Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

643 replies

Digita · 29/08/2022 12:13

To think it’s unwise to lose the idea of God(s) in society?

Whenever I hear people arguing why faith in any sort of higher being is 'stupid' or 'delusional' I wonder if they've thought through the wider implications of a godless society. It might not be all that it's cracked up to be... the idea of higher beings might be invented but invented for a reason too. Is there a need for a philosophical concept of something more for accountability, law and order?

“Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage.” Why swear on a Bible? The Courts have kept swearing an oath on religious texts because there’s still a psychological, moral force behind it.

"Co-operation is a key component in human interaction and also, according to new research from the University of British Columbia, the spread of civilisation. Not because for any altruistic reason, though; instead it might be directly down to a fear of a vengeful god." Fear of punitive gods linked to rise of human civilisation’

‘A new study published in the journal, Nature, tests the theory that communities are fair and cooperate with outsiders because of the fear of divine retribution.’ ‘Moralistic gods, supernatural punishment and the expansion of human sociality’

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 11:14

That's not the sort of understanding of 'truth' that has any place in the criminal justice system, except perhaps for considerations of intent

I should have said 'that should have any place in the criminal justice system'.

The course you mention may be interesting but I'm not too convinced by the part you quoted. “the gods have a sense of justice that cannot be understood by any individual” .... that really doesn't sound like a good thing. More an excuse for arbitrary laws convenient to the powerful.

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 11:14

I do indeed understand how percentages and statistics work, thanks for the patronising bollocks though.
It is very simple: of the number of people who have voted - who may or may not be arsed to write on this thread - the vast majority have picked the YABU option.

It is there in front of everyone's eyes.

Digita · 30/08/2022 11:14

@Brefugee Silencing discussion is not how you're going to combat anything faith-based. Philosophical discussion ought to open up ideas and understanding - on all sides.

Also, the religious stuff you don't like seems to be deeply entangled with the justice and legal system that governs society, so it is what it is. That's kinda how the OP came about. If the studies suggest that 'fear' of gods (as opposed to favours) was useful to forming human civilisations (law, order etc. that characterise 'civilisation'), it begs the question of what society would lose without the concept of 'gods'. www.ox.ac.uk/news/2016-02-11-fear-divine-retribution-linked-spread-human-civilisations

Recommended course: Susan Sage Heinzelman’s “Representing Justice: Stories of Law and Literature”

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 11:08

For some reason I can't vote, the buttons appear for a moment when I load the page in the browser and then disappear again, so you're missing a YABU from me. I thought the 'you have one vote' just means each poster can only vote once?

Digita · 30/08/2022 10:58

@Brefugee "so, OP, you can see the vote and now you're calling it lies?"

Are you saying one vote (in total) is an adequate sample of votes to represent 16 pages worth of responses?

🤔

Do you understand how statistics and percentages work?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 30/08/2022 10:54

so, OP, you can see the vote and now you're calling it lies?
And you wonder why agnostics and atheists are rolling their eyes at you?

Again: keep your religion to yourself and we'll all rub along just fine. Try to put it in my way? We're going to have a problem.

(also for those who think the UK politics is not as bad, for religious fervour, as the US - your time will come. You only have to look at people like Rees-Mogg to see where it's going. And all that guff about how Theresa May was the daughter of a vicar so obvs very kind and caring. Well, i don't know about her personal religion, but she was a deeply divisive and cruel prime minister)

Digita · 30/08/2022 10:50

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps "No wonder the YABU % is so high!"

Mumsnet stats tell me: "You have one vote. All votes are anonymous."

So, that might explain the high YABU percentage.

"Lies, damned lies and statistics".

I genuinely wanted a discussion. The philosophy/religion section is quiet, whilst AIBU has more traffic and is more likely to get a general population response. I'm interested in what real people think and feel. These topics can be a charged issue, but that's not a reason to shy away from the discussion.

