Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
pointythings · 31/08/2022 09:38

He should have paid more attention to those who were less murderous than himself. Then we might only have had 50 million deaths?

That's Stalin's responsibility. Nor Karl Marx's. By the same token, Mao is responsible for Mao's atrocities. Not Karl Marx.

pointythings · 31/08/2022 09:36

@Malie there you go again with your obsession with Marx. The hypocrisy is astounding!

When Christians/other religions commit atrocities by abusing the teachings of their god for their own ends, that's nothing to do with the god or those teachings.

When communists commit atrocities by abusing the teachings of Karl Marx for their own ends, that's 100% Marx's fault.

You can't have it both ways.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 09:35

@DillonPanthersTexas

That's a fabulous clip.

Love him (his brother not so much).

Malie · 31/08/2022 09:35

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 09:25

Interesting you are completely at home talking about abuses committed by organised religion but not talking about Jesus. But he always was a bad fit into people’s preconceptions.

Personally? I have nothing against the jesus described in the gospels. He and i have pretty much alligned ideas about the distribution of wealth and resources. I don't even think he was as anti-women as the church went after reading all that stuff from Paul about how women should be silent. What with his friendship with Mary Magdelene and all that. Curing lepers and all? socialised medicine. Turning water in to wine: champagne socialist? (as I've previously said, socialists have no issue with champagne, as long as workers also have access to it)

So no. I don't have a problem with Jesus. I DO have a massive problem with Othering. And since we're talking about religion, i am perfectly happy to talk about how one religion or another persecutes unbelievers. Some religions are more happy than others to sit alongside other religions. But there is often a scapegoat and the 20th century showed us how that can work out when taken to another extreme.

Stalin didn't kill millions of people due to religious zealotry, for sure. Well, to be honest the fact that he was a meglomaniac who believed that only he was right is a kind of religious fervour. to paraphrase Shrek (the film) those deaths were a sacrifice he was prepared to make. His goal, of course, was to drag Russia kicking and screaming into the modern age. He should have paid more attention to what Marx, Engels and Trotsky actually said rather than going off half-cocked though. Mao, by the way, did the same thing.

He should have paid more attention to those who were less murderous than himself. Then we might only have had 50 million deaths?

Malie · 31/08/2022 09:31

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 09:17

tbh Malie is clearly a bit of a christian zealot (it is an evangelistic religion so i do get why they go on about it and try to convert people, annoying as it is) so I'm disregarding a lot of the feeling behind their posts.

It is gobsmackingly vulgar to write that about the Holocaust though. Shocking.

Also listing atrocities that had "nothing" to do with religion is a bit daft when it is clear from a lot of them that they come from feelings of Other, and some of that definitely has to do religion. Not to say that the religious angle isn't exploited by unscrupulous leaders for their own nefarious purposes.

Interesting you label me a ‘Chriatianzealot’ when there are so many ‘secular zealots’ on this thread😀 The lack of self awareness is pretty predictable though. I don’t believe that I ever said that atrocities had nothing to do with religion as when one reads the history of things like the Inquisition or the Crusades ((both sides) there were plenty. There were also 100 million deaths through people trying to propagate a secular region in the name of a guy called Marx which apparently people are offended to be reminded of. What I did say of course is that these atrocities had nothing to do with the teachings of Jesus Christ himself.

DillonPanthersTexas · 31/08/2022 09:26

Brefugee · Yesterday 07:12

It seems strange that so many posters are keen to berate both religion(s) and anyone who chooses to follow one.
If we choose to believe in "an imaginary sky fairy", "an invisible friend" why not leave us to our "delusions" instead of having 13 pages of posts about it ??

I think the late, great Chris Hitchens summed this up well.

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 09:25

Interesting you are completely at home talking about abuses committed by organised religion but not talking about Jesus. But he always was a bad fit into people’s preconceptions.

Personally? I have nothing against the jesus described in the gospels. He and i have pretty much alligned ideas about the distribution of wealth and resources. I don't even think he was as anti-women as the church went after reading all that stuff from Paul about how women should be silent. What with his friendship with Mary Magdelene and all that. Curing lepers and all? socialised medicine. Turning water in to wine: champagne socialist? (as I've previously said, socialists have no issue with champagne, as long as workers also have access to it)

So no. I don't have a problem with Jesus. I DO have a massive problem with Othering. And since we're talking about religion, i am perfectly happy to talk about how one religion or another persecutes unbelievers. Some religions are more happy than others to sit alongside other religions. But there is often a scapegoat and the 20th century showed us how that can work out when taken to another extreme.

