Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Malie · 29/08/2022 14:02

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:59

b) never ever interferes with the running of the state

I don't know how to break this to you, but the Head of State is also the Head of the Church of England. Make of that what you will.

"The idea that we need some higher power to hold our baser instincts in check might suit the higher ups in most religions, mostly patriarchal, in order to garner themselves more power."

But it's those in power are the ones who probably need to entertain a higher entity watching them in order to keep them in check. The ones in power are also the ones most likely to be corrupt and lawless by believing they're above the law. Wasn't the balancing of fortunes the job of the Goddess Nemesis in ancient times?

why We are non-conformists! 😀

Malie · 29/08/2022 14:01

Sunnyqueen · 29/08/2022 13:01

I'm agnostic, but think yes. God(s) or the theory of, have a place in society at a base level, its all the rest of the shit some religious people do that is the problem.

The whole swearing under oath thing is ridiculous though. Even the most devout will lie on the stand like its nothing. Might as well ask people to get on the stand and play a kazoo.

Can I have proof to this sweeping statement?

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:59

Brefugee · 29/08/2022 13:39

Meh. It looks as though you're saying that if we don't believe in some version of a higher power (sky fairy, whatever you want to call her) then we will descend into a morass of antisocial behaviour?

Really?

No. You can have your religions, as long as they don't a) interfere with anyone who doesn't follow that religion and b) never ever interferes with the running of the state and c) is fully accountable to the law for all issues

The idea that we need some higher power to hold our baser instincts in check might suit the higher ups in most religions, mostly patriarchal, in order to garner themselves more power. But they can do one.

b) never ever interferes with the running of the state

I don't know how to break this to you, but the Head of State is also the Head of the Church of England. Make of that what you will.

"The idea that we need some higher power to hold our baser instincts in check might suit the higher ups in most religions, mostly patriarchal, in order to garner themselves more power."

But it's those in power are the ones who probably need to entertain a higher entity watching them in order to keep them in check. The ones in power are also the ones most likely to be corrupt and lawless by believing they're above the law. Wasn't the balancing of fortunes the job of the Goddess Nemesis in ancient times?

OP posts:
Onlyforcake · 29/08/2022 13:59

YOU might need the idea of some ultimate authority that will punish you if you do wrong but A LOT of people just have empathy. Superstitious gumpf just holds back society and gets manipulated to create us vs them bullshit.

AlienatedChildGrown · 29/08/2022 13:56

I’m an atheist and thank .. well, pure chance I suppose since I don’t believe in anything.. or my life in a rural, still God-filled, small market town in Italy.

Because it seems that the “dumb old fashioned thing that nobody needs now” I looked down upon is a really great repellant against new tangled ideologies and their Zealots.

At least with a long established religion like Catholicism the “Burn Heretic !” phase is largely out of fashion.

It’s also amazing for me (think less broken home, more like “left coughing on the dust and trapped under the rubble” home) to see so many intact and “good enough” families. It means lots of hands on deck to rally around when the occasional marriage collapse happens. Everybody understand why the kids will need extra support and a parent suddenly left alone can’t deal with her grief and all the other shit suddenly on her plate, all by herself.

I occasionally go to mass because seeing so many people get so much comfort, community and “meaning of life” from their faith feels good. I’ve come a long way from being rather freaked out when DH spent his first night with me and prayed before sleeping 😬

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 13:54

The story of Jesus is a nice idea OP.

It has long since been replaced by abuse, murder, dead babies in septic tanks, the subjugation of women and on and on and on.

I'm from Ireland. I know many deeply religious people, but few christians.

Brefugee · 29/08/2022 13:54

The ‘historical abuse’ argument that gets trotted out on threads like these but seems like a smack in the face to people of faith who are actually doing really good things for others.

To be brutally honest? If the people who belong to those religions spent more time cleaning them up and holding the paedophiles and misogynists to account and getting rid of them (in the direction of the law) then I'd have more interest in hearing about their good works.

All those people who turn a blind eye to paedophile priests? and the mother & baby homes? I hope they rot in the hell they so clearly believe in. For eternity.

If it comes to taking an oath to tell the truth in court? well, we do know that even having sworn on a bible* people still commit perjury so I'm not sure what the point is. I am more inclined to believe someone who isn't known as a liar, say a schoolteacher of good repute, who doesn't swear on a holy book over, say, the person who does the church flowers and worships the ground a priest walks on (especially in the trial of said priest for child abuse). It's all swings and roundabouts.

*other religious tomes are available

Smartiepants79 · 29/08/2022 13:52

I have not read all the thread so apologies if I’m repeating someone.
I’ve been reading the book Sapiens.
Its fascinating.
It basically says that common beliefs are essential for holding together groups of people larger than about 100. Humans can’t keep social connections with 1000s of people without some common beliefs. Historically this has often been in ‘gods’ of varying kinds. In western civilisations it now often a belief in democracy or capitalism etc.. nearly all societal structures are abstract things that we have created. Without them you can’t control large number of people and have them all living in peace together.
Most human behaviour is influenced by fear - of judgement or consequences. Or hope for some kind of gain.

ImustLearn2Cook · 29/08/2022 13:50

Every person that I’ve met who has good attributes such as being kind, decent, caring, considerate, respectful, integrity, love, etc. is a person who has empathy. And this is regardless of whether they have faith in God or a religion or spiritual beliefs or not (atheism).

On the other hand, every person that I have met who has had bad attributes such as being nasty, cruel, indecent, selfish, uncaring, inconsiderate, disrespectful, dishonest, hate etc. is a person who lacks to some degree or completely devoid of empathy. And this is regardless of whether they have faith in God or a religion or spiritual beliefs or not (atheism).

Empathy is what we actually need.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 13:50

I'm an atheist. I'm a good person without the threat of existential punishment. I don't need a grand narrative about purpose and redemption to understand my place in the world, failure and forgiveness.

I achieved all this quietly. Answers can be found in nature, relationships, personal awareness, history, art, storytelling, robust debate but crucially the pain, grief and joy that comes from just moving through your life.

I think pragmatism is the best tool in life. It requires observation, learning and application. I think religion is a poor and passive substitute.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 13:48

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:38

I was trying to say the idea of 'parents' in childhood plays into religion too. 'God the father' is very purposeful, and I can see how it can appeal to the inner child of an adult who feels the need for a parent figure. 'Mary the mother' figure too.

I think those religious leaders used the Father and Mother bit as a clever marketing tool 😂 I don't need extra parents especially as an adult thanks!

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:46

Ylvamoon · 29/08/2022 13:30

I just think religion has two purposes:

1.) Keeping the population in check to accumulate wealth & power
2.) Beeing some sort moral compass for the whole purpose of point one.

Thats why historically you either have rulers put in place by the leaders of the local religion or said leaders are also part of the ruling powers.

I can see how the early Roman Catholic church was guilty of point one. But that, Protestantism came about as a result of RC accumulating wealth through faith.

So, it's not straightforward.

I do think religion and ruling powers were connected. But the story of Jesus, for example, flew in the face of that because he was an underdog born into poverty and a commoner. It suggests there's something more than accumulating wealth and power - because Jesus didn't accumulate wealth and his power appears to have come through being resurrected. Like, you can't buy a resurrection...

OP posts:
Bouledeneige · 29/08/2022 13:44

Sadly being religious provides no guarantee that society will act kindly or fairly. Because as the Bible argues people will always be tempted to evil and act in their own interests inside and outside religion (didn't Jesus have to banish traders from the temple?).

Sadly very few religious people practice what they preach but instead choose to use religion to judge, deprive others outside, reinforce hierarchy and misogyny. Too many fatwas, wars and murders, inquisitions, unfair taxes, abuse of women and children, forced adoption and hypocrisy has happened within religion to see any ideals that they espouse not better instituted outside their confines. Democracy, human rights and rule of law are better principles and personal morality are better guiding principles.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 13:43

Isitsixoclockalready · 29/08/2022 13:36

Not for me personally. I have no expectation of anything beyond my current lifespan or any sort of divine retribution. I don't believe that there is any grand plan - we just happen to exist because the conditions for life were right. That being said, I do have a strong sense of 'do as you would be done by' and not wanting to hurt others (I am not infallible but I try). If that is humanism then I guess that's what I am.

Yes I feel the same way. The meaning of life is life itself, a fleeting gift you were lucky enough to exist in. I believe in treating others the way I would like to be treated because that's fair and I Like people. I've never done something nice for or helped someone out because I think there's a higher power watching over me from the sky, I do it because sometime I might need some help and being nice to other people feels good and is generally beneficial to society if we try to help each other out

thecatsthecats · 29/08/2022 13:43

Dotcheck · 29/08/2022 12:24

OP
I do think that belief has had a key role in the development of civilisation- I’m just not sure that we still need it in the same way. It is very interesting though!

But how well is civilisation going? Are we better or worse off as a species for being civilised?

Sure, there are certain protections from society - provided that you're at a certain strata of it. But I deal with those for whom civilisation is, to be frank, a drawback. They don't have money to learn, to enjoy the products of civilisation, and whilst they may live longer on average than in the wild, they don't live healthy lives.

They would be better off hunting and gathering than living lives at the shitty end of civilisation, full of obstacles, poor nutrition, minimum wages etc.

Hyacinth2 · 29/08/2022 13:43

I quite envy people who have a faith - I think it would be good for mental health to pray to some powerful deity , ask for support, enlightenment with everyday life.

DianaGarageDoors · 29/08/2022 13:41

I don't believe that people need God to behave ethically. I do believe that religious faith and practice can provide comfort and meaning, a sense of one's life and oneself in relation to others, community and structure.

I think some of the problems in modern life- atomised, consumer-focused societies made up of individuals, too many of whom feel lost, lonely and alienated- stem from the fact that we've lost a lot of the benefits of religious practice and belief and not found a secular way to replace them. This isn't an argument for a return to organised religion (which of course also brought harms) and it certainly isn't an argument for the existence of God. But we should try, as a society, to recognise the benefits that religious practice can bring and recreate those in a secular way, to help people live meaningful, cohesive and connected lives.

Brefugee · 29/08/2022 13:39

Meh. It looks as though you're saying that if we don't believe in some version of a higher power (sky fairy, whatever you want to call her) then we will descend into a morass of antisocial behaviour?

Really?

No. You can have your religions, as long as they don't a) interfere with anyone who doesn't follow that religion and b) never ever interferes with the running of the state and c) is fully accountable to the law for all issues

The idea that we need some higher power to hold our baser instincts in check might suit the higher ups in most religions, mostly patriarchal, in order to garner themselves more power. But they can do one.

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:38

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 13:29

I'm not sure how you can make a comparison like that and expect me to see them as equal. Every child has parents we know this as a biological reality, gods are something know one actually knows exist are not, an imaginary force. An imaginary force that humans speak/spoke for.

A baby needs an adult in it's life when it's born or it will literally die, it needs to be taught everything by an adult, that's usually it's parents. So no, I don't see the two as similar at all

I was trying to say the idea of 'parents' in childhood plays into religion too. 'God the father' is very purposeful, and I can see how it can appeal to the inner child of an adult who feels the need for a parent figure. 'Mary the mother' figure too.

OP posts:
Isitsixoclockalready · 29/08/2022 13:36

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:24

But doesn't the idea of 'gods' come back to the hierarchy of parents?

Do you also not like the idea that if there were no parents, then children would be morally bankrupt animals?

"God Is Watching You: How the Fear of God Makes Us Human" by Dominic Johnson is an interesting book:

'He shows that belief in supernatural reward and punishment is no quirk of western or Christian culture, but a ubiquitous part of human nature that spans geographical regions, cultures, and human history.'

Not for me personally. I have no expectation of anything beyond my current lifespan or any sort of divine retribution. I don't believe that there is any grand plan - we just happen to exist because the conditions for life were right. That being said, I do have a strong sense of 'do as you would be done by' and not wanting to hurt others (I am not infallible but I try). If that is humanism then I guess that's what I am.

Sittingonabench · 29/08/2022 13:35

The idea of gods is far more likely to have been in response to answering unanswerable questions (at least historically). The changing of the seasons before we understood the motion of the planet and proximity to the sun - the gods are responsible. The different levels of emotions in people - love, war, caring etc. the gods are responsible. How all creatures live and have energy but different to humans - the gods. Your basis appears very focused on only a few belief codes. Many did not have a fair and just god to balance the scales of justice but had petty, jealous and unpredictable gods who may punish you if you caught their eye. People have free will and even with the threat of divine retribution don’t act how they Should. So to prove god has a positive impact you would need to test two identical sets of people one with a coded belief and one without. That is unlikely to be possible.

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:34

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 13:27

Overt religiosity in society hasn’t been typified by peace, throughout history. Most of the battles religions have been involved in have not been against atheism, but against different denominations within the same religion, and against other religions.

Secularism, on the other hand, has coincided with, and driven, an era that placed a much greater emphasis on human rights and personal liberty.

In secularism isn't there also risks of games being played over human rights and personal liberty?

Example: Tory leadership ex-candidate and Attorney General Suella Braverman said she would ‘eliminate’ the human right to protection from torture and inhuman treatment. www.independent.co.uk/independentpremium/uk-news/tory-leadership-candidate-suella-braverman-torture-human-rights-b2124323.html

People don't all agree on human rights and personal liberty.

OP posts:
Ylvamoon · 29/08/2022 13:30

I just think religion has two purposes:

1.) Keeping the population in check to accumulate wealth & power
2.) Beeing some sort moral compass for the whole purpose of point one.

Thats why historically you either have rulers put in place by the leaders of the local religion or said leaders are also part of the ruling powers.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 13:30

@Digita

'He shows that belief in supernatural reward and punishment is no quirk of western or Christian culture, but a ubiquitous part of human nature that spans geographical regions, cultures, and human history.'

Surely all it points to is the ubiquitous need in human nature for a reason or meaning for their existence, and some comfort that it's not just a pure accident.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 13:29

Digita · 29/08/2022 13:24

But doesn't the idea of 'gods' come back to the hierarchy of parents?

Do you also not like the idea that if there were no parents, then children would be morally bankrupt animals?

"God Is Watching You: How the Fear of God Makes Us Human" by Dominic Johnson is an interesting book:

'He shows that belief in supernatural reward and punishment is no quirk of western or Christian culture, but a ubiquitous part of human nature that spans geographical regions, cultures, and human history.'

I'm not sure how you can make a comparison like that and expect me to see them as equal. Every child has parents we know this as a biological reality, gods are something know one actually knows exist are not, an imaginary force. An imaginary force that humans speak/spoke for.

A baby needs an adult in it's life when it's born or it will literally die, it needs to be taught everything by an adult, that's usually it's parents. So no, I don't see the two as similar at all