Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
averageavocado · 31/08/2022 12:35

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 17:41

I don't think it matters what you think people will do. Many people will find it morally unacceptable to make it a legal possibility to destroy healthy foetuses right up until birth. It doesn't matter if statistics lead you to believe it unlikely anyone will actually do it, the majority reject it as unthinkable, and therefore that it should never even be a legal option.

surely what matters is what you would do - get your nose out of other womens bodies

Branleuse · 31/08/2022 11:24

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 31/08/2022 01:46

I know that child destruction doesn't apply to born infants-that's why I used the example of the destruction of an unborn child for you. Child destruction recognises that an unborn baby is a child, and that to destroy that child is illegal and, in Davison's case, resulted in a life-sentence. Personhood is a red herring-the unborn child has legal rights-these legal rights were violated when Davison destroyed the child-this was why a jury convicted him.

Its in the eye of the beholder though isnt it. The mother wanted her child and she was beaten and abused by a man that caused the death of the baby she was pregant with, violently against her will. They werent able to charge him with murder, but they managed to get him for something thankfully. This does not in any way conflct with a pro-choice stance.
Believing that a foetus doesnt become a person with human rights until its born safely does not in any way conflict with acknowledging the tragedy of a pregnant woman beaten and assaulted so severely by a man that the child was killed.
Ive had 3 kids, a couple of miscarriages and an abortion. My wanted children were "babies" to me long before official personhood, but In the eyes of the law and for medical reasons, its not until birth, and the "loss" of the other pregnancies whilst upsetting in some ways for various reasons, is not the same as losing a child that was born and existed as a person in their own right. Obviously.

Branleuse · 31/08/2022 11:07

GingerCake2018 · 31/08/2022 09:08

RTFT, or at least go back 3 or 4 posts!

to what bit? I have been reading the thread and commenting. If someones using the existence of a child born at 26 weeks just passing their GCSEs, as any kind of reason that women shouldnt be able to choose to terminate an unwanted pregnancy, then it still doesnt add up to me. I dont want people forced into abortions they dont want, or into pregnancies they dont want. I have very little interest in the foetuses themselves or their human rights, until theyre born.
Actually thats not 100% true, because I think if a woman decides shes going to continue the pregnancy then she should have a responsibility towards making sure she is not harming it and then birthing it into shitty situations on purpose.
I know drug addicts that will have baby after baby into abusive situations, born addicted, because they dont believe in abortion. Its fucked up. Its looking at it the wrong way round. The planet is full of people and we are destroying it. Its normal to love babies and I love babies and children, but I just cant get my head round why people want other women to continue pregnancies they dont want or dont feel they can manage the commitment, because theyve anthropomorphised a foetus in utero, thats in a dream state, with no knowledge of the world and no awareness.
This weird fetish about baby innocence is so harmful to women and is contributing to a much wider problem in the world. #
We need to concentrate on the ones already here.

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 10:53

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 31/08/2022 02:03

And to use an example from my own practice, child protection proceedings frequently place unborn children under a child protection order, in order to safeguard them from harm, and to promote their welfare up to, including, and after birth. The courts don't consider an abstract notion of personhood; they correctly acknowledge that an an unborn child (irrespective of gestational age or development) has rights which must be protected. In fact, when the rights of the mother come into conflict with the rights of her unborn child to remain free from harm, the rights of the child become paramount, under the Children Act, and may result in removal at birth.

That’s removal at birth, when personhood is established. You’ll notice that they have no power to stop a pregnant drinking or smoking for example, on account of the unborn having rights.

anyway, like I said earlier, I don’t think personhood honestly matters. No person has the right to someone else’s body. Hell, no person has the right to someone else’s corpse.

GingerCake2018 · 31/08/2022 09:08

Branleuse · 30/08/2022 23:26

Thats great for him. His mum wanted that pregnancy, and is doing ok. Wasnt forced into anything hopefully.

RTFT, or at least go back 3 or 4 posts!

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 09:03

Personhood is not a red herring. Read the Crowter JR ruling.

https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/crowter-v-secretary-of-state-for-health-and-social-care/

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 07:15

Why not removal before @GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok ?

OP posts:
GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 31/08/2022 02:03

And to use an example from my own practice, child protection proceedings frequently place unborn children under a child protection order, in order to safeguard them from harm, and to promote their welfare up to, including, and after birth. The courts don't consider an abstract notion of personhood; they correctly acknowledge that an an unborn child (irrespective of gestational age or development) has rights which must be protected. In fact, when the rights of the mother come into conflict with the rights of her unborn child to remain free from harm, the rights of the child become paramount, under the Children Act, and may result in removal at birth.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 31/08/2022 01:46

LangClegsInSpace · 30/08/2022 02:30

What Davidson did was disgusting. He was found guilty of GBH and ABH against his ex-partner. He was also found guilty of child destruction because he deliberately caused his ex-partner to lose her pregnancy.

Child destruction does not apply to born infants. If foetuses had personhood and human rights, the charge would not have been child destruction, it would have been murder.

I know that child destruction doesn't apply to born infants-that's why I used the example of the destruction of an unborn child for you. Child destruction recognises that an unborn baby is a child, and that to destroy that child is illegal and, in Davison's case, resulted in a life-sentence. Personhood is a red herring-the unborn child has legal rights-these legal rights were violated when Davison destroyed the child-this was why a jury convicted him.

Branleuse · 30/08/2022 23:26

GingerCake2018 · 30/08/2022 15:46

Why 26 weeks?

Increasing numbers of babies born before 26 weeks are surviving. My friends DC just got their GCSE results they were born at 25+0 nearly 17 years ago.

But, being born at 26 weeks without extensive and invasive medical intervention carries an extremely poor prognosis.

So your statement, as with the current abortion limit, are purely arbritary, with very little evidence base.

Thats great for him. His mum wanted that pregnancy, and is doing ok. Wasnt forced into anything hopefully.

FlimsySteve · 30/08/2022 18:52

YellowRoad · 30/08/2022 16:57

Well, what do you suggest? Abortion up to 40 weeks or no abortion at all?
There has to be a cut off point somewhere which works for the majority of cases. 26 weeks sounds reasonable to me. But maybe 25 weeks or 27 weeks would be better. I'll let someone else do the research on that.

Why does it sound reasonable to you? What makes a 26 week old different from a 25 week old foetus?

If it's your personal opinion on viability then perhaps that gives you a clue as to who it should apply to.

CecilyP · 30/08/2022 18:00

Ginger, completely taking abortion out of the equation, viability is the gestation at which a baby can be said to have been born. All birth statistics will be based on this, regardless of the level of care the baby will need to survive. In the U.K. it is also the legal cut off for abortion (in many other countries it is different). If you want to change the law, go ahead, lobby for it.

GingerCake2018 · 30/08/2022 17:50

YellowRoad · 30/08/2022 16:57

Well, what do you suggest? Abortion up to 40 weeks or no abortion at all?
There has to be a cut off point somewhere which works for the majority of cases. 26 weeks sounds reasonable to me. But maybe 25 weeks or 27 weeks would be better. I'll let someone else do the research on that.

I have already made it clear upthread that I would have no cut off and let the women make the decision (assuming she has the mental capacity to do so), there is no perfect answer or solution and never will be, therefore in the absense of a definitive solution the responsibility for the decision should lie with the pregnant women, who I trust to make the best decision for her and her fetus unique to her circumstnaces.

GingerCake2018 · 30/08/2022 17:46

CecilyP · 30/08/2022 17:18

YellowRoad, The cut off is 24 weeks as determined in the U.K. by the 1990 Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act. This was reduced from 28 weeks which was the cut off according to the 1967 Abortion Act. This did not happen in a vacuum; 24 weeks is now determined as viability. Prior to 1990 a loss between 24 and 28 weeks was a miscarriage, now it is a stillbirth or a neonatal death. Would this not also have been the case in Ireland despite abortion being illegal?

Any further change would have to be made by an Act of Parliament, not by random mumsnetters.

But what is viability?

A 24 week fetus would not survive without very advanced and expensive modern medical technology. A 24 week fetus would not survive in afghanistan, and even in the UK if delivered prehospitally without access to steriod injections in utero. So I'd argue that 24 weeks is far from "viable" and actually the point at which the majority of babies would survive without any medical intervention is much much later. It is all arbitrary, let the women whose body it is make the decision.

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/08/2022 17:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

CecilyP · 30/08/2022 17:18

YellowRoad · 30/08/2022 16:51

I'll let the professionals determine the cut off point.
20 weeks is too early, 30 weeks is too late.

YellowRoad, The cut off is 24 weeks as determined in the U.K. by the 1990 Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act. This was reduced from 28 weeks which was the cut off according to the 1967 Abortion Act. This did not happen in a vacuum; 24 weeks is now determined as viability. Prior to 1990 a loss between 24 and 28 weeks was a miscarriage, now it is a stillbirth or a neonatal death. Would this not also have been the case in Ireland despite abortion being illegal?

Any further change would have to be made by an Act of Parliament, not by random mumsnetters.

startrek90 · 30/08/2022 16:58

@FarmerRefuted (amazing username btw)

I comepletly agree with you. I've noticed that none of the forced birthers on this thread have commented on the reality that is currently being experienced by women in the USA and Poland who are now living this nightmare. No one has explained why its better for disabled people or indeed the baby that a woman in Louisiana is currently being forced to carry a baby to term that does not have a skull. This baby will die shortly after birth but not before suffering terribly.

I wish forced birthers could explain how disabled people benefit from this. How does the baby benefit? How does the mother of this child benefit?

I also noticed that none of the forced birthers on this thread, who are aghast that a woman would have an abortion on the grounds of disability, have told us how many disabled children they have adopted or fostered. What work are they doing to help support women looking after disabled children and adults? What are they doing to lobby the government for better services for disabled people. Are the financially supporting women who are raising disabled children? Providing respite care? Or indeed anything at all?

I suspect not. Its far easier to judge women from the sidelines and tell them what they SHOULD be doing, rather than helping with the actual practical reality.

I am a woman of faith. I also really resent forced birthers adopting religion to justify forcing women into truly barbaric situations. It especially rankles as the Bible is not actually against abortion, quite the opposite in fact. God has no issue with abortions only zealots do.

YellowRoad · 30/08/2022 16:58

We are not writing laws here, ffs 😁

YellowRoad · 30/08/2022 16:57

GingerCake2018 · 30/08/2022 15:46

Why 26 weeks?

Increasing numbers of babies born before 26 weeks are surviving. My friends DC just got their GCSE results they were born at 25+0 nearly 17 years ago.

But, being born at 26 weeks without extensive and invasive medical intervention carries an extremely poor prognosis.

So your statement, as with the current abortion limit, are purely arbritary, with very little evidence base.

Well, what do you suggest? Abortion up to 40 weeks or no abortion at all?
There has to be a cut off point somewhere which works for the majority of cases. 26 weeks sounds reasonable to me. But maybe 25 weeks or 27 weeks would be better. I'll let someone else do the research on that.

YellowRoad · 30/08/2022 16:51

FlimsySteve · 30/08/2022 15:37

What changes specifically at 26 weeks?

I'll let the professionals determine the cut off point.
20 weeks is too early, 30 weeks is too late.

Wouldloveanother · 30/08/2022 16:50

CecilyP · 30/08/2022 16:47

Some women very sadly find out they’re terminally ill while pregnant.

Yes, sadly they do, as well as other medical conditions which makes continuing the pregnancy a serious risk to life and health. However, after 24 weeks in most cases they will deliver the baby and provide care in the hope it will survive.

Absolutely but I could understand if, for example, a pregnant woman found out she was terminally ill and felt she couldn’t manage a very poorly and extremely premature baby alongside her own health issues.

OP posts:
CecilyP · 30/08/2022 16:49

Of course that isn't what they really want - they want to chip away at abortion rights

Yes I’m pretty sure of that!

Wouldloveanother · 30/08/2022 16:49

FarmerRefuted · 30/08/2022 16:44

Heidi Crowther is out there trying to deny women the right to choose which is a kick in the face when her own mother was afforded that choice, she was offered options and she was able to make the choice to continue her pregnancy. It's vile that she seeks to remove that ability to choose.

I don’t know if her mum was, I think I read somewhere her diagnosis was postnatal. In a way I can digest it better if it was a prenatal diagnosis and they willingly chose to proceed with the pregnancy - there’s a sincerity to it, and they practised what they preach, even if I don’t agree. But it’s hard seeing women who opted for the tests (even if they didn’t ‘work’) now try to limit the choices of other women. In many cases they also had testing for subsequent babies, but caution us against it!

OP posts:
CecilyP · 30/08/2022 16:47

Some women very sadly find out they’re terminally ill while pregnant.

Yes, sadly they do, as well as other medical conditions which makes continuing the pregnancy a serious risk to life and health. However, after 24 weeks in most cases they will deliver the baby and provide care in the hope it will survive.

pointythings · 30/08/2022 16:47

@CecilyP the Heidi crowd want foetuses with DS and other disabilities to be treated equally to foetuses where there are no medical issues, i.e. a 24 week cut-off, no abortion allowed after that.

So if it's equality they want, let's rack the limit up to 40 weeks for all pregnancies. Job done, equal rights for all.

Of course that isn't what they really want - they want to chip away at abortion rights. But I'd love to hear their arguments if we ever did get abortion to term for all pregnancies.