Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
Saz12 · 29/08/2022 21:09

I fundamentally believe that no woman should have to give over her body for the benefit of another person or a person-in-waiting. Nobody has the right to borrow my kidney function to keep someone else alive, even if it’s at no harm to myself. Neither should I have to gestate a feotus if I don’t want to (EVEN if you think at counts as a baby).

BUT... surely that doesn’t mean that you should administer heart-beat ending drugs to that woman who is borrowing my kidney function, or that feotus?

Of course it’s massively rubbish to have newborn babies enter in the care system (even if that system was hugely improved!) and it’s not what anyone would actually want. But worse than no life at all? Are we really saying that our “care” system is so grim that it would be better to have no existence at all?

isadoradancing123 · 29/08/2022 19:42

Its ok for Dominic Lawson to spout about disability rights, he was and is in a position to get the very best medical care and specialist education for his daughter. Most people are not in this position, also most disabilities need massive health and hospital input, the way things are going the health service wont be able to provide tthis

ddl1 · 29/08/2022 19:33

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 19:12

Try again...

Personhood is not conferring until birth, a fetus is not a person until then which is why abortion is not murder in the eyes of the law and even causing someone to lose a pregnancy, for example due to violence such as happened with Beth Newman and Alison Bolton, they would face charges of grievous bodily harm to the woman but would not be charged with murder of the unborn child.

Interestingly, for those who use religious arguments about abortion, the Bible itself makes a similar distinction. In 'Exodus', it is stated that people, whose violence causes a woman to miscarry, must pay a fine; while murder merits a death sentence.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 19:12

Try again...

Personhood is not conferring until birth, a fetus is not a person until then which is why abortion is not murder in the eyes of the law and even causing someone to lose a pregnancy, for example due to violence such as happened with Beth Newman and Alison Bolton, they would face charges of grievous bodily harm to the woman but would not be charged with murder of the unborn child.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 19:08

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 18:43

The ultimate question is whether anyone should have the right to deliberately end an individual human life.
A foetus, from conception is:
Individual - individuated genes, unique, therefore not a part of the mother's own body
Human-2 human parents, member of the homo sapiens sapientis species
Life-alive-how do we know? because we can kill it

Personhood is not conferring until birth, a fetus is not a person until then which is why abortion is not murder in the eyes of the law and even causing someone to los

Bagzzz · 29/08/2022 18:44

I have a couple of disabilities that could lead to abortion. I think it should be legal to term. My parents are worried about my future and so am I. As you can see I am in some ways very articulate and successful. However I’m not really independent.

Some people with my disability have severe physical issues and additional needs lifelong. It has to be the potential mother’s choice of that risk with current circumstances including Amy other children.

is that uncomfortable? Very. Do I wish I’d been aborted? - on balance yes if my parents could then have a child without disability. I’d never have been born so. I’m sure that child could have brought any of the joy I may have over to he year without starting out disabled.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 18:43

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 18:29

Because one exists inside the body of someone else, and the other is a biologically independent entity.

What a fetus is or isn’t in itself (conscious, alive, stage of development etc), is not the deciding factor for everyone. The deciding factor is the woman, and her wishes in regards to her own body.

The ultimate question is whether anyone should have the right to deliberately end an individual human life.
A foetus, from conception is:
Individual - individuated genes, unique, therefore not a part of the mother's own body
Human-2 human parents, member of the homo sapiens sapientis species
Life-alive-how do we know? because we can kill it

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 18:38

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:33

Because one exists inside the body of someone else, and the other is a biologically independent entity.

Thats certainly a good reason for keeping smothering infants illegal!

Sure. It’s also a good reason to support abortion to term, on demand.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:33

Because one exists inside the body of someone else, and the other is a biologically independent entity.

Thats certainly a good reason for keeping smothering infants illegal!

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 18:29

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:14

Because smothering children is illegal

Ffs

So is abortion after 24 weeks except in a very specific set of circumstances! Yet people on here are arguing to change that law.

Because one exists inside the body of someone else, and the other is a biologically independent entity.

What a fetus is or isn’t in itself (conscious, alive, stage of development etc), is not the deciding factor for everyone. The deciding factor is the woman, and her wishes in regards to her own body.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:25

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 18:06

How is that what this entire thread is about

The thread is about medical abortion campaigners trying to restrict the time people can abort due to certain disabilities

Yes that’s exactly what it’s about and therefore relevant.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:14

Because smothering children is illegal

Ffs

So is abortion after 24 weeks except in a very specific set of circumstances! Yet people on here are arguing to change that law.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 18:13

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 18:08

Consider the data we already have it's vanishingly unlikely anyone would abort a healthy baby at 40 weeks

If the vast majority of people don't at 21 weeks why would there be a flurry of women doing so much later?

I just don't believe in clairvoyance or that anyone can actually predict what all women will do. I don't think that's a solid basis for policy making.

GingerCake2018 · 29/08/2022 18:13

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 17:51

Why do you think more people would abort at 40 weeks than currently is seen at 20 weeks

Late term abortions are already rare now

If that term was extended the numbers aborting at 40 weeks would be tiny

Exactly, the idea that there would be queues of women choosing to go through a full pregnancy to then abort, is ludicrous and frankly insulting to women.

Allowing abortion to full time rather than to what are currently arbitruary cutoff points, given the success of preterm care, would allow a tiny number of women with strong reasons to believe their fetus would be better of not coming in to existence the chance to act on it even in the absence of a confirmed diagnosis.

Examples I can think of is Women pregnant when they get a significant diagnosis in an older child that has a degree of heritability associated with it but that can neither be confirmed or rule out in utero, or a women who has found out she was pregnant late and due to not knowing she was pregnant has exposed her child to significant alcohol (or other recreational or prescribed drugs) in utero, and does not wish to bring a fetus with Fetal alcohol syndrome to term.

These cases will be extremely rare, but the option should be there and the decision should lie solely with the mother.

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 18:08

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:55

@Annieisalright I don't know what would happen if we allowed abortions for any reason up until birth. I wouldn't dream of making a law based on predictions, I would base it on what society agrees would be allowable in all circumstances. It doesn't matter if late term abortions are rare now because they require a medical reason. That is completely different to making them allowable for any reason, obviously.

Consider the data we already have it's vanishingly unlikely anyone would abort a healthy baby at 40 weeks

If the vast majority of people don't at 21 weeks why would there be a flurry of women doing so much later?

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 18:06

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:05

I'm not in favour of allowing people to abort healthy 40-week babies; I just don't think it's a particularly relevant topic, as it's not happening.

Maybe I’ve misunderstood you but that is what this entire thread is about.

How is that what this entire thread is about

The thread is about medical abortion campaigners trying to restrict the time people can abort due to certain disabilities

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 18:05

I'm not in favour of allowing people to abort healthy 40-week babies; I just don't think it's a particularly relevant topic, as it's not happening.

Maybe I’ve misunderstood you but that is what this entire thread is about.

Sirzy · 29/08/2022 18:03

WhatALotOfAFussAboutNothing · 29/08/2022 17:57

It is state sponsored disability discrimination and eugenics to allow a disabled baby to be aborted to full term.

I cannot see why anyone would think it is acceptable.

Or it’s letting women have control over their bodies, how does anyone else have the right to tell a woman what she must or must not to.

don’t forget the amount of late term abortions is tiny. When it happens it’s for a very good reason.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:58

@ddl1 OK, that makes sense.

WhatALotOfAFussAboutNothing · 29/08/2022 17:57

It is state sponsored disability discrimination and eugenics to allow a disabled baby to be aborted to full term.

I cannot see why anyone would think it is acceptable.

ddl1 · 29/08/2022 17:56

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:50

@ddl1 But I don't think you are allowed to abort a healthy, full term baby without a medical reason at the moment? So we don't know what would happen if we removed the requirement and just said any reason is valid. We can't make laws based on what we think people will do, they have to be based on what is morally acceptable.

You're allowed to abort a 21-week foetus without a medical reason, and yet hardly anyone does, so yes, I think we do know.

I'm not in favour of allowing people to abort healthy 40-week babies; I just don't think it's a particularly relevant topic, as it's not happening.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:55

@Annieisalright I don't know what would happen if we allowed abortions for any reason up until birth. I wouldn't dream of making a law based on predictions, I would base it on what society agrees would be allowable in all circumstances. It doesn't matter if late term abortions are rare now because they require a medical reason. That is completely different to making them allowable for any reason, obviously.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 17:55

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 17:04

Not everyone does want to adopt a baby

Also the process for adopting a baby requires people to be foster carers first whilst going through the process to adopt

If you think actively putting a child through the stress and attachment destroying process of adoption from birth is a preferable option you have a screw loose

But, Annie, we are talking about maintaining the situation we have now and there aren’t very many new borns being placed for adoption.

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 17:51

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:50

@ddl1 But I don't think you are allowed to abort a healthy, full term baby without a medical reason at the moment? So we don't know what would happen if we removed the requirement and just said any reason is valid. We can't make laws based on what we think people will do, they have to be based on what is morally acceptable.

Why do you think more people would abort at 40 weeks than currently is seen at 20 weeks

Late term abortions are already rare now

If that term was extended the numbers aborting at 40 weeks would be tiny

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:50

@ddl1 But I don't think you are allowed to abort a healthy, full term baby without a medical reason at the moment? So we don't know what would happen if we removed the requirement and just said any reason is valid. We can't make laws based on what we think people will do, they have to be based on what is morally acceptable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread