Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 13:08

@pointythings I should be pretty obvious to anyone with half a brain that organised religion benefits men.

Please do not call into question the intelligence of those who disagree with you or who ask for more information.

Every person has an assertive right to be treated with respect, and the right to ask for information.

If you don't understand basic assertive principles then maybe you shouldn't be discussing/debating on this thread.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 13:06

@Digita

"Some people, it seems, can’t get their heads around separating the idea of a supernatural ‘god’ (something that requires imagination and intuition IMO) from the organisations of manmade ‘religion’. I’ve tried to explain that the OP is about the concept of a suprahuman being ‘watching’ to keep people in check, something that, according to research, has been useful for human civilisation."

So if you're question is "does the idea of god watching over us with a disapproving eye make mankind behave?"

No would be my answer.

Digita · 31/08/2022 13:04

@ErrolTheDragon "religious intolerance"

The person named 'Greatest Leader of All Times' in a recent BBC World Histories poll was nominated for creating a modern empire of toleration. But you've probably not heard of him before, although you've probably seen the jewels taken from his kingdom in the Tower of London.

Historian Mark Lockwood: “Though certainly an imperialist, Ranjit Singh represented a different, more enlightened, more inclusive model of state-building, and a much-needed path towards unity and toleration. We could still benefit from his example.”

Editor of BBC World Histories, Matt Elton, said: “Ranjit Singh’s overwhelming success in our poll suggests that the qualities of his leadership continue to inspire people around the world in the 21st century.

“And, at a time of global political tensions, it’s telling that Singh’s rule is interpreted as representing ideals of tolerance, freedom and cooperation.”

I read up about him afterwards and liked something he said when someone asked him why he only had one eye. "God wanted me to look upon all religions with one eye, which is why he took away the light from the other".

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b075t5mn

@AhNowTed Sorry about the links and backing up evidence. Habits from essay writing die hard!

OP posts:
pointythings · 31/08/2022 12:59

"It's fairly obvious who benefits from all this, and it ain't women.""
What in particular have you an issue with?

I should be pretty obvious to anyone with half a brain that organised religion benefits men. It gives them control of women's fertility (abortion rights), women's lives (the concept of Headship in fundamentalist Christianity and the absolute lack of independence for women in some Islamic countries and in ultra-orthodox Judaism, where for example men can withhold divorce from a woman with no recourse).

At the end of it all, organised religion feeds the patriarchy.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 12:58

The suprahuman concept doesn’t have to be ‘god’ either. It could be a 'fairy’ or just anything else that plays to the human curiosity of ‘something more’ that is capable of retribution if they’re caught in wrongdoing in order to keep people on their toes a bit. The OP questioned if society loses something valuable when it loses that concept of ‘god (or whatever) is watching’, especially in the justice system that requires people to tell the truth even if it’s at their disadvantage.

I think the thread has gone off in other directions because people (at least some of us) did think about that, concluded that no, it wasn't valuable. And those ideas so often, in practice, do give rise to a whole load more baggage including organised religions. You can't just separate out the bit you want.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 12:55

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 12:33

@AhNowTed
"You know if it was a simple message of god is watching so you have to be good, I'd happily let them get on with it.

So you think it's up to you to decide what people 'get on with' according to your viewpoint? Who/what makes you the controller of others behaviour.

"It's fairly obvious who benefits from all this, and it ain't women.""

What in particular have you an issue with?

No of course I'm not an arbitrator of what people believe. You know full well I meant I wouldn't bother to debate, or share my views if we were merely talking about a harmless watchful god without all the religion.

As to your second question, I can't believe you're serious, but I'll fire off a few for starters
Forced adoption
No contraception
Magdalen laundries
Mass baby "graves"
Mass baby septic tank "graves"
An appalling mortality rate in mother/baby homes
Child sex abuse on a massive scale
Sadistic physical abuse in religious schools

Further reading:
The Ferns report 2005
Commission to inquire into child abuse 2009
Murphy report 2009
Cloyne report 2011
Magdalene laundries report 2013
Mother and baby home report 2020

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 12:53

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 12:34

@ErrolTheDragon
"He wasn't always very nice to his mum either."

Please explain the reasoning for this statement.

Oh, I was being a bit flippant. I can't remember the chapter and verses off the top of my head but there's a couple of places where if you read them literally (which of course believers never do) wouldn't go down well on an MN AIBU thread.

goherbie · 31/08/2022 12:48

@Thesefeetaremadeforwalking

No one is denying that the Nazis used multiple "justifications" for their racial ideology. Galton's eugenics, the protocols of the elders of Zion and many other sources. But many of the anti Semitic tropes in there, or in Hitler's Mein Kampf can be traced back to the antisemitic tropes that were put out by the Christian Church, such as the medieval blood libels. I would recommend this book to explain it further. I have a copy at home, should you be interested in borrowing it. It is a fascinating read.

store.yadvashem.org/en/the-holocaust-and-the-christian-world-16

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 12:45

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 12:28

@goherbie , @ErrolTheDragon

"Wow. Did someone seriously just say that the Holocaust had 'nothing to do with religion'? Of course, religion wasn't the only factor, but to say it had nothing to do with it is astonishing."

Neither of you has obviously read this :- www.yadvashem.org/holocaust/holocaust-antisemitism/racism.html

And now maybe you need to think about it a bit more. The centuries leading up to it. Racism was a strong element (Slavs, Roma etc as well as Jews) of course but to pretend that the particularly virulent hatred of the Jews wasn't cradled in centuries of religious intolerance is extremely odd.

Digita · 31/08/2022 12:42

@Brefugee
“currently 418 votes, 82% of which are YABU”

Ah. I misunderstood the Mumsnet message “You have one vote. All votes are anonymous.” Just realised that means I have one and all votes are anonymous. My bad. Sorry.

“It is there in front of everyone's eyes.”

And therefore must be true, like the wooden Trojan Horse just being a wooden horse, so let's accept it as it is. Nothing else beneath the surface?

The quantitative voting % is the tip of the iceberg. I’d like to go a bit deeper into why some people think YABU and others YANBU.

The OP asks a wisdom point, so it’s also a leap to assume voters are ‘wise’ enough to know what is or is not ‘unwise’ – and that’s why discussion is valuable to see what else is going on.

"I'm not asking people to stop talking about religion."

There are (now) 20 pages of discussion that shows a lot of people have conflated ‘god’ with ‘religion’ automatically as if the two are synonymous. Some people, it seems, can’t get their heads around separating the idea of a supernatural ‘god’ (something that requires imagination and intuition IMO) from the organisations of manmade ‘religion’. I’ve tried to explain that the OP is about the concept of a suprahuman being ‘watching’ to keep people in check, something that, according to research, has been useful for human civilisation.

The suprahuman concept doesn’t have to be ‘god’ either. It could be a 'fairy’ or just anything else that plays to the human curiosity of ‘something more’ that is capable of retribution if they’re caught in wrongdoing in order to keep people on their toes a bit. The OP questioned if society loses something valuable when it loses that concept of ‘god (or whatever) is watching’, especially in the justice system that requires people to tell the truth even if it’s at their disadvantage.

As a child, it was Santa. As an adult, it tends to be 'god'. Using imagination for discipline has its uses.

Humans have imaginations, and that is a sign of intelligence too. Using that imagination to help keep law and order has apparently worked for human civilisation. What would happen if we stopped using the imagination of an ‘unknowable god’ or whatever to society? (and I don’t mean religion, but I understand that the two become conflated as one in some people's minds)

"I am asking for it to be removed from public life and not to receive public funds."

Does that include the royal family? And a national anthem asking ‘god’ to save the head of state?