Stalin didn't kill millions of people due to religious zealotry, for sure. Well, to be honest the fact that he was a meglomaniac who believed that only he was right is a kind of religious fervour. to paraphrase Shrek (the film) those deaths were a sacrifice he was prepared to make. His goal, of course, was to drag Russia kicking and screaming into the modern age. He should have paid more attention to what Marx, Engels and Trotsky actually said rather than going off half-cocked though. Mao, by the way, did the same thing.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 09:23

@Malie there's no need to be so snippy all the time.

Lots of folks have explained why they believe or don't believe in what they do, and folks have been respectful of that.

I understand you might feel attacked but you're not helping yourself by being so defensive.

So, why do you believe what you do?

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 09:19

And where is there persecution of Jews by the early church?

I was more thinking about the church once it had got itself organised. Learn some history? (Or maybe don't try shifting the goalposts to what suits you).

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 09:17

tbh Malie is clearly a bit of a christian zealot (it is an evangelistic religion so i do get why they go on about it and try to convert people, annoying as it is) so I'm disregarding a lot of the feeling behind their posts.

It is gobsmackingly vulgar to write that about the Holocaust though. Shocking.

Also listing atrocities that had "nothing" to do with religion is a bit daft when it is clear from a lot of them that they come from feelings of Other, and some of that definitely has to do religion. Not to say that the religious angle isn't exploited by unscrupulous leaders for their own nefarious purposes.

Malie · 31/08/2022 09:13

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 07:59

It’s interesting when we get to talk about Jesus Christ people accuse me of being disingenuous. That’s why they crucified him

yes, @Malie you are so right and all us ungodly heathens are wrong. I can't roll my eyes any further back in my head.

Have you tried not talking about Jesus to people who don't want to hear it? Or answering questions about where in the bible it gives instructions to persecute (to painful death in the past, and even now) groups of people - including and especially women? (i focus on the women because i am one. Gays, jews etc also have been hugely harmed by "Christianity")

Why you think the law about not murdering people is only there because it's in the bible? Before the bible people didn't tend to tolerate murderers in their family/social groups either.

Since a number of people have used the word "disingenuous" (maybe only 2?) on here, but you may have heard it outside of here, maybe a bit of self-reflection might be in order?

Interesting you are completely at home talking about abuses committed by organised religion but not talking about Jesus. But he always was a bad fit into people’s preconceptions.

Malie · 31/08/2022 09:10

pointythings · 31/08/2022 08:47

And just to say no-one is defending the abuses propagated by organised so-called religion. When did I say that?

@Malie your relentless focus on the persecution of Christians by other faiths suggested you were fully ignoring the plank in your own eye.

I have many issues with the New Testament, most particularly the writings of Paul, who was clearly a misogynist and whose writings have been used to oppress women. But Jesus was a pretty good bloke by all accounts.

As to what @ErrolTheDragon said and your response to it, that was pretty damn awful. The persecution of the Jews by Christians is very well documented.

Paul the man who in the midst of a male dominated society said, ‘In the Messiah there is neither Jew nor Greek, male nor female, bond nor free’ and the man who included women among his ministry team. And where is there persecution of Jews by the early church? Learn some history?

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 09:10

Moonmelodies · 31/08/2022 08:59

Wasn't there an earlier version of the Bible where Jesus killed some kid for bumping into him, and he also slayed some dragons?
I guess they quietly edited that out once people started asking questions.

Some of the early gospels (I think you're referring to to Infancy Gospel of Thomas) which didn't make it into the canon had some fairly odd stories and divergent theology.
Different sects of Christianity have different books in their canons, of course - one persons 'gospel' is another's 'apocrypha'.

In a sense this is straying from the subject of this thread, but considerations of evidence, reliability, impartiality and integrity are quite fundamental to it I think.

goherbie · 31/08/2022 09:08

@ErrolTheDragon

" The follow events had nothing to do with religion:-

The Holocaust – between 4 and 17 million deaths (racial motivation)

Wow. Did someone seriously just say that the Holocaust had 'nothing to do with religion'? Of course, religion wasn't the only factor, but to say it had nothing to do with it is astonishing."

Wow, I'm utterly gobsmacked at that too. The naivety of not understanding the history of Christian anti semitism that provided the background to the Holocaust is staggering. Any study in the Holocaust usually starts with the history of Christian anti semitism, because quite simply, you cannot understand the racist tropes the Nazis bought into without understanding where these tropes came from or what stereotypes they were tapping into. And trust me, I've studied the Holocaust a lot (including my undergraduate dissertation and at Yad Vashem, with some amazing world leading scholars, like Yehuda Bauer)

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 09:03

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 08:37

@AhNowTed

"The idea that we need some figure to keep us all in check is so ridiculous."

Yes it is.

Who do you think promulgates that idea?

