Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
GingerCake2018 · 29/08/2022 16:29

entropynow · 29/08/2022 16:23

Yes well how lovely for them. Proves nothing. If you really want balance, lets have less of the success narrative.

I hope if her child is in mainstream school they will be one of the few capable of living fully independently in society, however if not, I wonder what her opinion will be when she is in her late 70s like my Aunt and uncle, facing leaving behind a disabled adult child that never has and never will be independent.

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 16:27

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:53

I would let the voices of people with DS and those of their families be heard, for a start. Stop force teaming them with pro lifers and referring to them in derogatory ways, as on this thread.

No one tells a pregnant teenager their life will be horrendous and not worth living if they give birth. We should stop telling women with markers for DS that, too.

Many people tell teens just that

Have you not seen the posts on the millions of 'help my 16yo DD is pregnant' posts that pop up all the time on chat, 30 days only, Teenagers and relationships

unicormb · 29/08/2022 16:23

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 16:20

@unicormb but there’s a difference between a theoretical, non-born child and knowing and loving the one that you have. For example I aborted as a teen due to my age and how it would limit my life. I’m sure if I’d gone through with the pregnancy I would’ve loved the child, and not have wished retrospectively that I’d aborted, if that makes sense.

Yes I agree, if he didn't exist it would be a different story. But I am very easily led (thanks autism) and if a doctor repeatedly offered me an abortion I would probably think I had to take it.

entropynow · 29/08/2022 16:23

UndertheCedartree · 29/08/2022 10:39

I have a friend with a DC who has Down's Syndrome. By all accounts he is thriving. He can walk and talk and attends mainstream school. She is very vocal about the negative attitude of the medics towards her DC. She feels more balanced information should be given.

Yes well how lovely for them. Proves nothing. If you really want balance, lets have less of the success narrative.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 16:20

@unicormb but there’s a difference between a theoretical, non-born child and knowing and loving the one that you have. For example I aborted as a teen due to my age and how it would limit my life. I’m sure if I’d gone through with the pregnancy I would’ve loved the child, and not have wished retrospectively that I’d aborted, if that makes sense.

OP posts:
unicormb · 29/08/2022 16:17

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 16:10

I'd fight tooth and nail for my existing DC (and I do on a regular basis) but if I was to get pregnant again I'd have an abortion as quickly as possible because I'm at my capacity for how much care I can give a(nother) disabled child.

And I think it's absolutely fair to say that. And 100% your right.

I am pro choice, even when it comes to disability, but I share my story about my DS because I know he wouldn't exist if doctors had pushed an abortion at me, knowing myself and the sort of person I was before he was here. The choice should exist. But maybe the way that disability and options thereafter are discussed by obstetricians and their staff needs a rethink.

entropynow · 29/08/2022 16:13

MrsGluck · 29/08/2022 08:34

I thought the documentary was really good. I was in tears over the part where Ruth Madeley talks to a woman who had an abortion so she wouldn't give birth to a child with the condition Ruth has. It must have been an incredibly difficult conversation.

I noticed that the documentary never mentioned getting rid of the disability discrimination by allowing all abortions for all women without any time limits.

It won't because scans still happen and social pressure is still against disability.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 16:10

I'd fight tooth and nail for my existing DC (and I do on a regular basis) but if I was to get pregnant again I'd have an abortion as quickly as possible because I'm at my capacity for how much care I can give a(nother) disabled child.

unicormb · 29/08/2022 16:03

Fifife · 29/08/2022 15:45

I always think to parents screw what society thinks say you can't cope and will put them into care (even if you don't mean it). SS don't pull their fingers out until parents are at breaking point.

They really don't. They just assume you're all ticking along fine. Then when they finally come to assess you (because you have threatened them with the law about 50 times) they see that DH is in recovery from alcoholism because the last few years were so stressful, and that Mum's mind and body are gradually falling to bits. And that DC is actually disabled, and needs a lot of help to do everything, and suddenly somehow IS eligible for extra support/direct payments/respite etc, when three months ago they were bending over backwards to tell you they weren't disabled enough.

