Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you sent your August-born to school at 4 and later regretted it?

187 replies

Sandrine1982 · 29/08/2022 09:43

Hi

I know this has been discussed many times before but I'd like to hear from parents who have not deferred the school start for their kids.
I know some parents with August-born children and they all want to defer their children so they start reception at 5.
But I want to hear the other perspective.

Our DD is just 3 but the registration period will start soon and I really don't know what we should do. She was born 25 August but her due date was actually 1 September. She was born a bit early as I had to be induced.

She seems very bright and is an extremely active, lively, friendly and sociable child. She has been at nursery full time since she was 1 year old.
Her speech is developping fine and physically she's also developping great - she's quite tall and athletic for her age.

The only thing I'm worried about is emotional maturity and just general readiness for school. I'm not really worried about reception but her schooling later on, and the impact of school on her confidence levels if "it doesn't work out".

Can people offer their experiences if they haven't deferred and it all turned out ok?
And if we do send her to school and she's really struggling later on, can she repeat a year or something like that?
I'm not familiar with the UK system as I wasn't born here..

Thanks in advance.
xx

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sandrine1982 · 02/09/2022 16:31

@Thistleinthenight oh yes the tiredness is actually my biggest concern! DD still loves her naps, even though many kids her age have already dropped it :p

OP posts:
Sandrine1982 · 02/09/2022 16:30

Thank you all so much. I must say I'm leaning towards sending her next year, as expected. I spoke to the nursery staff and they said she will be ready. She's always gravitated towards older children so if I deferred, I might regret it more than if I didn't ... and if I deferred there is no way back, so to speak....

OP posts:
Thistleinthenight · 31/08/2022 09:39

My dd was late summer born. She used fall on to the floor to sleep as soon as we got her home from school at 4. She caught up in later years, but I always remember thinking that was hard on her.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 31/08/2022 06:43

It’s also a ridiculous piece of smug nonsense. So many people don’t get to plan even the time of year when their babies come. So many struggle to conceive. And talking about babies being ‘advanced’ well that has nothing to do with when they are born as the school year cohort doesn’t come in until they are four anyway.

That said, my summer babies were sort-of deliberate, it worked well with work for both of us and my DH was able to be home from work early all the way up until autumn (and it was less lonely with all the night feeding not being in the cold and dark).

I have worked for and with some incredibly intelligent people, some were summer born. A former boss was a world leading scientist, and FRS, his birthday is at the end of July.

Jumpking · 31/08/2022 06:32

This popped up as a Google suggestion. Made me think of this thread...apologies it's from The Sun

September babies

Gonewiththewind123 · 30/08/2022 19:59

The same is the case of many many preschool settings and the staff who work in them. Starting school later would delay starting formal education which is what we’re trying to say here. I can see all sides but do find the certainty and sureness disconcerting.

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 18:22

But Reception is largely play-based and child-led, not formal. It's just also run by people with teaching qualifications who have a much stronger idea of what the children need developmentally in order to best prepare them for their more formal education.

Gonewiththewind123 · 30/08/2022 18:15

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 18:05

In many cases, these children aren't identified until they are in school. In the examples I gave, the issue isn't that parents have been trying to access support and been unable to. In those examples, the parents are part of the problem. Whilst some children would be fine not starting school until later, leaving other children in environments that aren't stimulating or developmental would just serve to widen the attainment gap further.

If we are considering formal education as sat at tables having structured lessons, that typically doesn't start until Year One and, even then, in most settings Year One involves an element of provision based learning through play anyway.

There’s nothing to say though that extended play based early years non-school or preschool settings wouldn’t have the same outcome though. I can’t be as certain that formal education is the right thing to do!

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 18:05

In many cases, these children aren't identified until they are in school. In the examples I gave, the issue isn't that parents have been trying to access support and been unable to. In those examples, the parents are part of the problem. Whilst some children would be fine not starting school until later, leaving other children in environments that aren't stimulating or developmental would just serve to widen the attainment gap further.

If we are considering formal education as sat at tables having structured lessons, that typically doesn't start until Year One and, even then, in most settings Year One involves an element of provision based learning through play anyway.

Gonewiththewind123 · 30/08/2022 17:55

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 08:12

we start children in formal education way too young in England

Based on what?
I can say with certainty that if we didn't start when we do then we'd end up with some children with significant issues. For some children, the first time they've been in a stimulating environment is when they start school. I've lost count of the number of children, without SEN, who are struggling with communication because they don't get talked to at home or who can't use a toilet because, in the words of their parents, "Why would we teach them to go to the toilet? You're the teacher. It's your job."

You can't compare our school start to the likes of Finland without also comparing our societies, attitudes towards education, the support, education and training for parents and the expectations of parenting before the child starts school.

But there’s a distinction between formal education and what we know about when children are ready to learn formally, and making sure that children who need, or might need, additional support can access it early through the right means. One doesn’t necessarily mean the other.

dockspider · 30/08/2022 10:31

I also agree with you @MyBrilliantFriend - there’s actually a campaign to introduce a kindergarten stage going on in Scotland right now and there are a handful of kindergartens now open near me taking kids up to 6/7, though kids would currently have to transfer to P2/P3 if using that option.

DinosApple · 30/08/2022 10:12

Deferring wasn't an option for my child who is now 13.

She was one of four August born kids in her primary class. It was/is fine.

She is very bright, and has dyslexia (reading is her super power- but writing/spelling is her Achilles heel) and she is being assessed for ADHD. The primary tests they do are age adjusted.

But... An awful lot depends on the cohort which is something I never considered at the time. Her primary class were a lovely bunch of kids and she had good friends. But that is not always the case and I think that has a huge impact on children.

If your child is happy with their cohort I would not move them unless absolutely necessary.

randomsabreuse · 30/08/2022 09:57

In Scotland the youngest are 4 years and 6 months when they go to school (cut off end Feb) but lots of Jan and Feb born kids defer. So the age bands are wider but there's more flexibility to differentiate within the year group - from reading chapter books to basic phonics...

georgarina · 30/08/2022 09:54

MyBrilliantFriend · 30/08/2022 08:42

You will note I said FORMAL education.

Totally agree play- based provision is really important and appropriate from 3 or 4.

But we then expect them to pick up a pencil at just turned 4 and start forming letters accurately, and reading fluently etc etc. And the reality is that for many of these children it just doesn’t click until somewhere around Easter of Y1, so their first experience of school is that it’s all really hard - because they just aren’t there developmentally yet. And summer borns find it hardest of all (as a general rule).

It’s the content of the curriculum I’m referring to, rather than education of any kind.

Totally agree with this.

I started reception in the UK and HATED it - cried before school and begged not to go. I was the youngest, having just turned 4, and there was zero patience or tolerance - things like toilet accidents meant we were shouted at or made fun of by the teachers; we were constantly shouted at to 'hurry up!' or 'look what you've done,' and sit at desks without talking, and it was just a horrible and stressful experience.

Then I moved to the US and it was just completely different. Proper school starts a year later so there was much more acceptance and understanding of us being kids.

dockspider · 30/08/2022 09:46

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 09:25

That's not my experience at all, in any of the schools I've taught in ranging from naice village schools to those in areas of the highest deprivation. The children that we've had coming through our Receptions have loved the challenge and stimulation. They come up to older year groups, proudly showing off their letters and what they have written and created. The moment you step into their classroom, they mob you and are eager to show you everything that they've done and can do. It clicks well before Y1.

I haven’t had as much experience as you, but also had quite a different experience. I used to be a PSA in a very well to do catchment with P2 (Y1 equivalent) kids. Most of them were doing fine or well but there were a handful who had already made up their minds that they were stupid/hated reading/were rubbish at maths etc because they were simply kids that needed a bit more time before starting formal education. It’s so sad to hear a 6 year old child tell you that ‘books are boring’ because they can’t blend phonics, but in many other countries that same age child wouldn’t be expected to be learning to read yet. Or just setting off on it.

That was before I had kids of my own and was the first time I really started to question our education system!

whoruntheworldgirls · 30/08/2022 09:40

8 Aug daughter and didn't defer, she's going into year 2 in September and is doing really well, loves school and it's definitely helped her focus and be less distracted

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 09:25

That's not my experience at all, in any of the schools I've taught in ranging from naice village schools to those in areas of the highest deprivation. The children that we've had coming through our Receptions have loved the challenge and stimulation. They come up to older year groups, proudly showing off their letters and what they have written and created. The moment you step into their classroom, they mob you and are eager to show you everything that they've done and can do. It clicks well before Y1.

MyBrilliantFriend · 30/08/2022 08:42

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 08:12

we start children in formal education way too young in England

Based on what?
I can say with certainty that if we didn't start when we do then we'd end up with some children with significant issues. For some children, the first time they've been in a stimulating environment is when they start school. I've lost count of the number of children, without SEN, who are struggling with communication because they don't get talked to at home or who can't use a toilet because, in the words of their parents, "Why would we teach them to go to the toilet? You're the teacher. It's your job."

You can't compare our school start to the likes of Finland without also comparing our societies, attitudes towards education, the support, education and training for parents and the expectations of parenting before the child starts school.

You will note I said FORMAL education.

Totally agree play- based provision is really important and appropriate from 3 or 4.

But we then expect them to pick up a pencil at just turned 4 and start forming letters accurately, and reading fluently etc etc. And the reality is that for many of these children it just doesn’t click until somewhere around Easter of Y1, so their first experience of school is that it’s all really hard - because they just aren’t there developmentally yet. And summer borns find it hardest of all (as a general rule).

It’s the content of the curriculum I’m referring to, rather than education of any kind.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 30/08/2022 08:12

I have two summer born boys. Both started at just turned four - and one it was absolutely right for, the other not so much. The one who thrived was academically ready but socially behind, and the one who has had more difficulty was socially ready but academically not, if that helps at all. Covid has muddied the waters a little, so it’s hard to say whether he would still have found things difficult having not had half of year R as homeschool and missed half of preschool. He’s getting there now.

interestingly, the child who did well was at the tail end of a social group of children who fitted into his year group, the other child is the eldest of a group who went through nursery etc together, so I don’t know if that played into it perhaps and goes all the way back to his early years.

So I’d probably say that I’d give most children the benefit of the doubt for mainstream entry, especially if academically ready. I’d consider holding back if there were issues with things like pen grip, fine motor, speech, any indicator that they are not ready to write.

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 08:12

we start children in formal education way too young in England

Based on what?
I can say with certainty that if we didn't start when we do then we'd end up with some children with significant issues. For some children, the first time they've been in a stimulating environment is when they start school. I've lost count of the number of children, without SEN, who are struggling with communication because they don't get talked to at home or who can't use a toilet because, in the words of their parents, "Why would we teach them to go to the toilet? You're the teacher. It's your job."

You can't compare our school start to the likes of Finland without also comparing our societies, attitudes towards education, the support, education and training for parents and the expectations of parenting before the child starts school.

Ladylalaboo1 · 30/08/2022 08:10

My middle child was born end of July - it's tricky as she's now going in year 2 and has only just caught up and actually ahead of a quite a few peers. Not sure if this is down to a few things though. Obviously covid had a major impact, during a time when she would have been in reception/year 1 - learning to read etc. That and also she has severely bad vision in one eye, so for nursery, reception and half of year one was wearing patches. - we decided to stop the patching in jan as it wasn't working anyway and was effecting her confidence and ability to write or read etc - since we did that, and backed up by teacher, she completely changed - brilliant concentration so much more confident- her end of year phonics results were brilliant ( in the past she's been below) it's like for the last 6 months a light switch was flipped and it all just started to fit. So I'm not sure whether it's the young age thing or if it's the eye sight. I'm more inclined to think eye sight tbh. I did earlier on definitely notice a major difference with her and some of the older kids in her year that were born in sept/oct - just generally bigger and I noticed were in higher groups for reading etc. But like I've said it's evened out now. I don't think I would have deferred - she has a sister in the year above and was desperate to be in school and I think for nursery and reception especially it's more about foundations rather than really difficult work - (and with covid she wasn't even in much anyway ) but it was definitely the best for her imo - I think you know your child best and what would be the most Beneficial for them - for us not deferring was the best option and she's happy - I also think she probably would have been this way regardless when we started her as it was more likely the vision so it's just got it out of the way. She's never been the clingy type tbh runs off even now every morning happy -in contrast her sister who is an early November baby was really clingy would cry most mornings even in reception and even now some mornings will be more loveing and not want to leave. So I think predominately it's dependant on the child - for sure.

AmberDrop · 30/08/2022 08:08

Mid-August born DS for us and we didn’t consider deferring for a second.

He has done brilliantly at school and we have no regrets. It was a bit of a shock when he started after just turning 4 and then in the first week another child was having a 5th birthday party. A bit worrying to think how he would compare to a child so ,much older, but it was never an issue.

The only difference we noticed was around emotional resilience. DS was quicker to get tearful in challenging situations. But good teachers and TAs can help with this and grow confidence - along with support at home.

My top tip would be never to mention to DD that she is the youngest in the class or the year. She just doesn’t need to know and it’s best to avoid it becoming a distraction or ‘reason’ for any issues in her mind. Good luck!

OrlandointheWilderness · 30/08/2022 08:02

And yes, she did get 11+ weighting, but I think it is fair considering some of her classmates are just about a full year older than her. And she scored high enough she would've passed anyway.

OrlandointheWilderness · 30/08/2022 08:00

Oh she's just about to start secondary (grammar)

OrlandointheWilderness · 30/08/2022 08:00

My DD is 31st. We didn't defer and have never had an issue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread