Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Digita · 31/08/2022 23:07

@whumpthereitis ‘I do think the Greeks, and Romans, better covered the aspects of human nature in the pantheon, and the acknowledgment of these aspects both good and bad (and indulgences of them).’

But why don’t we use them again?

Even Stephen Fry has a soft spot for the Greek gods.

“Fry has repeatedly expressed opposition to organised religion, and has identified himself as an atheist and humanist, while declaring some sympathy for the ancient Greek belief in capricious gods.”

Loved his trilogy about the Greek myths and gods!

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 23:06

I forgot Salome.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 23:03

The New Testament is still pretty much the same old boys club, though. I don't see it as an improvement. Mary doesn't get much dialogue, and Mary Magdalen only crops up twice. Then there's the whore of Babylon in Revelations. I don't know if there are any other female characters, but it's mostly men who get to speak and dominate the text.

Digita · 31/08/2022 22:55

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 31/08/2022 19:32

Whenever Christian women start preaching or being evangelical I always think of the below passage.

"Therefore I want the men everywhere to pray, lifting up holy hands without anger or disputing. I also want the women to dress modestly, with decency and propriety, adorning themselves, not with elaborate hairstyles or gold or pearls or expensive clothes, but with good deeds, appropriate for women who profess to worship God.

A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man; she must be quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner. But women will be saved through childbearing,if they continue in faith, love and holiness with propriety."

And then wonder how many conveniently ignore that teaching while preaching faith in the rest of it?

You might have a better chance in your argument when them if you used a passage from New Testament. Awful stuff in the Old Testament gets explained away with ‘but then there was a New Testament’.

OP posts:
Digita · 31/08/2022 22:49

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 19:28

@Digita

Yeah I get what you're saying, but where's the consequence of displeasing watchful god?

Apart from our own conscience, and to me that's just not enough to affect any change in human behaviour.

“Yeah I get what you're saying, but where's the consequence of displeasing watchful god?”

Well it’s like having a witness to wrongdoing that someone is denying. And the not knowing what a watchful god is capable of, be it subtle or not.

The idea of a possible god sending a message or sign was being discussed a lot during the pandemic. It was so big and surreal that people were sincerely asking, “is this god?”. Yes, there’s a scientific explanation too (a virus that came from the wet markets) but thinking about how long wet markets have been around and the eating of wild animals, then why now? And why so big and impactful too?

The timing may have played a part for a watchful god because they’d be able to see the trajectory (which is why gods are associated with prophecy: a watchful god has got a bigger picture vision). A watchful god had seen enough and decided to trigger a change in the direction in how the threads were being woven in a tapestry, so that the overall outcome changed.

In addition to practical lockdown and vaccines, I wonder if any world leaders also consulted ‘spiritual watchdogs’… like in ancient times when soothsayers, oracles and astrologers (skilled in the art of reading divine signs) would advise rulers and monarchs what message the gods and universe were sending.

“Apart from our own conscience, and to me that's just not enough to affect any change in human behaviour.”

There’s something to say about a guilty conscience though. Have you seen the movie ‘The Duke’? It’s based on a true story. At the end the real thief came forward out of conscience.

Conscience isn’t played out the same with all people.

Lack of conscience can be attributed to why psychopaths and sociopaths do so well to become CEOs etc. Really interesting list of professions associated with being psychopaths: www.businessinsider.com/professions-with-the-most-psychopaths-2018-5?r=US&IR=T#2-lawyer-9

Maybe the watchful god is a sociopath and psychopath but on a much bigger scale, with being a god and all that. So that’s a reason to be cautious under the eye of a watchful god.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 20:08

Digita · 31/08/2022 18:28

Static deities don’t sound like real deities. Evolving deities makes more sense for just how life cycles work too. Maybe that’s the appeal of Dionysus even though he’s the god of insanity (something that seems counterintuitive to ‘want’ in any rational society). He’s reborn and recycled.

Upthread @ErrolTheDragon used the phrase “chained to one book”.

I thought that was interesting. If the god in the Old Testament is real then he’s probably moved on and evolved. But the text hasn’t kept up.

Pre-literate societies may have read the times as and when they were more mindfully in the present, taking divinities in their stride. But going with the flow gods might not be helpful for human civilisation that needs rule of law and order.

In whatever form Dionysus took, he was also brutal in any vengeance.

Lady Justice might be straight laced, calm and collected but can be like: “be good and follow the rule of law or else you risk the god of insanity, Dionysus, losing his shit.”

That would also explains why god is also viewed as monstrous by some too - but it’s the idea that you don’t want to unleash the monster. So behave.

