Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you sent your August-born to school at 4 and later regretted it?

187 replies

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 09:43

Hi

I know this has been discussed many times before but I'd like to hear from parents who have not deferred the school start for their kids.
I know some parents with August-born children and they all want to defer their children so they start reception at 5.
But I want to hear the other perspective.

Our DD is just 3 but the registration period will start soon and I really don't know what we should do. She was born 25 August but her due date was actually 1 September. She was born a bit early as I had to be induced.

She seems very bright and is an extremely active, lively, friendly and sociable child. She has been at nursery full time since she was 1 year old.
Her speech is developping fine and physically she's also developping great - she's quite tall and athletic for her age.

The only thing I'm worried about is emotional maturity and just general readiness for school. I'm not really worried about reception but her schooling later on, and the impact of school on her confidence levels if "it doesn't work out".

Can people offer their experiences if they haven't deferred and it all turned out ok?
And if we do send her to school and she's really struggling later on, can she repeat a year or something like that?
I'm not familiar with the UK system as I wasn't born here..

Thanks in advance.
xx

OP posts:
Aozora13 · 29/08/2022 11:11

So much depends on the child I think. My August-born is bright and loves learning. She’s also tall for her age and her teacher has commented on her maturity. She’d been at nursery since 1 so I knew how she coped in a more structured environment with other children. Having said that, the first term especially was tough, but tbf it was 2020 so tough on all kids I think. She’s now doing well academically and socially despite being second youngest in her class.

My middle DC turns 4 in October and actually I think she’ll benefit from the additional time in nursery as she’s much less confident than her sister was at the same age.

CaptainBarbosa · 29/08/2022 11:08

DS is a mid August baby.

I didn't defer. He has dyslexia also which has caused the biggest issue.

In Wales you start at 3. So he turned 3 and was in school like 3 weeks later. It was obvious in nursery, reception and year 1 he was basically a year behind the others, but by year 2 and 3 he has been ok.

Going in to year 4 now and socially he's fine, academically still a bit behind. Not much that can be done about it. Teachers are aware of the "summer Born's" in the class and do tailor things a bit to them.

Wales bring a brand new curriculum in this year, and having read it, I think it will actually benefit him a lot, and the fact he's a summer born won't really matter.

But I'd say in a nutshell wasn't ideal but we got through it and the school have been great with all the summer born children which has eased the issue.

plantsareglorious · 29/08/2022 11:06

I didn't defer and wish I had. He's doing ok but I'm often told he's 'behind' his peers. Of course he is, he's a year younger! Born late august.
He has struggled with being overtired and just too much info overload. He's finally settled now going into year 3 but all his peers are going to be 8 soon and he's literally just turned 7.
If I did it again I would one hundred percent defer but you have to inform the LA as soon as possible so he doesn't miss his reception year.

dizzydizzydizzy · 29/08/2022 11:04

I have 2 July born DDs. DD1 definitely struggled emotionally in the early years but it all came good in the end with 4xAstar ar A Level and a top uni place.

DD2 struggled more generally I would say and I have always wished I had the opportunity to keep her back (it wasn't possible at the time). She did well at school though but not as well as DD1.

Of course there are many factors at play, not just birth date. Poor DD2 was rather outshone by DD1 so that must have impacted her confidence.

yoyamilow · 29/08/2022 11:02

My DD2 is an early august baby. She is now 19. If I'd had the option at the time to defer starting school without missing reception I would definitely have done it. Although she was ready academically and has excelled in gcse, A level and first year uni, she has struggled emotionally and socially and with her mental health notably from secondary school onwards. She was diagnosed ASD at 16 and is now only just finding her feet in the world. We constantly worry about her.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 10:57

My SS was born in August and started school at 4, he ended up repeating a year in primary school because he was far too young and immature. Having said that my friends daughter was born in July and started when she was 4 and she was fine.

I had April and May babies and started both a year later when they were 5 as i didn't think it would do them any harm to keep them in Nursery an extra year

Phineyj · 29/08/2022 10:54

My sister is August born and went through school ok/well academically, although she did have some social issues (hard to say if these were the result of being younger though).

