Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
unicormb · 29/08/2022 14:25

I would have my autistic son over and over again if I could, he is pure magic.

If I'd had the choice before having him, and not knowing what I know and how much I would adore him, I would've aborted him. I'd have imagined a life of misery and drudgery. And if there had been a way to screen for it, and staff kept mentioning how I could abort him, I'd have absolutely been influenced by that and figured it was the right thing to do because they kept saying it so much.

On balance my child makes me feel joy rather than regret. But if his condition were screenable I'm certain he wouldn't exist. And because of that I didn't screen my second child.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 14:25

Fifife · 29/08/2022 14:11

I'm a HCP I mostly work with people with learning disabilities. The pro life group always present the best case scenario of a cute child with DS. Not the hormonal large teenager doubly incontinent smearing and physically attacking people then getting dementia at age 40. People should be allowed to say they don't want that life long responsibility. Parents are then doubly shamed when they ask the state to take over the care. I've had frail parents of adult children crying for support as their child is assaulting them but they are too old to safely restrain and look after them. I love my job but it's made me very pro choice , I can go home when I leave work for the parents is 24/7 with pitiful respite.

It's individual choice

It’s a very good point about all the ‘poster children’ being either very young and adorable, or very high functioning adults such as Heidi or Reuben from CBeebies etc. It does seem like they say they want ‘balanced information’ to be given to expectant parents but simultaneously only show the more ‘socially accepted’ version of DS.

OP posts:
Fifife · 29/08/2022 14:25

If the state funded proper respite care , part time placements and behavioural interventions more women might want to continue a pregnancy. You can't expect women to want to have children with disabilities when the support is shocking.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 14:25

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:18

Fair point, but @FarmerRefuted stated they were fine with abortion being legal on the grounds of deafness. I have mentioned my friend, but I am sure there are many partially or wholly deaf people who lead happy, useful lives. Do you think there should have been an option to abort them on the grounds of their hearing not being perfect?

No, what I said was that I think women should be given all available information about their pregnancy so that they can make an informed choice about whether or not to continue.

Which choice they make is their own decision.

LangClegsInSpace · 29/08/2022 14:24

There is no list of conditions gnilliwdog. Abortion past 24 weeks is allowed if a foetus's condition is likely to result in serious disability. It's an individual clinical decision between a doctor and a pregnant woman, backed up by a second medical opinion.

Canada has no legal time limit. Women there sometimes have problems accessing abortion care in the first place but as far as I know, the lack of time limit itself does not cause any problems.

Like us, Canada has a well regulated medical profession.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:24

@Wouldloveanother My children are noyb. But I do think it's a joyless attitude to reject difference. Again, thank goodness you don't make the laws, where it's acceptable to terminate any one without 100% hearing, 20/20 vision and a nice NT mind.

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:24

Now that is just disingenuous. You would advocate for late term abortions for all foetuses to create a theoretical parity knowing that the outcomes would largely remain the same.

It’s not disingenuous at all. The outcomes could remain the same, they could change if society’s largely shit attitude towards disability changed.
To me “I don’t want this baby” is valid at any stage of pregnancy, for any reason. The limit for abortion should not be lowered, but it should not be extended for one particular health condition either. It should be extended for all.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 14:21

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:02

I am glad we live in a society where you don't get to make the laws. @FarmerRefuted @pointythings Yes, I have a friend who is considerably deaf, who holds a good degree, is a brilliant teacher and an asset to the world. I have friends with autism and ADHD who have a different take on the world that only enriches it. Some of them are highly intelligent, they are all honest and kind people. There is no question in my mind as to whether they should be here or not, or whether a doctor would be justified in offering to abort them because they were different.

There seem to be a lot of people without disabled children who feel indulgently ‘uncomfortable’ at the thought of disabled fetuses being terminated, because they want to ‘see diverse people around them’ like they’re some kind of art installation. Before leaving the caring responsibilities for those people to others, obviously.

