Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you sent your August-born to school at 4 and later regretted it?

187 replies

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 09:43

Hi

I know this has been discussed many times before but I'd like to hear from parents who have not deferred the school start for their kids.
I know some parents with August-born children and they all want to defer their children so they start reception at 5.
But I want to hear the other perspective.

Our DD is just 3 but the registration period will start soon and I really don't know what we should do. She was born 25 August but her due date was actually 1 September. She was born a bit early as I had to be induced.

She seems very bright and is an extremely active, lively, friendly and sociable child. She has been at nursery full time since she was 1 year old.
Her speech is developping fine and physically she's also developping great - she's quite tall and athletic for her age.

The only thing I'm worried about is emotional maturity and just general readiness for school. I'm not really worried about reception but her schooling later on, and the impact of school on her confidence levels if "it doesn't work out".

Can people offer their experiences if they haven't deferred and it all turned out ok?
And if we do send her to school and she's really struggling later on, can she repeat a year or something like that?
I'm not familiar with the UK system as I wasn't born here..

Thanks in advance.
xx

OP posts:
TheSandwoman · 29/08/2022 19:55

Mumteedum · 29/08/2022 10:03

DS is very end July born. He has been fine academically. First term in reception, I was still picking him up in the pushchair and he wasn't quite able to toilet properly. It was all fine. School were great. I would say he is emotionally behind his peers even now he's about to start high school.

BUT iirc, deferral doesn't mean that you'd drop down a year. It just means you start late. So essentially your child misses out on reception. I think that's a worse option.

This is completely wrong. Summer borns can defer and start reception the term after they turn 5, at compulsory school age. I wish these threads weren't full if so much misinformation.

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 19:34

Absolutely get your point 😀 @Mumteedum but maintain that the statutory guidance does more or less guarantee this if parents are well informed and able to challenge constructively. (that’s not to say it can’t be a difficult process for some to get to that stage). There was going to be some further reinforcing legislation to guarantee it, but the government have recently paused or stopped it (supposedly on the basis that school’s/authorities) should be doing it anyway.

Iamnotthe1 · 29/08/2022 19:18

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 19:14

Absolutely - I don’t think I’ve said it’s automatic 😃. Just that parents do have the absolute right to defer entry to school to the first term after 5th birthday and that the authority has to prove it would be in the child’s best interests to miss reception (which is hard to do if pressed). Authorities can and do decline, but if appealed it’s a hard case for them to fight.

This is what you replied to me:
there is national statutory guidance which more or less guarantees the right for offset reception start for summer borns, if parents wish.

A rejection rate ranging from of 1 out of every 6 to 1 out of every 10 (including appeals) is not more or less a guarentee.

I8toys · 29/08/2022 19:17

My DS is an August birth. He was absolutely fine with reception as he had been going to nursery so not much of a change for him.

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 19:14

Absolutely - I don’t think I’ve said it’s automatic 😃. Just that parents do have the absolute right to defer entry to school to the first term after 5th birthday and that the authority has to prove it would be in the child’s best interests to miss reception (which is hard to do if pressed). Authorities can and do decline, but if appealed it’s a hard case for them to fight.

Iamnotthe1 · 29/08/2022 19:06

@Gonewiththewind123

Suggesting that it's automatic is misleading though. The latest Government data analysis that we have shows that only 22% of local authorities accept all requests with 78% only accepting some of the requests made, depending on how they judge the validity of the reasons for the request. Whilst it's more common to be accepted, between 10 - 15 percent are rejected. That's hundreds of children nationally.

I'm not saying that LAs don't accept requests nor that they shouldn't but I am saying that you can't say it's automatic acceptance because more than 1 in every 10 isn't.

Madamecastafiore · 29/08/2022 19:05

DD was July birthday and went 2 months after turning 4. She did fine. Reception is about learning through play, getting used to being at school and building social confidence in a group, all things that are invaluable if they are younger.

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 19:04

Yeah @Mumteedum local authorities do interpret in different ways, possibly to put people off as you say. And the decision does ultimately rest with the authority but it’s a hard thing for them to defend!

