Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Malie · 29/08/2022 14:23

Thingstodotoday · 29/08/2022 14:17

@Malie do you need some help understanding the term “most”?
It’s not hard to feel intellectually superior when this is the quality of the counterarguments!

Frankly this is all the argument that was needed.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 14:20

TitoMojito · 29/08/2022 14:10

I wondered about this: is it fair? Do an oath and affirmation carry the same weight in reality? In theory, both an oath and affirmation should be equal. But does everyone else witnessing feel the same way?

For example.

One is claiming to declare the truth before a 'higher being' witness who (in theory) they believe has the power to punish them if they are telling lies (a deterrent).

The other is claiming to tell the truth without any concept of another 'higher being' or a 'deterrant'

The higher power/deterrent in this situation is prosecution for perjury.

If I was on a jury, my inclination would be to give more weight to the affirmer - as it's not the default option it implies they've thought about it, not just mouthing the words. And swearing on a centuries old book (which if you've studied it with any seriousness you know is not remotely self-consistent let alone 'the truth') doesn't incline me to think that person is necessarily a good judge of reliable evidence.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 14:19

I was brought up in a faith school, Sunday school every week.

I knew it was twaddle before I left primary.

I remember vividly the bit of the bible that said humans have the power over all other living creatures. Even as a 5 year old I thought hang on that's not right.

GeekyThings · 29/08/2022 14:19

I think this thread is ignoring the correlation between religion and unsuccessful societies due to economic inequality. Basically the more wealthy a society is, with the wealth spread out further across the population, the less religious that society tends to be. Because religion, to an extent, is a psychological coping mechanism - the more anxious you are about your daily life, the more likely it will be that you will look to find something, or someone, to help ease that burden.

So, really, the only reason that I can see for wanting to retain a religion in order to keep society stable would be if you prefer society to be unequal and to have large portions of it living in poverty. In those instances religion can be a useful tool to keep the peace in groups of people living under stressful circumstances. But even that isn't surefire, and actually many of the more religious areas of the world are also very dangerous places to live in general, so clearly it isn't a perfect strategy by a long stretch!

If the aim is to keep society stable and peaceful, really religion isn't the thing to be concentrating on, or even concerned with - it's wealth, and more particularly getting rid of wealth inequality. Religion will probably dissipate along with the wealth gap, but society on the whole won't need it because people will be happier, and happier people don't need as much of a crutch to just get on with the day.

It reminds me of a comedian I saw once who pointed out - you never hear of someone finding god when everything's going well for them; you'll hear someone say 'my dog died, my car blew up, I lost my job and my house, but I've found god, so that's ok'; but it's much less likely you'll ever hear 'i got married, got my dream job, won the lottery, oh, and I also found god'!

Thingstodotoday · 29/08/2022 14:17

Malie · 29/08/2022 12:28

Go to North Korea. You will find Utopia there.

@Malie do you need some help understanding the term “most”?
It’s not hard to feel intellectually superior when this is the quality of the counterarguments!

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 14:15

Having watched love ones die from cancer, dementia and other things.

I'd say if good exists god should be considered disgusting and shouldn't be worshiped at all.

mamabear715 · 29/08/2022 14:14

*Kill, not ill!

mamabear715 · 29/08/2022 14:14

I'm Christian, & spiritual, but kinda follow my own path.
To me, Johnny 5, the robot in Short Circuit movie sums it up best. :-)

Newton Crosby 'Why did you disobey your programme?'
Number Five 'Programme say to kill, to disassemble, to make dead. Number Five cannot.'
Newton Crosby 'Why 'cannot'?'
Number Five 'Is WRONG! Newton Crosby, Ph.D, not KNOW this?'
Newton Crosby 'Of course I know it's wrong to ill, but who told you?
Number Five 'I told me..'

Love it.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 14:14

LemonSwan · 29/08/2022 14:09

I get what you are saying OP. I am not practicing in any religion but I do keep a bible in the house.

I would feel extremely uncomfortable lieing with my hand on a bible.

It’s a bit like a horse shoe isn’t it. Why keep it the wrong way round? Is it worth the risk 🤷‍♀️

That's just superstition though, isn't it?

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 14:13

TitoMojito · 29/08/2022 14:05

Do you think generations of faith-based communities may have influenced your moral compass?

Not remotely.

No, me neither.

Elphame · 29/08/2022 14:13

I don't need to be treated like a naughty child to know the difference between right and wrong.

The sooner the English church is dis-established the better as far as I'm concerned.

Organised religion is directly responsible for millions of deaths and people are still being killed in its name.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 14:11

LemonSwan · 29/08/2022 14:09

I get what you are saying OP. I am not practicing in any religion but I do keep a bible in the house.

I would feel extremely uncomfortable lieing with my hand on a bible.

It’s a bit like a horse shoe isn’t it. Why keep it the wrong way round? Is it worth the risk 🤷‍♀️

I try not to lie anyway but having a bible in my hand would certainly not make me less likely to 😂

TitoMojito · 29/08/2022 14:10

I wondered about this: is it fair? Do an oath and affirmation carry the same weight in reality? In theory, both an oath and affirmation should be equal. But does everyone else witnessing feel the same way?

For example.

One is claiming to declare the truth before a 'higher being' witness who (in theory) they believe has the power to punish them if they are telling lies (a deterrent).

The other is claiming to tell the truth without any concept of another 'higher being' or a 'deterrant'

The higher power/deterrent in this situation is prosecution for perjury.

goherbie · 29/08/2022 14:10

No I don't think it's unwise to lose the sense of God in society. It's hard to judge religion, because religion is always found in a cultural context that defines it.

However, if I were forced to pick a religion, on ethical grounds the religion I would argue teaches the kindest / nicest morality, to me is Buddhism. Whilst not being entirely atheistic, it does acknowledge the existence of gods, but considers them largely to be an irrelevance (see the Buddha's teaching of the poisoned arrow).

Of course, Buddhism is not without its issues too, the situation in Myanmar and the issue of female bhikkunis show that misogyny is alive and well in all cultures. But again, it is difficult to disentangle religion from culture.

But, simply put, to me the superiority of Buddhist ethics over Christian / Jewish / Muslim ethics amply shows that belief in God is not necessary for a sound ethical system.

LemonSwan · 29/08/2022 14:09

I get what you are saying OP. I am not practicing in any religion but I do keep a bible in the house.

I would feel extremely uncomfortable lieing with my hand on a bible.

It’s a bit like a horse shoe isn’t it. Why keep it the wrong way round? Is it worth the risk 🤷‍♀️

Carpy88999 · 29/08/2022 14:08

If the only reason people are good is because they fear supernatural consequences for misdeads they're not really good people at all imo.

KangarooKenny · 29/08/2022 14:06

I personally think that god and the commandments were devised to bring law and rules to a lawless society.
There are many of the commandments that people could do with adhering to these days.

DragonflyNights · 29/08/2022 14:06

Then again, this study has shown that toddlers show altruism (so they claim). And they are not likely to have much fear of a vengeful god yet.

www.washington.edu/news/2020/02/04/altruistic-babies-study-shows-infants-are-willing-to-give-up-food-help-others/

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 14:06

You're flogging a dead horse OP 😂

Brefugee · 29/08/2022 14:06

I don't know how to break this to you, but the Head of State is also the Head of the Church of England. Make of that what you will.

Patronising twaddle. You assume that I'm ok with this. I am not.

Malie · 29/08/2022 14:05

Onlyforcake · 29/08/2022 13:59

YOU might need the idea of some ultimate authority that will punish you if you do wrong but A LOT of people just have empathy. Superstitious gumpf just holds back society and gets manipulated to create us vs them bullshit.

It is when I read posts like this that I realise that when people cease to be
ieve in God they believe anything

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 14:05

I can see how the early Roman Catholic church was guilty of point one. But that, Protestantism came about as a result of RC accumulating wealth through faith.

The Catholic church still is UpTo it they are rich beyond belief, they have helped spreads of HIV and other diseases in Africa, their so called outreach programs in Africa have probably cost more lives.

The Catholic church helps protect and cover up and move paedo priests to keep carrying out their activities elsewhere.

TitoMojito · 29/08/2022 14:05

Do you think generations of faith-based communities may have influenced your moral compass?

Not remotely.

Digita · 29/08/2022 14:03

Onlyforcake · 29/08/2022 13:59

YOU might need the idea of some ultimate authority that will punish you if you do wrong but A LOT of people just have empathy. Superstitious gumpf just holds back society and gets manipulated to create us vs them bullshit.

Empathy has its own issues, sadly.

"We think of empathy – the ability to feel the suffering of others for ourselves – as the ultimate source of all good behaviour. But while it inspires care and protection in personal relationships, it has the opposite effect in the wider world. As the latest research in psychology and neuroscience shows, we feel empathy most for those we find attractive and who seem similar to us and not at all for those who are different, distant or anonymous. Empathy therefore biases us in favour of individuals we know while numbing us to the plight of thousands. Guiding us expertly through the experiments, case studies and arguments on all sides, Paul Bloom ultimately shows that some of our worst decisions – in charity, child-raising, criminal justice, climate change and war – are motivated by this wolf in sheep's clothing."

  • 'Against Empathy: The Case for Rational Compassion' by Paul Bloom
OP posts:
Isitsixoclockalready · 29/08/2022 14:03

Smartiepants79 · 29/08/2022 13:52

I have not read all the thread so apologies if I’m repeating someone.
I’ve been reading the book Sapiens.
Its fascinating.
It basically says that common beliefs are essential for holding together groups of people larger than about 100. Humans can’t keep social connections with 1000s of people without some common beliefs. Historically this has often been in ‘gods’ of varying kinds. In western civilisations it now often a belief in democracy or capitalism etc.. nearly all societal structures are abstract things that we have created. Without them you can’t control large number of people and have them all living in peace together.
Most human behaviour is influenced by fear - of judgement or consequences. Or hope for some kind of gain.

I can see that but at the same time, one doesn't need religion as the binding glue and I think that the more that we discover about the universe, the less that the idea of a divine being makes sense and given all the religions out there with different ideas of what their divinity is, it's hard to reconcile all of those different belief structures together to agree on a common deity, so who is right?

I guess that you might be approaching the argument, not so much from the point of view of it being necessary that there is one, agreed supreme being but more that a belief is necessary for societal structure. I think that other methods such as a sense of community or patriotism or nationalism probably replaces that need.

Swipe left for the next trending thread