Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Digita · 29/08/2022 17:11

@goherbie "However, the question is whether God is needed for morality. not whether all religions are susceptible to abuse / predators / power plays. That's a given, I think"

Yeah, it was a more nuanced point about a god or higher being capable of enforcing some sort of divine retribution, not organised religion that acts as a marketing firm for god(s) and is open to all sorts in the wrong hands.

@MarthaChuzzlewhit "It's time for a better idea than God. And in any case that concept has lost its power to make the masses behave themselves.
How about a belief in humanity? Wouldn't that be nice..."

That would be nice, but sadly unlikely. There's some magnetic about the 'God' concept - I think it's the not knowing. Fear plays a big part in using God to enforce morality - and fear is a big part of the 'not knowing' and 'unknowable'.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 17:10

Maybe the original sun worshippers had it right.

We're here because our planet occupies that sweet spot of not too close and not too far away from the sun.

Orbit worshiping perhaps.

Or better still accident of nature acknowledging, but I'm struggling with a marketing brief 😀

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 17:08

So many interesting ideas! I've not made it to the end of the thread yet, so hope I'm not being too repetitive!

Universal values are anything but. What we class as obvious moral truths are actually often based on religion.

In some cultures it was morally correct to abandon infants with disabilities on the hillside to die of exposure, ditto the elderly non productive members of the clan, to protect the clans future.

There's a Chinese morality tale praising the virtue of the woman who breast fed her elderly MiL and allowed her infant to starve, during a famine. She preserved the wisdom of the elder, I suppose, but it was told as an example of obedience and respect for elders.

I lived in Singapore for a while and the people's heroes televised included a child about 10 who physically disciplined her little brother by lashing him with her belt. She was seen as a responsible big sister helping her gran bring up her brother.

There is nothing universal about western values. Some cultures would say it's better to prioritise family success than be honest, for example. Lie and cheat if it means your family gets ahead.

It's lazy and dangerous to make assumptions about the drive to be ethical.

Jesus's words were truly radical, at the time. They are only mainstream now because of the success of Christianity.

BertieBotts · 29/08/2022 17:04

"The research suggests people don't do as they should but rather as they want. Human selfishness trumps the things that should happen."

See, I don't think this is quite right either. Yes motivation comes into it, but actually people do what is easy. A lot of people will do the right thing if you make it easy and not penalising for them to do it. One big problem is that society is set up so that helping others generally disadvantages individuals which discourages people from doing things like that. Conserving your own money/energy/time/resources looks like selfishness, but isn't it also sensible/what you need to do to survive?

"Should" is a really unhelpful concept in general IMO. Too loaded and everyone's ideas of morals are not the same.

And actually, I don't think children are feral without parental input either. In general, they seem to do quite well. Descent into bullying and "strongest wins" is IMO a reaction to punitive input by adults or learnt behaviour from the same.

I don't think fear of retribution by a god is any better as a technique than fear of punishment by authority, and we know that is only so effective. In general, I don't think discouraging/punishing misdemeanours is a good way to manage behaviour anyway. Enabling good behaviour, protection from the effects of wrongdoing, and helping people work through their problems is better. On a societal level, that means things like safety nets/welfare benefits, secure affordable housing, access to food/essentials, high quality education, accessible healthcare and mental healthcare, addiction support, high quality accessible social care. While some of these functions have been performed by religious organisations in the past, it's not the only possible source, governments for example could provide these things.

That is the way we should go as a society IMO, not relying on someone's idea/fear of a "god". People can have their beliefs in God or whatever but society should look after people.

MarthaChuzzlewhit · 29/08/2022 17:03

I actually believe that teaching children the concept of "hell" should be considered a form of child abuse.

MarthaChuzzlewhit · 29/08/2022 17:02

The universal principle ("do unto others") was not invented by religions, although they like to lay claim to it.

MarthaChuzzlewhit · 29/08/2022 17:00

It's time for a better idea than God. And in any case that concept has lost its power to make the masses behave themselves.
How about a belief in humanity? Wouldn't that be nice...

The universe is the only great power we need to believe in. Unfortunately for humanity, it is indifferent to us!

goherbie · 29/08/2022 16:56

@AlienatedChildGrown

Totally agree, although this type of abuse is not unique to religion. Predators will abuse any system to their benefit.... religion, the boy scouts, politics, Children’s homes, boarding schools even fame and charity work. (think jimmy saville). Likewise, misogyny can be found in all strains from religion, to schools, to the police... These things are not unique to religion.

However, the question is whether God is needed for morality. not whether all religions are susceptible to abuse / predators / power plays. That's a given, I think

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 16:55

@AryaStarkWolf

And of course celibacy was only introduced to stop wives having a claim on church assets.

Fuck all to do with piety.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 16:49

Another interesting debate over the years is, does the CC turn priests into paedophiles. I don't believe that's true. I think that priesthood gave paedophiles a ready outlet and would be an attractive career with easy access to children. Be shocked if any were even religious.

@AhNowTed Yeah that is an interesting debate, when I was younger I used to think it was the celibacy that turned them into paedophiles, now I think it's the other way round

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 16:44

@AlienatedChildGrown

Interesting post.

Lots of similarities between your experience and mine.

Parents didn't report. In most cases they didn't believe or want to believe their own children. Such was the power the church held over them, coupled by their own (wilful) ignorance.

Another interesting debate over the years is, does the CC turn priests into paedophiles. I don't believe that's true. I think that priesthood gave paedophiles a ready outlet and would be an attractive career with easy access to children. Be shocked if any were even religious.

LemonSwan · 29/08/2022 16:44

@ErrolTheDragon

Yes definitely superstition. But I class religion type stuff like hand on bible in the same sphere.

Also why I would never proclaim there’s not a god. Not worth the risk is it really 🤣

AlienatedChildGrown · 29/08/2022 16:20

goherbie · 29/08/2022 14:10

No I don't think it's unwise to lose the sense of God in society. It's hard to judge religion, because religion is always found in a cultural context that defines it.

However, if I were forced to pick a religion, on ethical grounds the religion I would argue teaches the kindest / nicest morality, to me is Buddhism. Whilst not being entirely atheistic, it does acknowledge the existence of gods, but considers them largely to be an irrelevance (see the Buddha's teaching of the poisoned arrow).

Of course, Buddhism is not without its issues too, the situation in Myanmar and the issue of female bhikkunis show that misogyny is alive and well in all cultures. But again, it is difficult to disentangle religion from culture.

But, simply put, to me the superiority of Buddhist ethics over Christian / Jewish / Muslim ethics amply shows that belief in God is not necessary for a sound ethical system.

You find the same issues in Buddhism that you do in Catholicism when it comes to the practice. No matter how the book or writings phrase it, some people find wriggle room for their own interpretation. And then, upon observing the reverence and authority of those further up in the hierarchy of the faith, set out to work their way up as a power play.

Men all over the world yearn to increase their opportunities to abuse small children, younger men and woman. It becomes enticing when the system you are in doesn’t like crappy PR so shuffles you off to a different church or temple, rather than report you to the authorities. An added bonus is the friction between following your faith as represented by its power holders and taking your case to the secular justice system. Which tends to curtail the number of victims’ parents who will choose reporting over acts of contrition and exhibiting forgiveness. Not to forget the nice touch of telling parents they or their little boy must have done something in a past life to have merited his abuse during his “baby monk” period.

Living in Bangkok, married to a Thai, living in a Thai household where everybody was a practising Buddhist was eye opening. Any impression I had that Buddhism was the nice, cuddly version of religion was knocked out of me, bit by bit over all the years. There are pleanty of lovely people who become monks. Probably the majority. But just like every other power structure it suffers from the issue of predators using it as a climbing frame to position themselves better to feed their ego and urges.

Same shit wherever you go. Regardless of the name (religious, cult-ish, secular) on top of the power structure, the self interested and malevolent will climb it & use it to their advantage.

ThinWomansBrain · 29/08/2022 16:11

& not believing in a God/Gods or organised religion does not render an individual with no sense of social justice.

ThinWomansBrain · 29/08/2022 16:09

Given the number of wars and disputes that seem to have religion as the key area of dispute, it doesn't seem the greatest of ideas.
Depending on the reference sourced, a quick google indicated that somewhere between 30 & 60& of UK poulation state they have no religion.
But you carry on believing whichever fairystories you choose entirely your right, as it is mine not to.

powershowerforanhour · 29/08/2022 16:02

So basically a massive, society-wide "Just you wait until your father gets home" type thing?

There are a lot of reasons to like religion- chiefly as most have some form of "love thy neighbour" and look after those less fortunate type ideas and many preach forgiveness, tolerance of difference etc- but god as ultimate bogeyman enforcer isn't really one of them.

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 16:02

If malie believes in god can she explain why they are so evil and disgusting such as 😊 giving my relatives cancer.

And don't come back with it's man's choice as that's pure crap. And if you come back with it's part of plan thats crap too.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 16:01

@DragonflyNights all 3,000 of them 😂

Rounddog · 29/08/2022 16:01

Buddhism seems to get a lot of better press than other religions/practices. I was in a number of Buddhist monasteries and they had very, very young children who were sent there by their families to live with stranger adult men. At 6 in the morning extremely young children were nodding off during puja while they were starting off their monk training. I do not believe that in time they won’t have the same abuse issues that other religions have experienced. The practice of sending children off to live in monasteries is not a healthy practice no matter what the religion is. Children should live with their parents if at all possible.

DragonflyNights · 29/08/2022 16:00

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:47

I’m a loss to your argument. The belief in God is fundamental to mankind. In societies with belief in God is repressed people still believe and in fact the church grows. You just seem to live in a world of fantasy. It’s very enough to have a worldview but to blame all the problems on the world on religion alone is just to hide your head in the sand without any regard for history whatsoever. Like a Marxist saying all the problems in the world are caused by capitalism. Of course religion has caused problems but anything can cause problems in the wrong hands. Science can cause problems in the wrong hands but we don’t stop doing science. To make sweeping statements he’s just to prove a lack of thought in the area.

Which God are you talking about that’s apparently fundamental to humankind?? One in particular or any of them?

Fairislefandango · 29/08/2022 15:59

Wouldn't that suggest the 'god(s)' were invented to enforce morality?

Yes, but they were invented by people. And they tend to enforce whatever the people in charge of the religion decide constitutes morality. This is not necessarily a good thing.

Imperfect though systems of government are, I'd rather depend on laws put in place by elected representatives to make people behave themselves than rules decided by whatever religious group happens to be dominant. If any particular branch of any particular religion can even be described as sufficiently dominant to represent much of the populus at a time when religion is massively on the wane.

I'm a staunch atheist. I'm not going to argue that there aren't any positive social aspects of having a shared, organised religion. Of course there are some. But to say you can't have a moral compass without religion is ridiculous. About as ridiculous as suggesting that having a religion means that all people of that religion have the same moral compass, or that even the ones who do have the same moral compass actually abide by it!

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:57

Willing to be proved wrong but where's all these lovely religious countries where there's no down-side?

Againstmachine · 29/08/2022 15:52

The Czech Republic is not an atheist state to my knowledge.

Except I didnt state it was but it's recognized as the least religious state in the world ahead of your darling north Korea.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:52

@Malie

"The belief in God is fundamental to mankind."

That's your OPINION and that's all it is.

Based on BLIND FAITH. Nothing more.

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:47

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 15:43

@Malie

AhNowTed
Oh here we go. The "if you don't like it leave" argument. Well done.

"Is the same as our dear old Cambridge spies who spied for the Soviets during the Cold War. When they actually were forced to live in dear old mother Russia they found it wasn’t quite the Utopia it had seemed from the U.K."

It's not the same though.

You seem to suggest that if I don't like something I should leave. I don't agree with this particular government, so should I leave?

Should Tories leave when Labour is in power.

Should Muslims leave a Christian country.

I'm at a loss as to your actual argument.

I’m a loss to your argument. The belief in God is fundamental to mankind. In societies with belief in God is repressed people still believe and in fact the church grows. You just seem to live in a world of fantasy. It’s very enough to have a worldview but to blame all the problems on the world on religion alone is just to hide your head in the sand without any regard for history whatsoever. Like a Marxist saying all the problems in the world are caused by capitalism. Of course religion has caused problems but anything can cause problems in the wrong hands. Science can cause problems in the wrong hands but we don’t stop doing science. To make sweeping statements he’s just to prove a lack of thought in the area.