Then there’s the tourism point. The RF tourism appeal is the ‘magical’ fairy tale idea of ‘Queens’, ‘Kings’, Princes’ and ‘Princesses’. But strip away the suprahuman concept of the RF being chosen ‘by the grace of god’ and needing to be revered as ‘god’s representatives on earth’, then they are just regular humans like the rest of us and their claim to anything ‘more’ or ‘supernatural’ becomes untenable – not to mention ridiculous and delusional. No god, then no credible RF. Unless the RF use the disclaimer that they’re for ‘entertainment purposes only’ and the tourism income may continue flowing in – but I assume you expect that to be separate from public life and funds.

OP posts:
Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 12:34

@ErrolTheDragon
"He wasn't always very nice to his mum either."

Please explain the reasoning for this statement.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 12:33

@AhNowTed
"You know if it was a simple message of god is watching so you have to be good, I'd happily let them get on with it.

So you think it's up to you to decide what people 'get on with' according to your viewpoint? Who/what makes you the controller of others behaviour.

"It's fairly obvious who benefits from all this, and it ain't women.""

What in particular have you an issue with?

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 31/08/2022 12:28

@goherbie , @ErrolTheDragon

"Wow. Did someone seriously just say that the Holocaust had 'nothing to do with religion'? Of course, religion wasn't the only factor, but to say it had nothing to do with it is astonishing."

Neither of you has obviously read this :- www.yadvashem.org/holocaust/holocaust-antisemitism/racism.html

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 12:18

@Longleggedgiraffe

"Why doesn’t he show himself to those who don’t believe?"

I'd imagine a bit like the moving statues. By some miracle they showed up in Catholic Ireland!!

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 12:15

Moonmelodies · 31/08/2022 12:03

People make Jesus out to be some kind of good guy, but he didn't distance himself from his mean old Dad, who murdered millions in the Bible and rained terror upon his detractors, not to mention the kittens drowned in the flood.

He wasn't always very nice to his mum either.

Moonmelodies · 31/08/2022 12:03

People make Jesus out to be some kind of good guy, but he didn't distance himself from his mean old Dad, who murdered millions in the Bible and rained terror upon his detractors, not to mention the kittens drowned in the flood.

Longleggedgiraffe · 31/08/2022 12:02

By all means, if you find solace and comfort in one who you call God, then it is absolutely fine for you to feel this way.
I imagine you are thinking of all the suffering going on at the moment. l am an atheist and I have to ask you, where is god at the moment? That faceless entity who is supposed to love us but allows all sorts of dreadful things to happen to people, children in particular,? Why is he allowing all this suffering, both at home and abroad? Why isn’t he in Ukraine? Why isn’t he in Downing Street, advising our leaders to show compassion? Why doesn’t he show himself to those who don’t believe?
There is much good work done in his name, but even that is limited by the humans doing it. If he’s supposed to be the Almighty, perhaps he should be a little less modest, and show himself once in a while.

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 11:39

goherbie · 31/08/2022 10:56

"its perfectly possible to appreciate the philosophy of Jesus and decry what has been done in it’s name."

Is that possible though? Sorry to be nerdy, but most scholars agree we don't actually know what Jesus actually said or taught. So much of what is attributed to Jesus is often what his followers wanted to say, that we can't reliably disentangle Jesus' actual thoughts and teachings from the Christians / followers who has spread the Christian message from the gospel writers, through to today. Christians have always projected their beliefs onto the teachings of Jesus. Unraveling this is what makes theology so fascinating.

This is a fairly clear, if somewhat basic explanation (it is aimed at A level students). About 14 mins in is the relevant bit vimeo.com/showcase/7155624/video/420574966

Way back in the days when i was studying this stuff someone told me that the Russians as a people like to be oppressed and that's why they went from absolute monarchy to absolute meglomaniac - but i don't think it is as simple as that. I agree that they really didn't have much chance to try anything else and that made even a "simple" revolution and rebuilding so diifficult. Add both world wars into the mix and it's a recipie for disaster.

you, I don’t think that’s true, but at the same time I don’t think that’s not true, either. There’s a strong fatalist quality to Russian culture, and almost a comforting sense of helplessness when it comes to challenging the powers that be. There’s a familiarity in knowing your place, and not challenging it.

it is more complex than that though. Stalin specifically purged the ‘thinking’ class in the late 30s, and those would have been the ones to ‘infect’ the general populace with ideas. If the progenitors and motivators have gone, so has the appetite for their ideals. Fear too plays a huge part, because it’s not like the outcome has historically been great for those that have challenged said powers, and nor has it been great for their families. Risking yourself is one thing, risking your wife, kids, and elderly parents is another.

Russia is a huge country, oppressively large, in fact. Its easy to feel inconsequential in the face of it. It’s also historically been very difficult to connect and coordinate a group of thinkers in Vladivostok to one’s in Saint Petersburg, for example.

it’s also not like the first forays in capitalism and democracy went particularly well, either. Russia in the 90s was a mess (economic collapse and Yeltsin’s gangster capitalism). It’s no wonder people were put off the idea of capitalism and democracy considering what their experience of it was. This video provides a bit of insight:

Brefugee · 31/08/2022 10:57

I’d argue that he was actually smarter than Trotsky tbh, and not simply because he outmanoeuvred him

well of course i simplified with how Stalin actually came to power (we'd be here all day) but i agree with your assessment of Trotsky who was really just a thinker caught up in it all (IMO). Lenin is a little more difficult for me to get on with, i don't think he realised what they were about to unleash.

Way back in the days when i was studying this stuff someone told me that the Russians as a people like to be oppressed and that's why they went from absolute monarchy to absolute meglomaniac - but i don't think it is as simple as that. I agree that they really didn't have much chance to try anything else and that made even a "simple" revolution and rebuilding so diifficult. Add both world wars into the mix and it's a recipie for disaster.

I'm also not a Marxist. I don't believe the cult of personality is useful at all in any respect.

What I did say of course is that these atrocities had nothing to do with the teachings of Jesus Christ himself.

you can believe that if you like. But you aren't correct. It is (fallible) men's (yes, men, women didn't have much of a say generally, although queens were around we can argue all day about how much actual power they had and how much came from those surrounding them) interpretations of the bible* that led to things like the crusades and the spanish inquisition. Not to mention witch burning which is a whole other misogynistic bag of hate.

It is all very well to keep saying "but Jesus was a peaceful chap" - I'm sure he was. Religious leaders, however are a whole other kettle of fish. And you know this.

*other religious works are available

goherbie · 31/08/2022 10:56

"its perfectly possible to appreciate the philosophy of Jesus and decry what has been done in it’s name."

Is that possible though? Sorry to be nerdy, but most scholars agree we don't actually know what Jesus actually said or taught. So much of what is attributed to Jesus is often what his followers wanted to say, that we can't reliably disentangle Jesus' actual thoughts and teachings from the Christians / followers who has spread the Christian message from the gospel writers, through to today. Christians have always projected their beliefs onto the teachings of Jesus. Unraveling this is what makes theology so fascinating.

This is a fairly clear, if somewhat basic explanation (it is aimed at A level students). About 14 mins in is the relevant bit vimeo.com/showcase/7155624/video/420574966

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 10:45

pointythings · 31/08/2022 10:22

@whumpthereitis an astute analysis of why Russia doesn't 'do' democracy.

And let's be really clear about this for the benefit of a certain poster on this thread: those deaths under stalin were down to the choices Stalin made. Not Marx. Not atheism.

Russia is a strange country, identity wise. It’s not the east, and it’s not the west. It’s Eurasia, so it’s both. It’s recognisable and yet completely alien to those looking in. That said, figuring out Russian identity is a favourite pastime of Russians themselves.

Marxism in Russia developed the way it did because of where it did. Similarly, you had Maoism in China, and Titoism in Yugoslavia. All fashioned in the shape of the environment they were enacted in.

