Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 15:05

*Who said they're inferior?"

It's pretty obvious that this is a deeply held belief. It is apparently vital that society retain the right to use medical advances to kill them while other babies enjoy protection from those medical 'treatments'. That kind of eugenics doesn't exist without an underlying philosophical position that death for a child like this is a lesser thing, and correspondingly, that their life is less valuable. It's unnecessary. We will never get far in women's rights by trampling on the rights of vulnerable others - it doesn't build the kind of logic that leads to a fairer society.

mrtumblescrackdealer · 29/08/2022 15:05

For all of those saying that rejecting difference isn't acceptable, and that people with a disability are a blessing, from what basis have you made that decision?

Let me tell you about my son. He's 9. I love him to bits. He has an x linked, familial dominant syndrome that has almost full penetrance. In layman's terms that means that if you're a boy born into my family, you are almost certainly going to have the family syndrome. We just don't know what it is yet.
He might be 9 but cognitively he is much younger. Imagine a 9 year old toddler because that's effectively what he is. Toddler mentality with the size and strength of a 9 year old. It's an interesting mix. Before I had him I had no idea what the acronyms DLA/HRC/ASD/SEMH/EHCP/VCB/CPVA/ISP/MLD and lots more besides meant. All of those apply to him now.
His care is constant. He cannot be left alone for a second. Things like drinking out of the toilet, eating soap and soil, attempting to jump out of second floor windows, releasing his seatbelt in moving vehicles, running away, tantrums and meltdowns are all commonplace in my house. I live in fort knox. All my upstairs windows have restrictors on them. All my downstairs windows are locked. I have door alarms on my front and back door. I've already ended up in A and E once this summer as a direct result of my son's actions. My mental health is absolutely wrecked and I live day-day. I haven't worked since I was 20 weeks pregnant with him. I can't work. The amount of time I spend on dealing with his needs is well in excess of a full time job.

And there is absolutely no support whatsoever if you have a disabled child with complex needs. Respite. Doesn't exist. Carers. I've been advertising without success for 2 years. He's in an independent specialist school costing my local authority in the region of £125k per annum because there was nothing suitable in my county for him. Disability benefits are absolutely shocking as well. Before I had my son I was earning on average 32k per annum. Now I no longer work, my wages are paid by the government in the form of carer's allowance. It works out at 41p per HOUR. Fwiw if you are recruiting private carers for a disabled child, the going rate in my area is around £20 per hour.

I am by no means the only person in this situation. Its a scenario borne out by many, many parent carers caring for disabled children that I know of and also nationally.

As for my attitude on abortion because of disability, I believe that everyone has the right to make the decision that is right for them and their family. No-one has the right to say what anyone else should or shouldn't be doing. A lot of the campaigns doing the rounds at the moment about abortion on the grounds of disability have (in my opinion) a completely unrealistic view of what it's actually like to be the parent of a disabled child.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 29/08/2022 15:03

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:53

I would let the voices of people with DS and those of their families be heard, for a start. Stop force teaming them with pro lifers and referring to them in derogatory ways, as on this thread.

No one tells a pregnant teenager their life will be horrendous and not worth living if they give birth. We should stop telling women with markers for DS that, too.

Because those two situations are not equivalent. A teenage mother may find life as a parent more difficult ( or with the right support and circumstances, she may be perfectly okay - and so may her child). A severely disabled child which may or may not survive into a severely disabled adult has very serious impacts on the family and on other children within the family. Many grow up to have difficult and frustrating lives.

DS campaigners always seem to feature the more high functioning members, well, of course, they would. The doubly incontinent, non verbal do not feature, nor those who probably suffer even more, those who have enough awareness to know how limited their lives are . And yes, I do know what I am talking about first hand, although thankfully not as a parent.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 15:01

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:53

@unicormb There is something weird to me about a bunch of people declaring another group inferior, less able, less worthy. Even the word 'disabled' is strange to me, with its assumption that there is one right way to be.

A child with disabilities isn't a group. He or she is an individual, as is the pregnant woman who is also the most statistically likely individual responsible for cobblimg together scant and ever changing resources in order to support to provide a good quality of life for this child against a backdrop of a multitude of confounding responsibilities that might make that impossible.

EveningOverRooftops · 29/08/2022 14:59

Fifife · 29/08/2022 14:11

I'm a HCP I mostly work with people with learning disabilities. The pro life group always present the best case scenario of a cute child with DS. Not the hormonal large teenager doubly incontinent smearing and physically attacking people then getting dementia at age 40. People should be allowed to say they don't want that life long responsibility. Parents are then doubly shamed when they ask the state to take over the care. I've had frail parents of adult children crying for support as their child is assaulting them but they are too old to safely restrain and look after them. I love my job but it's made me very pro choice , I can go home when I leave work for the parents is 24/7 with pitiful respite.