OP posts:
WhereshouldIgo · 30/08/2022 10:44

Given that most people in this country do not have a faith that regularly compels them to church/ mosque/ temple then I think that your theory is BS.
it’s not faith or fear of god that prevents most people from stealing, killing etc.

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 10:43

Well, not so much in the UK. We are not the USA.

not old enough to remember the Tories as the party of the family and Cecil Parkinson? Sure it happens in the UK. Boris flipping Johnson FGS

AryaStarkWolf · 30/08/2022 10:43

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 18:54

@Digita

I'm starting to get quite annoyed.

You continue to assert that we "haven't engaged with god in any meaningful way", and therefore haven't fully explored the possibility there is one.

Let me say this again.

I was born and raised in Ireland. Then a deeply religious country.

The country was run by the Catholic Church. Schools, health and state.

I have had plenty of time to engage with god in a meaningful way.

I am 57. Have had much heartache and tragedy. The kind of things that would have one wanting to believe.

I don't believe in your god.

I don't need your god to either give meaning to my life or give it purpose.

Your god story is ridiculously fantastical.

There is not a shred of proof.

Even priests call it blind faith.

YOU even said god is unknowable.

A book and a label doesn't make it any more knowable.

Yep. 100% (also Irish here, grew up indoctrinated through school & state etc)

Just to add, not one single time during the Pandemic did I question whether god started it, fucks sake, that was ALL us

Brefugee · 30/08/2022 10:40

My concern for a godless state is that it could quickly become lawless too

(too much wall of text, i read this far and am losing the will to live)

There is ZERO evidence that a "godless" state could become lawless. Why do you think that? Yet again we have to come back to this: we don't need a religious text to tell us how to behave. We have laws for that. Now some of them are the same as in religious texts because - hey, who would have thought it! - religion used to be a way of keeping people in check. So not killing, stealing and all that - for sure there is an overlap. There is zero reason to ban things like eating shellfish and dairy in the same meal now - although when those rules were thought up in a hot country without refrigeration, sure they made a lot of sense (not wasting medical resources unnecessarily, for example)

Studies of small children show that they are very much invested in fairness and sharing. That is human nature as a social animal. How do ants do it? Or is there a great formicary in the sky and an actual Ant Goddess?

Again: your religion is your own personal business. Pretty much like other freedoms your ability to enjoy that ends where it impinges on other people's lives. Sure if you think you're going to turn into a whirling dervish of rape, murder and pillage if you don't follow the tenets of a religion, go for it. The rest of us, not so much

Digita · 30/08/2022 10:37

ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 09:31

"There is no inherent conflict between religion and science, she argues, as they are separate magisteria concerned with separate questions. There is more than one kind of truth - science arrives at one while art, literature, and religion arrive at another.

There are certainly different domains of knowledge and experience. However, the 'truths', and the means of finding them, are different. Objective, verifiable (or falsifiable) versus subjective. The 'truth' of one religion (or small branch thereof) is the heresy of another. That's not the sort of understanding of 'truth' that has any place in the criminal justice system, except perhaps for considerations of intent.

Are you sure that’s true of the justice system?

In Susan Sage Heinzelman’s course “Representing Justice: Stories of Law and Literature”, she states something I found thought-provoking:

“One of the points of the course is to break down the stereotypical definition of literature as ‘fictive and subjective’ (and therefore primarily emotionally persuasive) and law as ‘factual and objective’ (and therefore primarily intellectually persuasive). Aligned with these stereotypical expectations is the assumption that literature is the realm of the feminine, and law, that of the masculine. This course should unsettle those assumptions and suggest how deeply and inextricably intertwined these two discourses are.”

The first few lectures focus on how the criminal justice and legal systems were formed. God(s) are intrinsically linked to Justice (possibly explains why Lady Justice, the Goddes Themis, continues to be a symbol for the courts). E.g. “the gods have a sense of justice that cannot be understood by any individual” (in one of the texts). “The concept of justice, personified in the figure of Dike, daughter of Zeus and Themis, is finally a suprahuman concept”.

Really interesting course btw.

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 30/08/2022 10:36

AhNowTed · 29/08/2022 16:55

@AryaStarkWolf

And of course celibacy was only introduced to stop wives having a claim on church assets.

Fuck all to do with piety.

Yep. Corrupt to it's core

Hyacinth2 · 30/08/2022 10:04

I expect people are goady as they are so outnumbered, tsaoist (?sp), buddhist, Christian and it's various forms, Jewish, Hinduism and its various forms, muslim and its various forms, Mormon etc
Seems humans needed a higher being so that's how it is.

Winederlust · 30/08/2022 10:04

UWhatNow · 29/08/2022 12:29

“I am not so sure about organised religion though. It seems to be open to abuse-historically and contemporarily- and has caused/causes so much conflict.”

I hear this a lot about ‘religion’ and I don’t disagree but you must balance this with much of the charity and outreach work done by all religious denominations such as food banks, Langars, charity donations, third world aid programmes, visiting elderly and sick, youth mentoring, homelessness charities etc. Much of this is faith led. I know lots of Christians who quietly give their time, money and energy to serving others - sometimes locally on a small level that nobody would really notice but means a lot to the people they help.

The ‘historical abuse’ argument that gets trotted out on threads like these but seems like a smack in the face to people of faith who are actually doing really good things for others.

You don't have to have religious faith to do any of those things though, you just need to be a nice, decent person. If these people didn't have faith would they still do such charity and outreach work? That's the test, not whether they follow a religion or not.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 30/08/2022 09:51

If they think there's no god, then there's no fear of divine retribution either. So, anything goes.

That's a bit of a leap, isn't it?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 30/08/2022 09:50

I've got no problem with people believing in their God and I must have get admit I get really rankled and pissed off with people saying the 'sky fairy' and 'imaginary friend in the sky blah blah blah.' It's so fucking rude, so just STOP that already,

Most people I know who are Christians. genuinely don't really care what anyone else thinks, as it's your opinion if you want to think it's an imaginary friend in the sky. But to berate peoples religion like this is quite nasty. Anyway, I digress.

The problem is @Digita that although there is no problem with anybody having a deep faith, (indeed it just bring a lot of comfort to people,) I think posting stuff like you posted on here is going to drive the atheists and the haters of religion (and the people who disbelieve in it,) even further away, as there is a lot of preaching here - really really bad preaching here. And all the links and telling people what's what. No wonder the YABU % is so high! Basically saying 'if you're not a good iccle girl u goin' to hell.' Just stop with that.

I have noticed children from religious families are very well behaved/do better at school etc, but also some of them end up rebelling against society, no longer being the 'good kid they were' and absolutely HATING religion when they're older.

I'm a Christian and my husband is an atheist and we rub along brilliantly ... He's got fantastic respect for my religion and he loves to hear about what's been going on at church etc, and I have no problem with him being an atheist ... Indeed if I ever had another man (if my DH he died or left me,) he would absolutely have to be an atheist or Christian. I wouldn't accept any other religion, and would never convert to another religion. but I would accept a non believer as long as he didn't mock me coz then he's gone! But yeah this thread really is very very goady.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 30/08/2022 09:50

YABU

ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 09:49

Sounds like God wasn't having any of their dishonesty, no matter how morally superior they felt.

That anecdote sounds more like the proposition of a god as ultimate policeman doesn't really work that well. What actually worked in that case was evidence and the law. Maybe people who don't have a firm grip on the difference between objective and subjective truth are more likely to come adrift? Maybe they thought their god would protect them... and I dare say having been caught they think their god (rather than whoever they wronged by their lies) would forgive them. Hmm

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 30/08/2022 09:49

YABU.

Digita · 30/08/2022 09:42

@Sandinmyknickers
"Someone swearing on a religious text means that they answer to a higher authority (I.e. not the courts), I could say gives them a valid cause in their mind to lie if they feel they are 'serving god' for some other greater good."