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:18

x2boys · 29/08/2022 14:06

I have a child with severe autism and learning disabilities, he's just as disabled and in many cases more so then a child with down syndrome ,that's the thing you have no way of knowing how a child with a condition such as autism or down syndrome andcmany other disabilities are going to be impacted on one end of the scale you can have a person lead a fairly normal independent life and on the other a person will need 1:1 care 24/7 for the rest of their lives .

Fair point, but @FarmerRefuted stated they were fine with abortion being legal on the grounds of deafness. I have mentioned my friend, but I am sure there are many partially or wholly deaf people who lead happy, useful lives. Do you think there should have been an option to abort them on the grounds of their hearing not being perfect?

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 14:17

It’s sad we’ve reached a point where advocating for people with a disability to live fulfilled, happy lives is taken as an assault on a woman’s right to choose.

Now that is just disingenuous. You would advocate for late term abortions for all foetuses to create a theoretical parity knowing that the outcomes would largely remain the same.

The campaigners are advocating for restriction on terminations on foetuses with disabilities - knowing fine we'll that the window for an informed is completely changed because of the anomaly scanning dates.

It's not pro choicers building an antagonist narrative with disability campaigners here.

NFLBingo · 29/08/2022 14:16

PotatoHammock · 29/08/2022 12:34

Just to be clear, many medical conditions are only picked up at the 20 week anatomy scan. It's categorically untrue to say that "many surgeons" in the UK refuse to carry out abortions after 18 weeks. Medical professionals abide by the law not their own arbitrary gut feelings.

That depends on where they’re located, it’s absolutely true that those who are hired by charities and private termination clinics are able to set their own limits, some go to the legal limits whereas others choose lower, they also set their own rules on who they will or will not perform the procedure on (no more than X c-sections etc).
I’m also talking about choosing to abort a full-term pregnancy for any reason anyway, not due to medical abnormalities, that is a different kettle of fish.

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:12

they could rally their resources and push for that very thing today.

They do. I support several organisations that do that very thing.
It’s sad we’ve reached a point where advocating for people with a disability to live fulfilled, happy lives is taken as an assault on a woman’s right to choose.

Fifife · 29/08/2022 14:11

I'm a HCP I mostly work with people with learning disabilities. The pro life group always present the best case scenario of a cute child with DS. Not the hormonal large teenager doubly incontinent smearing and physically attacking people then getting dementia at age 40. People should be allowed to say they don't want that life long responsibility. Parents are then doubly shamed when they ask the state to take over the care. I've had frail parents of adult children crying for support as their child is assaulting them but they are too old to safely restrain and look after them. I love my job but it's made me very pro choice , I can go home when I leave work for the parents is 24/7 with pitiful respite.

It's individual choice

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 14:09

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:07

They could continue to campaign for greater awareness and support and that would be fine.
The basis for abortion would be fair. Every woman permitted to choose, up to term, for whatever reason. If there are more abortions for a particular reason then people can campaign against that reason. They just can’t block the abortion a woman may want.

But they could do that, they could rally their resources and push for that very thing today.

x2boys · 29/08/2022 14:08

That doesn't mean my son isn't dearly loved or doesn't have a great quality of life however

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:07

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 14:04

The timeframe should not just be for medical reasons then. It should be for social reasons, or mental health reasons or Know what, I just don’t want to be pregnant anymore reasons

And, what happens when the late term abortions remain, for the pragmatic reasons around anomaly testing dates, almost exclusively those women who are terminating disabled children? Will disability right campaigners simply adopt a different tactic to manouvere women into birthing babies with disabilities?

They could continue to campaign for greater awareness and support and that would be fine.
The basis for abortion would be fair. Every woman permitted to choose, up to term, for whatever reason. If there are more abortions for a particular reason then people can campaign against that reason. They just can’t block the abortion a woman may want.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 14:07

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:02

I am glad we live in a society where you don't get to make the laws. @FarmerRefuted @pointythings Yes, I have a friend who is considerably deaf, who holds a good degree, is a brilliant teacher and an asset to the world. I have friends with autism and ADHD who have a different take on the world that only enriches it. Some of them are highly intelligent, they are all honest and kind people. There is no question in my mind as to whether they should be here or not, or whether a doctor would be justified in offering to abort them because they were different.

I have two disabled children.

x2boys · 29/08/2022 14:06

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 13:51

You are fine with making abortion legal for autism, partial deafness or visual impairments? Jeez, that's some Brave New World scenario. To any disabled people or parents reading this - I love the world with difference in it. This is the society I want, not some world where it is acceptable to screen out anyone who doesn't fit some narrow band of 'acceptable.'

I have a child with severe autism and learning disabilities, he's just as disabled and in many cases more so then a child with down syndrome ,that's the thing you have no way of knowing how a child with a condition such as autism or down syndrome andcmany other disabilities are going to be impacted on one end of the scale you can have a person lead a fairly normal independent life and on the other a person will need 1:1 care 24/7 for the rest of their lives .

LangClegsInSpace · 29/08/2022 14:05

I would let the voices of people with DS and those of their families be heard, for a start. Stop force teaming them with pro lifers and referring to them in derogatory ways, as on this thread.

Who is force teaming them?

I said nothing about people with DS and their families in general. But the people behind the court case, Don't Screen Us Out, the DS Act, the APPG and the NDSPG are pro-lifers. It's the same small, highly organised group of people.

This is a good article, written by a disability rights campaigner who has a profoundly disabled child:

https://makingrightsmakesense.wordpress.com/2022/01/21/a-cunning-fox/

BrownTableMat · 29/08/2022 14:04

I think that one issue is that conditions like autism or even DS cover such a spectrum of impairment. We all probably know people with diagnosed autism who lead happy and fulfilling lives, with minimal support needs. We have probably also all met people with DS who similarly function well and are happy (though very, very few of them will not need significant support and care throughout their lives). However, by definition we will tend to see far less of the non-verbal autistic person who needs 24-hour specialist care and is dangerously violent towards their caregivers, or the severely-affected person with DS who will never walk or talk and whose life will be tragically blighted and cut short by physical health issues. And we certainly don’t see the toll that having a child so impaired will take on a family, and on the child’s mother in particular.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 14:04

The timeframe should not just be for medical reasons then. It should be for social reasons, or mental health reasons or Know what, I just don’t want to be pregnant anymore reasons

And, what happens when the late term abortions remain, for the pragmatic reasons around anomaly testing dates, almost exclusively those women who are terminating disabled children? Will disability right campaigners simply adopt a different tactic to manouvere women into birthing babies with disabilities?

Mumspair1 · 29/08/2022 14:04

Samcro · 29/08/2022 09:34

@PicturesOfDogs why is it ok for a disability? I really don't understand.

What is confusing? A child with a disability has far, far greater needs than one without. Surely that bit is obvious. I don't agree with having one if there is nothing wrong with a child.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 14:03

My concern is the disproportionate testing and subsequent pressure put on women to abort for Down Syndrome.

There’s testing for all sorts of conditions; early testing identifies Downs Syndrome as well as other trisomy incompatible with life. Other conditions are picked up as a result of routine scans. Amniocentesis picks up Downs, Spina Bifida and some other conditions. If results are positive, the provisions of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 come in to play. Nobody should be pressured and I am reasonably sure most doctors give a prognosis and let parents make up their minds. If parents want more information, there’s loads available on-line.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:02

I am glad we live in a society where you don't get to make the laws. @FarmerRefuted @pointythings Yes, I have a friend who is considerably deaf, who holds a good degree, is a brilliant teacher and an asset to the world. I have friends with autism and ADHD who have a different take on the world that only enriches it. Some of them are highly intelligent, they are all honest and kind people. There is no question in my mind as to whether they should be here or not, or whether a doctor would be justified in offering to abort them because they were different.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 14:00

I think the timeframe is about right for non-medical reasons seeing as, at present, women have until 24wks to make a decision along the lines of "I don't want to be pregnant anymore" and the overwhelming majority take care of that issue prior to 10wks with the remaining majority of them sorting it by 20wks - only 1% take place at that point.