But as I said before, I would do it all again because my DS is my shining beacon of loveliness in a sea of bureaucratic bullshit.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 15:53

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 15:05

*Who said they're inferior?"

It's pretty obvious that this is a deeply held belief. It is apparently vital that society retain the right to use medical advances to kill them while other babies enjoy protection from those medical 'treatments'. That kind of eugenics doesn't exist without an underlying philosophical position that death for a child like this is a lesser thing, and correspondingly, that their life is less valuable. It's unnecessary. We will never get far in women's rights by trampling on the rights of vulnerable others - it doesn't build the kind of logic that leads to a fairer society.

But neither testing nor termination are compulsory. Many women reject both. Other women know their limitations and what they can cope with. It is they, not society, that will have the bulk of caring responsibility.

Fifife · 29/08/2022 15:45

I always think to parents screw what society thinks say you can't cope and will put them into care (even if you don't mean it). SS don't pull their fingers out until parents are at breaking point.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 29/08/2022 15:45

I think I remember Dominic Lawson campaigning against a minimum wage in catering for under 21 year olds, the reason being that his daughter was currently employed ( in a sheltered way) in a local pub for a small wage. They couldn’t pay her the full MW because she was not doing a full job. It would be illegal to employ her for less, or for nothing.

I have every sympathy for anyone trying to do their best for their child, but not at the expense of everyone else’s child. Lawson just wants to alter law for his personal perceived benefit.

unicormb · 29/08/2022 15:42

The fight for care is exhausting. We are only now, with my son at 8 years old, accessing the care and support he deserves, as we now have a disability specific social worker and a directory payment package for respite hours. That support unlocked a lot of other things - free summer school with 1-1 assistance, blue badge application supporting statements etc etc. It took me two years of fighting to get that help, and three rejections, and I did give up at times, and have to come back to it all after a break. In the end it's finally paid off, and as his social worker said to me recently 'His involvement with us will increase as he gets older, rather than decrease, so it's good we have him in our books now'.

I also had to take our LA to tribunal for his school place.

My son needs 1-1 care at all times, as like a PP said he's like a toddler in a bigger child's body (no impulse control, v little danger awareness, sensory seeking by mouthing things etc etc). And it's exhausting. But I swear I would still have him all over again even if I knew what I was getting into. I can't imagine life without him, the idea leaves me cold.

Fifife · 29/08/2022 15:41

I know a family friend who had a safeguarding raised against her her daughter is in her 40s with DS and has dementia. Family friend was giving her lots of Lorazepam as family friend is is in her 70s and her DD was becoming violent. It's easy for people to judge but when offered no support and early support isn't given. Her DD was sectioned under the MHA and will probably spend the rest of her days in a institution could have been prevented if better support and early intervention given.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 15:39

I’m disabled, I’m on several medications and wouldn’t survive for long without them. I’m in some form of pain most days, my sleep is disturbed, there’s a lot of things I can’t do or that require an inordinate amount of ‘forward planning’. If I could ‘screen out’ my illness I absolutely would because it’s debilitating, exhausting and some days I cry. It’s not ‘me’, it’s an unwelcome intruder in my life.

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 15:34

mrtumblescrackdealer · 29/08/2022 15:05

For all of those saying that rejecting difference isn't acceptable, and that people with a disability are a blessing, from what basis have you made that decision?

Let me tell you about my son. He's 9. I love him to bits. He has an x linked, familial dominant syndrome that has almost full penetrance. In layman's terms that means that if you're a boy born into my family, you are almost certainly going to have the family syndrome. We just don't know what it is yet.
He might be 9 but cognitively he is much younger. Imagine a 9 year old toddler because that's effectively what he is. Toddler mentality with the size and strength of a 9 year old. It's an interesting mix. Before I had him I had no idea what the acronyms DLA/HRC/ASD/SEMH/EHCP/VCB/CPVA/ISP/MLD and lots more besides meant. All of those apply to him now.
His care is constant. He cannot be left alone for a second. Things like drinking out of the toilet, eating soap and soil, attempting to jump out of second floor windows, releasing his seatbelt in moving vehicles, running away, tantrums and meltdowns are all commonplace in my house. I live in fort knox. All my upstairs windows have restrictors on them. All my downstairs windows are locked. I have door alarms on my front and back door. I've already ended up in A and E once this summer as a direct result of my son's actions. My mental health is absolutely wrecked and I live day-day. I haven't worked since I was 20 weeks pregnant with him. I can't work. The amount of time I spend on dealing with his needs is well in excess of a full time job.

And there is absolutely no support whatsoever if you have a disabled child with complex needs. Respite. Doesn't exist. Carers. I've been advertising without success for 2 years. He's in an independent specialist school costing my local authority in the region of £125k per annum because there was nothing suitable in my county for him. Disability benefits are absolutely shocking as well. Before I had my son I was earning on average 32k per annum. Now I no longer work, my wages are paid by the government in the form of carer's allowance. It works out at 41p per HOUR. Fwiw if you are recruiting private carers for a disabled child, the going rate in my area is around £20 per hour.

I am by no means the only person in this situation. Its a scenario borne out by many, many parent carers caring for disabled children that I know of and also nationally.

As for my attitude on abortion because of disability, I believe that everyone has the right to make the decision that is right for them and their family. No-one has the right to say what anyone else should or shouldn't be doing. A lot of the campaigns doing the rounds at the moment about abortion on the grounds of disability have (in my opinion) a completely unrealistic view of what it's actually like to be the parent of a disabled child.

I’m so sorry for the appalling way you are treated as your son’s carer, and for the shocking lack of provision for him. I agree with every word you say.

OP posts:
unicormb · 29/08/2022 15:32

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 14:53

@unicormb There is something weird to me about a bunch of people declaring another group inferior, less able, less worthy. Even the word 'disabled' is strange to me, with its assumption that there is one right way to be.

The correct term for describing prejudice against disabled people is ableism. Not disableism. And disabled isn't a dirty word, a lot of disabled people are perfectly happy with it.

GingerCake2018 · 29/08/2022 15:25

mrtumblescrackdealer · 29/08/2022 15:05

For all of those saying that rejecting difference isn't acceptable, and that people with a disability are a blessing, from what basis have you made that decision?

Let me tell you about my son. He's 9. I love him to bits. He has an x linked, familial dominant syndrome that has almost full penetrance. In layman's terms that means that if you're a boy born into my family, you are almost certainly going to have the family syndrome. We just don't know what it is yet.
He might be 9 but cognitively he is much younger. Imagine a 9 year old toddler because that's effectively what he is. Toddler mentality with the size and strength of a 9 year old. It's an interesting mix. Before I had him I had no idea what the acronyms DLA/HRC/ASD/SEMH/EHCP/VCB/CPVA/ISP/MLD and lots more besides meant. All of those apply to him now.
His care is constant. He cannot be left alone for a second. Things like drinking out of the toilet, eating soap and soil, attempting to jump out of second floor windows, releasing his seatbelt in moving vehicles, running away, tantrums and meltdowns are all commonplace in my house. I live in fort knox. All my upstairs windows have restrictors on them. All my downstairs windows are locked. I have door alarms on my front and back door. I've already ended up in A and E once this summer as a direct result of my son's actions. My mental health is absolutely wrecked and I live day-day. I haven't worked since I was 20 weeks pregnant with him. I can't work. The amount of time I spend on dealing with his needs is well in excess of a full time job.

And there is absolutely no support whatsoever if you have a disabled child with complex needs. Respite. Doesn't exist. Carers. I've been advertising without success for 2 years. He's in an independent specialist school costing my local authority in the region of £125k per annum because there was nothing suitable in my county for him. Disability benefits are absolutely shocking as well. Before I had my son I was earning on average 32k per annum. Now I no longer work, my wages are paid by the government in the form of carer's allowance. It works out at 41p per HOUR. Fwiw if you are recruiting private carers for a disabled child, the going rate in my area is around £20 per hour.

I am by no means the only person in this situation. Its a scenario borne out by many, many parent carers caring for disabled children that I know of and also nationally.

As for my attitude on abortion because of disability, I believe that everyone has the right to make the decision that is right for them and their family. No-one has the right to say what anyone else should or shouldn't be doing. A lot of the campaigns doing the rounds at the moment about abortion on the grounds of disability have (in my opinion) a completely unrealistic view of what it's actually like to be the parent of a disabled child.

My Aunt and Uncle are in a similar position to you but 40+ years on. They are both in their late 70s now, with the knowledge that they will not live for ever, and that my Cousin will likely outlive them.

My Aunt aborted her next pregnancy after my disabled cousin due to some concerns and her absolute belief that this was the right thing to do as it was not worth the risk of a similar outcome. She is vocally pro choice.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 15:24

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 15:05

*Who said they're inferior?"

It's pretty obvious that this is a deeply held belief. It is apparently vital that society retain the right to use medical advances to kill them while other babies enjoy protection from those medical 'treatments'. That kind of eugenics doesn't exist without an underlying philosophical position that death for a child like this is a lesser thing, and correspondingly, that their life is less valuable. It's unnecessary. We will never get far in women's rights by trampling on the rights of vulnerable others - it doesn't build the kind of logic that leads to a fairer society.

So if a woman who already has a severely disabled child (let’s say profound autism and non verbal) becomes pregnant, and the birth of another disabled baby would severely compromise her ability to care for child number 1, so she decides upon termination, that’s eugenics?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 29/08/2022 15:24

I don’t for a second hold the belief that people with disabilities are in any way inferior. My Ds is the most wonderful person I know but that doesn’t mean it’s not hard for both of us and it has a massive impact on everything.

just because personally it’s not a decision I think i would make in most cases though doesn’t mean I don’t understand why for many they decide for whatever reason it is better all around. That is personal choice which will be based on a myriad of different complex factors.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 15:23

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 15:18

Personally, I wouldn’t want to change the law just to appease these campaigners. And while I realise they can no longer claim discrimination, that’s not really what they are after is it.

I agree. I think our focus should be ensuring living disabled people are treated with value, respect and good quality care.

OP posts:
GingerCake2018 · 29/08/2022 15:18

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

I trust the women whose body is continuous with the fetus to make that decision. I doubt there would be a queue of women going through 8 months of pregnancy and then requesting abortion without truely exceptional reason, and I trust women to determine their own truely exceptional reasons.

The legal framework already exists in the form of the Mental Capacity Act, Mental health Act and Gilleck competancy to ensure that vulnerable women are protected from themselves and from others who my have suprious motives. Therefore I think any women outside of these parameters are capable of making the best decision for their body and their fetus.

And why would you even thing that you'd need to ring its neck FFS, you provide the mother with drugs that peacefully stops the fetuses circulation.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 15:18

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 14:47

Because the campaigners say this is specifically about discrimination within the law (although I suspect that’s not the full story). So then they would have it wouldn’t they?

Personally, I wouldn’t want to change the law just to appease these campaigners. And while I realise they can no longer claim discrimination, that’s not really what they are after is it.

undermilkjug · 29/08/2022 15:17

It seems to me that reducing the time limit for abortion to bring parity between TFMR and 'choice' terminations is likely to result in more TFMR than not.

The time limits have already been set out above but if you effectively have 3 days to decide whether you are able to parent a child with a pre-natal diagnosis with no idea as to severity and limited time to get counselling and talk to people with experience of the condition, or have a termination within a very tight timescale 99% of people will terminate.

Babies born with known pre-natal disabilities will be limited to the much smaller number who have no pre-natal screening.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 15:12

A child with disabilities requires a greater quantity and quality of care. It is sheer ignorance and bad faith to suggest otherwise. Some women and families can take on this responsibilities and others know they would fall short of the demand. Only you have said inferior. It is a slight of hand that suits a pro-life narrative.