I wouldn’t typify Dionysus as the god of insanity. Not wholly, anyway. He’s the god of wild abandon, of wine and revelry. I do think the Greeks, and Romans, better covered the aspects of human nature in the pantheon, and the acknowledgment of these aspects both good and bad (and indulgences of them).

I see the appeal of this over the Abrahamic religions at least, but when you consider Christianity as a religion of slaves then of course it holds abnegation and denial of self as a virtue. Of course if your earthly life is spent in miserable service you’ll want to feel it is for something, that your suffering is in fact noble and will be rewarded in the next life. Ironically, I think that is a major aspect of why it has been utilised so successfully, as it is in itself bondage.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 19:33

If the god in the Old Testament is real then he’s probably moved on and evolved.

I'm pretty sure the Judeo-Christian god is supposed to be outside of time and space, the same from everlasting to everlasting.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 31/08/2022 19:32

Whenever Christian women start preaching or being evangelical I always think of the below passage.

"Therefore I want the men everywhere to pray, lifting up holy hands without anger or disputing. I also want the women to dress modestly, with decency and propriety, adorning themselves, not with elaborate hairstyles or gold or pearls or expensive clothes, but with good deeds, appropriate for women who profess to worship God.

A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man; she must be quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner. But women will be saved through childbearing,if they continue in faith, love and holiness with propriety."

And then wonder how many conveniently ignore that teaching while preaching faith in the rest of it?

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 19:28

@Digita

Yeah I get what you're saying, but where's the consequence of displeasing watchful god?

Apart from our own conscience, and to me that's just not enough to affect any change in human behaviour.

Digita · 31/08/2022 19:17

@AhNowTed ”watchful god”

Maybe a watchful god who monitors our actions in relation to all things, from human civilisation, justice, animals and to the health of the planet. A watchful god may well see them all threads of the same tapestry and needs to keep an eye. Humans are the dominant species on earth so that’s why there would be greater interest in human affairs such as justice than other animals.

The OP was about god in relation to law and order, so that would be the purpose of being watchful. A watchful god would be watching the laws of nature, but also human laws too because that has knock on effects on laws of nature.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 18:47

Posted too soon (user error) but you get the idea.

AhNowTed · 31/08/2022 18:46

I've yet to catch up on a few posts, but I still can't get past this:

The OP asserts that we separate god from religion. Got it.

But if humanity does so, isn't god reduced to a watchful god who may disapprove of our actions.

I can't see how that has the power over mankind to force people to behave.

It's a fairly innocuous outcome.

It's only when you introduce the facets of religion like guilt and shame and sin that has any desired effect.

Without religion god is rendered a harmless entity.

So the idea that a watchful god so

Digita · 31/08/2022 18:28

pointythings · 31/08/2022 18:02

People have been recycling and co-opting earlier deities for as long as they've existed, sometimes because it appealed, often for reasons of conquest and subjugation of the conquered. There's a reason why many churches are built on pre-Christian places of worship. Christmas trees have their roots in pagan traditions. There really isn't anything new under the sun, deities are a bit like fashions. I mean, boot cut jeans are apparently in again as well.

Static deities don’t sound like real deities. Evolving deities makes more sense for just how life cycles work too. Maybe that’s the appeal of Dionysus even though he’s the god of insanity (something that seems counterintuitive to ‘want’ in any rational society). He’s reborn and recycled.

Upthread @ErrolTheDragon used the phrase “chained to one book”.

I thought that was interesting. If the god in the Old Testament is real then he’s probably moved on and evolved. But the text hasn’t kept up.

Pre-literate societies may have read the times as and when they were more mindfully in the present, taking divinities in their stride. But going with the flow gods might not be helpful for human civilisation that needs rule of law and order.

In whatever form Dionysus took, he was also brutal in any vengeance.

Lady Justice might be straight laced, calm and collected but can be like: “be good and follow the rule of law or else you risk the god of insanity, Dionysus, losing his shit.”

That would also explains why god is also viewed as monstrous by some too - but it’s the idea that you don’t want to unleash the monster. So behave.

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 18:14

Odd, though, as Aphrodite was also the goddess of love, and I assume not celibate, so quite different to Mary.

Digita · 31/08/2022 18:06

@gnilliwdog ”Interesting. I heard the virgin Mary is a reworking of ancient nature and fertility goddesses.”

Bettany Hughes suggests that Aphrodite was reworked as the Virgin Mary. She was the mother of Rome as Venus. Then morphed into Mary.

