Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you sent your August-born to school at 4 and later regretted it?

187 replies

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 09:43

Hi

I know this has been discussed many times before but I'd like to hear from parents who have not deferred the school start for their kids.
I know some parents with August-born children and they all want to defer their children so they start reception at 5.
But I want to hear the other perspective.

Our DD is just 3 but the registration period will start soon and I really don't know what we should do. She was born 25 August but her due date was actually 1 September. She was born a bit early as I had to be induced.

She seems very bright and is an extremely active, lively, friendly and sociable child. She has been at nursery full time since she was 1 year old.
Her speech is developping fine and physically she's also developping great - she's quite tall and athletic for her age.

The only thing I'm worried about is emotional maturity and just general readiness for school. I'm not really worried about reception but her schooling later on, and the impact of school on her confidence levels if "it doesn't work out".

Can people offer their experiences if they haven't deferred and it all turned out ok?
And if we do send her to school and she's really struggling later on, can she repeat a year or something like that?
I'm not familiar with the UK system as I wasn't born here..

Thanks in advance.
xx

OP posts:
Connie2468 · 29/08/2022 12:57

My August born started school a year or two before defer Reception start was an option. He's now in secondary school.

He was very young when he started school, but did seem 'ready' - I wasn't worried about him.
He was definitely more socially ready than physically/academically ready, but he did catch up.
He's done well at school and has always been at or exceeding expected level, top sets in secondary etc.

BUT
If I had my time again, I would 100% defer an August born.
Yes, if they're bright, sociable and well supported at home they will probably do fine, but they will not do as well as they would have if they were the oldest in the year and started at nearly 5.
Starting at just 4 is a disadvantage. It makes things much harder for them.
Even at secondary school, although my son is holding his own academically, he is much smaller than the boys a year older.
Just two non-academic examples:
He wasn't picked for sports teams so much in primary as he was smaller and less physically co-ordinated than children a year older, so by secondary had much less experience in sports.
He wasn't given big speaking roles in infants plays as they went to the oldest children who were more confident and able to remember lines so by secondary had much less experience of performing and public speaking.

I have a September born child now as well and the difference in their school experiences has been very obvious. I would never willingly disadvantage my child if I had the choice (even if they would do 'fine').

vdbfamily · 29/08/2022 12:48

my DD has just had her 16 th birthday this week. She started school a week after her 4 th birthday. She went to bog standard schools and just got 11x 9's in her GCSEs. If they are not struggling developmentally so far, they will be fine. However, she is 3rd child so had been walking siblings to school and was desperate to start. Did not even say goodbye on her first day, just got in a queue and went in whilst I was talking to another parent!

Bakingdiva · 29/08/2022 12:38

I was a slightly different situation, born in September and I went to school a year early (the year I was 4) so slightly younger than the august borns. I never struggled, was one of the top in the year and had lots of friends.

I think it depends on the child rather than the age.

Pinkishpurple · 29/08/2022 12:29

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 11:53

Thanks everyone.

yes DD seems very bright but it's hard to tell whether she will be ready academically. Also hard to tell how bright she is, from just general observation, compared to her peers. I can't really tell where she "should" be, if that makes sense. Some kids her age are speaking much better (but she's raised as a bilingual so that is probably having an impact), others can sit still at the table and have a meal for much longer. I know that everyone is different, but sometimes I can't help comparing. She's reliably toilet trained though.

The only other problem is concentration. She has been so active since she was born, that for a long time I have thought she's ADHD. However DP gets upset when I mention this to him and tells me she's just a typical toddler. He's most probably right.

Someone has asked what we would do if we deferred? She's do another year at nursery. Thinking about that scenario, I can't help but feel that it would be so boring for her...
(and financially really hard for us too)...

Go to the Flexible Admissions for Summer Borns page on Facebook they have all the research and how it all works on there.

dockspider · 29/08/2022 12:27

Someone has asked what we would do if we deferred? She's do another year at nursery. Thinking about that scenario, I can't help but feel that it would be so boring for her...
(and financially really hard for us too)...

The financial aspect is obviously a worry and I can't comment on that! Re nursery being boring - you could talk to the manager about their plans for the older children. Again it is different in Scotland as there is typically a cohort of older kids and the nurseries IME provide well for them.

dockspider · 29/08/2022 12:20

I'm in Scotland where deferral is more common - kids here start at 4.5 at the youngest and it was previously 5.5 at the oldest (the cut off is at the end of February) but it's now becoming more common to defer autumn borns such that kids can start school at almost 6.

I have two winter babies; I've deferred one already and the other is only 3 now but will definitely be deferring when his time comes. DD was reading, writing, doing sums etc before she started school - but her nursery saw that she was keen and gently encouraged this. When she went into P1 she could basically already do all the work that was expected by the end of the year and that meant she could just focus that year on friendships, new routines, etc. It was very, very obvious all through P1 and P2 who the non-deferred winter borns were for various academic/social/behavioural reasons.

Pretty much everyone I asked for advice - Mum friends, teacher friends, ed psych friends said the same thing which was that you might regret not deferring but you will never regret deferring.

Anecdotally - I was the youngest in my year at school. Everyone looking at me from the outside, including my parents, would have said that it was great that I was in that school year. I flew through my exams, always had loads of friends, participated in sports, etc. In reality as a teenager I felt incredibly young compared to my peers and it made me really unhappy. I took a gap year and felt 'right' going to Uni. One of my good friends was in the same position and she was able to repeat a school year after ill health and she said she finally felt like she belonged, when she was the oldest rather than youngest in the year. Just a thought that things can go very smoothly in primary but less so in secondary.

Frazzled2207 · 29/08/2022 12:11

I didn’t defer my august born who is now about to start y5, but did think about it and
worried about it a lot.

He was very small starting school and def seemed emotionally and physically behind some of his (autumn born) peers but def not all. Academically however there’s not been any real issues, in fact it’s clear now that holding him back a year could have been detrimental. He’s now exceeding expectations in most areas.

My second was a June born and similar story.

I will say that even if your dc seems very very young now, it could be a different story in just a few months’ time.

bookworm14 · 29/08/2022 12:07

My DD is mid August-born and due to go into year 3. She’s doing really well so far and got either ‘exceeding’ or ‘expected’ for everything in her end of year 2 report. I have zero regrets about not deferring her.

skgnome · 29/08/2022 12:05

We did not deferred
DD was ready, she wanted to go and even at her pre-school sessions she was one of the most determined kids to learn and get ready for “ big school”
she was the youngest of the year all through primary school, some girls were a year older and you could see a massive difference - saying that most her friends were between 2 months - 2 weeks older than her, so not that big of a gap
she is dyslexic… before the diagnosis I thought it was maybe not deferring what was keeping her behind, but once she got the props support, she flourished and finished primary on the top percentile of her class (both maths and english!)
would keeping her a year would have been beneficial? Maybe… but socially and academically she seems to be doing well
Will it be hard for her later when all her friends are turning 18 and she has to wait to legally drink and go to clubs? Again, maybe, but most kids will be drinking and using fake IDs well before anyway…
she can always take a gap year later on, and then that year disappears

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 12:04

Haha @pushpushthebutton about the sweets! But at least she gets to have a birthday party in the park or a do a barbecue which is surely a plus, no?

OP posts:
pushpushthebutton · 29/08/2022 11:57

My DD is a mid August baby. We didn’t defer. She spoke and toilet trained pretty early and went to nursery from 10 months. She’s always
been pretty sociable.

She did struggle initially especially with reading and writing but had a big catch up in year 2 and is similar to her peers now. She also used to get really tired after school in reception but this settled with time. I didn’t sign her up for activities after school until year 1 due to this.

Her main complaint about a summer birthday is that she can’t bring in sweets to the class on her birthday due to the summer holidays but there is no easy way round that!

BorgQueen · 29/08/2022 11:56

My DGS just turned 3 last week, he’ll be in reception next September, I think it depends on the child, his Mum ( my DD) is a Maths teacher and he will definitely be ready, he barely spoke a word last Xmas and she was worried 🙄 but his vocabulary now is unbelievable for a 3 year old.

nokidshere · 29/08/2022 11:54

My late August DS had no problems starting school at just 4. He loved school, was confident, academically fine and emotionally able , although he did fall asleep at 4pm most days during the first term.

The differences started to show really between yrs 6-8, for a time he seemed emotionally immature compared to the older children and his confidence wavered a bit.

He turned 21 last week, he's just graduated with a first class honours degree, has landed himself a full time job, as well as a highly prestigious (in his field) part time job. He is confident, pro active, sociable and focussed.

I don't think that, for most children, starting young is a problem as long as you acknowledge that at some points the age difference might be more apparent, either academically, emotionally or both.

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 11:53

Thanks everyone.

yes DD seems very bright but it's hard to tell whether she will be ready academically. Also hard to tell how bright she is, from just general observation, compared to her peers. I can't really tell where she "should" be, if that makes sense. Some kids her age are speaking much better (but she's raised as a bilingual so that is probably having an impact), others can sit still at the table and have a meal for much longer. I know that everyone is different, but sometimes I can't help comparing. She's reliably toilet trained though.

The only other problem is concentration. She has been so active since she was born, that for a long time I have thought she's ADHD. However DP gets upset when I mention this to him and tells me she's just a typical toddler. He's most probably right.

Someone has asked what we would do if we deferred? She's do another year at nursery. Thinking about that scenario, I can't help but feel that it would be so boring for her...
(and financially really hard for us too)...

OP posts:
Pinkishpurple · 29/08/2022 11:50

So much rubbish being written here. Please just do your own research. I hate it when people just spout rubbish as fact on here!

MulberryMoon · 29/08/2022 11:46

Dd is mid July. She was born 04 and joined reception before it became easier to defer. Academically she was fine, but emotionally/socially she would have been much better deferring.

Jules912 · 29/08/2022 11:45

I'm also August born and can't say it made any difference academically. Was slightly annoying in upper high school/ sixth form when I couldn't do things like driving and drinking ( not at the same time!) when most my friends could.

Mumteedum · 29/08/2022 11:44

user1491810905 · 29/08/2022 10:13

No @Mumteedum you aren't correct there. If you defer you definitely don't miss reception.

As a teacher I would absolutely urge you to defer.

A child who is only just 4 is, in my experience going to struggle. Sure they don't all struggle academically, sure they catch up. Some are emotionally and physically immature. I certainly would have kept my own child back if he was an august birthday and not able to use the toilet confidently. There is absolutely nothing wrong with a young 4yo who can't toilet reliably but I would question why you wouldn't give them that extra year to mature and grow up if you can.

OP I think you'd be best off asking if any people who did defer regret it.... I suspect that would be a resounding no. Of course most who don't defer will say it's fine because for the majority it will be. But for many of those who are fine I do still think an extra year at home would have been beneficial and I certainly don't think it would be any harm.

My own DC are bright September and October born, all performing at or above expectations. They are not geniuses of course and have never been particularly bored or under stimulated at school. Nothing out of the ordinary anyway!

As a professional I really do urge anyone with august or late July birthdays to just defer. Especially for any who were born premature or had any minor issues in the early years - late crawling, hearing problems, late to talk etc. Just give them the extra year.

I am correct. I just checked. It seems it is different in different authorities. "Summer Born Children

Children with a date of birth in the summer term wishing to start school in the September after their fifth birthday would start in Year 1 and consequently miss the entire reception year."

So hasn't changed here in a decade. Despite some issues, I'm glad I didn't defer with skipping reception being the option.
🤷

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 29/08/2022 11:44

As others have said, the really important thing is to check policies in your local authority for deferral- as it does vary. In some places they may still go straight into Y1, which would not be ideal. You do also need to check the transition arrangements, as secondary schools are not required to accept children being in a lower year group than their chronological age (as this can affect funding at various stages)- it can also affect funding post 16, because students between 16-19 get funding for one repeat year, but this doesn't apply for the year when the child hits 20.

Deferring to go into a lower year group is a relatively new phenomenon, so secondary schools/colleges may not have a lot of experience with it.

I believe in some LAs it can be agreed that the child will stay in their new year group all the way through- but it's important to get this in writing, and it may not apply if you move to a different LA.

I do think in reception etc, it is very likely you'd get a benefit from deferring but I'm not sure this would outweigh the problems you'd get later on if your child was forced to skip a year.

AryaStarkWolf · 29/08/2022 11:41

rerr · 29/08/2022 11:28

It’s only in reception where the difference is noticed, by year 1&2, you can’t even tell who’s was born when. Don’t defer

That's not true at all. Totally depends on the child, falling behind socially or education wise can set the child back for the coming years as well which is what happened to my SS

Pinkishpurple · 29/08/2022 11:36

rerr · 29/08/2022 11:28

It’s only in reception where the difference is noticed, by year 1&2, you can’t even tell who’s was born when. Don’t defer

Absolute rubbish! There is plenty of readily available information that totally disproves this!

Pinkishpurple · 29/08/2022 11:34

All my 3 are summer born, the first two have really struggled with little support initially and even now with more support they still struggle. My eldest thinks she is stupid. My third child i used the summer born legislation to send him to reception a year late, he's so much more ready to learn and loves school, although he still struggles he's not at the bottom of the class which is where he would have been if I'd sent him on time. I wish i had sent my eldest two a year later, they'd have some self esteem left. Also reception (playbased learning) isn't the problem for summer borns it's when they get to year 1!

rerr · 29/08/2022 11:28

It’s only in reception where the difference is noticed, by year 1&2, you can’t even tell who’s was born when. Don’t defer

randomsabreuse · 29/08/2022 11:25

I have a mid August born girl who started reception then moved to Scotland meaning she had to go into P1 which is mostly like reception but they move faster...

She's athletic (but narrow build), wasn't the smallest in her reception class, is one of the tallest in her mixed P1/2 class - so kids up to 18 months older.

Because of the foundations in reception she's been consistently working with the kids in the year above, friends come from both years.

On reflection I'm glad we didn't defer her in the English system - her personality would not suit being the oldest as she's pretty bossy and girls are generally more mature.

My opinion would be different for a shy, slight boy born the same dates - but a confident girl is probably better off not deferring given that girls generally mature quicker than boys!

kimchifox · 29/08/2022 11:12

Did not defer DS. I sometimes think it would have been better for him academically but he's just done A levels and did very well - he was also extremely tall all the way through and is sporting so judging by the comments I overheard it would have been very difficult from that perspective as no one believed he was the age he was anyway.

I've got mixed feeling about it because Feb born DS 2 has some SLD and if his whole class were either deferred or "old for the year" and all four to six months older if would make life much more difficult for him as he struggles to keep up as it is!