Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you sent your August-born to school at 4 and later regretted it?

187 replies

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 09:43

Hi

I know this has been discussed many times before but I'd like to hear from parents who have not deferred the school start for their kids.
I know some parents with August-born children and they all want to defer their children so they start reception at 5.
But I want to hear the other perspective.

Our DD is just 3 but the registration period will start soon and I really don't know what we should do. She was born 25 August but her due date was actually 1 September. She was born a bit early as I had to be induced.

She seems very bright and is an extremely active, lively, friendly and sociable child. She has been at nursery full time since she was 1 year old.
Her speech is developping fine and physically she's also developping great - she's quite tall and athletic for her age.

The only thing I'm worried about is emotional maturity and just general readiness for school. I'm not really worried about reception but her schooling later on, and the impact of school on her confidence levels if "it doesn't work out".

Can people offer their experiences if they haven't deferred and it all turned out ok?
And if we do send her to school and she's really struggling later on, can she repeat a year or something like that?
I'm not familiar with the UK system as I wasn't born here..

Thanks in advance.
xx

OP posts:
YerAWizardHarry · 29/08/2022 10:30

Slightly different as we are in Scotland but I didn’t defer my end of Jan born son so he’s the youngest by quite a bit in his class. He is totally fine but not sure whether fine cuts it… he’s almost 10 now.

6 year old DSS was deferred and is doing fantastically.

Sarahcoggles · 29/08/2022 10:30

I would add that everyone told me it would even out as DS got older, but actually it's got worse. It wasn't too bad in primary school , but secondary has been much harder for him, where emotional maturity seems more significant.

modgepodge · 29/08/2022 10:28

User478 · 29/08/2022 10:17

If you're in a grammar school area (and want to potentially send them to Grammar school) check what the arrangements for 11+ tests are for deferred pupils, in our area they either sit with their "correct" cohort or get "weighted" as they are older than the others taking the test (particularly unfair as they wouldn't penalise someone born at 00.01 on the 1st September, but the cut off has to be somewhere)

Where I am (bucks and berks) the 11+ is age weighted, so children born in September are ‘penalised’ compared to summer borns, as they have to get a higher raw score to achieve the pass mark. This is to account for the fact that being a summer born is still a disadvantage academically at 10/11 when they sit this exam and on average those pupils score lower than older pupils in the same school year.

We haven’t yet had any pupils reach this age who are deferred at my school so I don’t know what happens if they want to sit the 11+ but deferred reception.

Sarahcoggles · 29/08/2022 10:26

I have an August born 17 year old son and deferring wasn't an option when he started school. I actually wrote to my MP and the dept of education but was told I was essentially being ridiculous. Yet a few years later the rules changed!
Anyway, I think that being the youngest in the year has had a lasting bad effect on DS. He was a month premature so should have been in the year below.

DS is clever, so has had no trouble at all keeping up academically. He's neurotypical, has always had lots of friends, is universally liked by pupils and teachers, plays sport etc. But his nature is cautious, he lacks confidence, and has found it very hard being the youngest all the time.

It started in reception when the other kids had Spider-Man swimming bags and laughed at this Thomas the Tank Engine bag, so he had to get a spider man one, even though he had no interest in spider man. And it's continued. All his friends started being interested in girls before him, drinking before he felt ready - just everything.

He's about to start the second year of 6th form and has no idea what he wants to do, says he feels too young to be making these decisions.

His lack of confidence and feeling of inferiority (due to young age) has led him to surround himself with people who are less intelligent than him and have no aspirations.

The girls in his year are all older than him, and since girls are more mature anyway, it's been has hard for him to have girlfriends.

Being unable to defer him is one of the biggest regrets of my life. I think it will stay with him for a long time. He would have been a different person if he hadn't felt constantly under pressure to be someone that he wasn't.

That said, girls are often different, and you know your child's personality best. I knew DS would struggle and I was right, but there was nothing I could do.

TheNoodlesIncident · 29/08/2022 10:20

Your DD sounds like she'll be fine.

I didn’t defer my August born and don’t regret it. He has ASD and was massively emotionally developmentally behind*. However he started school at just turned three in the F1 class, started Reception just turned four and did fine. He came on in leaps and bounds at school, the trained staff and other kids were far better for him than just being at home with me.