She took a gap year after school though as it was very evident that at just turned 18, she wouldn't manage university just yet. I am September born and so there would have been a 23 month gap between us if we'd both gone to university "at the same age"!

Popplebandit · 29/08/2022 10:53

I have had two Summer born and one January born go to school. It was a similar outcome and liked it :) The eldest is 13 now and she is doing very well at school despite being one of the young ones. I don’t think it is as important as it feels when you have your first little one about to go to school! Parenthood is a minefield of these decisions where you worry and want the best for your child - and wish you had a crystal ball!!

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 29/08/2022 10:50

My daughter is expecting twins which are due 22nd September.

She's been having a few signs of labour this weekend, so she's taken to bed. She is hoping to get to 1st of September. The consultant asked her if she had any thoughts about the academic year when they discussed induction. Her induction is this Thursday.

Iamnotthe1 · 29/08/2022 10:48

Very bright kids find year 6 boring

Based on what? I teach at one of the highest performing primaries in England and have taught some exceptionally academic children. I can assure you, they didn't find Year Six boring at all.

However the point about SEN is a valid one. We recently had a parent defer her August born boy because she was still going through the process of diagnosis for him and wanted to secure an EHCP before he started primary. Absolutely the right decision for him.

Mumspair1 · 29/08/2022 10:42

It depends on your child. My ds is also August born but he is extremely mature as often noted by his teachers. He is very academic as well so it would have disadvantaged him if we deferred.

JoanThursday · 29/08/2022 10:41

Another one with an August-born son.

There wasn't really a standard option to defer when he was starting school - or at least not one we knew about. He did have some physical difficulties with writing and could not hold a pencil properly until at least christmas - i remember feeling very worried by that!

He's always been very sociable and had no problem making friends. Nodded off a few times in the afternoons at school - but i think they were prepared for that and had a 'quiet corner' where the children could take a break.

By y2, any differences had ironed themselves out. He's about to go into y9 now, taller than most of his peers, doing really well and getting involved in anything and everything. No regrets.

Londonnorth · 29/08/2022 10:40

If she’s very bright then don’t hold her back. Bright kids outgrow nursery by age 4 and primary by year 5. Very bright kids find year 6 boring and year 7 easy and repetitive. So making them do an extra year is going to be really dull. Girls also mature faster than boys so that won’t be an issue after a year or two. I would only hold back a child with Sen or who is behind, not one who is ‘very bright’. Not unless you are happy for them to skip from year 5 to year 7 - which means missing out on all the year 6 milestones (year 6 play, residential, leavers events) and moving on without her friends - which she won’t want to do. It is rubbish being the youngest when everyone is turning 18 but also hard being the oldest and expected to be the most sensible and come top of the class at primary. Many children don’t like the pressure of being the oldest in the class.

Namechange600 · 29/08/2022 10:39

i wish I had deferred my august born who was due in September and 3 weeks early. 4 is so young to start school. As a Pp said if they have sen on top then that makes things even more tricky - but often you may not know your child has sen until they’re well into the school system and then it’s often too late. Mine has ASD and dyslexia but also very bright but the demands of school and her needs mean that she underperforms a lot eg didn’t pass maths sats. I’m sure her being the youngest doesn’t help. I wish she had a year to mature and learn more outside school before starting. Horses for courses though as the saying goes. Good luck x

choosername1234 · 29/08/2022 10:38

Late Aug boy here, I debated whether or not to defer and in the end I didn't. I spoke to his nursery teachers who assured me that he would cope well despite a speech delay requiring speech therapy, and they have been proved correct. It helped that he was quite a tall child (so not the smallest despite being the youngest) and he was very confident and chatty. It's a personal decision but I am happy with the decision that we made

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 10:37

@Sarahcoggles

I'm August born myself. There's no reason why I should have been delayed! Why should parents be allowed take such a decision that could negatively impact their children later. See info on school sports

YahBooFucks · 29/08/2022 10:35

I very, very nearly deferred my mid-August born DS. I only changed my mind when I was told that this might cause issues when he went to secondary school in that some schools insist deferred children join in their correct age cohort (so, he might have to start secondary school in year 8). I work in a secondary school and the admissions officer confirmed this was the case in my school (I understand it's discretionary so wouldn't happen all the time, and that it can be fought but I reeeeeaaaaly didn't fancy facing this issue in the future!). Anyway, he started in reception last year 2 weeks after turning 4 and has absolutely thrived - I have zero regrets... He's doing very well 'academically', socially and emotionally. It's worth noting that I had no concerns about my DS at all - my reason for considering deferment was only that I liked the idea of him being older and at an advantage, rather than a disadvantage.

There are lots of factors and variables in this decision so it's a very personal one to make but from my experience, and in my circumstances, I'm very happy I didn't defer my DS.

Melawati · 29/08/2022 10:35

DD2 has just turned 18 and is about to go to uni. I did have a bit of a wobble about her starting school. DD1 was in the year above and in the middle of the year age wise and was really thriving, but there were a couple of younger ones in the class who were struggling.
But DD2 was in the school nursery class and the reception teachers knew her pretty well. Everyone recommended we just go for it, and it’s worked out well for her.
The worst part for her has definitely been being the youngest and not being able to do things her friends could do - especially this summer post A levels not being able to socialise at pubs/clubs.

Sarahcoggles · 29/08/2022 10:34

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 10:31

I'm a late August birthday born 5 weeks preemie (due October 1st) hasn't affected me at all. I would have been very angry with my parents if I was a year behind! I went to university at just 18, no issues at all. Dp is also late August, also no issues. I think it's modern parents overthinking it and trying to game the system for perceived advantage when there isn't at a population level (individuals could have specific reasons why delaying is a good idea)

I'm sorry but that's simply not correct. The option to defer summer born children is relatively recent, and was brought about due to studies consistently showing that summer born kids performed less well. Do you really think government policy would have changed on something so significant if it was just pushy parents trying to gain advantage?! Just because your child has been OK, you can't deny population studies of large numbers.

Iamnotthe1 · 29/08/2022 10:33

Most children are not deferred and do absolutely fine. As a teacher, I have to say that, for most, by Key Stage 2, there's no real noticeable difference and definitely not by upper Key stage 2. Summer born children tend to progress quicker upon starting school so 'catch up' in no time.

What you do have to be aware of are the typical practices in place in your authority. In some, they allow deferring and then a placement in the following Reception class. In others, it's straight into Year 1. For some, it depends on the deferring reasons and a judgement call will be made whether it,s Reception or Year 1. In a few, it's that they go into Reception but, when they transfer to secondary, they are moved back to their chronological year group (straight into Year 8). You have to know what the typical practices are in your local authority because it will be different for other posters and you may not get your choice of what you'd want to happen.

It's also worth keeping in mind that deferring won't necessarily bring what you'd like it to. In the last few years, I've taught several deferred children who were placed out of their chronological year group to make them the oldest rather than the youngest. None of them were academically strong and there was no noticeable difference between their personal confidence levels and those of the rest of the class.

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 10:33

Oh and remember sports in particular are age specific - dd had a lad in her class who couldn't take part in a primary school event because he was too told (August born but delayed)

Sarahcoggles · 29/08/2022 10:32

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 10:05

I have an August-born and regret not deferring. At the time they started reception the rules were that you could defer but when you did eve tally start the following September you would go straight into Year One with the cohort you should have been in had you started the previous year. I didn't want DC to miss out on the foundation year so didn't defer. The rules are different now though and you stay with the class you started with.

I think DC would have benefited more from starting a year later and even now in secondary school they are still noticeably behind their peers in terms of emotional and social maturity.

Exactly my experience

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 10:31

I'm a late August birthday born 5 weeks preemie (due October 1st) hasn't affected me at all. I would have been very angry with my parents if I was a year behind! I went to university at just 18, no issues at all. Dp is also late August, also no issues. I think it's modern parents overthinking it and trying to game the system for perceived advantage when there isn't at a population level (individuals could have specific reasons why delaying is a good idea)

BogOffTraceyBeaker · 29/08/2022 10:30

Her birth date and her due date will have no influence. This boils down to her being the oldest in class or the youngest. What do you plan to do with her if you don’t put her in school for another year?

earlydoors42 · 29/08/2022 10:30

My son was born mid August. He's just going into high school next year and I never regretted my decision to send him. Didn't notice him being behind or anything.