Mumteedum · 29/08/2022 18:59

Well it is past relevant for me but it seems somewhat wrong the way local government sites put this if it is as you say @Gonewiththewind123

It's very off putting. It sounded to me as a parent that it would seem quite onerous getting a deferal and a risk if skipping reception year. Clearly you are well informed but it doesn't come across as the way you say it works. See attached.

Have you sent your August-born to school at 4 and later regretted it?
Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 18:34

@Mumteedum also worth being aware that the burden is on the admissions authority to evidence best interests which is very very difficult to do. It’s commonly misunderstood.

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 18:32

Sorry - comment was for @Mumteedum

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 18:31

It’s not a misconception thanks! There is a statutory right to request a start at compulsory school age - the term after 5th birthday. The school or authority (depending who is the admissions authority) has to demonstrate that that it would be in child’s best interest to start in year 1, and by implication miss the formative reception year (same applies for transition to secondary). It’s pretty much impossible for a school to evidence that it would be in a child’s best interests.

RadFad · 29/08/2022 17:24

My DD1 is 26th August. I didn't defer her start. As said above emotional maturity is slightly obvious next to an Autumn born child in her year but no enough to be an issue. She had been in nursery 4 full days since 11 months and had no issues settling in.
She's just going into year 3 and she's as expected in all areas but music and art where she is slightly above but she loves creative things so not surprised.

I have 2 friends born 4th and 6th August, neither deferred start in school and one is a Clinical Psychologist and the other a band 8a clinical nurse practitioner so it didn't hold them back.
A husband of one of my NCT class was also August born and was very high up in the teaching profession.
I know it's anecdotal but I found it reassuring as so many people make you feel like your child is doomed to a life of failure if they're summer born and not deferred 🙄.

Jumpking · 29/08/2022 17:03

DS born mid August. Went to Reception age 4. He was very ready for it. He was a fluent reader when he started, so ended up mid year going to year 2 for Literacy each morning, and was the best in that class at reading and composing stories, less so at writing them.

Continued excelling at reading and maths, writing falling further behind. This meant his teachers in UKS2 & secondary were getting more and more frustrated with him, as he had ideas and could verbalise answers but wouldn't put them down on paper.

GCSEs he got 6s-9s during COVID. He thinks he'd never have got those scores had he actually taken the papers. I agree with him.
College-failed 1st year of A levels as didn't do the work. Failed 2nd year of easy Btech course as didn't do the work.

I put his progressive lack of effort down to 2 things.

  1. learning came very easily to him, so he never learned how to learn, how to fail and improve from it

  2. only being 4 years old starting reception meant his hand muscles weren't developed enough for the writing being asked of him in the year 2 class. Him going to the year 2 class means he had an hour less each day than his peers developing the strength in his hands and doing all the prewriting skills reception focus on to build those muscles and forming letter shapes. Meaning writing came harder to him.

So whilst I don't regret sending him as an August baby, I do regret the school sending him to year 2 each day. I knew nothing about it until the next term's parents evening and by then it was nearly the end of the school year.

bumpytrumpy · 29/08/2022 16:36

dockspider · 29/08/2022 12:27

Someone has asked what we would do if we deferred? She's do another year at nursery. Thinking about that scenario, I can't help but feel that it would be so boring for her...
(and financially really hard for us too)...

The financial aspect is obviously a worry and I can't comment on that! Re nursery being boring - you could talk to the manager about their plans for the older children. Again it is different in Scotland as there is typically a cohort of older kids and the nurseries IME provide well for them.

Are you currently receiving the 30 hours free? If so that would continue

cadburyegg · 29/08/2022 16:29

My mums due date with me was in September, I was born early August. I don't know what happened but my parents were given the wrong information about when I should start school so I was thrown in the deep end and had to start in Year 1. So not only was I the youngest in the year, I'd missed Reception as well. I learnt to read at 3 and remember my primary teachers being amazed by my reading and writing skills. Throughout school, English was the only subject i really did well in. I really struggled until the end of A levels. I'm not the most academic anyway but I also think I struggled with emotional maturity. I took a gap year before starting university and I remember feeling so happy when I did start, I found that for the first time ever that I was at the same level as my peers. I always felt so out of place before.

But then, someone has to be the youngest. I do feel for parents of summer born children.

Houselamp · 29/08/2022 16:23

Yes she was born August 29th and we didn't defer, it was totally fine.
She seemed very young to go but she was sociable and happy and loved school. Always got good grades.

I think the only noticable difference was that she was one of the smallest in the class. This did not matter in terms of PE or anything because she caught up by year 2 and all 4-7 year olds are awful at sports :)

It made no difference at all to her life that she was the youngest in the class- somebody has to be.

Fairislefandango · 29/08/2022 16:10

I have a late August dd. She was ready to go to school at 4 and we've never regretted it. She is very bright and was very socially aware for a 4yo. She's 17 now and about to apply to university.

Iamnotthe1 · 29/08/2022 16:05

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 15:47

That’s not entirely accurate these days @Iamnotthe1 - there is national statutory guidance which more or less guarantees the right for offset reception start for summer borns, if parents wish. There are some inconsistencies in application but they rarely stand up to appeal.

This is a common misconception: the right to defer is guarenteed but the rest is up for debate. The legislation states that the decision is the authority's to make, taking into account what they believe will be in the best interests of the child, and parents can only request it. Some authorities do this themselves after seeking the views of all involved, some create panels of 'experts' to discuss it and decide and some have panels which include the parents of the child (but not all do).

The legislation also states a similar discussion will occur at the transition to secondary school after the parent applies for a deferred start there too (whilst in Year 5). In most situations, they'll just let it continue but, again, the local authority can force a child to move year groups there if they believe it's in the best interests of the child.

Exhaustedcog · 29/08/2022 16:01

My little one is august born. She took a little time to settle in socially but totally found her feet during reception year. She just finished primary with beyond year expectations in all her sats. It was fine. All turned out well!

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 15:51

If you’re in England there is a statutory right for parents to request offset reception start @Mumteedum - some schools and LAs resist it a bit but it’s very difficult for them to decline and they almost never get away with it.

Gonewiththewind123 · 29/08/2022 15:47

That’s not entirely accurate these days @Iamnotthe1 - there is national statutory guidance which more or less guarantees the right for offset reception start for summer borns, if parents wish. There are some inconsistencies in application but they rarely stand up to appeal.

EHopes · 29/08/2022 15:30

I'm not in the uk, so had a little flexibility.

My first 2 are middle of the year group age wise. My younger 2 are summer born.

#3 really didn't seem ready to start and we ended up moving schools and having her repeat FYOS.

Based partly on that, we held our youngest back and he had a bonus kinder year. He had significant speech/communication problems and is happier being amongst the eldest. No regrets despite him being gifted and needing to be extended significantly in maths.

ChateauMargaux · 29/08/2022 14:58

Regardless of anecdotes, research shows that summer borns in the UK (where the school age cut off is 1 Sept) are disadvantaged in terms of academic and sporting achievements and that this disadvantage persists to third level and beyond.

My 14th August baby has just finished secondary school achieving A A A* and will take up a place at a top university in the coming weeks but there have been many times that I have thought he would have been better off with children in the lower age bracket. Academically, he has always held his own but socially, the difference have been evident, these differences compound themselves as summer borns never get to be at the same level as the older ones, they are always playing catch up.

He is lucky that the sport he plays is not very popular and has age divisions that span 3 years and the country he plays in has a 31 December cut off for age the result being that while he never shone in school where the cut off is 31 August for sport, he never received extra attention, outside of school he was player of the year, and ultimately team captain of the team that won a national competition as well as being selected to play with the national team and the local adults side.

All anecdotal, but, as I said, the research shows that this advantage persists beyond further education. On a population level, it does not level out in year 1.

Pinkandgreentrousers · 29/08/2022 14:57

I'm glad I didn't defer my August son, he would not have been pushed if he had waited a year and although emotionally he was younger, academically he did extremely well and is now at uni. The same as my other 2 summer babies.