Lying under oath is not "serving god". For example, God, according to the Old Testament is clear that perjury is wrong and makes it one of the Ten Commandments. I am yet to find where a religious text says that lying under oath is somehow 'serving god'; to the contrary, it's more likely a crime against God.

"(I was a juror on a trial once where later evidence showed that a number of religious witnesses- including a community religious figure- were all lying through their teeth. But they were so convincing and I believe it was the moral superiority that they felt they were doing the right thing protecting someone that made them so convincing)"

They got caught out. Sounds like God wasn't having any of their dishonesty, no matter how morally superior they felt. The rules in Court are clear 'do not lie' (that includes cover-ups and good intentions).

As in the OP. "Society needs reasons for people to tell the truth even when it is to their disadvantage." Sounds like those community religious figures conveniently forgot the 'vengeful god' bit, which the research claims is the useful bit to society.

Mary Beard says something about how a legal system can't run if people can come fib their pants off, so perjury has to be punished very hard. The Romans believed perjury was also a divine matter. So, where the state couldn't prosecute due to lack of evidence (possibly a common reason people took their chances on lying to get themselves off the hook), they believed a god would step in to finish off the job by punishing the perjury more severely. Roman gods were presented as badass and nothing got past them.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 30/08/2022 09:31

"There is no inherent conflict between religion and science, she argues, as they are separate magisteria concerned with separate questions. There is more than one kind of truth - science arrives at one while art, literature, and religion arrive at another.

There are certainly different domains of knowledge and experience. However, the 'truths', and the means of finding them, are different. Objective, verifiable (or falsifiable) versus subjective. The 'truth' of one religion (or small branch thereof) is the heresy of another. That's not the sort of understanding of 'truth' that has any place in the criminal justice system, except perhaps for considerations of intent.

InWalksBarberalla · 30/08/2022 09:26

UWhatNow · 29/08/2022 12:29

“I am not so sure about organised religion though. It seems to be open to abuse-historically and contemporarily- and has caused/causes so much conflict.”

I hear this a lot about ‘religion’ and I don’t disagree but you must balance this with much of the charity and outreach work done by all religious denominations such as food banks, Langars, charity donations, third world aid programmes, visiting elderly and sick, youth mentoring, homelessness charities etc. Much of this is faith led. I know lots of Christians who quietly give their time, money and energy to serving others - sometimes locally on a small level that nobody would really notice but means a lot to the people they help.

The ‘historical abuse’ argument that gets trotted out on threads like these but seems like a smack in the face to people of faith who are actually doing really good things for others.

Organised religions charity and outreach programs are about controlling the masses and expanding their span of control.

And as for the missionary work - well that is just as bad as their abuses. And provdes an handiy avenue to ship out problem priests to African countries.

And of course good people are involved in this charity work with good intentions. Nobody is saying that all religious people are evil or anything. I'm sure there are just as many good religious people as they are atheist people. The argument seems to be that the religious people wouldn't continue their good works if they didn't have a God or church telling them to.

InWalksBarberalla · 30/08/2022 09:18

Given the current state of the world with large chunks of the population believing in a God of some sort, I'm more than happy to see what a world is like without any believers.

AhNowTed · 30/08/2022 09:16

@Digita

"Do you not think it's possible to believe in god and not religion?

Religion tries to interpret God - and I often view it as someone else's experience of God that isn't the same as my own. But I think it's possible to interpret God for oneself without religion and other interpretations (although hearing them out can be useful for contemplation). In the end, it's a private faith; everyone experiences it differently and is on different paths/journeys anyway.

But Religion comes with other add-ons, such as community that appeals to humans as social animals. And because the experience of God can feel lonely and experienced in solitude, it can be reassuring that one isn't alone - and that others also experience the spiritual 'something more' too, albeit in different ways."

Yes I'm sure it's not only possible, but preferable.

Even a vengeful god, and a simplistic message that god is watching.

Non-believers would happily stay silent and allow believers to get on with it.

It's the less savoury multitude of man-made add-ons that one takes issue with.