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 10:30

Malie · 31/08/2022 09:31

Interesting you label me a ‘Chriatianzealot’ when there are so many ‘secular zealots’ on this thread😀 The lack of self awareness is pretty predictable though. I don’t believe that I ever said that atrocities had nothing to do with religion as when one reads the history of things like the Inquisition or the Crusades ((both sides) there were plenty. There were also 100 million deaths through people trying to propagate a secular region in the name of a guy called Marx which apparently people are offended to be reminded of. What I did say of course is that these atrocities had nothing to do with the teachings of Jesus Christ himself.

its perfectly possible to appreciate the philosophy of Jesus and decry what has been done in it’s name. Same applies to that of Marx, ironically. Look how many denominations of Christianity there are, and then look at how many offshoots there are from Marxism. People take a philosophy and twist it to suit their own ends. That’s not religion or secularism, that’s human nature. We’re not actually a ‘nice’ species, really, although we struggle with reconciling that darkness with what we believe ourselves to be (hello, Jung). Although there are certainly ‘good’ facets to human nature, there are also ones capable of justifying, and committing, horrific violence on a mass scale.

Going back to the point anyway, you can also appreciate Jesus without ‘buying into’ belief in any supernatural elements.

incidentally, whilst I’m not religious, that doesn’t make me a Marxist. I’m not one, by any stretch of the imagination. My father was born in the Soviet Union, and I was born in Yugoslavia, so I do have a decent idea as to the reality of those systems.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 10:27

What are we agreed on? Whether religious or not, power corrupts. And I'm not seeing much evidence through the various aspects of history discussed that believing/knowing you're being watched and that the result of offending the watcher may be retribution (rather than necessarily justice) doesn't make for happy, peaceful societies.

pointythings · 31/08/2022 10:22

@whumpthereitis an astute analysis of why Russia doesn't 'do' democracy.

And let's be really clear about this for the benefit of a certain poster on this thread: those deaths under stalin were down to the choices Stalin made. Not Marx. Not atheism.

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 10:19

Lenin believed in revolution - and considering what they revolted against, it is not surprising it was bloodthirsty. He wasn't a complete meglomaniac though, which is why Stalin managed to elbow him out and take over

This. If you look at the regime the revolution replaced you can see why soviet communism developed in the way it did. Siberian exile, secret police, lack of solid democratic infrastructure…all products of Tsarism, which was autocracy of a different flavour. Russia as a country is very, very different to the countries of Western Europe. it spent centuries as a Mongol vassal state, and the era of the Tsars was absolutist. While the Enlightenment was taking off in the west, Russians were serfs. There is no real history of democracy that wasn’t crushed as soon as attempts to implement it were made (Novgorod, meet the full fury of Tsar Ivan). Of course the Soviet Union developed in accordance with it’s frame of reference.

Stalin didn’t elbow Lenin out of the way, though. Lenin was ailing and had a series of strokes. By the time Stalin was rude to Nadezhda Krupskaya and Lenin realised the scale of his ambition, it was too late, he was incapacitated and dying. He wrote a letter denouncing Stalin, which Stalin destroyed. Stalin was essentially a bureaucrat that was able to consolidate power quietly from his position of general Secretary. His background (Georgian, peasant, not an intellectual firebrand in the vein of Trotsky) meant that he was underestimated by Lenin and Trotsky, who never looked upon him as an equal or as a valid contender to Lenin’s proverbial crown. He was a dependable workhorse for the revolution in their eyes, and a pen pusher. Whereas Trotsky was the quintessential brainy intellectual, Stalin was practical, and cunning. I’d argue that he was actually smarter than Trotsky tbh, and not simply because he outmanoeuvred him.

It’s actually incredibly difficult to put a true number on the number of deaths Stalin is responsible for. Estimates range from 6 million to 100 million, but based on what I’ve read from historians in recent years it seems the number is more likely to be around the 10 million mark.

Swipe left for the next trending thread