Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
HotSummerLoving · 29/08/2022 11:07

I have a child with a life limiting genetic disease. I would not knowingly have another child with the same condition.
If I accidentally became pregnant & found out the baby would be born with the same condition, I would have a termination.
My child who is 15 has lived experience of the condition & has said to me, in the same circumstances they would do the same.

WhatNoRaisins · 29/08/2022 10:58

It's a bit like the trend of minimising disabilities as "just a difference", all part of the same agenda not to mention a massive fuck you to the families who are struggling.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 10:56

Feelinglow27 · 29/08/2022 08:36

Surprised, and relieved, that the comments below the article all seem to be mostly pro-choice

Yes, if you get a chance to read just one, look at ProudMo from about an hour ago.

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 10:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mwnci123 · 29/08/2022 10:48

I think extending the abortion limit for all pregnancies would be so unpopular as to be ultimately harmful to the cause of women's reproductive rights.

Thank you to the pro-choice disabled poster talking about the importance of understanding/ empathising with the opposing view. It's to be expected that anti abortion campaigners will focus on late term abortion despite the low prevalence- it's the tactically obvious thing to do. But suggesting that disabled people are basically puppets when they question late term abortion of disabled foetuses is patronising and obtuse IMO. I had all the testing going and would have terminated my pregnancies in the event of a significant disability, but honestly I am not going to tell someone living with the same condition that they don't have a valid perspective in questioning that.

JacquelineCarlyle · 29/08/2022 10:42

GreenEggsAndBabycham · 29/08/2022 07:58

I'm all for equality. Abortion should be available on demand, up to full term, for all women, in all circumstances. End of.

Would that make these campaigners happy?

I agree with this.

UndertheCedartree · 29/08/2022 10:39

I have a friend with a DC who has Down's Syndrome. By all accounts he is thriving. He can walk and talk and attends mainstream school. She is very vocal about the negative attitude of the medics towards her DC. She feels more balanced information should be given.

Samcro · 29/08/2022 10:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

as a parent of a severely disabled adult. (caused at birth) i will ask what I like.

babyjellyfish · 29/08/2022 10:25

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 10:14

The vast majority of abortions in the UK take place before 10wks (89%) and almost all take place before 16wks with only 1% taking place between 16wks and 20wks.

The amount of abortions that place post-24wks is tiny - 276 in 2021.

Even if limits were removed there is nothing to indicate that this would vastly change, most women who want to end a pregnancy because they don't want it will do so as early as possible because women aren't idiots. They legally have until 24wks to abort but they still mostly opt to do it pre-10wks.

The whole "no limits" thing is a red herring though and often latched onto by pro-lifers who use it to harp on about murdering viable babies as if hoardes of women will suddenly opt to abort 39wk pregnancies despite all evidence being to the contrary.

The point I was making is that it isn't possible to provide the statistics requested.

For what it's worth I think the current abortion laws in the UK should be left unchanged.

x2boys · 29/08/2022 10:19

Horcruxe · 29/08/2022 10:07

There does seem to be an underlying agenda.

To limit the current abortion laws.

So you have a programme with presenters have disabilities who are living fulfilling lives putting out their case.

The first step would be to limit abortions for pregnancies with health conditions and then the next would be to lower the age limit from 24 weeks.

You never see programmes showing parents who have children with very severe disabilities who are struggling, have had to give up their jobs and now need to provide 24 hours care. Parents who wish they had not been put in this situation. No parent would go onto TV and say I wish I had aborted my child.

No parent would say my severely disabled child has no quality of life and now the lives of my other children are ruined. My healthy children are traumatized, they get no time from me, the stress of caring for my child broke down my marriage and I'm having to live on the limited support offered by this government. I'm depressed and not coping. I wish I had never had my child.

No parent would go on TV and broadcast that to the world.

This will never be the picture painted in these kinds of programmes. It will always be accomplished people, the people will be able to live a mostly active life, and as the case here even have won some Olympic medals.

This is true the narrative is usually look ar what people with disabilities can achieve
There was a brilliant series on BBC a couple of years ago however, "There she goes " about a young girl with severe learning disabilities and how her family life was portrayed, the writer based it on his own daughter who has severe learning disabilities andvis non verbal, it was very Frank, and realistic as a parent of a child with similar disabilities it made me laugh and cry ,it showed how tough it was for the family but also how the parents were just normal every day people doing there best ,there were also some very funny ,and poignant moments .

Ducksinthebath · 29/08/2022 10:16

Horcruxe · 29/08/2022 10:07

There does seem to be an underlying agenda.

To limit the current abortion laws.

So you have a programme with presenters have disabilities who are living fulfilling lives putting out their case.

The first step would be to limit abortions for pregnancies with health conditions and then the next would be to lower the age limit from 24 weeks.

You never see programmes showing parents who have children with very severe disabilities who are struggling, have had to give up their jobs and now need to provide 24 hours care. Parents who wish they had not been put in this situation. No parent would go onto TV and say I wish I had aborted my child.

No parent would say my severely disabled child has no quality of life and now the lives of my other children are ruined. My healthy children are traumatized, they get no time from me, the stress of caring for my child broke down my marriage and I'm having to live on the limited support offered by this government. I'm depressed and not coping. I wish I had never had my child.

No parent would go on TV and broadcast that to the world.

This will never be the picture painted in these kinds of programmes. It will always be accomplished people, the people will be able to live a mostly active life, and as the case here even have won some Olympic medals.

I agree. The closest you get to depicting that kind of life is a sanitised version on home makeover or food economy programmes. The reality for many families with disabled children is horrific. And for severely disabled people without a loving family it just doesn’t bear thinking about.

Paralympians, TV actors and TV actors’ children are not representative.

Popcorncovered · 29/08/2022 10:14

averageavocado · 29/08/2022 09:41

Could you share your verified statistics on how often this happen

We have lots of laws about things that don't happen particularly often. Laws don't just cover things that happen with a certain frequency.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 10:14

babyjellyfish · 29/08/2022 10:05

It doesn't, because late term abortions for non medical reasons aren't legal.

The vast majority of abortions in the UK take place before 10wks (89%) and almost all take place before 16wks with only 1% taking place between 16wks and 20wks.

The amount of abortions that place post-24wks is tiny - 276 in 2021.

Even if limits were removed there is nothing to indicate that this would vastly change, most women who want to end a pregnancy because they don't want it will do so as early as possible because women aren't idiots. They legally have until 24wks to abort but they still mostly opt to do it pre-10wks.

The whole "no limits" thing is a red herring though and often latched onto by pro-lifers who use it to harp on about murdering viable babies as if hoardes of women will suddenly opt to abort 39wk pregnancies despite all evidence being to the contrary.

Horcruxe · 29/08/2022 10:07

There does seem to be an underlying agenda.

To limit the current abortion laws.

So you have a programme with presenters have disabilities who are living fulfilling lives putting out their case.

The first step would be to limit abortions for pregnancies with health conditions and then the next would be to lower the age limit from 24 weeks.

You never see programmes showing parents who have children with very severe disabilities who are struggling, have had to give up their jobs and now need to provide 24 hours care. Parents who wish they had not been put in this situation. No parent would go onto TV and say I wish I had aborted my child.

No parent would say my severely disabled child has no quality of life and now the lives of my other children are ruined. My healthy children are traumatized, they get no time from me, the stress of caring for my child broke down my marriage and I'm having to live on the limited support offered by this government. I'm depressed and not coping. I wish I had never had my child.

No parent would go on TV and broadcast that to the world.

This will never be the picture painted in these kinds of programmes. It will always be accomplished people, the people will be able to live a mostly active life, and as the case here even have won some Olympic medals.

babyjellyfish · 29/08/2022 10:05

averageavocado · 29/08/2022 09:41

Could you share your verified statistics on how often this happen

It doesn't, because late term abortions for non medical reasons aren't legal.

UnboxedThoughts · 29/08/2022 10:04

The discourse around abortion should be this:

  1. Trusting women to make the best decision for their own bodies, and their own families, with the input from partners/doctors/close family as needed by the woman herself.
  2. Society then placing high value on supporting these women in raising children, disabled or no, to ensure the rising generation is wanted and welcomed, healthy and happy, well educated and financially secure.

In the UK, we are much, much closer to #1 than #2, but both need to work in conjunction with each other in order to ensure a secure future for all children.

Until we have both #1 and #2, women's autonomy will continue to be used for political point scoring.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 09:58

What’s the difference, in practice, between performing a term limit abortion and then a C section under GA and just performing the C section and taking the baby away for a closed adoption?

Pressure from friends/family/partner to "just keep it" and the knowledge that people will judge you for going down the adoption route alongside promises from family and friends that they will help you (which fade away to nothing within a few months).

Social Services don't do "from birth" adoptions because the woman has to have the opportunity to think it over and change her mind (which is where my point above becomes relevant).

There are already 80,000 children in care in the UK and there are only approximately 3500 adoptions per year. Adding these hypothetical babies into the mix will increase the numbers in care but will not necessarily increase the number of adoptions because a, there is a shortage of prospective adopters as not everyone wants to adopt or is suitable to adopt and b, not everyone is willing or suitable to take on the care of a disabled child. They can't stay with foster families because there is a shortage of those too so would end up in care homes, babies and infants don't tend to do well in care homes.

