Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?

238 replies

CanIJustAskAnotherStupidQuestion · 28/08/2022 22:39

I have friends and colleagues in Nordics, Spain, Italy, Germany and they all keep asking what the hell is going on in Britain, with double digit inflation and 80% increases in fuel costs. They don’t seem to be feeling all of this to the same extent.

So why is it happening here, and not so much elsewhere? I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes). But what about elsewhere?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Branster · 29/08/2022 09:44

@Calmdown14 that's exactly it. UK has had lower pricing fir a very long time compared to other countries in Europe.
And relative to income as well.
Discretionary spending has been higher in the UK and this is what is now changing by the looks of it. Less spare funds.
Yes, a coffee might be Euro2 in some country which looks cheap from UK, but relative to local income it might equate to a £3.50 coffee here.

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 09:43

DitzyBluebells · 29/08/2022 04:18

I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes).

If it's nationalised why would they get hit in taxes especially? A nationalised company is basically providing a public service, that's their purpose in life. If costs have gone up those will likely be passed onto the consumer, but that's it.

We're getting hit with huge rising costs because there's a middle man (private energy company) whose purpose in life is to make a profit, and because what they're selling is one of life's basic essentials people don't have the option of saying "no thanks I'll go without". They're not running a public service for the lowest effective price they can. They're running a company to make themselves as much profit as possible.

Nationalisation means that all taxpayers pay for the service. Currently EDF is selling at below market cost, which means that taxpayers will have to fund the difference, and if there's not the money in the budget already then taxes will need to increase. As it will be classed as critical national infrastructure, it's not like a private company which can cease to trade if it cannot afford to run - the government (taxpayers!) are liable for running costs, infrastructure and service.

thegcatsmother · 29/08/2022 09:36

De Croo (the Belgian PM) has said the next 3-5 winters will be difficult. The German politicians seem to be divided on selling out Ukraine to get the gas flowing again, or making a stand.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 09:36

@PersonaNonGarter
"The French are in complete chaos - EDF has had to be nationalised. And they are unable to take advantage of the energy crisis as they are not able to generate as much as usual. Further, they are in the grip of a crime wave and the government is paralysed as Macron lost his majority."

EDF was originally a nationalised company, and was then partly privatised, with the French government retaining over 80% of the shares, so EDF has always been under government control. The government has bought back the remaining shares in order to ensure that the "profits" generated are retained by the French treasury - i.e. the taxpayers (as opposed to the UK, where the "profits" are sent overseas to the foreign investors rather then benefitting the consumers/taxpayers).

Macron has not lost his majority - at the last election he polled over 55% of the votes.

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 09:35

maddy68 · 28/08/2022 22:49

I am in Spain. Our government has properly capped fuel costs. So affordable heating and petrol.

They have given free train fairs so commuters don't have to worry about the cost of getting to work.

Rental caps tents can't go up

Trailing of universal income

It's good to live in a socialist country. Ps our healthcare is sooo good

And yet you have an unemployment rate of around 13%, and youth u employment of over 25%. Sounds like a really happy and sustainable position to be in. You'd have thought with that wonderful EU FoM and the right to live and work anywhere in the EU, that some of those workers would have exercised that right to make their lot better, wouldn't you?

RosaGallica · 29/08/2022 09:35

OrangeDuck · 29/08/2022 09:22

Question about property. If we should expect going forward it becomes the norm for future generations to not own property and we should prepare them for this - then who does own it?Even if they rent, someone has to own the property for them to rent it from? How does this work in Spain where pp have explained that couples in their 30s etc cannot buy property. Who owns all these properties that they live in? If people cannot afford to buy property what happens when properties are left empty? It's just blowing my mind a bit trying to work out how we would adjust to the new norm being for the next generations to not own property - where will they live if no one can afford property to rent out? Will the government have to provide more council houses again?

I can see that renting will increase but surely we still need people to own the properties to rent out? Is this where the rich can come swooping in and mop up properties and rent out at extortionate prices??

Good question, and yes the rich owning everything is exactly what they appear to want. Just like in Victorian times, except that this time “the rich” can come from anywhere on the planet. We haven’t a hope of ever working enough to clear out of renting if we’re facing competition for buying from all around the globe.

If it wasn’t a very deliberate strategy to impoverish the British people and force them to become the new slaves of the world in place of places like Bangladesh then it sure looks like something very close to it.

hop321 · 29/08/2022 09:31

I'm a Conservative voter but I think Liz Truss is proposing economic measures that might make her popular now, but aren't the right answer for our economic health as a country.

Zonder · 29/08/2022 09:30

poshme · 29/08/2022 08:28

Uk unemployment rate 3.8%

How many countries in Europe have worse unemployment?

UK isn't worse off for everything.
European Union (EU27)
6%
Spain
12.6%
Greece
12.3%
Italy
8.1%
Sweden
7.6%
France
7.2%
Finland
6.5%
Latvia
6.4%
Croatia
6.3%
Portugal
6.1%
Slovakia
6%
Lithuania
5.8%
Estonia
5.7%
Belgium
5.5%
Romania
5.3%
Cyprus
5.1%
Ireland
4.8%
Denmark
4.5%
Austria
4.3%
Bulgaria
4.3%
Luxembourg
4.2%

Our unemployment figures are massaged and manipulated by the whole zero hours contract fiasco and the fact that many people in jobs don't earn a living wage. It looks like people are employed even if they're barely working any hours.

hop321 · 29/08/2022 09:29

But people WILL pay for this. The money has to be taken from people and put back into the economy sooner than later.

This is the thing. Many of the examples given involve government subsidies, which would increase our enormous public debt even more. There's no 'freebies' just borrowing that will have to be repaid through higher taxes in the future.

Jedsnewstar · 29/08/2022 09:27

RudsyFarmer · 28/08/2022 22:56

Germany have capped energy rises.

I’m starting to become cynical that the UK government is allowing this to spiral in the hope that some of the recently arrived economic migrants might row themselves back across the channel when they realise what a shit show it is here.

I don’t they are doing this, they don’t care about the economic migrants. They have had the ability to stop them for years but don’t. The do the menial jobs we won’t.

Zonder · 29/08/2022 09:26

londonrach · 29/08/2022 06:57

Just driven through Europe ..France, Germany, Belgium Holland etc and their fuel is as expensive as ours and the cost of eating out is awful. We didn't go high end food wise just where locals go. It was a shock as thought it be cheaper than uk.

That's partly because of the post Brexit exchange rate - we get less euros to the pound now so it is more expensive to us.

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 09:26

PersonaNonGarter · 29/08/2022 08:38

Spain does not have better politicians than us. Did you miss the bit were Catalonia held an independence referendum and then locked up the winners? Or the police and parliamentarians famous misogyny?

Only parochial morons think it is much better ‘over there’. These crises are global. Energy needs to be paid for somehow.

Even the monarchy is shady. Real shady. Spain is ranked the lowest on the corruption index out of all the major eurozone countries.

basilmint · 29/08/2022 09:23

I'm not sure the lower unemployment rate in the UK is actually of any benefit when so many people in-work cannot afford the basics.

OrangeDuck · 29/08/2022 09:22

Question about property. If we should expect going forward it becomes the norm for future generations to not own property and we should prepare them for this - then who does own it?Even if they rent, someone has to own the property for them to rent it from? How does this work in Spain where pp have explained that couples in their 30s etc cannot buy property. Who owns all these properties that they live in? If people cannot afford to buy property what happens when properties are left empty? It's just blowing my mind a bit trying to work out how we would adjust to the new norm being for the next generations to not own property - where will they live if no one can afford property to rent out? Will the government have to provide more council houses again?

I can see that renting will increase but surely we still need people to own the properties to rent out? Is this where the rich can come swooping in and mop up properties and rent out at extortionate prices??

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 09:21

ToodlePipYouLongHairedGit · 29/08/2022 08:33

Spain has applied a sticking plaster effect. It will have to be paid for by the tax payer in the years to come when they will face austerity for longer, even when other countries are out of this mess.

That’s how they always do it. And Italy too and France. Remember when Greece had to be bailed out back in early 2010s? There was then the real possibility that Italy and Spain would also go under and need to be bailed out.

Spain’s economy is one global shock away from bankruptcy. They simply do not make enough to money to justify what they spend. Hence why the unemployment rate never recovered after 2008.

Ginandthings · 29/08/2022 09:21

I read that Germany were the country facing the toughest winter due to their dependence on imported gas, there were a few articles saying that they are turning back on coal power stations and also asking for a reduction in gas usage across the eu to share the pain of the restrictions to nord stream. I don’t think it’s all sunshine and roses anywhere at the moment.

KonTikki · 29/08/2022 09:14

Being on holiday in a European country and living, paying your taxes to the same country are two very different things.
Almost all the serious issues facing us today are global problems.
Certainly individual countries deal with the same issues in varying ways, but its swings and roundabouts.
The important lesson is not to enact policies that penalise our children and grandchildren.
Creating artificially cheap prices to appease the electorate today will have to be paid for tomorrow.
This is simplistic, lazy and poor governance.

MotherofPearl · 29/08/2022 09:12

Kendodd · 28/08/2022 22:49

Do you think us constantly voting Tory could possibly be a factor?

Exactly this.

poshme · 29/08/2022 09:09

@Calmdown14 I think you're right about the dual fuel thing- our price rises are not as bad as some people because we have always had to pay more (no mains gas here so electricity has always cost more)

I can't cut back any more on usage. I found an old bill recently- we now use 3/4 of the electricity that we used 10 years ago, and far less than the average for the number of people/size of house.
Short of eating cold meals every day, I can't cut anything else.

RosaGallica · 29/08/2022 09:07

I would say that in the main they have actual democracies run by people who are interested in the practical effects of their policies and systems on the ground, rather than being run by people eager to make themselves look good by fiddling statistics.

Redqueenheart · 29/08/2022 08:58

Easy. They actually have decent governments...

The UK has a bunch of psychopaths who only care about making themselves and their mates richer and let utility companies make massive profits and increase their tariffs to ludicrous levels.

The French government knows Full-time well that the population would bring the country to a halt and ultimately bring them down if they tried anything like the current Tory shower...so they kept the price increase low and the energy companies are owned by the state, not by private companies.

Same thing in Scandinavian countries.

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 08:55

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 29/08/2022 08:18

The problem is the baseline. The UK never really recovered from the recession. Most other European countries recovered well, wages increased and went beyond their pre recession level. British people have been losing buying power for over a decade. Throw the current crisis on top of that and other countries are in better shape to deal with it - economically and socially.

The UK didn’t really go through the recession to the extent that Portugal, Spain, Italy or Greece did. Those countries had to overhaul their economies and lifestyle basically. Property devalued massively (UK housing costs have been on the rise for decades), simple things like eating out, paid-for leisure activities or holidays were off the table for low to mid-income families. Not just the poor.

The current 30 year olds in Spain grew up very differently to the British 30 year olds, who have had a higher level of disposable income throughout their lives. The standard of living is different. You still can’t afford to buy property as a young adult in Spain. There’s nothing to inherit because your parents’ house is now valued at 50k whilst they still have 200k left on the mortgage. All this talk of ‘house deposits’ on MN sounds like Japanese script to a Spanish couple in their 30s who’d like to settle down.

I do agree that socially some countries are better prepared to deal with it than others.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 29/08/2022 08:55

I think many people have forgotten that we are at the far end of supply chains. Over the last few decades the world has become far smaller than it was in say the 60s, 70s even. We have had free access to cheap everything, green beans from Kenya, cheap fuel from Russia, cheap cars from Korea.

And now, not because of Tories or Brexit, but because of covid and Russian actions, the world has got larger again and our geographical reality is becoming more obvious. Add to that the raising of the ridiculously low interest rates etc and we are living in the eye of a perfect storm.

Regardless of what we all think about it we are all going to have to tighten our belts, take proper stock of how we live, use a wide range of good and services and relearn the austerity measures of yesteryear.

And that will include changes in benefit packages, for better and worse.

I might have a slightly different perspective, but others here work in food banks too and will have seen and heard the same things I have heard from service providers and users alike. Many in greatest need are now being pragmatic rather than outraged. Are working together to discuss ways and means rather than looking to the government for help.

Lists of hardship funds, ways to contact utility providers, support with what to say, to ask for. Supplies of microwaves, slow cookers, all sorts of alternative cooking vessels are being sought, and often provided by individuals and organisations. Old fashioned blankets, jumpers, knitting sessions, yarn drops. We have really changed, added to what we do within our community hub.

It's scary, it's shit, but it is necessary. Sorry, I rambled...

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 08:50

@poshme Low unemployment is not necessarily an indicator of economic health.

The UK currently has low unemployment because there is a shortage of workers, over a million EU skilled and willing workers having left since Brexit and another half a million older workers deciding to leave the job market after Covid made them re-assess their lives.

A society cannot lose that many workers without there being a detrimental impact on services and prices. The NHS and social care facilities have 250,000 vacancies. Bus drivers are changing jobs and becoming lorry drivers - resulting in a shortage of bus drivers. The food and drinks industry is short of workers across all stages of the production chain - from fruit pickers to packers and sorters, food factory workers and delivery drivers. All of this has a knock-on effect on prices and availability.

The Government keeps talking about growth, but the UK cannot grow if there are not the workers available, with the skills required, to facilitate this growth.

PersonaNonGarter · 29/08/2022 08:38

Spain does not have better politicians than us. Did you miss the bit were Catalonia held an independence referendum and then locked up the winners? Or the police and parliamentarians famous misogyny?

Only parochial morons think it is much better ‘over there’. These crises are global. Energy needs to be paid for somehow.