Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Wallaw · 29/08/2022 18:33

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 17:36

Yes, prosperity gospel is shocking.

There are lots of abuses done in the name of religion, and abuses organised religions have failed to adequately challenge.

I find it interesting that people can be truly awful despite religion. So not only can an individual be awful, they can successfully corrupt an institution set up for 'good'.

I see some of the appalling things PPs have spoken about as evidence of the need for God, evidence of our ability to corrupt and be corrupted, and a failure of the churches rather than a result of them.

@picklemewalnuts
@AhNowTed

Yes, and these guys seem to fall from grace with some regularity. I'm American and find it horrifying. These are also the religions that spread hatred and divisiveness against anyone who is different in some way (particularly lgbtq populations) Their political influence is immense, always for candidates that oppose separation of church and state and who will therefore allow them to keep charitable status so as to not tax their prosperity.

I know a lot of atheists whose moral codes are considerably better than that.

Carpy88999 · 29/08/2022 18:33

I swear my oath to the flying spaghetti monster. His existence is also unknowable.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 18:32

@Digita

Please don't patronise me.

It may be hard for you to accept but billions of people do not believe in your god. Nor your blind faith.

For good reason.

I would absolutely defend your right to believe, but please, enough of the oh I'm sure you all have doubts. No, we don't.

Your god is as relevant to me a Santa Claus.

Flat04 · 29/08/2022 18:28

Digita · 29/08/2022 18:21

'What if' moments are healthy for general self-evaluation from time to time. Keeps everyone on their toes and questioning.

God's existence is unknowable.

Yeah, but inasmuch as it happens, it's sort of hedging your bets. Doesn't have much to do with morality as far as I can see - not that I'm saying people can't actually change for a variety of reasons, I believe they can.

And if belief in god keeps us moral out of fear, how do we reconcile that some believe in retributive god and some in benevolent god. And does benevolent god keep people in line as well as angry god?

NumptiesIncorporated · 29/08/2022 18:26

Horrific acts have been done both by religious people and in the name of religion.

Worshipping a god didn't stop paedophilia in the Catholic church, for example.

There are plenty of people that wouldn't do those things that have no belief in god.

Yabu.

Digita · 29/08/2022 18:23

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 18:12

@Digita

Honestly, staunch atheists don't have a "what if" moment, whether in the dock or otherwise.

It might comfort you to think that everyone has some unconscious faith, or occasional "what is there is" moments, we don't.

I read somewhere: "Whether you’re religious or not, or even if you just think about God from time to time, it’s almost impossible to avoid the question: Is God behind this pandemic that’s causing so much suffering in our world? One thing is for sure: you cannot believe in God without asking this question."

So, the 'what if' moments do happen and questioning is encouraged.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 18:23

Yeah, atheists really don't have that 'what if' thing...
And I'd take a bet that a lot of the witnesses saying the words of the oath rather than affirming are apatheists who don't really either. It's just part of the 'ceremony'.

Digita · 29/08/2022 18:21

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 18:12

@Digita

Honestly, staunch atheists don't have a "what if" moment, whether in the dock or otherwise.

It might comfort you to think that everyone has some unconscious faith, or occasional "what is there is" moments, we don't.

'What if' moments are healthy for general self-evaluation from time to time. Keeps everyone on their toes and questioning.

God's existence is unknowable.

OP posts:
AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 18:12

@Digita

Honestly, staunch atheists don't have a "what if" moment, whether in the dock or otherwise.

It might comfort you to think that everyone has some unconscious faith, or occasional "what is there is" moments, we don't.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 17:59

Digita · 29/08/2022 17:42

@TitoMojito "The higher power/deterrent in this situation is prosecution for perjury."

If only.

Isn't perjury challenging to prosecute? If so, it's sadly not the deterrent it should be. For example, the fallibility of human memory can be used as a defence.

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.”

If 'do you really want to risk a vengeful God coming after you?' works as an effective deterrent for perjury then it is what it is.

To all those who say 'oh but it wouldn't mean anything to me because I'm a staunch atheist', it would be interesting to see in practice. There's a lot of subconscious psychology that plays on people's guilt. The whole, 'but what if?'.

It’s not actually required to swear on the Bible. You can choose not to, and instead affirm that you will be honest.

I would say that not wanting to go to prison for perjury is a more effective motivator for honesty than swearing on a book that has no meaning to you. As for underlying psychology in regards to doubt , I imagine that would be likely to occur in those that have had religious belief/‘the fear of god’ instilled in them from childhood, as opposed to those of us who were never presented with religion as ‘truth’.

Huntswomanonthemove · 29/08/2022 17:47

Religion causes more problems for mankind, than anything else.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 17:46

@picklemewalnuts thank you for the terminology. Prosperity gospel, who knew!

A 2006 Times poll found that 17 percent of American Christians identify explicitly with the movement, while 31 percent espouse the idea that “if you give your money to God God will bless you with more money.” A full 61 percent agree with the more general idea that “God wants people to be prosperous.”

Kashmirsilver · 29/08/2022 17:45

ThinWomansBrain · 29/08/2022 16:11

& not believing in a God/Gods or organised religion does not render an individual with no sense of social justice.

Why?
Where do people think morality or a sense of social justice comes from?

Is it natural or supernatural?
The problem with these threads is they become a vehicle for passive-aggressive insults for those who have zero understanding of the fundamental concept of human value systems.

orbitalcrisis · 29/08/2022 17:44

@Malie USA. There are more people on prison in the US than in the whole rest of the world. 1in 1000 of those people identify as athirst, it's 1 in 100 in the general US population.

Nordic countries are by far the safest (most equal and happiest) and are also some of the least religious people in the world.

Digita · 29/08/2022 17:42

@TitoMojito "The higher power/deterrent in this situation is prosecution for perjury."

If only.

Isn't perjury challenging to prosecute? If so, it's sadly not the deterrent it should be. For example, the fallibility of human memory can be used as a defence.

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.”

If 'do you really want to risk a vengeful God coming after you?' works as an effective deterrent for perjury then it is what it is.

To all those who say 'oh but it wouldn't mean anything to me because I'm a staunch atheist', it would be interesting to see in practice. There's a lot of subconscious psychology that plays on people's guilt. The whole, 'but what if?'.

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 29/08/2022 17:41

Brefugee · 29/08/2022 13:54

The ‘historical abuse’ argument that gets trotted out on threads like these but seems like a smack in the face to people of faith who are actually doing really good things for others.

To be brutally honest? If the people who belong to those religions spent more time cleaning them up and holding the paedophiles and misogynists to account and getting rid of them (in the direction of the law) then I'd have more interest in hearing about their good works.

All those people who turn a blind eye to paedophile priests? and the mother & baby homes? I hope they rot in the hell they so clearly believe in. For eternity.

If it comes to taking an oath to tell the truth in court? well, we do know that even having sworn on a bible* people still commit perjury so I'm not sure what the point is. I am more inclined to believe someone who isn't known as a liar, say a schoolteacher of good repute, who doesn't swear on a holy book over, say, the person who does the church flowers and worships the ground a priest walks on (especially in the trial of said priest for child abuse). It's all swings and roundabouts.

*other religious tomes are available

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 17:38

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 17:08

So many interesting ideas! I've not made it to the end of the thread yet, so hope I'm not being too repetitive!

Universal values are anything but. What we class as obvious moral truths are actually often based on religion.

In some cultures it was morally correct to abandon infants with disabilities on the hillside to die of exposure, ditto the elderly non productive members of the clan, to protect the clans future.

There's a Chinese morality tale praising the virtue of the woman who breast fed her elderly MiL and allowed her infant to starve, during a famine. She preserved the wisdom of the elder, I suppose, but it was told as an example of obedience and respect for elders.

I lived in Singapore for a while and the people's heroes televised included a child about 10 who physically disciplined her little brother by lashing him with her belt. She was seen as a responsible big sister helping her gran bring up her brother.

There is nothing universal about western values. Some cultures would say it's better to prioritise family success than be honest, for example. Lie and cheat if it means your family gets ahead.

It's lazy and dangerous to make assumptions about the drive to be ethical.

Jesus's words were truly radical, at the time. They are only mainstream now because of the success of Christianity.

@NippyWoowoo ?

I think your moral values have been influenced by the teachings of religions. Perhaps not by the actions of religious institutions, but probably by the teachings themselves.

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 17:36

Yes, prosperity gospel is shocking.

There are lots of abuses done in the name of religion, and abuses organised religions have failed to adequately challenge.

I find it interesting that people can be truly awful despite religion. So not only can an individual be awful, they can successfully corrupt an institution set up for 'good'.

I see some of the appalling things PPs have spoken about as evidence of the need for God, evidence of our ability to corrupt and be corrupted, and a failure of the churches rather than a result of them.

NippyWoowoo · 29/08/2022 17:33

Do you think generations of faith-based communities may have influenced your moral compass?

No, HTH.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 17:31

I could never understand how the evangelical so-called preachers in America got away with it. Fleecing their poor congregations out of millions.

And then I worked in American and it was explained to me.

The con is basically the richer I am, the closer I am to god (he bestows me with wealth). So give to my church and you have a chance of getting closer to god and therefore he will bestow some wealth to you too.

These poor sods actually revel in the preacher riding around in his limo as proof positive that he's right.

It's a fucking totally immoral but highly successful plan.

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 17:26

"Modern Abrahamic religions were invented so the people in power could control, use and oppress society, especially the poor and uneducated, and women."

Christianity specifically subverts that! Jesus is born to an unmarried mother, welcomed first by shepherds, ministers directly to women... the early church managed to revert to patriarchy, but Jesus certainly didn't!

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 29/08/2022 17:17

"Faith" is often just a way of abdicating responsibility for your own actions/ decisions onto an unprovable higher power.
It give people licence to make bad choices in their lives without feeling the need to own them because "God will provide" or "it is His will".
It's dangerous stuff and the root of most of humanity's problems over the years.
The sooner we grow out of this stuff the better.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 17:14

Malie · 29/08/2022 15:04

well the former Soviet Bloc or Communist China? Trying to get you in touch with reality

—dislikes Stalin
—loves to suggest exiling unbelievers

Ironic.

It’s not a binary choice between a religious society and a totalitarian one. Not that religion itself hasn’t had its own issues with dictatorial tendencies.

feistyoneyouare · 29/08/2022 17:13

YANBU as far as I'm concerned, but it's a pity some pps aren't able to express dissent without sneering.

TiredzzZZ · 29/08/2022 17:11

I don't believe in any god. I'm a nice person though I think! I don't drink, do drugs etc... I am raising children to be kind. I work with offenders and in therapy with people on the verge of suicide. I'm soon to be a foster carer. I try and be a decent human (though sometimes get a bit cross on this anonymous forum, sorry).

I don't think we need to be religious to be nice decent humans. I have found that when working with people in crisis, a larger than might be expected number of my clients have been raised in v religious homes. They tend to have big guilt complexes and a fear of being 'bad'. It's anecdotal of course, but I think religion can be helpful, but also for some quite unhelpful and lead to notable.mental.heqlth difficulties.

I don't think religion is the answer to creating decent and empathic individuals. Sometimes religion can be a cloak to disguise quite evil behaviour actually. I think the answer is good parenting