Obviously deferring was the road not taken so I can't say how things would have panned out if I had chosen that (it wasn't suggested at the time and it would have meant missing reception which was a hard no). Ultimately though he made incredible progress in school so I can't regret that.

*He is still delayed developmentally and is behind his peers in terms of maturity etc, but that's par for the course with ASD and doesn't reflect on his birthdate at all. Months make a difference when they are very young, not so much by secondary age...

sashagabadon · 29/08/2022 10:19

Funnily enough we were talking about this the other day , that she’d be off to uni this year rather than last year if she had been born 2 hours later than she was and she said she was so glad she was born in august and also glad I kept her in year as she’d have completely different friends and completely different life and maybe choices too. I am glad I didn’t meddle as is she!

Himawarigirl · 29/08/2022 10:18

My son is late July and has been fine. He’s heading into year 3 now. I was quite influenced by a boy in his nursery who had been held back and was obviously bored and could already do many of the things they’d be learning in reception. And he saw many of the kids who were in his year group as babyish, as they were so much younger than him. Obviously that’s just one child and not all those held back would be the same but it had an influence on us. My friend is also a reception teacher and she reassured me a lot as she said that academically the speed with which they learn doesn’t break down based on their place in the year. All children are different and learn at different speeds. She said that you can see the younger ones need a little more support with some of the social side of things but that is 100% part of her remit as the teacher to support the children with and they are v aware of how young some of the children are and the support they may need as a result. So it’s not like they get thrown into the class and you have to just hope for the best. I think if it had been my first child I’d have worried more but he had seen his sister going to school and was excited etc. I’ve read that you can actually see the impacts of them being younger further down the line, E.g. when they get to secondary. So that is still a little worrying but we don’t regret the decision and won’t be deferring our other summer baby either.

User478 · 29/08/2022 10:17

If you're in a grammar school area (and want to potentially send them to Grammar school) check what the arrangements for 11+ tests are for deferred pupils, in our area they either sit with their "correct" cohort or get "weighted" as they are older than the others taking the test (particularly unfair as they wouldn't penalise someone born at 00.01 on the 1st September, but the cut off has to be somewhere)

Fifife · 29/08/2022 10:14

My DD is summer born and she's now in year 5 shes caught up with the class she's one of the tallest and we had to pay less childcare than if she started at 5. No regrets here

user1491810905 · 29/08/2022 10:13

No @Mumteedum you aren't correct there. If you defer you definitely don't miss reception.

As a teacher I would absolutely urge you to defer.

A child who is only just 4 is, in my experience going to struggle. Sure they don't all struggle academically, sure they catch up. Some are emotionally and physically immature. I certainly would have kept my own child back if he was an august birthday and not able to use the toilet confidently. There is absolutely nothing wrong with a young 4yo who can't toilet reliably but I would question why you wouldn't give them that extra year to mature and grow up if you can.

OP I think you'd be best off asking if any people who did defer regret it.... I suspect that would be a resounding no. Of course most who don't defer will say it's fine because for the majority it will be. But for many of those who are fine I do still think an extra year at home would have been beneficial and I certainly don't think it would be any harm.

My own DC are bright September and October born, all performing at or above expectations. They are not geniuses of course and have never been particularly bored or under stimulated at school. Nothing out of the ordinary anyway!

As a professional I really do urge anyone with august or late July birthdays to just defer. Especially for any who were born premature or had any minor issues in the early years - late crawling, hearing problems, late to talk etc. Just give them the extra year.

Hannahthepink · 29/08/2022 10:13

I have a July child and we didn't defer, lots of friends were asking if we would.
She was quiet and we had a little wobble at first, mainly because it was mid-covid and we missed out on settling in etc, but honestly, I am so glad we did it.
By the following September, she had grown up so much that she would have seemed very old amongst the new reception class. The different ages seem so important at the beginning of reception, but by the time they start year 1, it is usually evened out.
Without bragging(!) she is in the top group for literacy, loves school and has a wonderful group of friends, no regrets!

sashagabadon · 29/08/2022 10:12

I hate a late born dd. She is about to turn 19 in two days time and I did not defer her or feel she missed out in any way. In fact I am glad I kept her in year as it worked out perfectly for her with a nice friendship group etc. main frustrations as she got older was always being youngest so couldn’t do things like cinema at 14 when her friends were 15. Pub at 17 when her friends were 18. That sort of thing but fake ID generally does the trick!
my advice is not to mess with the correct order of things , just give extra support if need be but otherwise don’t meddle and try to social engineer outcomes.
covid worked well for her for example as she sat her GCSE’s as normal 2019 but got teacher assessed a levels which worked out well and she got into a fab uni.
Not saying she wouldn’t have done as well this year if I had delayed her a year but you just don’t know what could happen.

edwinbear · 29/08/2022 10:12

DS is Aug 26th, we didn't defer. he's about to go into Y9. Absolutely no regrets at all, he'd been in nursery since 12 months which maybe helped. He was a bit behind with reading in KS1 but caught up in KS2. No issues at all with social interaction and also a talented sportsman which can sometimes be a concern with young for year children. He's been 'A' team rugby, football, cricket, swimming and athletics/cross country for as long as I can remember, despite being a bit smaller than some of his Sept/Oct/Nov born peers.

MakeMineALarge1 · 29/08/2022 10:09

My DS is an August birthday
I had no reservations about sending him he'd been in nursery since he was 2
He loved it, he wasn't at a disadvantage emotionally or educationally

welshpolarbear · 29/08/2022 10:09

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 10:05

Oh no I would definitely not want her to miss reception... but I think the rules are now different? You can apply to the council and the school, and if they agree you just start reception a year later ... that's what I've been told anyway ..

That was the kind of incorrect information I was scared with.

They would never have to miss a year. Honestly.

zingally · 29/08/2022 10:09

I've taught Reception for nearly 15 years, and can tell you that July and August borns perform less well academically for the first maybe 1.5-2 years, for maybe 60-70% of those children.

Assuming your child doesn't have additional SEN on top of being a summer born, they'll have caught up by the time they go into the juniors.

Mangogogogo · 29/08/2022 10:08

Openrelationship · 29/08/2022 09:47

I have an august 31st baby and didn’t defer! He seemed young at first and you could tell emotional maturity differences with him and the autumn born kids through reception but by middle of year 1 it became a level playing field.
I don’t regret it but I was never a competitive parent wanting the kid who read first, was top of the class etc. Someone’s got to be the youngest and in the scheme of things I don’t think it matters too much as long as your child is happy and confident.

This is exactly how I feel and I sent two august born boys.

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 10:07

My daughter isn't August born but almost. We sent her she and at the beginning she was sat with a classroom assistant at the table for children who needed extra help for various reasons. It was like a little class within a class. At that stage we would have deferred if it had seemed like an option. Her talking was so behind and she was more like nursery level in what she chose to play with.

A few years on it turns out she is doing work mostly for the year above and I dread to think how bored she would be if stuck in KS1 for another year. Still the smallest and most naïve but academically she needs to be where she is. But it took a lot of extra support at the beginning.

Haggisfish3 · 29/08/2022 10:06

Deferral doesn’t mean you start I. The next year group down it just means they start a year later, so entering reception with all the others who started in reception.

WishDragon · 29/08/2022 10:05

You definitely don’t want her to to miss reception year. It’s fun and settles them in.

Jules912 · 29/08/2022 10:05

DS has a June birthday and was fine. DD is September born and was so bored at nursery that last year.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 10:05

I have an August-born and regret not deferring. At the time they started reception the rules were that you could defer but when you did eve tally start the following September you would go straight into Year One with the cohort you should have been in had you started the previous year. I didn't want DC to miss out on the foundation year so didn't defer. The rules are different now though and you stay with the class you started with.

I think DC would have benefited more from starting a year later and even now in secondary school they are still noticeably behind their peers in terms of emotional and social maturity.

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 10:05

Oh no I would definitely not want her to miss reception... but I think the rules are now different? You can apply to the council and the school, and if they agree you just start reception a year later ... that's what I've been told anyway ..

OP posts:
whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 29/08/2022 10:04

No; he started school a week after his 4th birthday, but was more than ready for school having been to nursery since he was 6 months old, as I worked full time. He thrived at school and is now at Cambridge. Interestingly he recently had birthday drinks with several of his college friends also celebrating their birthdays this week, so from that purely anecdotal evidence I'd say being a late August baby doesn't hold you back academically.

Haggisfish3 · 29/08/2022 10:04

We sent dd who has July birthday. She’s been fine. Tiny, yes, but hasn’t suffered any ill effects. She’s always been bright, though, so I wasn’t concerned about her academic progress being affected.

Swipe left for the next trending thread