Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
AnnoyedFromSlough · 16/02/2023 11:33

Someone I know posted this recently.

I know many very moral non religious people. I also know some highly immoral religious people - people that think they are better than most, and show that by their actions. For example, doing everything they could to stop someone from going to their long term, living together partner's funeral.

Religion doesn't stop people from being awful, and non-religion doesn't make bad people out of good.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?
Fairislefandango · 15/02/2023 14:24

And now that religion has lost its grip on most of us, who will have the moral authority to restrain us?

You do realise that those who invented religions and have always being in charge of imposing religions' supposed moral authority on the people in order to 'restrain' us were all morally (often extremely) fallible human beings, right? Quis custodet ipsos custodes and all that...

poweredbysteam · 15/02/2023 12:34

SammyScrounge · 14/02/2023 20:57

G.K Chesterton once said that 'People who.don't.believe in God will believe in anything.'
These days everyone is able to choose their own beliefs or even invent them. They can decide for themselves what is moral or what is not, or even if there is such a thing as meaningful morality.

Take a good look at some of the things people believe in these days.Bizarre ludicrous things abound. People are afraid to challenge the strangest beliefs even when they are harmful to society as a whole.

It seems to me that religion and a broad acceptance of its tenets were a unifying force in society. And there is nothing to replace it.

There is a relatively new theory of the origins.of civilisations. Broadly it used to be thought that hunter gatherers settled down to farming and then built temples to their gods; a new school of thought says the temples and huge religious complexes came first and then people settled there to assist in the running and maintenance of these holy places and priests. And that is how civilisation began.

I have no idea which theory, if either, is correct. But what if religion is the foundation of civilisation? And now that religion has lost its grip on most of us, who will have the moral authority to restrain us?

Personally, I fear the future. Our society is rotten through and through; the media worships depravity, our leaders will not speak out against it.
An example is that idiot who stripped off on TV and played the piano with his penis. That was the moment I realised we're finished as a respected nation. When that man is classed as entertainment, or a satire on society, or an amusing comment on modern art we have lost the plot.

People have been moaning about the lack of 'morals' and the state of entertainment and kids these days for millenia.

pointythings · 14/02/2023 21:27

And now that religion has lost its grip on most of us, who will have the moral authority to restrain us?
We don't need to be restrained by a religious authority. It is perfectly possible to have humane secular laws which work well and maintain a stable society. You have been taken in by the fallacy that you need religion to have good morals.

Personally, I fear the future. Our society is rotten through and through; the media worships depravity, our leaders will not speak out against it.
An example is that idiot who stripped off on TV and played the piano with his penis. That was the moment I realised we're finished as a respected nation. When that man is classed as entertainment, or a satire on society, or an amusing comment on modern art we have lost the plot.

I beg to differ. When I look around me, what I see are decent people doing their best, going about their business. Some manage it better than others, but the people I know work hard, abide by the law, are kind to each other, support charities of all kinds and are worthwhile. We currently have a government that is rotten through and through, but with any luck the cycle of democracy will change that. Society is not doing too badly at all.

And if you think penis piano man was the moment the UK was finished as a respected nation, you haven't been paying attention - that respect was lost when our government stopped respecting international law and international treaties, proposed sending asylum seekers to another country without due process and broke its own laws. A penis on tv is hardly an earthshaking event, unless you're clutching your pearls too hard.

Mississippi6 · 14/02/2023 21:02

Religion was useful in that respect when humans were primitive and wild and had to be threatened with punishment by God in order to not kill each other. These days we have the police and legal systems in place, therefore the religion’s past its due date.

SammyScrounge · 14/02/2023 20:57

G.K Chesterton once said that 'People who.don't.believe in God will believe in anything.'
These days everyone is able to choose their own beliefs or even invent them. They can decide for themselves what is moral or what is not, or even if there is such a thing as meaningful morality.

Take a good look at some of the things people believe in these days.Bizarre ludicrous things abound. People are afraid to challenge the strangest beliefs even when they are harmful to society as a whole.

It seems to me that religion and a broad acceptance of its tenets were a unifying force in society. And there is nothing to replace it.

There is a relatively new theory of the origins.of civilisations. Broadly it used to be thought that hunter gatherers settled down to farming and then built temples to their gods; a new school of thought says the temples and huge religious complexes came first and then people settled there to assist in the running and maintenance of these holy places and priests. And that is how civilisation began.

I have no idea which theory, if either, is correct. But what if religion is the foundation of civilisation? And now that religion has lost its grip on most of us, who will have the moral authority to restrain us?

Personally, I fear the future. Our society is rotten through and through; the media worships depravity, our leaders will not speak out against it.
An example is that idiot who stripped off on TV and played the piano with his penis. That was the moment I realised we're finished as a respected nation. When that man is classed as entertainment, or a satire on society, or an amusing comment on modern art we have lost the plot.

Digita · 02/09/2022 18:33

@whumpthereitis ”Cassandra is an interesting one, and her decisions make more or less sense depending on the origin story. In one, she accepted the gift of prophecy in exchange for being his consort, not on receiving it refused him. Perhaps her worship is an act of atonement? Perhaps in serving him she hopes for mercy? She’s a tragic figure, but retains her beauty.”

Both Apollo and Cassandra are an interesting duo.

Apollo’s a god of prophecy so likely knew she would reject his advances. Also find it interesting that she rejects him after she receives the gift of prophecy, which begs the question of what she saw would happen if she agreed to become his consort (sounds like rejecting him and being cursed may have been the lesser of two evils that she foresaw).

Apollo also avenges Cassandra’s murder, so he stands up for her in the end. Then apparently Cassandra ends up in Elysium fields (is that the spelling?) which was a favourable outcome for human afterlife.

OP posts:
Bloodoranged · 02/09/2022 13:08

Malie · 02/09/2022 12:48

You make my point nicely!

What is your point exactly?

Malie · 02/09/2022 12:48

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 22:00

Amazing how Mr Fry gets so angry with a deity he doesn’t believe in! 😀

Yeah because what people have done in their name is harmless. If you can't see why he is angry you aren't paying attention.

You make my point nicely!

Novum · 02/09/2022 11:41

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

Surely the best incentive to tell the truth is precisely that recognition that Society needs it. Because if you rely on religion to be that incentive, you take the risk that the other person isn't religious, or that their religion takes a more flexible attitude to truth. The courts don't insist on swearing on oath, and evidence has just as much force if it is simply affirmed. So far as they are concerned, the most effective incentive is the fact that if you lie you can be prosecuted for perjury.

whumpthereitis · 02/09/2022 11:05

Digita · 01/09/2022 12:46

@whumpthereitis The trilogy is brilliant!

“Human theatre playing out the squabbles of bored gods.”

But just think how theatrical some court room dramas can be?

It’s like a stage, with dressing up in wigs etc. Lots of performance involved.

I can see how gods might be interested in human law and justice for entertainment value too.

Wouldn’t that be a twist on the ‘god is watching you’?
Yes, but it’s not for any ‘sanctified or holy’ reasons; it’s for entertainment and sport. There would be rules being paid attention to as in any sport too, so perjury would be a foul that would get flagged up.

“Odysseus knew that the attentions of the gods was rarely a herald of good fortune. Pay your respects and keep your head down.”

Not paying respect to gods earned their attention too… not a safe bet from an atheist position either.

Odysseus still caught the gods’ attention because of his cunning and skilfulness, so paying respects and keeping his head down wasn’t enough. He didn’t want to go to war and even feigned madness, but got caught and ended up being away for 20 years.

The gods bring mixed fortunes and act out of self-interest. Once on their radar you’ve got to play along… because they’re gods.

Always felt Cassandra was a complex character. On stage her fellow humans don’t believes her true prophecies. But the audience pay attention to what she says, because they know she knows what’s going to happen next.

Also, if Apollo cursed Cassandra then why does she choose to become his priestess? That story never added up.

I just bit the bullet and bought a kindle so those are going to be my first downloads.

the Greek gods I think are more appealing in their sheer humanness. They are capricious, but I think ultimately they must just be really, really bored. You’ve got all eternity to occupy, of course you’re going to make your own entertainment. It reminds me of a quite from Constantine: “Gods a kid with an ant farm lady, he’s not planning anything”

Unfortunately for Odysseus he was exceptional, so despite his best efforts he wasn’t going to escape their notice for long.

Cassandra is an interesting one, and her decisions make more or less sense depending on the origin story. In one, she accepted the gift of prophecy in exchange for being his consort, not on receiving it refused him. Perhaps her worship is an act of atonement? Perhaps in serving him she hopes for mercy? She’s a tragic figure, but retains her beauty. Conversely, Medusa was physically transformed as punishment for an act committed against her, and became monstrous.

The Abrahamic god always puts me in mind of a cruel slave driver, which I suppose is pertinent when you consider his origins.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/09/2022 23:24

God and Devil possibly two sides of same coin.

Like in Manichaeism maybe?

Digita · 01/09/2022 22:34

@Againstmachine “If God existed and I met them I'd put a gun to their head and pull the trigger as they are more a murderous bastard than any figure in history.”

But what if it turned out that God had a license to kill?
And you almost certainly wouldn’t.

There’s a lot we don’t know. Hence philosophical discussion and exploration.

Being mortal means humans die; death is sadly an inevitability.

Doctors sometimes talk about how medicine is also about helping patients die well too. www.bmj.com/content/346/bmj.f2656

“Despite the media commotion, a surprisingly high proportion of middle-aged and older adults viewed cancer as 'the best way to die' and rated cancer death as better than heart disease.” Is cancer a good way to die? A population-based survey among middle-aged and older adults in the United Kingdom

Some people think a slower death gives them time to put affairs in order and resolve goodbyes. Still awful though. But the nature of death is awful, so it’s also about facing adversity with fortitude and bravery.

And that’s probably why the idea of rebirth and Jesus with his resurrection after suffering brings some people comfort about the afterlife etc. It offers some people hope of something beyond death.

OP posts:
pointythings · 01/09/2022 22:26

Stephen Fry has a point about the Biblical version of God though (matters of whether he exists aside for a moment): in the book of Job he basically gives Satan the go-ahead to completely ruin and torment the poor guy to test his devotion. If that were an experiment in modern research, it absolutely would not pass ethics, mainly because it's monstrous.

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 22:00

Amazing how Mr Fry gets so angry with a deity he doesn’t believe in! 😀

Yeah because what people have done in their name is harmless. If you can't see why he is angry you aren't paying attention.

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 21:58

*That was a giant unreasonable leap. But I’ll bite and ask - how do you know that a god’s behind cancer?

Just looked up cancer causes and god isn’t listed. Some causes are self-inflicted, for example, smoking and poor diet.

Is it always helpful to blame god for all the things that go wrong?*

Ah but God created cancer so it's all his fault, and he could cure it.

But he's made a choice to let this happen.

It's easy to blame humans, if there is a higher power humans can't be to blame.

If God can't change anything whats point in praying to them.

If God existed and I met them I'd put a gun to their head and pull the trigger as they are more a murderous bastard than any figure in history.

Digita · 01/09/2022 20:09

Malie · 01/09/2022 19:52

Amazing how Mr Fry gets so angry with a deity he doesn’t believe in! 😀

And has a soft spot for capricious gods too.

OP posts:
Digita · 01/09/2022 20:04

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:48

So you think it's acceptable for a god to give people cancer, even of they did exist I'd revile them.

If you think it's acceptable to worship a scumbag that's Upto you, it's funny you talk about morals but a god with none is ok with you

That was a giant unreasonable leap. But I’ll bite and ask - how do you know that a god’s behind cancer?

Just looked up cancer causes and god isn’t listed. Some causes are self-inflicted, for example, smoking and poor diet.

Is it always helpful to blame god for all the things that go wrong?

OP posts:
Malie · 01/09/2022 19:52

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:11

In Stephen Fry’s retelling of Troy, someone suggests a lottery is “thanks to the gods”. Odysseus was a bit more wary and insightful, saying something like “if the gods are involved and have anything to do with this then it’s more likely a curse”.

I'd suggest you watch Stephen Fry's interview with Gay Byrne on God.

As he quite correctly asserts that if there is a god then it is a very vile creature.

Amazing how Mr Fry gets so angry with a deity he doesn’t believe in! 😀

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:48

So you think it's acceptable for a god to give people cancer, even of they did exist I'd revile them.

If you think it's acceptable to worship a scumbag that's Upto you, it's funny you talk about morals but a god with none is ok with you

Digita · 01/09/2022 19:40

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:33

Note really there is no reason to worship a vile creature, and probably worse than the devil if you believe.

There’s a difference between worshiping (and expecting reward) to not pissing off a god.

God and Devil possibly two sides of same coin.

Like Dr Jekyll and Hyde. In which case, might be tactical to keep the good side sweet.

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:33

Note really there is no reason to worship a vile creature, and probably worse than the devil if you believe.

Digita · 01/09/2022 19:20

Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:11

In Stephen Fry’s retelling of Troy, someone suggests a lottery is “thanks to the gods”. Odysseus was a bit more wary and insightful, saying something like “if the gods are involved and have anything to do with this then it’s more likely a curse”.

I'd suggest you watch Stephen Fry's interview with Gay Byrne on God.

As he quite correctly asserts that if there is a god then it is a very vile creature.

Have seen that. If god is vile then that’s more of a reason not to piss god off or get on god’s radar.

That’s why Odysseus paid his respects and kept his head down, although he still caught their eye because of his usefulness to the gods.

Link here if anyone wants to see:

“Stephen Fry on God | The Meaning Of Life | RTÉ One”

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 01/09/2022 19:11

In Stephen Fry’s retelling of Troy, someone suggests a lottery is “thanks to the gods”. Odysseus was a bit more wary and insightful, saying something like “if the gods are involved and have anything to do with this then it’s more likely a curse”.

I'd suggest you watch Stephen Fry's interview with Gay Byrne on God.

As he quite correctly asserts that if there is a god then it is a very vile creature.

Digita · 01/09/2022 18:14

There’s a subtle military presence in many churches and cathedrals. Though only for pomp and ceremony and war memorial stuff. But still suggests a connection between religion/god and military.

CofE has a page dedicated to flags and military colours in relation to the Royal British Legion too.

www.churchofengland.org/resources/churchcare/advice-and-guidance-church-buildings/flags-and-military-colours

OP posts: