Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 30/08/2022 01:46

LangClegsInSpace · 30/08/2022 01:20

Yes you did, you said 'The philosophical notion of personhood is inherently flawed'

Personhood is a legal concept and it's not at all vague.

Foetuses are human and they are alive but they do not have legal personhood, they do not have human rights, until they are born.

No, unborn babies are protected under the Infant Life(Preservation) Act and the Offences Against the Person Act, see the CPS briefing (06 Jan 2022) re. Asa Davison's life sentence for killing his unborn child
www.cps.gov.uk/wessex/news/updated-sentence-violent-abuser-guilty-causing-death-unborn-baby#:~:text=Update%3A%20Asa%20Davison,course%20of%20justice.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 30/08/2022 01:32

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 19:12

Try again...

Personhood is not conferring until birth, a fetus is not a person until then which is why abortion is not murder in the eyes of the law and even causing someone to lose a pregnancy, for example due to violence such as happened with Beth Newman and Alison Bolton, they would face charges of grievous bodily harm to the woman but would not be charged with murder of the unborn child.

This is the introduction of personhood into the discussion

LangClegsInSpace · 30/08/2022 01:20

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 30/08/2022 01:01

I haven't introduced any philosophical "notions", I was responding to an earlier comment which seemed to lend more weight to a vague concept of personhood, rather than the reality of an individual, human life (in this case, the unborn baby).

Yes you did, you said 'The philosophical notion of personhood is inherently flawed'

Personhood is a legal concept and it's not at all vague.

Foetuses are human and they are alive but they do not have legal personhood, they do not have human rights, until they are born.

LangClegsInSpace · 30/08/2022 01:12

Fifife · 30/08/2022 00:42

Unless you are rich and have unlimited means, supporting a severely disabled child can be full of difficulties. I've had parents crying because the child won't sleep and they keep going into their siblings room and turning the lights on. The entire family is at breaking point from severe sleep deprivation. Before we take women's rights away disability services need to be better funded, better respite which might then effect the abortion rates.

I'm well trained in disability and positive behaviour support and I personally wouldn't choose to have a severely disabled child because I see the battles these parents fight everyday for a little bit of support. Putting more children into care won't effect the outcome they will spend most of their lives in institutions from very early on.

This too. As @OhmygodDont said,

Our care system really is that bad yes

And it's getting worse.

This group of campaigners who are attempting to restrict women's abortion rights in the name of disability rights don't seem to have any campaigns around improving the care system or the benefit system.

Those are the things that send the biggest message that disabled people's lives are worth less. The care system and the benefit system are that bad because society really does not give a shit about disabled people or their carers.

Those are the things that would lead me to consider ending a pregnancy on the grounds of disability. I would not continue with a pregnancy of a disabled foetus unless I was sure that they and I had access to the necesary care and support.

Even then I would worry tremendously about what would happen to them after I died.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 30/08/2022 01:01

I haven't introduced any philosophical "notions", I was responding to an earlier comment which seemed to lend more weight to a vague concept of personhood, rather than the reality of an individual, human life (in this case, the unborn baby).

LangClegsInSpace · 30/08/2022 00:45

Exactly @FarmerRefuted .

Fifife · 30/08/2022 00:42

Unless you are rich and have unlimited means, supporting a severely disabled child can be full of difficulties. I've had parents crying because the child won't sleep and they keep going into their siblings room and turning the lights on. The entire family is at breaking point from severe sleep deprivation. Before we take women's rights away disability services need to be better funded, better respite which might then effect the abortion rates.

I'm well trained in disability and positive behaviour support and I personally wouldn't choose to have a severely disabled child because I see the battles these parents fight everyday for a little bit of support. Putting more children into care won't effect the outcome they will spend most of their lives in institutions from very early on.

FarmerRefuted · 30/08/2022 00:37

And the reason we have law is to take away the emotional and philosophical discussions by setting out in black and white exactly what is permitted and what is not. Whether you agree with abortion or not, the law says it is permissable and the circumstances under which that applies.

LangClegsInSpace · 30/08/2022 00:14

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 23:42

The philosophical notion of personhood is inherently flawed, depending as it does upon a subjective choice of a particular philosophical approach. Biology is immutable, which is why individual human life and not "personhood" is what ought to be considered.

This is a discussion about the Abortion Act and various asssults upon it.

The legal concept of personhood is well established.

I don't care about your 'philodophical notions' I care about the law and women's rights under the law.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 23:58

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 23:42

The philosophical notion of personhood is inherently flawed, depending as it does upon a subjective choice of a particular philosophical approach. Biology is immutable, which is why individual human life and not "personhood" is what ought to be considered.

Sure, and you can consider it to be of lesser concern when placed in direct opposition to someone else’s right to bodily autonomy (hell, you can’t even take from a corpse without consent, in order to save someone’s life). You can absolutely believe a fetus is alive and support abortion. They are not mutually exclusive positions.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 23:42

The philosophical notion of personhood is inherently flawed, depending as it does upon a subjective choice of a particular philosophical approach. Biology is immutable, which is why individual human life and not "personhood" is what ought to be considered.

JacquelineCarlyle · 29/08/2022 23:00

I completely agree @whumpthereitis

VestaTilley · 29/08/2022 22:42

I agree @SlagathaChristie

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 22:40

it is the case that aborting most babies with DS will make it harder for some women to go against the grain and access support as the parent of a child with DS. That is the case and has played out elsewhere.

So it is up to women to have disabled children they don’t want, so as to better serve the interests of the women with disabled children they do want?

interesting concept, but no. Women have their own agency when it comes to decisions they make over their own bodies and their own lives. They’re not merely useful pawns best utilised to achieve X goal. Lovely sentiment though: “fuck what you want and what is best for the life you already have, we need numbers. Get under the fucking bus”

And no, babies aren’t routinely left to die after late term abortions. At least not in this country. Furthermore, the fact that you can’t comprehend a material difference between giving birth and abortion, doesn’t mean that there isn’t one, and it doesn’t mean that any individual woman should not have full choice when it comes to what is being done to her body.

Location is no minor consideration when said ‘location’ is someone else’s body.

LangClegsInSpace · 29/08/2022 22:39

I do not feel there is intrinsically a significant difference in a doctor plunging a lethal needle into a baby in the later stages of pregnancy, and that lethal injection being delivered to a newly born child. They're in a different location. Either it was abhorrent before and still is, or it wasn't.

Women's bodies are not 'a location', they are our bodies. Women are people with full legal rights, including human rights, including bodily autonomy.

Foetuses are not legal persons. They do not share human rights until after they are born. That is the significant difference.

Giving human rights to foetuses always ends very very badly for women, even those not seeking an abortion. It's not even necessary for making your strong pro-life arguments. In the UK it's illegal to abort a foetus past 24 weeks except in certain very strict circumstances yet no foetus has legal personhood or human rights in the UK.

There are countless instances of live babies being left to die following failed abortions, suggesting that service providers don't get this great difference either.

Citation please.

For a woman, there is no material difference in giving birth (unless there is some great consolation in having the child cut up first which I don't believe for a moment).

This is really nasty and dehumanising. Please bear in mind that there are women on this thread who have had to make harrowing decisions about much wanted pregnancies.

That's as far as I got with your post. I found it too disgusting to read to the end.

undermilkjug · 29/08/2022 22:33

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 22:28

If the law said that post-24wks your only option was to keep the baby or put the baby up for adoption, no abortion allowed then three potential outcomes would occur.

  1. Women would be pressured by society/friends/family into keeping and raising a disabled child whose needs they are unable/ill-equipped to provide. Everyone in that scenario suffers, especially the child.
  1. The number of disabled children in the care system increases. Some of these children will be too severely disabled to be fostered let alone adopted as they will never leave hospital or a professional care setting. There are not enough potential adopters to take on the current children in care never mind increasing the numbers and many of those potential adopters will be in the same position as rhe birth parents - unable to meet the needs of a disabled child.
  1. Women will seek unsafe means to end the pregnancy and the number of backstreet abortions will increase along with maternal death rates. There is no way to ban abortions, only safe abortions.

The only other one to add is that there would be more abortions at 24 weeks. Instead of seeing if surgery to repair a spinal cord could potentially work for your baby, or whether your DS baby had heart defects or other additional issues, parents would be so conscious of the hard time limit that they would be much more likely to abort and there would be increased medical pressure to do so.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 22:28

If the law said that post-24wks your only option was to keep the baby or put the baby up for adoption, no abortion allowed then three potential outcomes would occur.

  1. Women would be pressured by society/friends/family into keeping and raising a disabled child whose needs they are unable/ill-equipped to provide. Everyone in that scenario suffers, especially the child.
  1. The number of disabled children in the care system increases. Some of these children will be too severely disabled to be fostered let alone adopted as they will never leave hospital or a professional care setting. There are not enough potential adopters to take on the current children in care never mind increasing the numbers and many of those potential adopters will be in the same position as rhe birth parents - unable to meet the needs of a disabled child.
  1. Women will seek unsafe means to end the pregnancy and the number of backstreet abortions will increase along with maternal death rates. There is no way to ban abortions, only safe abortions.
FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 22:22

Saz12 · 29/08/2022 21:09

I fundamentally believe that no woman should have to give over her body for the benefit of another person or a person-in-waiting. Nobody has the right to borrow my kidney function to keep someone else alive, even if it’s at no harm to myself. Neither should I have to gestate a feotus if I don’t want to (EVEN if you think at counts as a baby).

BUT... surely that doesn’t mean that you should administer heart-beat ending drugs to that woman who is borrowing my kidney function, or that feotus?

Of course it’s massively rubbish to have newborn babies enter in the care system (even if that system was hugely improved!) and it’s not what anyone would actually want. But worse than no life at all? Are we really saying that our “care” system is so grim that it would be better to have no existence at all?

Of the 272 babies aborted post-24wks in 2021, their mother has made the decision to end the pregnancy for medical reasons. Given that no action was taken to end the pregnancy prior to that and that they're all on medical grounds, its a fair assumption that they were all wanted pregnancies and that it hasn't been an easy decision for these women to make but they are acting in what they consider to be the best interests of everyone involved. The safety net of post-24wk abortion on medical grounds exists because its needed, even if our care system was perfect and had no negative effects on development outcomes it would still have to be an option - forced adoption is just as abhorrent as forced parenthood.

ddl1 · 29/08/2022 22:21

There are countless instances of live babies being left to die following failed abortions, suggesting that service providers don't get this great difference either.

No, there aren't. There may be a few occasions where this has happened as a result of mistakes about the dates of pregnancy, but vanishingly rare. Where did you get this idea about 'countless instances' from?

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 22:13

There are countless instances of live babies being left to die following failed abortions

Bullshit.

The fetal heartbeat is monitored to ensure it has stopped before the induction/section begins.

Thornethorn · 29/08/2022 22:01

Any adoptive parent could tell you that you don't get through the screening process without kissing goodbye to the idea that you are likely to finish the process with a 'healthy baby'. Most babies available for adoption have already had a very difficult life in utero and may well be forever changed even from birth. So there is a different mindset about adopting to begin with.

I do not feel there is intrinsically a significant difference in a doctor plunging a lethal needle into a baby in the later stages of pregnancy, and that lethal injection being delivered to a newly born child. They're in a different location. Either it was abhorrent before and still is, or it wasn't. There are countless instances of live babies being left to die following failed abortions, suggesting that service providers don't get this great difference either. For a woman, there is no material difference in giving birth (unless there is some great consolation in having the child cut up first which I don't believe for a moment). There is something insane about it being terribly wrong to leave a child to die that only moments earlier it was ethically acceptable to kill. Life is not fair or painless and that's no way to make it fair. Some women seem determined to ensure that no matter what happens it's our job as women to make sure we're never left in an unpleasant situation no matter what arguments have to be made to achieve it. I think there are times when you win one battle and lose a different one in the process - it is the case that aborting most babies with DS will make it harder for some women to go against the grain and access support as the parent of a child with DS. That is the case and has played out elsewhere. These realities are coming down the line and they do matter, as well as other considerations. Perhaps we would ultimately decide that nothing turns on it but we still should be alert to all the implications and not hide behind the idea that this is a morally neutral act or allow ourselves to assume that aborting for disability will have no impact on service provision. There are policy makers who would love it to be not the done thing to have a child with disabilities. Where does that leave mothers of children with disabilities.

Reading these thread I'm not entirely sure that many posters here would make the latter illegal for disabled children if they had the choice. It really does come across that way. It makes me wonder where we'll be in twenty years.

Women's choices shouldn't be conflated with disablism. The issues should be separated out and levelled up. This lazy pivot from 'it's a woman's choice to do what she wants with her body' to 'she should get an extra choice if the child has disabilities' is ethically untenable, even if just as an argument. They're different issues.

JacquelineCarlyle · 29/08/2022 21:56

Totally agree @startrek90

startrek90 · 29/08/2022 21:34

I have a question for those that would ban abortion for disability.... Have you thought it through to the end? Because of forced birthers getting their way in the states there is a poor woman right now who is being forced to carry to term her pregnancy of a child which has no skull. Because the law won't let abortion on the grounds of disability she is carrying a child that will suffer and die shortly after birth. How is that better? Like really explain how it is better to bring a child into the world knowing that they will suffer? There are thousand of disabled children all over the world needing to be adopted have any of you forced birthers adopted them?? Will you? Why not?

It just seems to me that's it's very easy to forced women to do what you want them too, whilst never dealing with the consequences yourself.

OhmygodDont · 29/08/2022 21:20

Saz12 · 29/08/2022 21:09

I fundamentally believe that no woman should have to give over her body for the benefit of another person or a person-in-waiting. Nobody has the right to borrow my kidney function to keep someone else alive, even if it’s at no harm to myself. Neither should I have to gestate a feotus if I don’t want to (EVEN if you think at counts as a baby).

BUT... surely that doesn’t mean that you should administer heart-beat ending drugs to that woman who is borrowing my kidney function, or that feotus?

Of course it’s massively rubbish to have newborn babies enter in the care system (even if that system was hugely improved!) and it’s not what anyone would actually want. But worse than no life at all? Are we really saying that our “care” system is so grim that it would be better to have no existence at all?

Our care system really is that bad yes.

you think children wants to grow up in foster care till they are 18 when it’s then bye. No real family no belonging. Knowing they can always just be shoved into a different house if the foster parents decide to? Living in care is horrible for children.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 21:19

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 18:43

The ultimate question is whether anyone should have the right to deliberately end an individual human life.
A foetus, from conception is:
Individual - individuated genes, unique, therefore not a part of the mother's own body
Human-2 human parents, member of the homo sapiens sapientis species
Life-alive-how do we know? because we can kill it

well yes, pretty sure I covered that. Yes, they should. I say ‘I believe’ but of course we do have that right in specific circumstances.

I’ve never claimed a fetus is part of a woman’s body. It is however reliant on a woman’s body in order to develop, and a woman is well within her rights to deny said use of her body (at least within a legal timeframe, although I am very much in favour of extending it throughout pregnancy).