Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
DogInATent · 29/08/2022 21:40

Having a belief in a higher power is neither a prerequisite or guarantor of moral behaviour.

Humanism and forms of spiritual atheism have frameworks for ethics and morals that don't require a higher power to hang them from.

Digita · 29/08/2022 21:38

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 21:13

The major religions seem to have so much focus on maleness that I have turned to the feminine divine just to even up the balance. I have a few favourite goddesses who are not bothered about worship, they just like to be brought into the world and made alive. I do this by loving them and honouring them with actions like feeding birds, watering plants or laughing. It's delightfully easy and comforting for me, though wouldn't expect others to understand. I do find all the macho god stuff quite boring.

That sounds delightful. May ask which goddesses?

OP posts:
Digita · 29/08/2022 21:28

TerrysGotPeeves · 29/08/2022 20:56

Love your username, @AhNowTed . I'm also Irish, and the notion of 'not having engaged with God in any meaningful way' is indeed laughable. I went to a Catholic school, 'religion' was taught every day, we had First Confession at age 6, First Communion shortly after, and Confirmation at 12. We had regular school masses. Then secondary school was the parish priest visiting regularly, nuns chastising us for talking to boys, mass and confession (which we were absolutely made to do) at the end of every term.

I was brought to mass every week, I've been taught the songs (did you have to learn the one about Zaccheus? 😂). I've even met a Pope. Still not religious after 13 years of Catholic education and indoctrination.

You have both conflated God and Religion. They are not the same thing.

It sounds like you've engaged with the Catholic religion (one of many religions) and ticked the boxes. That's not the same as engaging with God in a meaningful way, necessarily.

"Religions are human institutions that, at their best, help people to experience and be close to God. However, the relationship between a religion and God is like the relationship between a radio and music. Just because you don't have one does not mean that you can't experience the other." - Reb Jeff

OP posts:
Zombiemum1946 · 29/08/2022 21:15

Oh and religions are largely used for the subjugation of women and girls so is this really the forum to push any particular form of god bothering?

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 21:13

The major religions seem to have so much focus on maleness that I have turned to the feminine divine just to even up the balance. I have a few favourite goddesses who are not bothered about worship, they just like to be brought into the world and made alive. I do this by loving them and honouring them with actions like feeding birds, watering plants or laughing. It's delightfully easy and comforting for me, though wouldn't expect others to understand. I do find all the macho god stuff quite boring.

1dayatatime · 29/08/2022 21:11

The way I see it is:

Before there was established religions (by this I mean the main ones Christianity, Hinduism, Islam Judaism etc etc) the was "beliefs" such as was practiced in nomadic tribes etc. The problem with "beliefs" was that there was no standard text or reference document on what was right or wrong, decent or indecent, kind or unkind, respecting or disrespecting others.

So there developed a need to show / scare the good folk of the Middle Ages to live in a right, decent and kind way ( with varying degrees of success).

Now that the basic concept from religion of how we should live our lives in a decent, kind and respectful manner has been established for the last say 100 years there has been a decrease in the last day 50 years of people declaring no religion or feeling that they don't need the concept of an invisible being up in the sky telling them what is right or wrong.

The problem though with this approach is that without a standard text or reference document from a religion on what is right or wrong, then what is right or wrong is open to interpretation by each individual. And we see these different interpretations on AIBU all the time. The issue is that what is right or wrong becomes more fragmented over time with an incentive for a race to the bottom. For example Robin Hood still gets sympathy because he only stole from the rich (despite this still being theft) and let's not forget Robin got to decide who was "rich".

So in short I do still see a need for religion(s) today to give a standard moral direction and although some may say they will decide what is right or wrong the problem is what they view as right or wrong is not the same as what a wider functioning society needs as right or wrong.

Zombiemum1946 · 29/08/2022 21:10

Victims of abuse by the religious self righteous would beg to differ.

pointythings · 29/08/2022 21:06

@Malie I would have to disagree with that professor, and I am definitely an atheist. Just goes to show we are all individuals with our own take on belief!

I suspect there is a lot of overlap between 'the Christian life' and the 'Muslim/Hindu/Buddhist/Jewish life'. You could even include the Pagan life, given the first tenet of the Pagan faith is 'do no harm'.

Brefugee · 29/08/2022 21:05

So, if there is a God then you wouldn't know anyway because you don't appraise or engage with the possibility in any meaningful way.
Tis folly to be wise when ignorance is bliss.

I've read a lot of patronising piffle in my time (I studied Philosophy so you're up against it here) but this takes the cake, tbh.

It is typical of religion to move the goal posts, pretty much like OP is doing on this thread. Just a lot of words and then "ah, but god* is unknowable"

*goddesses are available

Fairislefandango · 29/08/2022 21:01

If 'do you really want to risk a vengeful God coming after you?' works as an effective deterrent for perjury then it is what it is.

To all those who say 'oh but it wouldn't mean anything to me because I'm a staunch atheist', it would be interesting to see in practice. There's a lot of subconscious psychology that plays on people's guilt. The whole, 'but what if?'.

This is nonsense. Even plenty of people who do believe in god manage to commit all kinds of crimes and atrocities, so what makes you think that a vague, fleeting 'what if there's a vengeful god?' moment would be enough to deter the few atheists who'd have those moments from doing something bad?

I can honestly say that if I were for some reason contemplating committing some terrible crime, my fears would be of the law, the actual consequences of my actions for myself and others, the judgment of people I know, and to a lesser extent of people I don't know. The possibility of the existence of deities wouldn't even enter my mind! But all of those other fears are a pretty good deterrent.

Malie · 29/08/2022 21:01

pointythings · 29/08/2022 20:39

God is not necessary for any rational hypothesis if you take a completely materialistic worldview with life having no ultimate meaning. If you go deeper then it is unsatisfying.

I'm not at all sure I understand what you mean here. When you refer to life having 'ultimate meaning' do you mean the soul and an afterlife? Because all lives have ultimate meaning, god or no god. We all leave something of ourselves behind - the consequences of all the choices we made and actions we took, the lessons we learned. That isn't materialistic, and knowing that you did what you could to make the world a better place isn't unsatisfying. Are you saying that it is impossible to go 'deeper' without believing in a god?

The purpose of the Christian life certainly is not ‘going to heaven’. That is mediaeval theology. I recently heard an atheist professor say, ‘Life has no meaning whatever.’ That was honest given her worldview. It is also the worldview of the naturalist Ecclesiastes 1

TerrysGotPeeves · 29/08/2022 20:56

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 18:54

@Digita

I'm starting to get quite annoyed.

You continue to assert that we "haven't engaged with god in any meaningful way", and therefore haven't fully explored the possibility there is one.

Let me say this again.

I was born and raised in Ireland. Then a deeply religious country.

The country was run by the Catholic Church. Schools, health and state.

I have had plenty of time to engage with god in a meaningful way.

I am 57. Have had much heartache and tragedy. The kind of things that would have one wanting to believe.

I don't believe in your god.

I don't need your god to either give meaning to my life or give it purpose.

Your god story is ridiculously fantastical.

There is not a shred of proof.

Even priests call it blind faith.

YOU even said god is unknowable.

A book and a label doesn't make it any more knowable.

Love your username, @AhNowTed . I'm also Irish, and the notion of 'not having engaged with God in any meaningful way' is indeed laughable. I went to a Catholic school, 'religion' was taught every day, we had First Confession at age 6, First Communion shortly after, and Confirmation at 12. We had regular school masses. Then secondary school was the parish priest visiting regularly, nuns chastising us for talking to boys, mass and confession (which we were absolutely made to do) at the end of every term.

I was brought to mass every week, I've been taught the songs (did you have to learn the one about Zaccheus? 😂). I've even met a Pope. Still not religious after 13 years of Catholic education and indoctrination.

Digita · 29/08/2022 20:47

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 29/08/2022 20:05

If a god's existence is unknowable then surely by extension it's will must also be unknowable?

If it's will is unknowable then why would think your religion is the correct religion?

I don't know if I consider myself to have a religion. Like Pi in 'Life of Pi', I found a few fits, but not one size fits all.

Thinking of something more, call it god or gods, as 'unknowable' is about recognising it's too big and I have limitations as a human. I meditate, for instance, to connect with the unknowable, and I feel it's essential for transcendence; one day, I will die, but I'd like to have invested in my spiritual well-being for when that day comes. Death is unknowable too, but we still know it death happens. Meditating on death has been helpful in dealing with the unknowable and being mindful.

"Knowing the Unknowable God: How Faith Thrives on Divine Mystery" by James R. Lucas

OP posts:
Bretonbear · 29/08/2022 20:44

I don't need an imaginary being to guide me as to what is right and wrong.

pointythings · 29/08/2022 20:39

God is not necessary for any rational hypothesis if you take a completely materialistic worldview with life having no ultimate meaning. If you go deeper then it is unsatisfying.

I'm not at all sure I understand what you mean here. When you refer to life having 'ultimate meaning' do you mean the soul and an afterlife? Because all lives have ultimate meaning, god or no god. We all leave something of ourselves behind - the consequences of all the choices we made and actions we took, the lessons we learned. That isn't materialistic, and knowing that you did what you could to make the world a better place isn't unsatisfying. Are you saying that it is impossible to go 'deeper' without believing in a god?

Hawkins001 · 29/08/2022 20:33

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:25

What is your reasoning for considering him a mythic being?

Because a being would have form, structure, dna, molecules, ect, a living breathing being, basically like Q, beings from star trek. That to me would be god, like beings, with extraordinary abilities.

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:32

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 19:31

So, if there is a God then you wouldn't know anyway because you don't appraise or engage with the possibility in any meaningful way.

Tis folly to be wise when ignorance is bliss.

In my case, it would be more accurate to have said that I don't have any 'what ifs' any more. Because I was raised in a Christian family, and was a convinced believer into my early 20s. You are in fact, completely and utterly wrong in your glib assertion, appraising and engaging was exactly what I did. My 'what ifs' were 'what if there isn't a God, after all", I suppose. And the conclusion was that everything then made a lot more sense. God was not necessary for any rational hypothesis.

God is not necessary for any rational hypothesis if you take a completely materialistic worldview with life having no ultimate meaning. If you go deeper then it is unsatisfying.

Digita · 29/08/2022 20:26

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 19:31

So, if there is a God then you wouldn't know anyway because you don't appraise or engage with the possibility in any meaningful way.

Tis folly to be wise when ignorance is bliss.

In my case, it would be more accurate to have said that I don't have any 'what ifs' any more. Because I was raised in a Christian family, and was a convinced believer into my early 20s. You are in fact, completely and utterly wrong in your glib assertion, appraising and engaging was exactly what I did. My 'what ifs' were 'what if there isn't a God, after all", I suppose. And the conclusion was that everything then made a lot more sense. God was not necessary for any rational hypothesis.

Thanks for sharing your experience.

Did you have 'what if' appraisal moments with just Christianity or other faith possibilities too?

OP posts:
Malie · 29/08/2022 20:25

Hawkins001 · 29/08/2022 20:15

How and what is your evidence and reasoning for a mythic being ?

What is your reasoning for considering him a mythic being?

AlienatedChildGrown · 29/08/2022 20:24

goherbie · 29/08/2022 16:56

@AlienatedChildGrown

Totally agree, although this type of abuse is not unique to religion. Predators will abuse any system to their benefit.... religion, the boy scouts, politics, Children’s homes, boarding schools even fame and charity work. (think jimmy saville). Likewise, misogyny can be found in all strains from religion, to schools, to the police... These things are not unique to religion.

However, the question is whether God is needed for morality. not whether all religions are susceptible to abuse / predators / power plays. That's a given, I think

I agree. Removing religion (and therefore both its hierarchy and access to the more vulnerable) merely creates a void. One that doesn’t stay unfilled. New names, new ideologies, new Though Leaders, new willing minions who love a bit of pitchforks, new yelling of “burn heretic”.

And a brand new, evolving hierarchy for predators to climb. Being new it will have even less capacity to weed out the more obvious ones that try to worm their way up. Being new they won’t have the long, ugly history of cover ups revealed. So will probably try their own versions of “controlling the narrative” at the cost of the victims. While the young and vulnerable collateral damage piles high.

Hawkins001 · 29/08/2022 20:16

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:11

Just look through your post and see the numbers of unprovable assumptions you have just made based entirely from your own worldview, many of which do not exist in other societies

I would.say @pointythings , that's quite a good analysis

Hawkins001 · 29/08/2022 20:15

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:08

We get our evidence from reason. I believe in God because I use the same reason

How and what is your evidence and reasoning for a mythic being ?

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:11

pointythings · 29/08/2022 20:07

@Malie of course religion isn't responsible for all the world's ills. Neither is secularism or atheism. I think the problem is with authoritarianism, where freedom to think, question and speak out is not permitted. That happens in dictatorships like China and North Korea, but it also happens in organised religions. And of course in Russia, the Russian Orthodox Church is hand in hand with Putin, so they get it from both sides.

But back to the thread - is belief in God essential for a functioning society? I think it isn't. I think the things that we perceive as 'good' and assign to religion - things like common laws that keep society ticking over, people taking care of each other - are about the survival of people as a species, so more an evolutionary driver. The majority of people don't want to break down the society they live in, so obey the law.

Just look through your post and see the numbers of unprovable assumptions you have just made based entirely from your own worldview, many of which do not exist in other societies

pointythings · 29/08/2022 20:08

@Digita I couldn't care less about god when I make my decisions about how I live my life. I follow my conscience. Not lying, cheating, stealing, killing etc. is actually pretty easy to do, no deity required.

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:08

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 19:50

What we know about the stars comes from humans too but you’re not seriously suggesting that humans created the stars are you

What was I saying upthread about some people not understanding evidence....

We get our evidence from reason. I believe in God because I use the same reason