Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 07:47

You obviously haven’t read any history

Oh, but I have.
You do of course need to bear in mind that history is written by the victors, which has led to an account written by the Christians who 'won'.

somewhereovertherain · 31/08/2022 07:46

Considering religion is all about control and so many of the world ills are directly related to one religion or another the sooner it leaves society the better.

and on a personal note the more involved in organised religion people are the more two faced and evil they seem to be.

i think the world would be a much better place without any religion or god.

Malie · 31/08/2022 07:41

pointythings · 30/08/2022 20:14

@Malie you are being wilfully disingenuous again and ignoring my point. I was not talking about Jesus and the New Testament. I was talking about abuse by priests in the Church, abuse by nuns in the Magdalene Laundries, the killing of babies and young children in orphanages run by the religious and the efforts of the church to cover all of these up. Is that evil by organised religion that you are willing to acknowledge?

And just to say no-one is defending the abuses propagated by organised so-called religion. When did I say that?

Malie · 31/08/2022 07:25

ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 21:19

.... and organised religion that persecuted the early church

Not nearly to the extent portrayed in popular fiction, but leaving that aside, then the slightly later church, once it had got organised and had the backing of the Roman Emperors, persecuted most of the range religions which had until then rubbed along peaceably enough into extinction.
The Christian church persistently persecuted the Jews over the centuries.

You obviously haven’t read any history

Malie · 31/08/2022 07:23

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 21:14

@Malie all your arguments are disingenuous and in bad faith. There is absolutely no point in even trying to discuss anything with you because you don't engage.
Truly happy for you that your faith warms your cockles and all that. But you don't half talk some nonsense.

It’s interesting when we get to talk about Jesus Christ people accuse me of being disingenuous. That’s why they crucified him

Malie · 31/08/2022 07:22

pointythings · 30/08/2022 20:14

@Malie you are being wilfully disingenuous again and ignoring my point. I was not talking about Jesus and the New Testament. I was talking about abuse by priests in the Church, abuse by nuns in the Magdalene Laundries, the killing of babies and young children in orphanages run by the religious and the efforts of the church to cover all of these up. Is that evil by organised religion that you are willing to acknowledge?

So you are being disingenuous by not answering my post. It’s impossible to argue with you

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 06:49

I have always thought that the Christian Right and Communism have more in common than their representatives would like to admit: in both cases, ideologies that advocate humaneness and peace and respect for all are turned into the opposite by greedy and oppressive leaders.

exactly my position too.

pointythings · 30/08/2022 22:06

@ddl1 👏

ddl1 · 30/08/2022 21:33

There is nothing wrong with Jesus and the New Testament. It's the way in which the authoritarian and corrupt have misused the teachings of the New Testament (and other religious texts). Thus 'Love your enemy' becomes 'Burn the heretics'; 'Kill the natives'; 'Blow up the Protestants/Catholics of Northern Ireland'. A Gospel that says absolutely nothing about homosexuality but does suggest that those who reject immigrants may be in danger of Hell ('I was a stranger and you took me not in - depart, ye cursed') becomes a manifesto for far-right xenophobes and homophobes. A warning to the rich about their difficulties in entering the Kingdom of Heaven becomes greedy televangelism.

There is also nothing wrong (except impracticality) with the abstract principles of communism: with the view that all should be equally helped and protected and 'from each according to his ability; to each according to his needs'. There is a great deal wrong with the ways in which the authoritarian and corrupt have used these in the cause of oppressive dictatorship; of violence and warmongering; of extremely unequal societies where the leaders live in luxury while most people struggle at best, starve at worst.

I have always thought that the Christian Right and Communism have more in common than their representatives would like to admit: in both cases, ideologies that advocate humaneness and peace and respect for all are turned into the opposite by greedy and oppressive leaders.

The moral is perhaps that in general the people who want power are the last people who should have it; and that having an ideology that they can use to justify their power and reject 'heretics'/ 'dissidents' is likely to make them even worse. And that both gods and strong nontheistic ideologies should be kept as distant from political power as petrol should from fire.

Ponderingwindow · 30/08/2022 21:30

Digita

your premise seems to be that the potential that a god or gods have special insight should act as incentive for people to be their best selves. I think the exact opposite is true. If we start with the premise that premise, humans will never be their best. Our goal should be to learn and grow as individuals and as a species. The capacity for any insight exists within the collective us. If we provide the right stepping stones are descendants can answer the questions that we can not. Belief in gods makes us complacent.

ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 21:19

.... and organised religion that persecuted the early church

Not nearly to the extent portrayed in popular fiction, but leaving that aside, then the slightly later church, once it had got organised and had the backing of the Roman Emperors, persecuted most of the range religions which had until then rubbed along peaceably enough into extinction.
The Christian church persistently persecuted the Jews over the centuries.

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 21:14

@Malie all your arguments are disingenuous and in bad faith. There is absolutely no point in even trying to discuss anything with you because you don't engage.
Truly happy for you that your faith warms your cockles and all that. But you don't half talk some nonsense.

pointythings · 30/08/2022 20:14

@Malie you are being wilfully disingenuous again and ignoring my point. I was not talking about Jesus and the New Testament. I was talking about abuse by priests in the Church, abuse by nuns in the Magdalene Laundries, the killing of babies and young children in orphanages run by the religious and the efforts of the church to cover all of these up. Is that evil by organised religion that you are willing to acknowledge?

Malie · 30/08/2022 19:58

pointythings · 30/08/2022 18:17

@Malie and just to be clear, when you concede that organised religion has been a force for evil, do you include Christianity in that?

Well if you can show me what Jesus taught in the new Testament is a force for evil then please do

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 18:19

I’m always amused by the way you people go to great lengths to excuse Narx. Almost like a cult. Of course Lenin wasn’t a murderer either I suppose?

it's as though you're obsessed. Marx was a philosopher who lived in poverty. If people misused his words that's on them. Kind of reminds me of something... can't quite put my finger on it.
Lenin believed in revolution - and considering what they revolted against, it is not surprising it was bloodthirsty. He wasn't a complete meglomaniac though, which is why Stalin managed to elbow him out and take over.

You could say this very same thing about phoney champagne socialist do-gooders, virtue signallers, etc. You don't have to be religious to behave in this way.

Well the use of words tells me all i need to know about where you stand. However we are talking about if religion is useful here, so of course i pointed out religious charities (who had been brought up before as being a Force For Good). Under socialism champagne is a desirable object and a true socialist will want champagne for all (who want it) rather than the 1%.

The entire point of the counter arguments to the premise of this thread is that no, religion alone doesn't make people act in a good way. The counterpoint of that is also true and nobody had said otherwise.

pointythings · 30/08/2022 18:17

@Malie and just to be clear, when you concede that organised religion has been a force for evil, do you include Christianity in that?

Malie · 30/08/2022 17:58

pointythings · 30/08/2022 17:01

@Malie we get it, you hate Marx. You hate communism. You can stop beating the horse, it's dead.

Nobody is excusing anyone though. We are pointing out that people will use whatever excuse suits them to wield power, to oppress and to abuse if they are so inclined. That includes dicatorial regimes of all kinds - the communist ones, certainly, but also the juntas in Latin America, the dictatorships on the African continent. It also includes large religious organisations. We're still finding the bodies of indigenous children in the grounds of religiously founded orphanages in North America and I doubt that all the child victims of the Magdalene Laundries in Ireland have been found yet. Will you admit that organised religion has also been a force for evil?

Of course organised religion has been a force for evil. Anyone can see that. It was organised religion that had Jesus crucified in the first place and organised religion that persecuted the early church. Throughout history some of the biggest opponents of New Testament Christianity have been organised religion of all sorts. The New Testament is full of warnings about it.

TheWelshposter · 30/08/2022 17:20

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 29/08/2022 12:53

How on earth is it an insult?! There is absolutely zero evidence that your particular god (just the one you believe in, not the 1000s that went before yours) exists so clearly it must be something that people make up and imagine and which exists only in their mind 🤷‍♀️

If I've got that wrong and you can tell me where to look to see your particular god then let me know!

I've never had a believer come up with a credible shred of evidence in my life. But yet religion affects laws, education, holidays, women's rights, everything in my country 🙄

So until I see evidence then surely it is all "imaginary"? Or maybe fictional is a better word.

AryaStarkWolf · 30/08/2022 17:13

whumpthereitis · 30/08/2022 15:47

I’m quite fond of holidays and cats. Each to their own though.

I can’t say I’ve ever felt the lack of religion in my own self, or felt the need to look for god or greater meaning. You can’t fill a hole that’s not there.

Holidays & Cats 👏

**Although one could argue that cats are gods so..........

pointythings · 30/08/2022 17:01

@Malie we get it, you hate Marx. You hate communism. You can stop beating the horse, it's dead.

Nobody is excusing anyone though. We are pointing out that people will use whatever excuse suits them to wield power, to oppress and to abuse if they are so inclined. That includes dicatorial regimes of all kinds - the communist ones, certainly, but also the juntas in Latin America, the dictatorships on the African continent. It also includes large religious organisations. We're still finding the bodies of indigenous children in the grounds of religiously founded orphanages in North America and I doubt that all the child victims of the Magdalene Laundries in Ireland have been found yet. Will you admit that organised religion has also been a force for evil?

derxa · 30/08/2022 17:00

When I have been at my lowest ebb I have placed my burden on a higher power and it worked. No sky fairies.

apintortwo · 30/08/2022 16:41

But is any action ever truly altruistic? Because if you give a bun to a starving person and that makes you feel in any way satisfied - who did you do it for? the starving person (for sure, i hope) or you (it is not a bad thing to do a good deed and be pleased about it). But we don't need religion to be altruistic or work for charity.

You could say this very same thing about phoney champagne socialist do-gooders, virtue signallers, etc. You don't have to be religious to behave in this way.

Malie · 30/08/2022 16:41

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 16:01

Thankfully it’s Faith that makes life worth living

that is lovely for you and I'm happy that it gives you pleasure.

Stalin (as others did) used Marxism because it was what looked like the opposite of the oppression of the Tsars. We know how that worked out. But that's like saying he was a Marxist in the same way Charles Manson was a religious leader (was that Christianity?) or those numbskulls in Texas, or any number of those suicide cults. Ie: NOT AT ALL

Hitler - more problematic. Austria tends to the Catholic and like the pp who grew up in Ireland said, it pervades all aspects of your life when you grow up in a catholic country (I don't think Austria now or then compares to Ireland in this respect though, but it does play a large part of their lives now as it did then). As other dictators do and did, he used what he could to persuade people to do what he wanted. And if that was saying he was a Christian, or putting the fear of god in them via the SS or finding a scapegoat for them all to focus their anger on (pick one, Jews, the disabled, gays, communists etc) that is what he did. And there are similarities in the way people went for what he was offering, like a cult, with religions.

So i suppose what the really interesting question is: what is it about people that makes them think they need a cult-like thing in their lives? (some science nerds are like this about some aspects of science too - so it is probably something in the human psyche that makes these things popular)

I’m always amused by the way you people go to great lengths to excuse dear old KM. Almost like a cult. Of course Lenin wasn’t a murderer either I suppose? Or all those others?

Malie · 30/08/2022 16:41

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 16:01

Thankfully it’s Faith that makes life worth living

that is lovely for you and I'm happy that it gives you pleasure.

Stalin (as others did) used Marxism because it was what looked like the opposite of the oppression of the Tsars. We know how that worked out. But that's like saying he was a Marxist in the same way Charles Manson was a religious leader (was that Christianity?) or those numbskulls in Texas, or any number of those suicide cults. Ie: NOT AT ALL

Hitler - more problematic. Austria tends to the Catholic and like the pp who grew up in Ireland said, it pervades all aspects of your life when you grow up in a catholic country (I don't think Austria now or then compares to Ireland in this respect though, but it does play a large part of their lives now as it did then). As other dictators do and did, he used what he could to persuade people to do what he wanted. And if that was saying he was a Christian, or putting the fear of god in them via the SS or finding a scapegoat for them all to focus their anger on (pick one, Jews, the disabled, gays, communists etc) that is what he did. And there are similarities in the way people went for what he was offering, like a cult, with religions.

So i suppose what the really interesting question is: what is it about people that makes them think they need a cult-like thing in their lives? (some science nerds are like this about some aspects of science too - so it is probably something in the human psyche that makes these things popular)

I’m always amused by the way you people go to great lengths to excuse Narx. Almost like a cult. Of course Lenin wasn’t a murderer either I suppose?

Malie · 30/08/2022 16:37

ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 15:44

It's probably too simplistic to say Hitler was or wasn't 'a Christian'. There were certainly points when he said he was. Otoh he wasn't an atheist - that's pretty clear . I think there's quite a lot of evidence he'd have supported the title of this thread, with the 'idea of god' being whatever served his ends.

Very simplistic to believe he was. I don’t think exactly his actions reflected the teachings of Jesus Christ

Swipe left for the next trending thread