Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 04/09/2022 01:07

Thank you for your comments, I was responding to another poster .If you read our exchange, I responded to their view that the unborn are not protected in law until they attain personhood i.e. after birth. My example cited a recent case where the law sentenced a man who attacked his partner and her unborn child died-he was sentenced to life imprisonment.
But to respond to your observations: I'm not aware of one person on this thread who has subscribed to your description of the care system for disabled children. if you want your opinions to be taken seriously, please don't appoint yourself as the voice of all parents/children/people protecting children and families.

"not dead", "not beaten" and "not neglected"??? It is precisely to protect an unborn child from these horrors that courts have ruled that removal at birth is necessary in some cases.

Quality of life is troubling, insofar as almost everybody I have ever met uses the term loosely, and in relation to their own desires. No problem with that, not until these subjective opinions are used to end the lives of the vulnerable.

Who should determine quality of life? Seriously-are you aware of the Quality Adjusted Life Year model that was imported into health economics some years ago? Or the green paper on the draft Mental Capacity legislation in the 90's? If you aren't familiar with the Appeal Court ruling in the case of Tony Bland, please read it. This is the case which fundamentally altered the interpretation of acts of commission v acts of omission, which eroded the notion of best interests and which incorrectly interpreted food and fluids as "artificial treatment".

WiddlinDiddlin · 03/09/2022 14:51

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 03/09/2022 02:00

Because removal before birth (i.e. abortion) would be deliberately killing the child. Removal after birth would protect the child.

Again..

We're talking about (for very late abortions), children so seriously disabled they will suffer pain and die during or shortly after birth.

For earlier ones, we're still talking about children with significant disability.

But lets imagine we're talking about children who will live...

Please tell me what you think the care system is like for disabled children. Is it all fluffy unicorn teddies and trips to see Santa in Iceland? And then one bright sunny day, a nice couple turn up and invite the child home with them and theres jelly and icecream for tea every night and they all lived happily ever after?

Because any sane person knows thats bullshit. The reality is grim, and for children who will make it to adulthood, it's even worse.

You're not protecting anyone if you can't offer them a quality of life and 'not dead' is not quality of life, ditto 'not beaten, not neglected in terms of food/housing/clothing/education'.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 03/09/2022 02:00

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 07:15

Why not removal before @GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok ?

Because removal before birth (i.e. abortion) would be deliberately killing the child. Removal after birth would protect the child.

user1477391263 · 31/08/2022 21:45

Before we take women's rights away disability services need to be better funded, better respite which might then effect the abortion rates.

I doubt it. Social services for disabled children are the best in the world in the Nordic countries, where almost 100% of fetuses with Down syndrome (for example) are aborted.

It's just a fact that most people don't want to be the parent of a very disabled child, no matter how often the respite care bus comes round etc.

user1477391263 · 31/08/2022 21:41

We're currently facing a cost of living crisis, an NHS that is slowly breaking down, an aging population requiring carers who don't currently exist, a threatening recession, and a whole bunch of other dysfunctional stuff.

There is zero appetite for a pushback on termination of pregnancies where the fetus has a severe medical problem, trust me.

We had a thread yesterday about a family talking about completely disrupting their teens' educaiton by relocating to the far north of Scotland because they were pushed to the absolute breaking point by business failure in addition to being the carer to a child with complex medical needs. I thought of this thread when I was reading the discussion about this despairing family.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 21:25

@LangClegsInSpace I still am not sure, but have read a couple of articles that state women in Canada must travel to America for abortions after a certain date, though this may have changed. Also, isn't it now the case that if a woman's doctors decide there is a risk of grave injury to her mental/physical health a late abortion will be granted? Admittedly, the doctor has to be persuaded of a serious threat rather than a mild one, but I can't see how it is much different to the scenario you propose where a doctor acts in the best interests of the patient. Do you think the current requirements for termination after 24 weeks are too high?

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 19:53

And it's worth remembering that while we have the Abortion Act, this does not give women the legal right to an abortion in the UK.

The Abortion Act simply says that performing an abortion within a strict set of criteria will not be illegal.

Take it out of criminal law altogether. Treat it as healthcare.

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 19:28

My understanding is that late term abortions in Canada take place in hospitals not clinics and the data is separated by location.

There are certainly problems with access in Canada, as there are everywhere, but the law (or lack of law) in itself does not appear to be a problem. I don't believe it would be a problem in the UK and I think it would solve the two problems I posted above.

The article you linked to argues that because there is no law, there is no legal right to an abortion. This is technically true, however:

'the right to an abortion doesn't exist in Canada in the same way it is enshrined in Roe v. Wade.'

We saw how that worked out.

Another way of looking at it is this: If there is no law, then there is nothing that can be chipped away at. We wouldn't have private members' bills seeking to lower the time limit every few years.

When R v W was repealed, WHO made a strong statement that abortion is healthcare. We should start treating it as healthcare instead of as a matter for criminal law.

That doesn't mean a woman with a healthy 39 week pregnancy could demand an abortion and the doctor would just say 'ok then', any more than they would agree to cut off her leg, just because she asked. Doctors are duty bound to act in the best interests of their patients (for the avoidance of doubt, the patient is the pregnant woman). It simply means that doctors would be able to act in the best interests of their patients, at whatever stage of pregnancy, without the additional constraints of strict time limits and fear of prosecution.

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 18:52

One thing I found interesting in the programme was the two presenters discussing the results of the poll they commissioned.

Unless I misheard, around 1/4 of the public think there should be no time limit. That's a lot higher than I thought it would be and I suspect it's substantially higher than it was just a few years ago. I wonder if it will be like same sex marriage which had low support for years then reached a kind of tipping point and suddenly the vast majority were in favour, or at least neutral, and now nobody can quite remember why there was a fuss in the first place.

Discussing these results, the male presenter said 'at least they think we're equal'

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 18:48

@LangClegsInSpace Yes, I see it is decriminalised in Canada. But it seems similar to Alaska, where in practice no clinics offer abortion after 23 weeks and 6 days. Or has that changed?
www.ctvnews.ca/canada/what-is-the-legal-status-of-abortion-in-canada-1.5890266

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 18:41

MN numbered list feature is total pants 😂I didn't even try to use it, it just did half of a job automatically.

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 18:38

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 14:12

@whumpthereitis we have good laws in the UK that balance rights and harms. Pushing to remove any limits whatsoever trivialises the issue and doesn't seem serious. I believe there will be little appetite for it amongst most people.

Canada has no time limit. Abortion there is simply regulated in the same way as any other medical procedure.

https://www.actioncanadashr.org/news/2022-06-24-why-we-dont-need-new-abortion-law-canada

It seems to work OK and their stats look pretty similar to ours:

https://www.arcc-cdac.ca/media/2020/07/statistics-abortion-in-canada.pdf

The next argument is usually, 'well if nobody would use it anyway, what's the point in changing it?'

Two good reasons:

  1. No woman would be placed in a position where she was up against a hard deadline and had to make a rushed decision

  2. It would end what some see as discrimination against disabled people because of the different time limits we currently have

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 18:22

@buzzbuzzybuzz No, I don't do the mind reading thing, as I said!

buzzbuzzybuzz · 31/08/2022 18:18

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 17:28

@whumpthereitis I believe the law should state a good reason is needed for the abortion of full term healthy babies. Any old reason won't do. It is complex, and things change as our understanding and society changes. But I imagine current guidelines were reached with serious consideration of what abortion entails. I don't see lawmakers throwing that out the window and saying 'you know what, it doesn't matter. Any time for any reason is fine.' We will agree to disagree, I suppose!

How many women would abort a baby "for any old reason" though?

VoiceaFromUranus · 31/08/2022 18:15

I found it to be an incredibly one sided programme. Both presenters were extremely high functioning and didn't appear to have the plethora of wonderful issues that go with a lot of disabilities.

It's not just the life of painful shit that a hell of a lot of disabled people have to contend with. It's the knock on effect onto the parents, the siblings and so on.

Brothers and sisters who have to give up their childhood and access to parents.

It's the way the system appears to consider disabilities stopping the second you leave education when loads of support disappears.

It's the total lack of accessible properties should the individual be able to live at all independently.

It's the thought that your child is absolutely screwed when you die because they won't be getting that level of care from anyone else.

Life at any costs is an ill thought out policy and is extremely cruel in far too many cases.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 18:11

@GingerCake2018 Maybe you will have your way, and it's your right to your view. I maintain that many people will regard it as unacceptable, and that the work done by lawmakers so far will not be thrown out the window. I imagine they have given considerable thought to the guidelines, because not everyone sees the ending of life as insignificant in relation to a woman's choice.

GingerCake2018 · 31/08/2022 18:06

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 17:58

@GingerCake2018 I can't take this slightly mystical approach where I know the workings of everyone's mind, and can predict all their future actions. I don't believe laws should be made with the aid of fortune tellers or psychics. My view is the law should spell out what is and isn't acceptable, regardless of what we might think half the population will do.

This is not a mystical approach, the legislation is already in place and used every day in healthcare and in court to assess someones suitability to make a decision. I don't think anyone would have any objection to the requirement that a MCA and mental health assessment should be carried out by 2 independent specialist MCA HCPs and two independent Psychiatrist in what will be extremely rare cases, and if any doubt reviewed in court, but beyond that, if the women has capacity, Her body; Her Choice. End of.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 17:58

@GingerCake2018 I can't take this slightly mystical approach where I know the workings of everyone's mind, and can predict all their future actions. I don't believe laws should be made with the aid of fortune tellers or psychics. My view is the law should spell out what is and isn't acceptable, regardless of what we might think half the population will do.

