Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Softplayhooray · 29/08/2022 15:45

KettrickenSmiled · 29/08/2022 12:20

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

What does it say about religious communities that e.g. prey on small boys without compunction, then cover up the abuse for decades. OP? Seems those priests fear of divine retribution didn't stop them forcibly sodomising children.

Well said! Sadly, fear of religious retribution stopped a lot of young boys from feeling they could speak up, though.

OP there are so many options out the people/you. Biocentrism, a general love of science and how phenomenal it is, a love of nature as divine, so many other things. It doesn't need to be a narrow construct of 'God' versus a fear that society will fall apart without it.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:43

@Malie

AhNowTed
Oh here we go. The "if you don't like it leave" argument. Well done.

"Is the same as our dear old Cambridge spies who spied for the Soviets during the Cold War. When they actually were forced to live in dear old mother Russia they found it wasn’t quite the Utopia it had seemed from the U.K."

It's not the same though.

You seem to suggest that if I don't like something I should leave. I don't agree with this particular government, so should I leave?

Should Tories leave when Labour is in power.

Should Muslims leave a Christian country.

I'm at a loss as to your actual argument.

stopitstopitnow · 29/08/2022 15:42

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 15:34

As far as sales pitches go, ‘find Jesus or fuck off to North Korea’ needs work.

You're not wrong. Don't "God" and Kim Jong Un both demand total obedience? So "move to North Korea if you don't believe" is just swapping one dictator for another.

Simonjt · 29/08/2022 15:40

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:34

Such as…?

Ever been to Afghanistan, Venezeula or Syria?!

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 29/08/2022 15:38

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:36

I think your answer just shows the thought you put into your research

You're embarrassing yourself now 🤦‍♀️

Is this how your religion encourages its followers to behave?

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:36

@Linning

"if you think a belief in religion keep people in check then you are massively wrong, if anything it has historically proven to do the opposite and fuel hatred and discrimination."

Growing up in a deeply religious country I can attest to this absolutely.

The horrific damage done to generations, and still be covered up to this day.

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:36

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 15:34

As far as sales pitches go, ‘find Jesus or fuck off to North Korea’ needs work.

I think your answer just shows the thought you put into your research

Wallaw · 29/08/2022 15:35

goherbie · 29/08/2022 15:24

@Wallaw

"How is it any more of a generalisation or shit argument than the original premise: loss of god in society = bad, when I could easily give you specifics in which god in society has not resulted in good?"

It's not, I don't think either argument works. What's the old mumsnet saying, the plural of Anecdote is not data? Shit saying, but you get my point.

Right, but I'm not arguing that belief of God in society is bad.

I'm arguing that God in society doesn't necessarily mean good, which, for the sake of this discussion, I'm equating with the original premise (that the loss of God in society is bad). I think there's plenty of evidence to support that case.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 15:34

Malie · 29/08/2022 14:58

North Korea?

As far as sales pitches go, ‘find Jesus or fuck off to North Korea’ needs work.

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:34

orbitalcrisis · 29/08/2022 15:30

If you only act in amoral way because you are afraid of being punished barbarically in an imaginary afterlife, you are intrinsically an immoral person, secular morality is far superior to religious morality.

The most religious countries generally have the highest crime rates.

Such as…?

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:33

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:25

Oh here we go. The "if you don't like it leave" argument. Well done.

Is the same as our dear old Cambridge spies who spied for the Soviets during the Cold War. When they actually were forced to live in dear old mother Russia they found it wasn’t quite the Utopia it had seemed from the U.K.

orbitalcrisis · 29/08/2022 15:30

If you only act in amoral way because you are afraid of being punished barbarically in an imaginary afterlife, you are intrinsically an immoral person, secular morality is far superior to religious morality.

The most religious countries generally have the highest crime rates.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:27

@Wallaw

"How is it any more of a generalisation or shit argument than the original premise: loss of god in society = bad, when I could easily give you specifics in which god in society has not resulted in good?"

Indeed. Can't think of one where it has. None.

Simonjt · 29/08/2022 15:26

goherbie · 29/08/2022 15:13

@Wallaw

Exactly, pointing to any specific regime and saying that's really bad, so whatever religion/ideology it belongs to is therefore bad is just a shit argument all round. Or more technically a hasty generalisation.

Stalin bad = atheism bad
Hitler bad = Christianity bad
Ferdinand and Isabella (Spanish inquisition) = Catholicism bad
Taliban = Islam bad

Whichever religion / ideology you find, you can get good and bad examples of all, so what does it prove, Diddly squat

Yep, as a young child I grew up in an area controlled by the taliban, funnily enough you were only okay and safe if you didn’t step out of line. My mother married a Sikh, they had to flee, not just my mother and father, but the wider family.

If they had remained they would have been killed because their marriage is forbidden under islam. That same area is now controlled by tehrik-i-taliban.

Flat04 · 29/08/2022 15:26

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:22

Go and live in one then

One of the ones where belief in God is illegal or where the lack of belief in (a specified) God is illegal?

Either way, a well-reasoned intelligent response. Easier I guess than examining the fundamental incoherence in your arguments?

You do seem a good case in point, by the way, that belief in God does not, by itself, make one a kinder person.

Linning · 29/08/2022 15:26

YABVVVU, have you missed how religion is historically the source of most discrimination, abuse and oppression? How religion has always been used as a way to oppress, discriminate and abuse people based on the belief that it was the right thing to do by god.

How many children taken away from their parents and forced-fed a specific religion? How many people were tortured or burned at the stake for failing to behave according to religion? How many women were stoned for not being pious enough? How many child-brides? How many faith based genocides? How many homophobes justify their hate and abuse on religion? How much of the abortion bad and restrictions on women bodies are based in religion?

if you think a belief in religion keep people in check then you are massively wrong, if anything it has historically proven to do the opposite and fuel hatred and discrimination.

Good people will be good people despite their religion and horrible people will remain horrible people despite the religion hence why sexual abuse and pedophilia is outrageously common in highly religious circles and why even people who do not commit the crime still condone it, because their faith doesn’t supersedes their perversion nor peer pressure.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:25

Oh here we go. The "if you don't like it leave" argument. Well done.

goherbie · 29/08/2022 15:24

@Wallaw

"How is it any more of a generalisation or shit argument than the original premise: loss of god in society = bad, when I could easily give you specifics in which god in society has not resulted in good?"

It's not, I don't think either argument works. What's the old mumsnet saying, the plural of Anecdote is not data? Shit saying, but you get my point.

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:22

Flat04 · 29/08/2022 15:20

Ah, yes, those societies where lack of belief in (a specified) God is illegal are so much better.

Go and live in one then

Flat04 · 29/08/2022 15:20

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:16

Not at all. I am talking about societies where belief in God was illegal

Ah, yes, those societies where lack of belief in (a specified) God is illegal are so much better.

Wallaw · 29/08/2022 15:19

goherbie · 29/08/2022 15:13

@Wallaw

Exactly, pointing to any specific regime and saying that's really bad, so whatever religion/ideology it belongs to is therefore bad is just a shit argument all round. Or more technically a hasty generalisation.

Stalin bad = atheism bad
Hitler bad = Christianity bad
Ferdinand and Isabella (Spanish inquisition) = Catholicism bad
Taliban = Islam bad

Whichever religion / ideology you find, you can get good and bad examples of all, so what does it prove, Diddly squat

@goherbie

How is it any more of a generalisation or shit argument than the original premise: loss of god in society = bad, when I could easily give you specifics in which god in society has not resulted in good?

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:18

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 15:14

@Malie

You are confusing communism with secular.

You do realize that some of the least religious country's aren't at this moment communist don't you. The Czech republic seems to be doing well for it's self.

The Czech Republic is not an atheist state to my knowledge.

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:16

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 15:14

@Malie

You are confusing communism with secular.

You do realize that some of the least religious country's aren't at this moment communist don't you. The Czech republic seems to be doing well for it's self.

Not at all. I am talking about societies where belief in God was illegal

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 15:14

@Malie

You are confusing communism with secular.

You do realize that some of the least religious country's aren't at this moment communist don't you. The Czech republic seems to be doing well for it's self.

goherbie · 29/08/2022 15:13

@Wallaw

Exactly, pointing to any specific regime and saying that's really bad, so whatever religion/ideology it belongs to is therefore bad is just a shit argument all round. Or more technically a hasty generalisation.

Stalin bad = atheism bad
Hitler bad = Christianity bad
Ferdinand and Isabella (Spanish inquisition) = Catholicism bad
Taliban = Islam bad

Whichever religion / ideology you find, you can get good and bad examples of all, so what does it prove, Diddly squat