Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
CecilyP · 29/08/2022 13:01

Just to be clear, many medical conditions are only picked up at the 20 week anatomy scan. It's categorically untrue to say that "many surgeons" in the UK refuse to carry out abortions after 18 weeks. Medical professionals abide by the law not their own arbitrary gut feelings.

i think the PP was referring to situations where there is no foetal abnormality. You’re right about conditions being picked up at 20 weeks or even later with amniocentesis, which is why there isn’t a set limit for termination for those conditions. This wasn’t a problem when the limit was 28 weeks. But 24 weeks meant the timeframe could be too short.

HannahSternDefoe · 29/08/2022 12:57

Fully pro choice.
The female carrying the foetus makes the decision if/when to abort within legal limits.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 12:55

YellowRoad · 29/08/2022 12:23

In terms of very late abortion what happens to her body will be identical either induction or C-section. The only difference is what is done to the baby.

This. The baby would have to come out either way. It won't just disappear. It's not like an early miscarriage. So there's no reason to not deliver the baby alive.

Well no, D&E is also an option when it comes to late term abortion. It is not the case that the ’baby will come out’ in a way that mimics live birth.

i’m not sure why anyone else’s levels of comfort, or indeed discomfort, should have an impact on any pregnancy other than their own. Your dislike of late termination doesn’t mean that it shouldn’t be an option for other women.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 12:42

@Georgeskitchen @SlagathaChristie I agree completely. UK law is sufficient, I think. It allows for various health reasons up to full term. We don't need to change it to up to 'full term for any reason,' I think.

PotatoHammock · 29/08/2022 12:34

NFLBingo · 29/08/2022 12:19

Also, whilst I understand the sentiment some have of allowing a termination up to birth, who do they think will be willing to remove a full-term pregnancy?
Many surgeons will not go above 18 weeks with termination companies and charities, which I can understand personally and current limits make me somewhat squeamish, but taking a fully formed and regular sized baby out for “any reason”, nah that’s crazy. Pretty much nobody is going to want to do that just because a pregnant person has decided it’s not longer for them.

Just to be clear, many medical conditions are only picked up at the 20 week anatomy scan. It's categorically untrue to say that "many surgeons" in the UK refuse to carry out abortions after 18 weeks. Medical professionals abide by the law not their own arbitrary gut feelings.

LaBellina · 29/08/2022 12:23

I think there’s no harm in informing women about their options. It becomes harmful when other people want to decide for a woman that she should keep a baby she doesn’t want in the name of equality. A fetus shouldn’t have more rights then the woman carrying it. End of.

YellowRoad · 29/08/2022 12:23

In terms of very late abortion what happens to her body will be identical either induction or C-section. The only difference is what is done to the baby.

This. The baby would have to come out either way. It won't just disappear. It's not like an early miscarriage. So there's no reason to not deliver the baby alive.

Asdson2022 · 29/08/2022 12:22

JennieTheZebra · 29/08/2022 09:29

@sashh The issue with both those situations, horrible as they are, is that the foetus still has to come out; poisoning it doesn’t mean the corpse has “gone away” and just leaving it makes it a massive infection risk. I think what PPs are struggling with is the idea that birth will have to be undergone, no matter what, and so performing a term limit abortion means killing the foetus almost for the sake of it iyswim. What’s the difference, in practice, between performing a term limit abortion and then a C section under GA and just performing the C section and taking the baby away for a closed adoption? As far as I can tell, the only real difference is that, in 18 years, the baby might want contact-and that could be upsetting or inconvenient. However, there are many upsetting or inconvenient people in the world and we don’t just kill them. This is really tricky in multiple different ways.

completely agree.

YellowRoad · 29/08/2022 12:20

Georgeskitchen · 29/08/2022 09:54

I am pro choice but I believe there has to be firm time limits. I can't get my head around aborting a 40 week foetus. Imo it seems dangerously close to murder

Same.

At 40 weeks the baby should just be delivered and put up for adoption, if it's not wanted, not aborted.

NFLBingo · 29/08/2022 12:19

SlagathaChristie · 29/08/2022 08:30

I really hate to stray from the main topic, but how on earth does anybody actually sit there and say they want abortion to be given up to full term, no medical reason needed?! Seriously, do you ever think about what that would entail? How would you physically kill a baby that would be born happily and healthily at that point? Leave it on a hillside? Wring its neck?

I can't fathom how a baby is the most wonderful, important, innocent creature on one side of his/her mother's vagina, but absolutely fine to kill on the other side. How far into labour or birth would you say it's OK to kill it?

I'm still in favour of some abortion being allowed, but the idea of killing a 39 week gestated baby is ridiculous.

As much as anyone talks about rights, we should talk about responsibility and duty too. And that's where the serious and difficult ethical questions come in with disability and abortion, because as pp have said, it's a hell of a responsibility to cope with.

Also, whilst I understand the sentiment some have of allowing a termination up to birth, who do they think will be willing to remove a full-term pregnancy?
Many surgeons will not go above 18 weeks with termination companies and charities, which I can understand personally and current limits make me somewhat squeamish, but taking a fully formed and regular sized baby out for “any reason”, nah that’s crazy. Pretty much nobody is going to want to do that just because a pregnant person has decided it’s not longer for them.

Sirzy · 29/08/2022 12:16

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 12:12

Why do you think you have any right to discuss or even question what level of disabilities women can abort over?

Exactly that is a decision for the individual woman with support from her support network and medical team.

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 12:16

I think disabilities do vary in their impact. It's possible to lead a fulfilling life when you are deaf or blind. My friend was born over 50 per cent deaf but has a good degree and is successful.

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 12:12

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 12:07

@Annieisalright

Disability is such a wide spectrum of situations. Nobody is going to question the morality of ending a pregnancy after 24 weeks which is not compatible with life. Edwards or other life limiting conditions, yes, ds starts to get contentious, a cleft lip? A club foot? So what many of us think is you need to define how disabled is appropriate for abortion after 24 weeks. I don't have an answer, it's more that once a foetus is potentially able to be born I'm uncomfortable with abortion unless exceptional eg not compatible with life

Why do you think you have any right to discuss or even question what level of disabilities women can abort over?

x2boys · 29/08/2022 12:12

Sirzy · 29/08/2022 12:10

I presume that is what they are labelling the traumatic processes of withdrawing care when it is obvious a newborn won’t survive

Ah right thank you

Sirzy · 29/08/2022 12:10

x2boys · 29/08/2022 11:58

Abortion after birth?

I presume that is what they are labelling the traumatic processes of withdrawing care when it is obvious a newborn won’t survive

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 12:07

@Annieisalright

Disability is such a wide spectrum of situations. Nobody is going to question the morality of ending a pregnancy after 24 weeks which is not compatible with life. Edwards or other life limiting conditions, yes, ds starts to get contentious, a cleft lip? A club foot? So what many of us think is you need to define how disabled is appropriate for abortion after 24 weeks. I don't have an answer, it's more that once a foetus is potentially able to be born I'm uncomfortable with abortion unless exceptional eg not compatible with life

x2boys · 29/08/2022 11:58

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 11:54

The crucial point in this discussion is whether any baby with a disability or even a suspected disability should be afforded the same protection under the law as other unborn babies.
The current law allows abortion up to and after birth (i.e. infanticide) on the grounds of disability.

Abortion after birth?

gogohmm · 29/08/2022 11:57

I thought the programme was fair. It covered both sides. We do need guidance through laws to these emotive issues. Personally I would prefer an earlier cut off date for choice (no disability) with a 2 week decision period for medical conditions identified outside of this general time period

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 29/08/2022 11:54

The crucial point in this discussion is whether any baby with a disability or even a suspected disability should be afforded the same protection under the law as other unborn babies.
The current law allows abortion up to and after birth (i.e. infanticide) on the grounds of disability.

Passtheduchyonthelefthandside · 29/08/2022 11:54

FlimsySteve · 29/08/2022 09:37

I totally agree with you. If a baby is viable, able to live unaided, then it's horrific to abort. The emotional trauma to all involved must be horrendous

So when it's about 16 years old then?

You have taken a very small chunk of what I said, out of context, and responded.

As you will see from my second paragraph, I am pro choice. My first paragraph was responding to another poster, who I agreed with, that having an abortion at full term must be horrendous for all involved.

Your quip about being 16 is ridiculous, clearly anyone who is born has a right to life. So unless you can make a clear and concise argument, sod off

applebot · 29/08/2022 11:52

But nobody disputes terminating a healthy fetus if the mother is at risk. The hypothetical would be if it was allowed for non medical reasons.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 11:48

babyjellyfish · 29/08/2022 10:05

It doesn't, because late term abortions for non medical reasons aren't legal.

2 further reasons they are allowed even if the foetus is healthy

1 the pregnancy places the mother's life in jeopardy

2 the pregnancy poses a risk of grave permanent injury to the mental or physical health of the mother

I think the numbers are tiny probably in single figures.

emertin · 29/08/2022 11:40

My DC has severe disabilities with a dire prognosis.
Life is difficult. Had to give up my career, my relationships with friends fell by the wayside, never get a full nights sleep, our world is very small. We are quite isolated. I gave it all up willingly for DC but understand why others wouldn't want this life. A life of sacrifice, society treating you like a burden and living on benefits.
What good would forcing births of disabled children on mothers do? The care system wouldn't be able to cope. That's far more cruel in my opinion.

Ciela · 29/08/2022 11:33

My stepson was born with microcephaly and if DH and I choose to have a child there is a 25% chance of our child having it too.

After speaking to my GP she said the risks were low enough that she wouldn’t tell us not to try if we want a child but if I do get pregnant they will monitor me far more closely.

As much DH loves his DS DH and I know we could not bring another child into the world with the same condition.

CecilyP · 29/08/2022 11:28

The difference is the woman’s choice, and what she consents to being done with her body.

In terms of very late abortion what happens to her body will be identical either induction or C-section. The only difference is what is done to the baby.

Adoption has it’s own issues, and isn’t a valid choice for many.

True, but is still a possibility. I doubt legislation will change regarding late abortion. Don’t see many MPs going for it. You can’t make laws on the the basis of ‘probably wouldn’t happen’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread