Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
Digita · 29/08/2022 22:31

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 22:15

Do you think science offers a moral compass of what's right or wrong?

No, that's not what science is about. You want the ethics department for that.
Of course, in western universities and many other institutions, the two work together.

Are you aware that the early scientists had faith?

Sure, some did - and some didn't.

No, I'm aware that's not what science is about. The poster suggested that a belief in science replaces anything faith-based, which is why I asked the question.

Ethics department: again, the question about enforcement that's troubling. If ethics are not enforceable, then they will be ignored.

Ben Goldacre had a lot to say about how unethical big pharma is and the challenges of enforcement when there's big money involved.

"Throughout Bad Pharma, we learn how those in positions of power have failed us. Universities, ethics committees, regulators, journal editors and government bodies alike have all recognised and promised to rectify the deceitful nature of the pharmaceutical industry, yet prospective follow-up procedures have often revealed non-compliance. So who are doctors and patients supposed to trust, if these once-trusted gatekeepers are found to be corrupt? If previous solutions have involved empty assurances and continued unaccountability, what else is there to do?" - warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/iatl/reinvention/archive/volume6issue2/lisinger/

That's where a godless society gets worrying IMO.

OP posts:
Isitsixoclockalready · 29/08/2022 22:21

Digita · 29/08/2022 22:11

Do you think science offers a moral compass of what's right or wrong?

Are you aware that the early scientists had faith? Faith there was a law-giver (a god or whatever) drove the scientists to believe they would find laws in nature. (here's a Wikipedia page all about it: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_atheism)

So, maybe you have "ancient hearsay" to thank for scientific progression?

Also, beware of scientism.

Science is different to religion in that it isn't based on an opinion or a want or desire that something should be the way that we want it, it's an observation on what is actually happening and as such is obviously fluid and subject to change based on further evidence as it comes in. In theory, science doesn't reject the idea of a creator but there is nothing in the way of data to give credence to it as a tangible hypothesis. I don't choose not to believe in a higher power because I don't wish to - there is just nothing there to give any genuine basis to it. Now, I'm not here to persuade anyone that they're wrong. I can't do anything about my lack of belief and if people find that religion gives them a purpose in life - why not?

Digita · 29/08/2022 22:21

Ponderingwindow · 29/08/2022 22:14

I don’t trust people who need an external moral compass. The instinct to not cause pain or harm to another is innate.

I'm not convinced that 'not causing pain or harm' is as innate as you think. The instinct of self-preservation is innate and can cause pain or harm because it's about selfishness and the survival of oneself over others.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 22:15

Do you think science offers a moral compass of what's right or wrong?

No, that's not what science is about. You want the ethics department for that.
Of course, in western universities and many other institutions, the two work together.

Are you aware that the early scientists had faith?

Sure, some did - and some didn't.

ddl1 · 29/08/2022 22:15

Do you think science offers a moral compass of what's right or wrong?

No. That's not its purpose. Not sure that religion does either, however.

Ponderingwindow · 29/08/2022 22:14

I don’t trust people who need an external moral compass. The instinct to not cause pain or harm to another is innate.

Wallaw · 29/08/2022 22:11

Digita · 29/08/2022 21:28

You have both conflated God and Religion. They are not the same thing.

It sounds like you've engaged with the Catholic religion (one of many religions) and ticked the boxes. That's not the same as engaging with God in a meaningful way, necessarily.

"Religions are human institutions that, at their best, help people to experience and be close to God. However, the relationship between a religion and God is like the relationship between a radio and music. Just because you don't have one does not mean that you can't experience the other." - Reb Jeff

That's a silly argument, @Digita.

The philosophical discussion (does losing God in society create problems) is based entirely around a supposition that has already conflated God and religion. The God we're discussing as a vengeful, judgmental entity used to keep people on the straight and narrow is an invention of religion.

Digita · 29/08/2022 22:11

girlfriend44 · 29/08/2022 21:48

Absolutely this.
I also believe in scientifically proven fact and not ancient hearsay.

Do you think science offers a moral compass of what's right or wrong?

Are you aware that the early scientists had faith? Faith there was a law-giver (a god or whatever) drove the scientists to believe they would find laws in nature. (here's a Wikipedia page all about it: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_atheism)

So, maybe you have "ancient hearsay" to thank for scientific progression?

Also, beware of scientism.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 22:09

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 29/08/2022 21:50

Another thread where the flying monkeys from the National Secular Society are out in force.
It seems strange that so many posters are keen to berate both religion(s) and anyone who chooses to follow one.
If we choose to believe in "an imaginary sky fairy", "an invisible friend" why not leave us to our "delusions" instead of having 13 pages of posts about it ??

This is an AIBU thread, posing the question '(am I being unreasonable) To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society? '. It's an open invitation to debate.

What a very odd (and rude) take on the responses.

Fairislefandango · 29/08/2022 22:09

It seems strange that so many posters are keen to berate both religion(s) and anyone who chooses to follow one.
If we choose to believe in "an imaginary sky fairy", "an invisible friend" why not leave us to our "delusions" instead of having 13 pages of posts about it ??

If people were starting threads just to harangue religious people about sky fairies you might have a point. As it is, people are responding to what the OP asked about.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 22:07

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 29/08/2022 21:50

Another thread where the flying monkeys from the National Secular Society are out in force.
It seems strange that so many posters are keen to berate both religion(s) and anyone who chooses to follow one.
If we choose to believe in "an imaginary sky fairy", "an invisible friend" why not leave us to our "delusions" instead of having 13 pages of posts about it ??

When you ask a question about religion to invite debate, it’s not particularly unusual for secularists to respond. Nor is it unusual for the religious to respond, and, apparently, the North Korean Tourism board.

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 22:04

Right, I get that @AhNowTed . And you've been really measured in your comments.
It's when people tell me what my god did, what s/he's like, etc that it's frustrating- I can't have a sensible conversation with someone who's telling me incorrectly what I believe, and disproving or condemning what they think I believe in, when it's nothing of the kind.

Like, for example, 'your god would rather force a teenager to give birth to a rapists child than allow her an abortion'. 'Your god hates gays'.
Ok, some people may believe variations of that but it's not the norm among people in English churches.

Isitsixoclockalready · 29/08/2022 22:02

Malie · 29/08/2022 20:32

God is not necessary for any rational hypothesis if you take a completely materialistic worldview with life having no ultimate meaning. If you go deeper then it is unsatisfying.

For me personally, life is what one makes of it. I'm not materialistic - my pleasures are relatively simple ones and I'm not religious. As far as I'm concerned, there was no particular reason for being here - that's not a big deal. In fact, I feel like not being overly concerned about some big meaning or purpose makes me less materialistic. That being said, if people find that religion helps them find a purpose in life and they need that then there's no harm.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 22:01

You know, whenever you talk about "Your God...", you are almost inevitably going to be wrong.

You simply can't know how the other person conceives God. All you are ever doing is refuting your own idea of who the other person belives in.

Well, yes... Because it (he, she, they) really are 'your god'.

pointythings · 29/08/2022 22:00

@Thesefeetaremadeforwalking there are no secular flying monkeys on this thread, just real human beings pointing out that you don't need gods to have a functioning society. You're free to disagree with that but please don't accuse us of having been sent by any organisation.

Apl · 29/08/2022 21:57

Go watch the Netflix documentary “Keep Sweet” and see how the fear of god kept women handing over girls to paedophiles for decades.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 21:57

@picklemewalnuts

I say "your god" to allow for any god. I'm not judging which particular flavour of god anyone believes in.

If I was to say just God, I'd be accused of referring to a particular god, ie a Christian one.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2022 21:56

Bretonbear · 29/08/2022 20:44

I don't need an imaginary being to guide me as to what is right and wrong.

No, and I don't need one to give my life 'ultimate meaning' either.

picklemewalnuts · 29/08/2022 21:53

You know, whenever you talk about "Your God...", you are almost inevitably going to be wrong.

You simply can't know how the other person conceives God. All you are ever doing is refuting your own idea of who the other person belives in.

The number of times people on here have accused me of believing in this, that or the other that bears no relation to my faith.

I'm truly sorry for all the awful experiences people have had at the hands of organised religion, or abusive families who happen to be religious.
That's not the God I know. Jesus told us not to judge, and to love each other as well as we love ourselves. If anything bad happened to you, then it was not in the name of Jesus despite what the perpetrator might claim.
I'm sickened by the abuses of the church in the past. I'm hovering on the edge at the moment, deciding whether to leave or whether to stay and work from within. The safeguarding requirements are pretty stringent these days. I don't think we'd be as easy a target for predators as we were.

BorisJohnsonsHair · 29/08/2022 21:52

I think religion causes far more poverty, war and oppression than anything else. Ridiculous nonsense to keep people in their place.

It has no place in today's society.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 29/08/2022 21:50

Another thread where the flying monkeys from the National Secular Society are out in force.
It seems strange that so many posters are keen to berate both religion(s) and anyone who chooses to follow one.
If we choose to believe in "an imaginary sky fairy", "an invisible friend" why not leave us to our "delusions" instead of having 13 pages of posts about it ??

girlfriend44 · 29/08/2022 21:48

Vonniee7 · 29/08/2022 12:22

YABU. I don't believe in god but still have a moral compass and can tell right from wrong.

Absolutely this.
I also believe in scientifically proven fact and not ancient hearsay.

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 21:42

No not Catholic.

And Irish people know all about god, we've had it up to here.

You can keep quoting, it means nothing.

Your god is a fairy story based on faith. There is not a single shred of evidence.

But carry on arguing over semantics if it makes you happy.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 21:41

@Digita I'm on Isis, Sekhmet and Kuan Yin at the mo, but that could change.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 29/08/2022 21:40

People can develop a sense of morality without the threat of punishment upon death by a not proven God.