with her landlord.

Doorhandleghost · 30/08/2022 06:59

This has been the most entertaining thread I've read on mumsnet for ages.

Clearly, OP, there is only one possible solution here - you need to move the dog AND the ex in with you immediately. You must then do all the cooking, cleaning, looking after the dog for ever in perpetuity - all because you had the audacity to marry a man who once owned a dog.

I find it interesting that your DH finds it quite easy to decide to have the dog, probably because he isn't going to have to look after it!

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 30/08/2022 05:23

I was fully prepared to agree with you that it’s absurd BUT DH has children that presumably love this dog, so it would be unfair not to take the dog if she truly can’t get another rental with it.

sleepygal · 30/08/2022 04:51

SpacePotato · 29/08/2022 21:14

It's not emotional blackmail to state that decisions in this situation are likely to have consequences

It is emotional blackmail. The step children are adults and should therefore be mature enough to understand the situation or perhaps try to help their mother find another solution.

It's the ex's dog. It's amazing that people are telling op she's a meany for not wanting to be physically and financially tied to someone else's pet for the next 5 to 10 years because it might upset adult step children.
The DH isn't around to look after it. Why should she?

The op does not want a dog. That should be the end of it.

Exactly this.

blisstwins · 30/08/2022 04:13

Exactly—take temporarily and then have it move into the new apartment if landlords can’t prevent/evict, see if one of the children can take, regime of possible. But very cruel to just shrug and say not my problem when this dog was part of the household.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 30/08/2022 04:06

What does OP’s DH want to happen? This hasn’t been mentioned.

I totally see both sides of the issue but as a dog lover I would do my best to make it work or find a solution which doesn’t end up the the dog being PTS.

I respect the OP’s stance and clear boundaries but I think there is a lack of kindness there. The ex is in a difficult position, and the dog was once part of the DH’s family. I understand why the dog stayed with the DC and now it’s difficult for her.

The OP is not being unreasonable but I think could have a kinder approach.

Sswhinesthebest · 30/08/2022 03:55

Tricky.
I feel for the poor dog, the kids and even the ex. It’s a much loved dog.
Not sure the op should have it though, if she really doesn’t want it.

allinatizzy · 30/08/2022 03:24

She wanted sole ownership of the dog, and now it's her dog, not his. She needs to work harder to find a solution that enables her to keep the dog or find a loving home for it, herself. It's her dog, her commitment, her responsibility to keep looking until she finds a way, even if it requires sacrifices.

I'd suggest you could agree to keep the dog as a temporary fix, but she would probably only see that as her foot in the door and stop looking for a long-term solution.

lickenchugget · 30/08/2022 02:57

It is your DH’s responsibility to make sure his DC are housed though, especially with 1 still under 18 I presume.

Its not DH’s responsibility to find his exW accommodation! I don’t think I have ever read anyone ever suggest this on MN either, why is the presence of a dog sending everyone crazy? He has a home for his DC, he does not have to find one for his ex.

MissingNashville · 30/08/2022 02:42

I’d like to put a few of these posters to sleep when they still potentially have a third of their life left. Ffs. 🙄 Some humans are fucking vile.

MyBabyLaura · 30/08/2022 02:29

I think it is inappropriate and cruel to suggest that he is put to sleep when you don’t know anything about him

I disagree. I know his long term owner can't keep him any more and he's old. That's enough reason to call time on the situation IMO.

PTS isn't cruel, the dog knows nothing about it, or the worse alternatives that could befall him if the ex puts a rehoming ad on a website somewhere or he isn't lucky enough to find a doting owner wanting an old dog from the shelter. It's unsettling for him to have to move homes and families at his age, even if he is lucky enough to get a nice new owner. More people should PTS their unwanted pets especially if old or health/behaviour problems. Its called taking responsibility.

If people did, there'd be less neglected animals in homes where they're not really wanted any more, not getting enough walks or proper care and timely vet intervention when ill etc. Less animals being passed around endlessly because guess what the new owners don't want to deal with its issues either, all those ads "we can't give critter the time/attention it needs" code for its a blooming nightmare. Or the ones who thought it's a nice idea then decide they CBA with the reality. Or same as the ex they're private rent and having to move. Less animals languishing in shelters desperate for attention which the staff don't have time to give them. I believe in quality of life, not life at all costs no matter what.

Inappropriate and cruel are the ones putting a guilt trip on OP that this is in any way her problem to solve.

OP dogs are great but a massive committment. Your home's 3x messier for a start. Between the paw prints, dropped food near the bowl, moulting hair, wet noses marks and drool. It's a lot of effort. They can make your home smell too if they've rolled in something and you don't have time to bath them or if the diet isn't right causing flatulence. I don't blame you for not wanting to take on the responsibility.

MyBabyLaura · 30/08/2022 01:59

@RaspberryParfait if he needs to house his DC he can house them in the house where he lives with OP. He doesn't need to be involved with finding accommodation for his ex. It's nothing to do with him. If his ex wants to live with the DC finding suitable accommodation is up to her. She could find it easier if she wasn't looking for somewhere that takes pets. People in private rental owning house pets is daft, this situation of struggling to find somewhere is going to occur every time they move.

CertainUncertain · 30/08/2022 01:57

I don't think you're being unreasonable.

I do think, if this dog is meaningful to his kids, it would be very disappointing if your husband didn't step up so he and his ex, together, could figure out a way for to manage to keep him. I know my own kids, even at that age, are incredibly attached to our dogs and would be devastated if we had to get rid of them. I wouldn't be able to do it, and, if his kids care, I think your husband should find a way not to.

Caveat, though, is that the responsibility shouldn't fall on you.

Lilithslove · 30/08/2022 01:32

This thread is bonkers. Of course the op isn't obliged to take on a dog. Having a dog in the same house as a small baby is a risk, but even without the baby she doesn't have to have him.

People keep pointing out that the dog is a sentient being so surely it needs to live with someone who wants to take care of it. How would the op taking it on reluctantly out of guilt be good for anyone?

Dogs are a huge commitment and need to live with people who care about them and are prepared to make sacrifices for them. It's absolutely fine that the op doesn't want to make sacrifices for a dog she didn't chose.

RaspberryParfait · 30/08/2022 01:21

YANBU about not wanting a dog in your home with a young child that it doesn’t know when it’s elderly and health problems may start to appear. Certainly not your responsibility to look after it either.

It is your DH’s responsibility to make sure his DC are housed though, especially with 1 still under 18 I presume. Even the one going to Uni will need a home for holidays and probably afterwards with the cost of housing so high. So I hope he’s assisting in finding a home for them. It’s not just his ex’s responsibility even if he pays maintenance. Especially as he’s got a secure home for himself and subsequent DC. Maybe he can find a dog friendly property and assist with moving costs?

SpacePotato · 30/08/2022 01:04

The fact you don't want it is irrelevant

No. It's the only thing that's relevant.

Do any of actual read that the DH won't be there all the time to look after the dog so OP, who does not want it, will be the one stuck walking it, feeding it, cleaning up it's shit etc every day.

Nice of you all to volunteer her to this massive commitment to a dog that has nothing to do with her at all.

bringbackveronicamars · 30/08/2022 01:03

I wouldn't take the dog in OP's shoes.

Landlords have to be more flexible with animals I thought ... his ex will have to find a rental and take the dog with her.