There then becomes more societal pressure to "just keep it" because otherwise you're more than likely condemning the hypothetical baby to a life in a care home and all that this entails.

Then let's not get into the affect closed adoption has on the adoptee in terms of understanding their history and identity.

catsrus · 29/08/2022 09:58

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 29/08/2022 08:51

She told me I had a very HIGH risk of Downs - 1 in 200. Gave me leaflets outlining the LOW risk of miscarriage from the amino of 0.5%.

I'm a bit surprised they told you that. The cut off for high chance starts at 1 in 150. 1 in 200 is not considered high.

Not as surprised as I was! This was a young GP with clearly strong views, who tried to influence my decision. I was an older woman with the skills to understand the issues - others may have just accepted her "expert" view.

My niece had to have a late abortion due to a condition incompatible with life. Very different scenario.

alpenguin · 29/08/2022 09:58

Branleuse · 29/08/2022 09:52

They dont think you should have been aborted though surely?
Majority of people would hopefully have considered your mothers right to decide to birth you or not, but once the child is here, you have as much right as anyone.
Before youre born, youre part of your mother.
I would likely have aborted for DS for example but that doesnt mean I think others should, or that there shouldnt be excellent provisions for disabled people.
People who deny the severity and huge difficulties faced by the disabled and their families, is either dishonest or stupid or both.

Way to pick up on one single sentence.

You missed the absolutely pro choice bits completely to focus on the fact that it’s possible to understand the other side of the argument without actually supporting it.

I have been told many times in my life if someone had a child with my disability theyd abort. That isn’t pleasant to hear but as I mentioned quite a few times, the decision is ultimately the mothers regardless of how disability activists might feel about it.

it never hurts to understand the opposing side though does it? Empathy doesn’t hurt

FourTeaFallOut · 29/08/2022 09:55

People who deny the severity and huge difficulties faced by the disabled and their families, is either dishonest or stupid or both

This is the crux of it.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 09:55

Some people seem to think a woman terminating a disabled fetus is casting an aspersion on the value of other, living disabled children. She isn’t. She’s saying for me, right here right now, this isn’t the right decision. Not that disabled people don’t have a right to life, or that other women should terminate. I terminated as a teenager. Does that mean I think all teenagers should terminate, or that all children born to teenage mums are lower in value than others? Of course not.

OP posts:
Georgeskitchen · 29/08/2022 09:54

I am pro choice but I believe there has to be firm time limits. I can't get my head around aborting a 40 week foetus. Imo it seems dangerously close to murder

Branleuse · 29/08/2022 09:52

alpenguin · 29/08/2022 09:43

As a pro choice lifelong disabled woman it’s a really difficult one for me.

Absolutely it’s a woman’s decision for any reason. I will stand by that even if it’s something I may not personally have chosen to do.

I also understand the argument from disability campaigners who fear it is a form of eugenics. The idea of getting rid of unwanted conditions because it makes life easier for the parents and the presumption that living with a disability is awful and something to try to change is for many hurtful and unthinkable. I’m not sure it would ever change my mind on pro-choice but I do see how hurtful it is to know people feel I’d rather have been aborted than given my chance to exist.

They dont think you should have been aborted though surely?
Majority of people would hopefully have considered your mothers right to decide to birth you or not, but once the child is here, you have as much right as anyone.
Before youre born, youre part of your mother.
I would likely have aborted for DS for example but that doesnt mean I think others should, or that there shouldnt be excellent provisions for disabled people.
People who deny the severity and huge difficulties faced by the disabled and their families, is either dishonest or stupid or both.

JenniferAllisonPhillipaSue · 29/08/2022 09:50

I was told there was a 1 in 5 chance that our child would have DS. We declined amnio and started to do our homework as to what that might mean. At no time did I feel ANY pressure, from family or from the medical profession, to consider terminating that pregnancy.

Branleuse · 29/08/2022 09:47

Samcro · 29/08/2022 09:34

@PicturesOfDogs why is it ok for a disability? I really don't understand.

Because in extreme cases of disability and deformity, it is incompatible with life, or it becomes clear that if the child is born, it wont have a good quality of life by most standards and will have excessive suffering instead. Its a kindness in some cases more than the cruelty or heartlessness its sometimes painted as. We can all usually identify when an animal is suffering in this way or feel sad at how we let elderly people suffer, and yet would guilt trip mothers into sacrificing themselves.

I have a disabilty, my children all have disabilities. I know there are some things I would have terminated for, and things I wouldnt, but others would.
Ultimately, I think its up to the woman herself.

The way the world is going, i really dont understand why people would want to concentrate on the plight of unborn foetuses.