GingerCake2018 · 31/08/2022 17:53

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 17:28

@whumpthereitis I believe the law should state a good reason is needed for the abortion of full term healthy babies. Any old reason won't do. It is complex, and things change as our understanding and society changes. But I imagine current guidelines were reached with serious consideration of what abortion entails. I don't see lawmakers throwing that out the window and saying 'you know what, it doesn't matter. Any time for any reason is fine.' We will agree to disagree, I suppose!

Do you think that little of your (presumably) fellow women, to think that that is really necessary?

We already have The Mental Capcity Act and the Mental Health Act there to safeguard vulnerable women from themselves and from others who my be acting with spurious intentions. Beyond that I think we need to trust that women know what is best for their own body and through attachment the fetus inside them.

GingerCake2018 · 31/08/2022 17:50

Branleuse · 31/08/2022 11:07

to what bit? I have been reading the thread and commenting. If someones using the existence of a child born at 26 weeks just passing their GCSEs, as any kind of reason that women shouldnt be able to choose to terminate an unwanted pregnancy, then it still doesnt add up to me. I dont want people forced into abortions they dont want, or into pregnancies they dont want. I have very little interest in the foetuses themselves or their human rights, until theyre born.
Actually thats not 100% true, because I think if a woman decides shes going to continue the pregnancy then she should have a responsibility towards making sure she is not harming it and then birthing it into shitty situations on purpose.
I know drug addicts that will have baby after baby into abusive situations, born addicted, because they dont believe in abortion. Its fucked up. Its looking at it the wrong way round. The planet is full of people and we are destroying it. Its normal to love babies and I love babies and children, but I just cant get my head round why people want other women to continue pregnancies they dont want or dont feel they can manage the commitment, because theyve anthropomorphised a foetus in utero, thats in a dream state, with no knowledge of the world and no awareness.
This weird fetish about baby innocence is so harmful to women and is contributing to a much wider problem in the world. #
We need to concentrate on the ones already here.

I am in favour of abortion to term.

I was using that example to demonstrate how arbitrary the various abortion cut off limits already are. There are children out there who were born at 22 weeks, but that does not, in my opinion, mean that a 22 week fetus is remotely "viable", it means that with enough money medical science can achieve some very unnatural things.

Without sophisticated neonatal medical care, the point of gestation at which the majority of babies would survive naturally is approximatly 32 weeks. My post was in reply to someone stating 26 weeks, where they got 26 weeks from is anybody's guess.

However no fetus is viable for very long at all without a live women's body as its life support system, as is clear when fullterm mum's of health fetuses tragically have large placental abruptions. Therefore it is the mother's body that is the key factor, and I believe in bodily autonomy, hence full term abortion.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 17:28

@whumpthereitis I believe the law should state a good reason is needed for the abortion of full term healthy babies. Any old reason won't do. It is complex, and things change as our understanding and society changes. But I imagine current guidelines were reached with serious consideration of what abortion entails. I don't see lawmakers throwing that out the window and saying 'you know what, it doesn't matter. Any time for any reason is fine.' We will agree to disagree, I suppose!

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 14:19

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 14:12

@whumpthereitis we have good laws in the UK that balance rights and harms. Pushing to remove any limits whatsoever trivialises the issue and doesn't seem serious. I believe there will be little appetite for it amongst most people.

Well, I don’t believe it’s an issue with inherent weight. That weight is going to vary depending on individual, and the only opinions that should matter are those of women towards their own pregnancies.

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 14:12

@whumpthereitis we have good laws in the UK that balance rights and harms. Pushing to remove any limits whatsoever trivialises the issue and doesn't seem serious. I believe there will be little appetite for it amongst most people.

whumpthereitis · 31/08/2022 14:06

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 12:50

@averageavocado I think that's quite silly. A fully developed foetus is not an inanimate thing, like a disposable tampon or whatever you think it is. Of course people will feel some empathy for its humanness and not think such a law is acceptable.

It’s not an inanimate object, but it’s not an independent entity. It exists in someone else’s body, and that someone else should retain full autonomy. You can’t demand organs from a corpse to benefit a born human, even to save their life, yet a fetus should have rights over the woman carrying it?

gnilliwdog · 31/08/2022 12:50

@averageavocado I think that's quite silly. A fully developed foetus is not an inanimate thing, like a disposable tampon or whatever you think it is. Of course people will feel some empathy for its humanness and not think such a law is acceptable.