You know if it was a simple message of god is watching so you have to be good, I'd happily let them get on with it.

It's fairly obvious who benefits from all this, and it ain't women.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 09:00

The follow events had nothing to do with religion:-

The Holocaust – between 4 and 17 million deaths (racial motivation)

Wow. Did someone seriously just say that the Holocaust had 'nothing to do with religion'? Of course, religion wasn't the only factor, but to say it had nothing to do with it is astonishing.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 08:59

@Tumbleweed101

I've never really understood what folks mean by spirituality.

I've just looked it up!

Why do you think we have the need to believe there is something greater than ourselves, that there's some big meaning?

I don't get it. But it's obvious a big need in many people, otherwise religion surely would never have been as successful as it is.

Moonmelodies · 31/08/2022 08:59

Wasn't there an earlier version of the Bible where Jesus killed some kid for bumping into him, and he also slayed some dragons?
I guess they quietly edited that out once people started asking questions.

pointythings · 31/08/2022 08:47

And just to say no-one is defending the abuses propagated by organised so-called religion. When did I say that?

@Malie your relentless focus on the persecution of Christians by other faiths suggested you were fully ignoring the plank in your own eye.

I have many issues with the New Testament, most particularly the writings of Paul, who was clearly a misogynist and whose writings have been used to oppress women. But Jesus was a pretty good bloke by all accounts.

As to what @ErrolTheDragon said and your response to it, that was pretty damn awful. The persecution of the Jews by Christians is very well documented.

Tumbleweed101 · 31/08/2022 08:42

I think the spiritual aspect is important for a society and does hold it together through shared belief. Even the most remote tribes have their own gods/goddesses and rituals.

I think we have lost a degree of social cohesion as our belief system has died back or been diluted by so many varieties of faith and religion. It's a shame we can't keep the good parts of religions rather than war making parts, the fighting and arguing seem to take over the nicer side so that people turn away from all of them altogether.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 08:37

@AhNowTed

"The idea that we need some figure to keep us all in check is so ridiculous."

Yes it is.

Who do you think promulgates that idea?

Fluffygreenslippers · 31/08/2022 08:29

I mean the taliban are big god worshippers. Seems to be working out great for Afganistan.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 08:28

I've always thought my lack of faith gives me a huge amount of peace and certainty.

I'm content to know I'm here because our planet occupies the sweet spot just far enough away from the sun.

So I'm not looking for any greater meaning than that. I'm not searching for anything and am content to know that when I'm gone I'm gone.

So I try to live a decent life, I've never hurt anyone and have a sense of social justice.

I do love a good hymn though 😂

The idea that we need some figure to keep us all in check is so ridiculous.

But if that's all it was, as I've said before I'd happily shut up and allow believers to get on with it.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 08:27

@somewhereovertherain
"Considering religion is all about control and so many of the world ills are directly related to one religion or another the sooner it leaves society the better."

To conflate "so many of the worlds' ills" to religion is disingenuous.

The follow events had nothing to do with religion:-

The Holocaust – between 4 and 17 million deaths (racial motivation)
Holodomor and Soviet famine – between 2.5 and 8 million deaths (political motivation)
Nigerian Civil War – 1 to 3 million deaths (ethnic motivation)
Cambodian Genocide – 1 to 3 million deaths (Communist ideological motivation)
Rwandan genocide of 1994 – 500k to 1 million deaths (ethnic motivation)
Expulsion of Germans after WW2 – 500k to 3 million deaths (ethnic motivation)
Zunghar Genocide – 480 to 600 thousand deaths (ethnic motivation)
Circassian Genocide – 400k to 1.5 million deaths (political and ethnic motivation)
Decossackisation – 300 to 500 thousand deaths (political and ethnic motivation)
Utashe Genocide (aka The Holocaust in Croatia) – 270 to 655 thousand deaths (racial motivation)
Darfur Conflict – 178 to 400 thousand deaths (ethnic motivation).

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 07:59

It’s interesting when we get to talk about Jesus Christ people accuse me of being disingenuous. That’s why they crucified him

yes, @Malie you are so right and all us ungodly heathens are wrong. I can't roll my eyes any further back in my head.

Have you tried not talking about Jesus to people who don't want to hear it? Or answering questions about where in the bible it gives instructions to persecute (to painful death in the past, and even now) groups of people - including and especially women? (i focus on the women because i am one. Gays, jews etc also have been hugely harmed by "Christianity")

Why you think the law about not murdering people is only there because it's in the bible? Before the bible people didn't tend to tolerate murderers in their family/social groups either.

Since a number of people have used the word "disingenuous" (maybe only 2?) on here, but you may have heard it outside of here, maybe a bit of self-reflection might be in order?

Swipe left for the next trending thread