OP posts:
pointythings · 31/08/2022 18:02

People have been recycling and co-opting earlier deities for as long as they've existed, sometimes because it appealed, often for reasons of conquest and subjugation of the conquered. There's a reason why many churches are built on pre-Christian places of worship. Christmas trees have their roots in pagan traditions. There really isn't anything new under the sun, deities are a bit like fashions. I mean, boot cut jeans are apparently in again as well.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 17:48

I read that Dionysus is the Greek god that inspired the idea of Jesus and resurrection.

Interesting. I heard the virgin Mary is a reworking of ancient nature and fertility goddesses.

Digita · 31/08/2022 17:42

@whumpthereitis ”Is that not though also the distinction between sanity and psychosis? What is the differentiation? Is it scale? What is the difference between a religious experience, and someone believing that aliens are communicating with them through the television? Would the latter cease to a symptom of mental illness if millions subscribed to that view?”

Probably is scale. And a fine line between imagination and reality. Thin Line Between Genius and Insanity too.

Mental health medicine is also not a hard science. Surprising amount of social, economic and political influence in mental health medicine according to Nathan Filer. The goal posts move all the time it seems.

The ‘divine frenzy’ experienced by the once celebrated Oracle at Delphi would probably be classified as ‘psychosis’ now and treated with stigma. And yet the Oracle at Delphi was celebrated for a reason and had people from all over the ancient world flocking to her for her uncanny insights.

Maybe believing in a god is a bit insane. But maybe we need a bit of insanity to measure sanity? Or, just escape from life and enjoy life more?

The ancient Greeks had Dionysus as a god of insanity (but also god of wine 🍷 and other ecstasies that makes life enjoyable). He was counterbalanced at Delphi by Apollo who was very much a god of reason.

The story of Dionysus shows him/her going through a lot of trauma, so the insanity makes a bit of sense. It’s like the ecstasy Dionysus represents counterbalances painful trauma. And he’s the one who gets reborn over and again - I read that Dionysus is the Greek god that inspired the idea of Jesus and resurrection. A comeback from suffering is appealing to the imagination (individual and collective).

OP posts:
Digita · 31/08/2022 17:14

@Brefugee “In fact, utilitarianism is about the closest thing to religion that i could get behind.”

That’s quite interesting given the OP is about law, order and justice too.

So, upthread the issue of perjury was raised. Utilitarianism could risk somehow justifying lying under oath/affirmation because they think they’re protecting the greater good - but it’s extremely shortsighted and risks destabilising the legal system. Lying under oath/affirmation for reasons of utilitarianism would still be perjury (a crime). The legal system simply couldn’t run if people could lie under oath if they thought they’re “serving a greater good in society in doing so”. That’s why society needs something to get people to tell the truth even if it’s at their disadvantage (and that includes the disadvantage to their community or group).

To back myself up:

”Perhaps the greatest difficulty with utilitarianism is that it fails to take into account considerations of justice. We can imagine instances where a certain course of action would produce great benefits for society, but they would be clearly unjust. During the apartheid regime in South Africa in the last century, South African whites, for example, sometimes claimed that all South Africans—including blacks—were better off under white rule. These whites claimed that in those African nations that have traded a whites-only government for a black or mixed one, social conditions have rapidly deteriorated. Civil wars, economic decline, famine, and unrest, they predicted, will be the result of allowing the black majority of South Africa to run the government. If such a prediction were true—and the end of apartheid has shown that the prediction was false—then the white government of South Africa would have been morally justified by utilitarianism, in spite of its injustice.

“If our moral decisions are to take into account considerations of justice, then apparently utilitarianism cannot be the sole principle guiding our decisions.”

www.scu.edu/ethics/ethics-resources/ethical-decision-making/calculating-consequences-the-utilitarian-approach/

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 16:59

Digita · 31/08/2022 16:35

@whumpthereitis ”As an atheist I have imagination, but I also have the ability to separate imagination from reality. There’s a difference between imagining a god, and believing there is one.”

I found that interesting. Maybe it’s that ability to separate imagination from reality that makes you atheist.

Whilst what makes a believer is that they experience imagination and reality in a mesh.

“There are plenty of things I can’t explain about existence (either because they haven’t been explained yet or because while they have been explained, I’m not a scientist that’s done a deep dive on the topic in order to learn more of it), but I can accept that I can’t explain it. I don’t feel the need to cover up my lack of understanding with ‘because god’.”

Like ‘god of the gaps’?

Being questioning of a lack of understanding can also entertain the question ‘but is it god?’ If so how/why?’.

So, if someone commits a wrongdoing and the. gets their karma one day. It might useful that they consider ‘did god find out and now punishing me?’. If they make a connection between a wrongdoing and a perceived punishment (like a cause and effect), then that is what I think the research is claiming is effective in moderating human behaviours. If they don’t make any connections between their wrongdoing and any perceived punishment (which would suggest a retributive god), then where’s the potential for learning from the wrongdoing?

I’m saying it’s an effective psychological tool for moderating behaviour in human society. Not, that I actually think that’s how it works.

Chances of shit happening are so high that the potential for that there’s capacity of kind of connection making. Still, I think karma and just works theories are problematic too.

Is that not though also the distinction between sanity and psychosis? What is the differentiation? Is it scale? What is the difference between a religious experience, and someone believing that aliens are communicating with them through the television? Would the latter cease to a symptom of mental illness if millions subscribed to that view?

I absolutely agree that it’s an effective psychological tool, and has been (and is) wielded as such. Whether that’s a force for good however is in the eye of the beholder. What is ‘good’, anyway? People are tricky creatures, we can justify anything and call it good, yet if we were on the receiving end of some of those things we would call them evil. It’s not like concepts of good and evil are built on solid foundations. For every positive outcome you can point to, you can also point to a negative, and call either one it’s opposite depending upon where you’re standing as you consider them.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 16:57

'It is worth emphasising that the subjects in this experiment were not cooperative with random strangers, only with strangers that shared the same god,'

Hmm... not necessarily conducive to toleration then? A justice system which privileges 'us' over 'them' is not one with having. Yet another reason for rejecting your proposition.

pointythings · 31/08/2022 16:56

@Digita just because we need something doesn't mean it is good for us. And where the things we need are not good for us, we can work to overcome that need and find other coping mechanisms. And if you are wondering whether I am seeing the need for a deity as a form of addiction - yes, I probably am.

Kashmirsilver · 31/08/2022 16:53

Digita · 31/08/2022 16:20

“The worship of a deity is a fundamental part of human existence.”

But why?

“God and religion exist in tandem. So your post is wholly incorrect.”

“In tandem” means alongside each other.

I said “One is a philosophical concept, and the other is an organised manmade religion that manipulates the philosophical concept.”

That is indeed in tandem, as in alongside each other. But I’d still argue god and religion are separate just as philosophy and religion are in tandem but separate disciplines.

So, my post is not “wholly incorrect”. In fact, I found the phrase “wholly incorrect” funny because it sounds I was being marked in an objective discipline like maths.

If you make an incorrect statement about a fundamental part of human existence then I'm quite within my rights to nudge you.
Your posts are full of incorrect assertions when talking about fundamental concepts. Interesting you mention math. Professor Lennox argued a case for God using math.
Morality has oft been used as an argument for supporting the existence of a God.
Kant also concluded the ultimate good/perfection is represented by a God.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/08/2022 16:52

Not sure why I got a special lecture on one example of someone promoting religious tolerance, given that upthread I'd alluded to the Romans generally rubbing along together ok with many religions. The fact that some people manage religious tolerance doesn't cancel out out the many horrible cases of religious intolerance.Confused

As to separating god and religion .... I doubt believers see the former as merely a 'philosophical concept'. It may be what you'd like this thread to stick to, but in practice, in real societies, "the idea of God(s) " nearly always seems to result in religious organisations. So no, in the context you set in your AIBU question, you really can't separate them.

Digita · 31/08/2022 16:46

pointythings · 31/08/2022 16:37

To be fair, @Kashmirsilver is onto something. When you look at human mythology (and I include religion in that for convenience) what you see is a range of deities who exhibit all the traits we humans possess. Helpful gods, kind gods, jealous gods, petty gods, selfish gods - it's all there. We make gods in our own image, perhaps as a way of justifying our own existence. The majority of human beings believe in some kind of deity. Not all, but atheists are in the minority.

None of that means that humanity needs gods in order to have a functioning society, however.

But if you agree with @Kashmirsilver ”The worship of a deity is a fundamental part of human existence.”

Then why are you also saying: “None of that means that humanity needs gods in order to have a functioning society, however.”

That’s ignoring a fundamental part of human existence that can act as a useful glue to hold together a functioning society.

I’ve gone back to the OP link.

“'Belief in rewards from the god could not account for the results – supernatural punishment seemed responsible,' said Dominic Johnson of Oxford University, who was not involved in the research, writing in an accompanying article in Nature. 'It is worth emphasising that the subjects in this experiment were not cooperative with random strangers, only with strangers that shared the same god,' Dr Johnson said.”

Maybe it’s that ‘same god’ idea that explains religion.

When really, faith is different for each individual because it’s subjective.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread