Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 09:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

alpenguin · 29/08/2022 09:43

As a pro choice lifelong disabled woman it’s a really difficult one for me.

Absolutely it’s a woman’s decision for any reason. I will stand by that even if it’s something I may not personally have chosen to do.

I also understand the argument from disability campaigners who fear it is a form of eugenics. The idea of getting rid of unwanted conditions because it makes life easier for the parents and the presumption that living with a disability is awful and something to try to change is for many hurtful and unthinkable. I’m not sure it would ever change my mind on pro-choice but I do see how hurtful it is to know people feel I’d rather have been aborted than given my chance to exist.

Facecream · 29/08/2022 09:41

I have a severely disabled DD, discovered indications of disability (clubfoot) at 20 week scan. The pressure to terminate was intense (from medics).
The key idea should be that support is given in pregnancy and if a baby is disabled there should be a lot more support.
However, no idea how that would be funded- which is probably the central reason that termination is permitted to full term.
There is no social support where I live: school fees (paid for not by me) are enormous, a disability of my DD’s type has numerous consultants involved, across two hospitals and she’s had a long neonatal stay and another ten days in hospital.
She has incontinence products, medications, occupational therapy items, wheelchair needs - all paid for by local authorities/the NHS. I only get carer’s allowance and she DLA but I can’t work any more, so I’m not contributing to society.

Sadly, I think it’s this that gives women the additional time frame to have terminations rather than a concern for the woman’s well-being or freedom to choose

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 09:41

FlimsySteve · 29/08/2022 09:38

Sorry I was quoting a pp there!

At what point is a foetus able to live unaided?

When it’s born and can be cared for independently. It may indeed be viable prior to delivery, but whilst it is in utero a woman should imo have full autonomy.

averageavocado · 29/08/2022 09:41

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

Could you share your verified statistics on how often this happen

Soontobe60 · 29/08/2022 09:39

Judithand2 · 29/08/2022 08:10

I am the mother of a severely disabled child. We were given the choice in pregnancy at 20 weeks and again when he was 3 months old & still on a ventilator.

we CHOSE to be his parents. It wasn’t a hard decision for us as we were financially secure, owned our home, lived near the hospital and in our early 30s so more mature.

It should be a choice. This life is so hard and the fact is it is not for everyone. We’ve never been happier now he is more medically stable we have the loveliest life. But it has been tough. If I was single, younger, broke etc this would have been a horrific life for all of us.

also if I was pregnant again with the same diagnosis for the baby I would not proceed with the pregnancy. I couldn’t put another child through that first year in ICU again

I have every admiration for your honesty x

FlimsySteve · 29/08/2022 09:38

Sorry I was quoting a pp there!

At what point is a foetus able to live unaided?

Samcro · 29/08/2022 09:38

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 09:36

How can an adult human with a functioning brain not understand some people don't want to give birth to disabled children?

fuck me. lovely post.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 09:38

JennieTheZebra · 29/08/2022 09:29

@sashh The issue with both those situations, horrible as they are, is that the foetus still has to come out; poisoning it doesn’t mean the corpse has “gone away” and just leaving it makes it a massive infection risk. I think what PPs are struggling with is the idea that birth will have to be undergone, no matter what, and so performing a term limit abortion means killing the foetus almost for the sake of it iyswim. What’s the difference, in practice, between performing a term limit abortion and then a C section under GA and just performing the C section and taking the baby away for a closed adoption? As far as I can tell, the only real difference is that, in 18 years, the baby might want contact-and that could be upsetting or inconvenient. However, there are many upsetting or inconvenient people in the world and we don’t just kill them. This is really tricky in multiple different ways.

The difference is the woman’s choice, and what she consents to being done with her body.

Adoption has it’s own issues, and isn’t a valid choice for many.

FlimsySteve · 29/08/2022 09:37

I totally agree with you. If a baby is viable, able to live unaided, then it's horrific to abort. The emotional trauma to all involved must be horrendous

So when it's about 16 years old then?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 29/08/2022 09:36

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 29/08/2022 08:51

She told me I had a very HIGH risk of Downs - 1 in 200. Gave me leaflets outlining the LOW risk of miscarriage from the amino of 0.5%.

I'm a bit surprised they told you that. The cut off for high chance starts at 1 in 150. 1 in 200 is not considered high.

24 years ago i was told the same thing

i didn’t have an amnio due to the risk of miscarriage

i did ask the dr if i could have one at 30 weeks where the risk was lower and he said ‘but you won’t be able to have an abortion then’

i wasnt going to have a pn abortion i just wanted to know if he had downs so i could prepare family and friends

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 09:36

Samcro · 29/08/2022 09:34

@PicturesOfDogs why is it ok for a disability? I really don't understand.

How can an adult human with a functioning brain not understand some people don't want to give birth to disabled children?

Branleuse · 29/08/2022 09:35

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

Why on earth would someone do that unless incredibly extreme reason. It just isnt a thing.
The abortion limit for severely disabled foetuses is so high because we cant legalise euthanasia.
Its not the pretty face of medicine but its an important choice, and its incredibly rare that it happens, and is between a woman, herself, herself, her doctors and herself.

Samcro · 29/08/2022 09:34

@PicturesOfDogs why is it ok for a disability? I really don't understand.

PicturesOfDogs · 29/08/2022 09:29

I think we have great abortion laws in England, tbh.
Just the right balance imo.
I am pro choice, but admit that abortion for no medical reason in late stars sits uneasy with me, so for me it’s the ideal balance.
I do notice more and more the pro life brigade, not sure if they’re become more prevalent or whether I’ve just never noticed before.
It seems to be us copying US discourse

JennieTheZebra · 29/08/2022 09:29

@sashh The issue with both those situations, horrible as they are, is that the foetus still has to come out; poisoning it doesn’t mean the corpse has “gone away” and just leaving it makes it a massive infection risk. I think what PPs are struggling with is the idea that birth will have to be undergone, no matter what, and so performing a term limit abortion means killing the foetus almost for the sake of it iyswim. What’s the difference, in practice, between performing a term limit abortion and then a C section under GA and just performing the C section and taking the baby away for a closed adoption? As far as I can tell, the only real difference is that, in 18 years, the baby might want contact-and that could be upsetting or inconvenient. However, there are many upsetting or inconvenient people in the world and we don’t just kill them. This is really tricky in multiple different ways.

PotatoHammock · 29/08/2022 09:27

No one should be pressuring women either way.

To me, this would be the ideal sequence of events:

Doctor explains the likely prognosis, including the levels of uncertainty (because women aren't idiots, and we can factor uncertainty into our decision making)

Doctor presents abortion as one of the valid choices at this stage.

Pregnant women who want to proceed with the pregnancy are not mortally offended by the word abortion, because they understand that other pregnant women will need this option. These women just say "no thank you abortion is not for me", and then the doctor says "absolutely fine, that's a perfectly valid decision. If you change your mind, or if you have doubts, then please know that you can raise this again at any point".

Women who wish to end the pregnancy are similarly told "absolutely fine, that's a perfectly valid decision. We'll book you in for X days time, you can of course change your mind, or discuss this further, at any point up til then".

Sparklingrainbow · 29/08/2022 09:25

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

I agree completely

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 09:24

Quite a lot of these movements if you scratch enough below the surface are funded or supported by religious organisations

That's what I really object to

As it's restricting choice put in a shiny 'don't be a dick to disabled people' wrapper

Robostripes · 29/08/2022 09:22

I absolutely hate these emotive programmes and articles. I had a TFMR three years ago at 16 weeks due to DS. It was my choice and it was the right one for me and my family. The vast majority of women make the same choice. The vast majority of people with DS children did not make (or have to make) that choice because their children were diagnosed postnatally. Of course people with living children who they love very much feel upset about the idea of their child being aborted, but do they have the same strength of feeling about every potential child not born because the woman has an abortion simply because she didn’t want a baby? No.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 09:22

There seem to be a small group of familiar names pushing very very hard for our rights to be restricted. It’s very difficult to challenge them directly as it looks like a personal attack on their children; which of course it isn’t.

OP posts:
Samcro · 29/08/2022 09:22

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

you can do it up to term for disability, so why not for a not disabled pregnancy.
I doubt many would do it. but why not. surely its its ok for disability why not for everyone.

lisers · 29/08/2022 09:09

Fortunately the majority of women get through pregnancy without being told their baby has a serious condition / disability.

Those who are less fortunate deserve our compassion and support whatever decision they make. For some continuing the pregnancy will be their choice but for those that do opt to terminate, it will inevitably have been after much consideration.

sashh · 29/08/2022 09:08

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

The number of late abortions are tiny.

And there are reasons for a late termination of even a healthy baby. They are to do with the woman / girl and yes the baby has to come second.

A 10 year old who has been abused but doesn't know they are pregnant?

Asylum seekers, who are often sexually abused on their journey to a safe country.

Horrific circumstances we can't even think of.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 09:01

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

I imagine it would be done in the same way it currently is. I think it unlikely that a change in the law would prompt a switch to exposure being the preferred method (for what? Dramatic effect?).

Swipe left for the next trending thread