It's individual choice

I agree. I have a friend who’s daughter has downs and is close in age to me.

he’s very pro life because he sees abortion for downs as his daughter being murdered but he’s also massively worried (he’s 55) at his daughter getting dementia. She still lives at home. Still needs a lot of support in her 30s

he’s lucky, really lucky, that even with the mentality of an 8-10 yo his daughter is a very very gentle being.

we talked about living wills recently and how I have it written that if I get dementia or any other issues that limits my cognitive ability significantly and is incurable and progressive I don’t want treatment for cancer, palliative care only. Or antibiotics to treat sepsis or pneumonia. I must be allowed to die.

it struck me his daughter doesn’t have that choice. She’s never had capacity to make that choice nor can she comprehend what dementia is. The majority if not all downs children do not have that capacity.

my own DC has a chromosome deletion, needs a lot of supervision despite being ‘normal’ because they behave in a risky way. Poss adhd and asd going on.

im not having any more children be ause my risk of another child with genetic issues could be high but I do want them and if I did get pregnant o would be having the whole battery of tests and would abort if I felt it necessary. I know my limits and they’re very low these days. I’m old and tired.

being a parent carer to a child with significant needs is a multifaceted long term grief and can leave families broken.

grief for the child you thought you’d have and grief for the child who isn’t capable of living the experience you’ve had. It’s the hard side of it no one wants to talk about and it all exists in such starkly different ways for different people. Try to talk about it and you’re told by those without kids you’re ‘lucky to have one’ fuck off. I’ve lost kids too. They’re very different pains.

my child isn’t ‘normal’ and isn’t having ‘normal’ experiences like their peers but I’m still incredibly lucky my DC should be able to live independently, just a bit later than most (though house prices and rent my DC for once might actually be ‘normal’)

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 14:58

could

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 14:57

The more we abort for disability, the less normal it will be for children and adults with disabilities to exist. Fewer provisions will be offered and reasonable adjustments will be made less often because there is so little demand. This will increase the pressure to have further terminations because there is so little in place. With there being so little in place to help and disability less common in society, it will be harder for women who wish to carry to justify keeping disabled babies to their families and doctors. If it goes on, we will have taken part in an exercise in eugenics while thinking we were focusing on women's rights.

So many reproductive choices threads end in posters being told they've no business to consider having their baby in adverse circumstances as it is - this does not constitute choice for me. I cannot imagine the hurdles those posters would have them jump through to justify having a disabled child. And yet they shouldn't have to do anything of the sort in a truly civilised society.

For feminists who only consider women it may be ok to have different rules for disabilities, even when the child couldn't have lived a fine life without hearing, with DS or with a cleft palate. It's not for me. I am as uncomfortable with a society where no one knows what DS is because those babies were all aborted as I am with a society where women aren't offered an intervention for DS after 24 weeks. It's not forced birth. Birth of some description (and who would really find it easier to deliver a dismembered late term baby) is inescapable at that point. Doctors are not fairy godmothers who can wave a wand.

OhmygodDont · 29/08/2022 14:56

I’d be happy for them to screen for everything if they could and it would then still be the womens right as to if she continues that pregnancy. It’s her body and the majority of the time it would be her giving up work or taking on any extra burden that having a disabled child would bring. Be that the extra hospital appointments, learning sign language, translation for those who don’t, time off though school exclusions, never getting any respite from a child who frowns into a very much stronger than them adult who cannot live alone but isn’t given a care place. Mothers who are looked down upon if they do place the same children into those fully funded care places with excellent staff.

it’s never men is it and it’s always women judging those women who go no I can’t do that.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 14:54

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:53

@unicormb There is something weird to me about a bunch of people declaring another group inferior, less able, less worthy. Even the word 'disabled' is strange to me, with its assumption that there is one right way to be.

Who said they’re inferior?

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:53

@unicormb There is something weird to me about a bunch of people declaring another group inferior, less able, less worthy. Even the word 'disabled' is strange to me, with its assumption that there is one right way to be.

Ciela · 29/08/2022 14:51

I have a disability (dyspraxia) and I am absolutely pro choice. My disability cannot be picked up on any scan but I am at the less affected end of the scale. I am married, have in the past had a full time job (thank you covid) and own a property. I occasionally trip over my own feet or slitter food and drink. At the other end of the scale because is affects amongst other things both fine and gross motor skills and coordination people at the other end of the scale struggle to stand up, walk and write.

BrownTableMat · 29/08/2022 14:50

I also think the debate is presented in a misleading way, very often. There was a high-profile case a few years back where someone was going on about how termination for a cleft palate was allowed, and this was terrible as a happy adult who’d been born with a cleft palate. On the face of it, this was verging on a reasonable argument. However, when you look into it, cleft palate picked up on a scan is rarely ‘just’ a cleft palate, I believe, and is more likely to be one indication among others of serious problems, many incompatible with life. Similarly, deafness picked up in utero could be ‘just’ deafness, or it could be one indication that something is very seriously wrong.

unicormb · 29/08/2022 14:47

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 14:44

Well no, D&E is also an option when it comes to late term abortion. It is not the case that the ’baby will come out’ in a way that mimics live birth.

I'm not sure giving birth to a decapitated baby would be any easier. It's quite a leap - and rather counter intuitive - to believe most women could believe they hadn't just given birth on the basis that the baby was delivered in parts.

We don't need to talk about forced birth. Birth is what naturally happens and there really is no meaningful way to avoid that. Doctors aren't there to make babies disappear, nor can they.

So much of this thread is horrifically disablist.

You mean ableist

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 14:47

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 14:44

Because if nobody’s going to do it, what is the point in changing the law? There still have to be reasons, both before and after 24 weeks, and 2 doctors have to agree.

Because the campaigners say this is specifically about discrimination within the law (although I suspect that’s not the full story). So then they would have it wouldn’t they?

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 29/08/2022 14:47

But it seems somewhat of a distraction when disability campaigners highlighted in the op are not proposing this at all.

I don't think it is a distraction. The appeal case that was recently heard was on the grounds that having different time limits constitutes unlawful indirect discrimination towards already born disabled people by implying their lives are worth less, and thus stigmatising them.

It's doubtful they will win because, even if the judge decides it does amount to indirect discrimination, this would still be lawful as a a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. But if they lose they will doubtless campaign for a change in the law through parliament.

Removing the time limit altogether would take away this argument, once and for all.

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 14:44

Well no, D&E is also an option when it comes to late term abortion. It is not the case that the ’baby will come out’ in a way that mimics live birth.

I'm not sure giving birth to a decapitated baby would be any easier. It's quite a leap - and rather counter intuitive - to believe most women could believe they hadn't just given birth on the basis that the baby was delivered in parts.

We don't need to talk about forced birth. Birth is what naturally happens and there really is no meaningful way to avoid that. Doctors aren't there to make babies disappear, nor can they.

So much of this thread is horrifically disablist.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 14:44

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:31

Then there wouldn’t be a rise in post-24 week abortions, @CecilyP so why not extend it to term anyway? If you can terminate for a disability you can terminate for any reason whatsoever. In fact, why have to give a reason at all?

Because if nobody’s going to do it, what is the point in changing the law? There still have to be reasons, both before and after 24 weeks, and 2 doctors have to agree.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 14:35

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:31

Then there wouldn’t be a rise in post-24 week abortions, @CecilyP so why not extend it to term anyway? If you can terminate for a disability you can terminate for any reason whatsoever. In fact, why have to give a reason at all?

Well, I agree, this is fair - if not unnecessary.

But it seems somewhat of a distraction when disability campaigners highlighted in the op are not proposing this at all.

x2boys · 29/08/2022 14:31

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:18

Fair point, but @FarmerRefuted stated they were fine with abortion being legal on the grounds of deafness. I have mentioned my friend, but I am sure there are many partially or wholly deaf people who lead happy, useful lives. Do you think there should have been an option to abort them on the grounds of their hearing not being perfect?

It's not my choice ,is it as others say if you agree with pro choice ,then it has to be for whatever reason
Personally no I don't think I could have an abortion it unless the circumstances were extreme, but it's not my place to tell others what to do
I also don't think women should be pressured into abortion for disability,either ultimately whatever they decide it should be up to them.

pointythings · 29/08/2022 14:31

@gnilliwdog it isn't about a list of 'differences', it's about each individual woman being able to assess what she will be dealing with and what she can handle as a parent. I very much doubt that many people would abort for deafness and blindness. Autism - probably a higher number, given it's a range of severity and you don't know where your child will fall. As I said, I wouldn't have aborted. I've been lucky - my autistic child will be able to live independently (though they have physical disabilities too, as of recently).

@Wouldloveanother my youngest is definitely an art installation. They have many piercings, blue hair (to match the blue wheelchair) and writes very good poetry as a hobby whilst doing a marine biology degree.

Saucery · 29/08/2022 14:31

Then there wouldn’t be a rise in post-24 week abortions, @CecilyP so why not extend it to term anyway? If you can terminate for a disability you can terminate for any reason whatsoever. In fact, why have to give a reason at all?

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 14:27

The timeframe should not just be for medical reasons then. It should be for social reasons, or mental health reasons or Know what, I just don’t want to be pregnant anymore reasons.

But women know those reasons we’ll before 24 weeks and generally act upon them. It is the very occasional one that is so late and so serious that it is allowed within the provisions of the 1990 Act.

Sirzy · 29/08/2022 14:27

This is nothing to do with trying to get rid of disability. It’s to do with giving women the choice and it’s nobody else’s place to judge that choice which must be horrendous to make.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 14:26

Fifife · 29/08/2022 14:25

If the state funded proper respite care , part time placements and behavioural interventions more women might want to continue a pregnancy. You can't expect women to want to have children with disabilities when the support is shocking.

I agree! I would have much less hesitation about having a disabled baby if there was great provision in place for them, to help them but also so I could retain quality of life.

OP posts:
Cam22 · 29/08/2022 14:25

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 09:36

How can an adult human with a functioning brain not understand some people don't want to give birth to disabled children?

Exactly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread